Issue 28286: gzip guessing of mode is ambiguous (original) (raw)

gzip.GzipFile can be open in two modes: reading and writing. The mode is specified by the mode parameter, but if it is not specified or is None, the mode is determined by the mode of passed file object. The problem is that the file object can support reading and writing. If the file object is opened with mode "rb", "rb+" or "wb+" (see also ), GzipFile will be opened for reading. If the file object is opened with mode "wb", "ab", "ab+", "xb", or "xb+", GzipFile will be opened for writing. Modes "rb+", "wb+", "ab+" and "xb+" support reading and writing, and GzipFile's choose looks arbitrary.

bz2 and lzma are free from this arbitrariness. The default value of the mode parameter is "r", and they never use file's mode as a guess.

This feature of the gzip module is not tested. Changing the default value of mode to "r" doesn't break gzip tests. But for certainty we should first deprecate this feature before dropping it.