J. S. Woodsworth (original) (raw)

Canadian cleric, politician, and labour activist (1874–1942)

J. S. Woodsworth
1st Leader of the Co-operative Commonwealth Federation
In officeAugust 1, 1932 – March 21, 1942
Preceded by	new party
Succeeded by	Major James Coldwell
1st National Chairman of the Co-operative Commonwealth Federation
In office1932–1938
Preceded by	new party
Succeeded by	Major James Coldwell
Member of the House of Commons of Canada
In officeOctober 29, 1925 – March 21, 1942
Preceded by	new constituency
Succeeded by	Stanley Knowles
Constituency	Winnipeg North Centre
In officeDecember 6, 1921 – October 29, 1925
Preceded by	George William Andrews
Succeeded by	constituency abolished
Constituency	Winnipeg Centre
Personal details
Born	James Shaver Charleston Woodsworth(1874-07-29)July 29, 1874Etobicoke, Ontario
Died	March 21, 1942(1942-03-21) (aged 67)Vancouver, British Columbia
Political party	Labour Party (1921–1932)Co-operative Commonwealth Federation (1932–1942)
Spouse	Lucy Staples ​(m. 1903)​
Children	Grace MacInnis
Alma mater	Victoria College, TorontoUniversity of Oxford
Occupation	Author, lecturer, minister, secretary, social activist, teacher

James Shaver Charleston Woodsworth (July 29, 1874 – March 21, 1942) was a Canadian Methodist minister, politician, and labour activist. He was a pioneer of the Canadian Social Gospel, a Christian religious movement with social democratic values and links to organized labour. A long-time leader and publicist in the movement, Woodsworth served as an elected member of the federal parliament from 1921 until his death in 1942. In 1932, he helped to found the Co-operative Commonwealth Federation (CCF), a socialist political party which was the predecessor to the New Democratic Party (NDP).[1]

While studying at Oxford, he became interested in social welfare, and upon his return to Canada as a minister of the Methodist Church he preached the Social Gospel to the poor and the working classes of Manitoba. As the superintendent of the All People's Mission in Winnipeg and the secretary of the Canadian Welfare League, he focused on investigating social conditions, worked with immigrants, and campaigned for social welfare.

Woodsworth's focus on social issues and inequality led him to become active in the political labour movement in Canada. He led the protest campaign following the brutal police action which caused one person to be killed during the Winnipeg General Strike in 1919 and helped to organize the Manitoba Independent Labour Party (ILP). He ran and was elected to the House of Commons as a member of the ILP in 1921. In 1932 during the Great Depression, Woodsworth and the ILP along with other socialist and labour groups founded the Co-operative Commonwealth Federation (CCF), with Woodsworth as its leader. The CCF, Canada's first widely successful socialist party, evolved into today's New Democratic Party.[2] Woodsworth influenced many of Canada's contemporary social programs including social assistance, pensions and medicare.

Childhood and early ministry

[edit]

The oldest of six children, Woodsworth was born on Applewood Farm[3] in Etobicoke, Ontario, to Esther Josephine Shaver and James Woodsworth.[4] His father was a Methodist minister, and his strong faith was a powerful factor in shaping his later life. His grandfather, Harold Richard Woodsworth, had opposed William Lyon Mackenzie in the 1837 Rebellions. The Woodsworth family moved to Brandon, Manitoba, in 1882, where his father became a Superintendent of Methodist Missions in western Canada. Following in his father's footsteps, Woodsworth was ordained as a Methodist minister in 1896 and spent two years as a circuit preacher in Manitoba before going to study at Victoria College in the University of Toronto and at Oxford University in England.[4] While studying at Oxford University in 1899, he became interested in social welfare work. During his stay, the Second Boer War broke out, and Woodsworth was immersed in discussions about the moral values of imperialism. In 1902, following his return to Canada, he took a position as minister at Grace Church in Winnipeg, and, in 1903, he married Lucy Staples.[4]

In this role, he worked with the poor immigrants in Winnipeg and preached the social gospel that called for the Kingdom of God "here and now" and was concerned with "... the welfare and behaviour of the individual in this world."[5] It was not long, however, before Woodsworth became restless as a minister. He had difficulty accepting Methodist dogma, and questioned the wisdom of the Church's emphasis on individual salvation without considering the social context in which an individual lived. In a statement of explanation presented to the Manitoba Methodist Church Conference in 1907, he cited concerns with matters such as baptism, tests for those entering the Church, and fasting as a religious exercise. He tendered his resignation, but it was refused and he was offered the opportunity to assume the Superintendency of All People's Mission in Winnipeg's North End.[6] For six years he worked with the poor and immigrant families, and during this time, he wrote and campaigned for compulsory education, juvenile courts, the construction of playgrounds, and other initiatives in support of social welfare.

