Economic Interests and the Origins of Electoral Systems | American Political Science Review | Cambridge Core (original) (raw)

Abstract

The standard explanation for the choice of electoral institutions, building on Rokkan's seminal work, is that proportional representation (PR) was adopted by a divided right to defend its class interests against a rising left. But new evidence shows that PR strengthens the left and redistribution, and we argue the standard view is wrong historically, analytically, and empirically. We offer a radically different explanation. Integrating two opposed interpretations of PR—minimum winning coalitions versus consensus—we propose that the right adopted PR when their support for consensual regulatory frameworks, especially those of labor markets and skill formation where co-specific investments were important, outweighed their opposition to the redistributive consequences; this occurred in countries with previously densely organized local economies. In countries with adversarial industrial relations, and weak coordination of business and unions, keeping majoritarian institutions helped contain the left. This explains the close association between current varieties of capitalism and electoral institutions, and why they persist over time.

References

Austen-Smith David.2000. “Redistributing Income Under Proportional Representation.”Journal of Political Economy 108 (December):1235–69.

Bawn Kathleen andFrances Rosenbluth.2006. “Coalition Parties versus Coalitions of Parties: How Electoral Agency Shapes the Political Logic of Costs and Benefits.”American Journal of Political Science 50 (April):251–65.

Bernhard Michael.2000. “Democratisation by Direct Constitution in Weimar Germany and Interwar Poland.”Journal of European Area Studies 8 (November):221–45.

Blais Andre Agnieszka Dobrzynska andIndridi H. Indridason.2005. “To Adopt or not to Adopt Proportional Representation: The Politics of Institutional Choice.”British Journal of Political Science 35 (January):182–190.

Boix Carles.1999. “Setting the Rules of the Game: The Choice of Electoral Systems in Advanced Democracies.”American Political Science Review 93 (September):609–24.

Caramani Daniele.2004.The Nationalization of Politics: The Formation of National Electorates and Party Systems in Western Europe.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.

Carey John M., andM. S. Shugart.1995. “Incentives to Cultivate a Personal Vote: A Rank Ordering of Electoral Formulas”Electoral Studies 14 (December):417–39.

Carstairs Andrew McLaren.1980.A Short History of Electoral Systems in Western Europe.London:George Allen & Unwin.

Coleman Donald C. 1975.Industry in Tudor and Stuart England.London:Macmillan.

Colomer Josep M. ed.2004.Handbook of Electoral System Choice.New York:Palgrave Macmillan.

Colomer Josep M. 2005. “It's Parties that Choose Electoral Systems (or, Duverger's Laws Upside Down).”Political Studies 53 (March):1–21.Google Scholar

Colomer Josep.2006.Political Institutions: Democracy and Social Choice.Oxford:Oxford University Press.

Cox Gary.1997.Making Votes Count: Strategic Coordination in the World's Electoral Systems.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.

Cox Gary.1999. “Electoral Rules and Electoral Coordination”Annual Review of Political Science 2:145–61.Google Scholar

Crepaz Markus.1998. “Inclusion versus exclusion - Political institutions and welfare expenditures”Comparative Politics 31 (1):61–80.Google Scholar

Crouch Colin.1993.Industrial Relations and European State Traditions.Oxford:Oxford University Press.

Doering Herbert.1995.Parliaments and Majority Rule in Western Europe.New York:St. Martin's Press.

Esping-Andersen Gösta.1990.The Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism.Princeton:Princeton University Press.

Estevez-Abe Margarita,Torben Iversen, andDavid Soskice.2001. “Social Protection and the Formation of Skills: A Reinterpretation of the Welfare State.” In Varieties of Capitalism, ed. Peter A. Hall andDavid Soskice.Oxford:Oxford University Press:145–183.

Gallagher Michael.1991. “Proportionality, Disproportionality and Electoral Systems.”Electoral Studies 10 (March):33–51.Google Scholar

Gourevitch Peter.2003. “The Politics of Corporate Governance Regulation.”Yale Law Journal 112 (May):1829–80.Google Scholar

Gourevitch Peter, andJames Shinn.2005.Political Power and Corporate Control: The New Global Politics of Corporate Governance.Princeton:Princeton University Press.

Guinnane Timothy W. 1994. “A Failed Institutional Transplant: Raiffeisen's Credit Cooperatives in Ireland, 1894–1914.”Explorations in Economic History 31 (January):38–61.

Guinnane Timothy W. 2001. “Cooperatives as Information Machines: German Rural Cooperatives, 1883–1914.”Journal of Economic History 61 (June):366–89.

Hall Peter A. andDavid Soskice, eds.2001.Varieties of Capitalism: The Institutional Foundations of Comparative Advantage.Oxford:Oxford University Press.

Hechter Michael, andWilliam Brustein.1980. “Regional Modes of Production and Patterns of State Formation in Western Europe.”The American Journal of Sociology 85 (March):1067–1094.Google Scholar

Herrigel Gary.1996.Industrial Constructions: The Sources of German Industrial Power.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.

Huber Evelyne, andJohn D. Stephens.2001.Development and Crisis of the Welfare State: Parties and Policies in Global Markets.Chicago:University of Chicago Press.

Iversen Torben.2005.Capitalism, Democracy, and Welfare.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.

