Disney drops—then doubles down on—DMCA claim over Star Wars figure pic (original) (raw)

"All we did was write a letter, and a few hours later, it was retracted," she said in an interview with Ars this morning, pleased with the result. "It pays to take the high road and get your facts in order, rather than overreacting. I feel good about it, and it's nice that they're recognizing they made a mistake."

So, is that a happy ending for Star Wars: The Copyright Awakens? Nope, there's one last twist. Not 10 minutes after getting off the phone today, Carvalho informed Ars that the image was taken down again. Disney sent an identical DMCA notice.

"For reasons we can't understand—Disney has now RESUBMITTED the claim, again removing the pictures (that they restored this morning)," she told her followers on Facebook.

This time, Facebook removed the entire post, not just the photo. It also administered a punishment to Kozisek, banning him from posting on the site for three days.

Images of the figure still abound elsewhere, for instance in this "pre-order" eBay listing. (Before searching or clicking on that link, note that some hard-core fans consider Rey's costume in this figure to have "spoiler" elements to it.)

Disney and Lucasfilm own the copyright to Star Wars action figures, and the companies may own rights to some photos taken of those figures. But a photo on a fan blog of a legally purchased product has an extremely strong claim to being “fair use,” according to EFF attorney Mitch Stolz.

So what’s going on here? One possibility is that at least someone at Disney was openminded about Carvalho’s thoughtful response, but the organization has a software-enabled copyright enforcement regime in place that they simply can’t stop. For fans dealing with images the company doesn’t like, the rule seems to be guilty until proven innocent.

Lucasfilm didn't respond to requests for comment yesterday. We've reached out to Disney and will update the story with any response we get.