As a mission worker, Woodsworth had the opportunity to see first hand the appalling circumstances in which many of his fellow citizens lived, and began writing the first of several books decrying the failure to provide workers with a living wage and arguing for the need to create a more egalitarian and compassionate social order.

In 1909, his Strangers Within Our Gates was published,[7] followed in 1911 by My Neighbour.[8] In Strangers Within Our Gates, Woodsworth elaborated on concerns related to immigration, and expressed sympathy for the difficulties new immigrants to Canada faced but also offered eugenic interpretations of human abilities and worth based on race. The organization of the book reflects Woodsworth's "hierarchy," with early chapters focusing on Great Britain, the United States, Scandinavians, Germans, and later chapters focusing on Italians, "Levantine races," and "Orientals," concluding with a chapter entitled "The Negro and the Indian."[9]

In 1913, Woodsworth left All People's to accept an appointment as Secretary of the Canadian Welfare League. During this time, he travelled extensively throughout the three Canadian prairie provinces, investigating social conditions, and writing and speaking on his findings. By 1914, he had become a socialist and an admirer of the British Labour Party.

In 1916, during World War I, he was asked to support the National Services Registration, better known as conscription. As church ministers were being asked to preach about the duty of men to serve in the military, Woodsworth decided to publish his objections. As a pacifist, he was morally opposed to the Church being used as a vehicle of recruitment, and was fired from his position with the Bureau of Social Research, where he was working at the time. In 1917, he received his final pastoral posting to Gibson's Landing, British Columbia. Woodsworth resigned from the Church in 1918 because of its support of the war. "I thought that as a Christian minister, I was a messenger of the Prince of Peace", he is quoted as saying. His resignation was accepted.

Political involvement in BC

[edit]

Woodsworth and his family remained in British Columbia, where, despite his slight stature, he took work as a stevedore. He joined the International Longshore and Warehouse Union, helped organize the Federated Labour Party of British Columbia, and wrote for a labour newspaper.

Winnipeg General Strike

[edit]

In 1919, he set out on a tour of Western Canada, arriving in Winnipeg just as the Winnipeg General Strike was happening. He immediately began presenting addresses at strike meetings.

The Royal Canadian Mounted Police and Winnipeg "special constables" charged into a crowd of strikers demonstrating in the centre of Winnipeg, killing two people and injuring 30, on Bloody Saturday, June 21, 1919. Woodsworth led the campaign of protest against this action.

The editor of the strike bulletin Western Labour News was arrested and charged with seditious libel. Woodsworth took over the duties and after just a week he too was arrested and charged with the same thing. Oddly, his seditious libel took the form of quoting from the Bible Isaiah 10:1 "Woe unto them that decree unrighteous decrees..." and from Isaiah 65:21,22 (KJV). He was released on bail after five days' imprisonment, and the charges were never filed. (Other strike leaders served a year's imprisonment for their activities.)

His involvement in the strike further established Woodsworth's credentials with the labour movement and propelled him to a twenty-year tenure in the House of Commons as a Winnipeg MP. They also affirmed his belief in the importance of social activism.

Political activism in BC, then in Winnipeg

[edit]

Woodsworth briefly returned to British Columbia in 1920 to run as a Federated Labour Party candidate in Vancouver in the provincial election. He received 7444 votes but was not elected. He then returned to Winnipeg.

He became involved in organizing the Manitoba Independent Labour Party (ILP), a replacement for the locally based moderate Dominion Labour Party. The ILP had a platform modelled on that of the British Labour Party, with the slogan "Human Needs before Property Rights."[10]

In December 1921, Woodsworth was elected to the House of Commons in the riding of Winnipeg Centre under the banner of the Independent Labour Party. This district was abolished before the next election, being rolled into the new Winnipeg North Centre. He served in the House of Commons for the next 20 years, until his death.

The first bill he proposed concerned unemployment insurance. Even though he was informed by the Clerk of the House of Commons that bills involving federal spending had to be presented by the government, he nonetheless continued to press his case for better labour legislation.

He also pursued constitutional reform but was unsuccessful in attempt to have Single Transferable Vote system adopted for federal elections.[11] In 1936, the government set up a committee to discuss constitutional reforms (but the First-past-the-post voting system was not replaced).

Woodsworth was an unflagging advocate for the worker, the farmer, and the immigrant.