Iversen Torben, andDavid Soskice.2006. “Electoral Systems and the Politics of Coalitions: Why Some Democracies Redistribute More Than Others.”American Political Science Review 100 (May):165–81.

Iversen Torben, andDavid Soskice.2007. “Distribution and Redistribution: The Shadow of the Nineteenth Century.”Typescript, Department of Government,Harvard University.

Kalyvas Stathis.1996.The Rise of Christian Democracy in Europe.Ithaca, NY:Cornell University Press.

Katzenstein Peter.1985.Small States in World Markets.Ithaca, NY:Cornell University Press.

Korpi Walter.1983.The Democratic Class Struggle.London:Routledge & Kegan Paul.

Leonardi A. 2006. “Italian Credit Cooperatives between Expansion and Retrenchment: 1883–1945.”International Economic History Congress,Session 72.

Lewis Gavin. 1978. “The Peasantry, Rural Change and Conservatism: Lower Austria at the Turn of the Century.”Past and Present 81 (November):119–43.

Lipset Seymour M., andStein Rokkan. 1967. “Cleavage Structures, Party Systems, and Voter Alignments: An Introduction.”In Party Systems and Voter Alignments: Cross-National Perspectives, ed. S. M. Lipset andS. Rokkan.New York:Free Press,1–64.

Lijphart Arend.1984.Democracies: Patterns of Majoritarian and Consensus Government in Twenty-One Countries.New Haven:Yale University Press.

Lijphart Arend, andMarcus Crepaz.1991. “Corporatism and Consensus Democracy in 18 Countries—Conceptual and Empirical Linkages.”British Journal of Political Science 21 (April):235–46.

Mares Isabela.2003.The Politics of Social Risk.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.

Marshall F. Ray.1958. “The Finnish Cooperative Movement.”Land Economics 34 (August):227–35.

Martin Cathie Jo.2006. “Sectional Parties, Divided Business.”Studies in American Political Development 20 (October):160–84.

McLean Iain.1996. “E. J. Nanson, Social Choice, and Electoral Reform.”Australian Journal of Political Science 31 (November):369–85.

Milesi-Ferretti G-M.,R. Perotti, andM. Rostagno.2002. “Electoral Systems and Public Spending.”Quarterly Journal of Economics 117 (May):609–57.

Neto Octavio A., andGary W. Cox.1997. “Electoral Institutions, Cleavage Structures, and the Number of Parties.”American Journal of Political Science 41 (January):149–74.

Obinger Herbert,Stephan Leibfried, andFrancis G. Castles.2005.Federalism and The Welfare State: New World and European Experiences.Cambridge University Press.

Ordeshook Peter, andOlga Shvetsova.1994. “Ethnic Heterogeneity, District Magnitude, and the Number of Parties.”American Journal of Political Science 38 (February):100–23.

Persson Torsten, andGuido Tabellini.2004.The Economic Effects of Constitutions.Cambridge:MIT Press.

Powell G. Bingham.2000.Elections as Instruments of Democracy: Majoritan and Proportional Visions.New Haven:Yale University Press.

Powell Bingham.2002. “PR, the Median Voter, and Economic Policy: An Exploration.”Paper presented at the 2002 Meetings of the American Political Science Association, Boston.

Powell G. Bingham.2006. “Election Laws and Representative Governments: Beyond Votes and Seats”British Journal of Political Science 36 (April):291–315.

Rodden Jonathan.2003. “Reviving Leviathan: Fiscal Federalism and the Growth of Government.”International Organization 57 (Fall):695–729.Google Scholar

Rodden Jonathan.2005. “Red States, Blue States, and the Welfare State: Political Geography, Representation, and Government Policy Around the World.”Typescript, Department of Political Science,MIT.

Rogowski Ronald.1987. “Trade and the Variety of Democratic Institutions.”International Organization 41 (Spring):203–23.Google Scholar

Rogowski Ronald, andDuncan MacRae.2004. “Inequality and Institutions? What Theory, History, and (Some) Data Tell Us.”Paper presented at American Political Science Association Meeting, Chicago,September 2004.

Rogowski Ronald, andMark Andreas Kayser.2002. “Majoritarian Electoral Systems and Consumer Power: Price-level Evidence from the OECD Countries.”American Journal of Political Science 46 (July):526–39.

Rokkan Stein.1970.Citizens, Elections, Parties: Approaches to the Comparative Study of the Processes of Development.Oslo:Universitetsforlaget.

Stephens John.1979.The Transition from Capitalism to Socialism.Illinois University Press.

Strom Kaare.1984. “Minority Governments in Parliamentary Democracies. The Rationality of Nonwinning Cabinet Solutions”Comparative Political Studies 17 (July):199–227.

Strom Kaare.1990.Minority Government and Majority Government.New York:Cambridge University Press.

Swenson Peter.2002.Capitalists against Markets: the Making of Labor Markets and Welfare States in the United States and Sweden.Oxford:Oxford University Press.

Symes D. G. 1963. “Changes in the Structure and Role of Farming in a West Norwegian Island.”Economic Geography:39 (October):319–31.

Thelen Kathleen.2004.How Institutions Evolve: the Political Economy of Skills in Germany, Britain, the United States and Japan.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.