In 1929, Woodsworth was a keynote speaker at the annual conference of the Student Christian Movement of Canada, a fledgling social justice movement founded in 1921, and inspired Stanley Knowles, then 21, who later became ordained and helped found the New Democratic Party.

Rejecting violent revolution and any association with the new Communist Party of Canada, Woodsworth became a master of parliamentary procedure and used the House of Commons as a public platform. He at first sat beside the Progressive Party of Canada. He was a leader of the radical farmer-and-labour Ginger Group. This group's activities led to the 1932 founding of the first country-wide democratic socialist party, the CCF.

When the Canadian Liberal Party only had minority government following the 1925 election, Woodsworth bargained his vote in the House for a promise from the Liberal government to enact an old age pension plan. Introduced in 1927, the plan is the cornerstone of Canada's social security system.

In 1932, Woodsworth toured Europe as a member of the League of Nations Assembly in Geneva.

Formation of the CCF

[edit]

After most of the world went into the Great Depression, Woodsworth and the ILP joined with various provincial farmer, labour and socialist groups in 1932 to found a new socialist party, the Co-operative Commonwealth Federation (CCF). Woodsworth was its first leader.[10] Woodsworth said: "I am convinced that we may develop in Canada a distinctive type of Socialism. I refuse to follow slavishly the British model or the American model or the Russian model. We in Canada will solve our problems along our own lines."[12]

In 1933, the CCF became the official opposition in British Columbia. In 1934, the party achieved the same result in Saskatchewan.[13] One of its founding groups, the UFA, was government in Alberta.

In the 1935 election, seven CCF Members of Parliament were elected to the House of Commons. (None of the UFA MPs were re-elected.) The CCF received 8.9 percent of the popular vote. The CCF, however, was never able to seriously challenge Canada's party system, which was then dominated by the Liberals and Conservatives. In particular, the enormous prestige of the long-time Liberal Prime Minister, William Lyon Mackenzie King, prevented the CCF from displacing the Liberals as the main party of the left, as had happened with the socialist parties in Britain, Australia and New Zealand.

In 1939, many CCF members opposed Woodsworth's opposition to Canada's entry into World War II.[10] During the debate on the declaration of war, Mackenzie King said: "There are few men in this Parliament for whom I have greater respect than the leader of the Co-operative Commonwealth Federation. I admire him in my heart, because time and again he has had the courage to say what lays on his conscience, regardless of what the world might think of him. A man of that calibre is an ornament to any Parliament."

I would ask, did the last war settle anything? I venture to say that it settled nothing; and the next war into which we are asked to enter, however big and bloody it may be, is not going to settle anything either. That is not the way in which settlements are brought about. While we are urged to fight for freedom and democracy, it should be remembered that war is the very negation of both. The victor may win; but if he does, it is by adopting the selfsame tactics which he condemns in his enemy. […]

I am among a considerable number in this country who believe, and we hold it as a mature conviction, that war is the inevitable outcome of the present economic and international system with its injustices, exploitations, and class interests. I suggest that the common people of the country gain nothing by slaughtering the common people of any other country. As one who has tried for a good many years to take a stand for the common people, personally I cannot give my consent to anything that will drag us into another war.

— J. S. Woodsworth, 8 September 1939[14]

Nevertheless, Woodsworth was almost alone in his opposition to the war. He was the only Member of Parliament to vote against the bill, and his days as a party leader were over.[10][15]

He was re-elected to the House on 26 March 1940, but suffered a stroke in the fall and, over the next 18 months, his health deteriorated. He died in Vancouver, British Columbia in early 1942, and his ashes were scattered in the Strait of Georgia.

Woodsworth's daughter, Grace MacInnis, followed in his footsteps as a CCF politician.

Woodsworth's legacy

[edit]

Woodsworth strongly influenced Canadian social policy, and many of the social concepts he pioneered are represented in contemporary programs such as social assistance, pensions, and medicare, which are deemed to be fundamentally important in Canadian society today. While the party for which he was central founder, today called the New Democratic Party, has largely abandoned Woodsworth's vision of a socialist Canada, Woodsworth's memory is still held in great respect within the party as well as across Canada.

Woodsworth College of the University of Toronto, and J. S. Woodsworth Secondary School in Ottawa, Ontario (closed in 2005), are named after him. The 18-storey Woodsworth condominiums in downtown Toronto are named after him.[16][17] Tredway Woodsworth Public School in Scarborough, Toronto is also named after him.[18] In Winnipeg a chrome coloured sixteen-story Manitoba provincial office building built in 1973 is named after him, with a sculptured bronze bust honoring revealed in 1974 to honor his 100th birthday.[19] The Ontario Woodsworth Memorial Foundation merged with the Douglas-Coldwell Foundation in 1987.

The Woodsworth home at 60 Maryland Street in Winnipeg, Manitoba is now the location of the Centre for Christian Studies.[20] CCS purchased Woodsworth House from the Woodsworth Historical Society in 1998, with a commitment to keep the Woodsworth name and to continue to display photographs of Woodsworth and reminders of his commitment to the social gospel and social justice.

In 2004, a CBC contest rated Woodsworth as the 100th Greatest Canadian of all time.

In October 2010, the town of Gibsons, British Columbia announced that it would be naming a street in a new subdivision after Woodsworth. Woodsworth lived in Gibsons for a short time, beginning in 1917. A Woodsworth street exists in Burnaby,[21] but not in Gibson.

There is a J.S. Woodsworth fonds at Library and Archives Canada.[22] Archival reference number is R5904.

• Allen, Richard (1973). The Social Passion: Religion and Social Reform in Canada, 1914-28. Toronto: University of Toronto Press. ISBN 978-0-8020-6199-7. Retrieved 2023-05-20.
• MacInnis, Grace (1953). J.S. Woodsworth: A Man to Remember. Toronto: Macmillan Company of Canada.
• McNaught, Kenneth (1959). A Prophet in Politics: A Biography of J. S. Woodsworth. Toronto: University of Toronto Press. Retrieved 2023-05-20.
• Mills, Allen (1991). Fool For Christ: The Political Thought of J.S. Woodsworth. Toronto: University of Toronto Press. ISBN 978-0-8020-6842-2.
• Payment, Shirley Frances (1999). The Big Project: James M. Shaver at All Peoples' Mission, Winnipeg, 1921–1941 (M.A., History thesis). University of Manitoba. Retrieved 2024-03-02.
• Pulkingham, Jane, ed. (2016). Human Welfare, Rights, and Social Activism: Rethinking the Legacy of J.S. Woodsworth. University of Toronto Press.

1. ^ McNaught, Kenneth (2008-02-14). "James Shaver Woodsworth". The Canadian Encyclopedia. Retrieved 2023-05-16.
2. ^ Quinlan, Don; et al. (10 September 2008). The Canadian Challenge (1st ed.). Oxford University Press Canada. p. 56. ISBN 978-0-19-543156-8.
3. ^ "Applewood Shaver House". 2017. Retrieved 2023-08-08.
4. ^ a b c McNaught, Kenneth; Mills, Allen (1959). A Prophet in Politics: A Biography of J.S. Woodsworth. University of Toronto Press. pp. 23. doi:10.3138/9781442670426. ISBN 978-0-8020-8427-9. JSTOR 10.3138/9781442670426.
5. ^ Young, Walter D. (1978). Democracy and Discontent. Mcgraw-Hill Ryerson Limited. pp. 7. ISBN 0-07-082671-4.
6. ^ McNaught, Kenneth (1959). A Prophet in Politics: A Biography of J.S. Woodsworth. University of Toronto Press. pp. 36. doi:10.3138/9781442670426. ISBN 0-8020-8427-3. JSTOR 10.3138/9781442670426.
7. ^ Woodsworth, J.S. (1972). Strangers Within Our Gates. University of Toronto Press. ISBN 978-0-8020-1891-5. Retrieved 2023-08-08.
8. ^ Woodsworth, J.S. (1972). My Neighbor: A Study of City Conditions, A Plea for Social Service. University of Toronto Press. Retrieved 2023-08-08.
9. ^ Woodsworth, J. S. (1909). Strangers within our gates: or, coming Canadians. Toronto: F.C. Stephenson.
10. ^ a b c d James Shaver Woodsworth, Canadian Encyclopedia.
11. ^ Woodsworth (Cohen, editor), Labor's Case in Parliament (1929)
12. ^ Horn, Michiel (1972). "The League for Social Reconstruction and the development of a Canadian socialism, 1932–1936". Journal of Canadian Studies. 7 (4): 3–17. doi:10.3138/jcs.7.4.3. ISSN 1911-0251. S2CID 151917915 – via Project Muse.
13. ^ Mills, Allen (1991). Fool for Christ: The Intellectual Politics of J.S. Woodsworth. University of Toronto Press. pp. 103. ISBN 9780802068422.
14. ^ House of Commons Debates, 18th Parl, 5th Sess, No 1 (8 September 1939) at 45.
15. ^ Once Upon a Time, Canadians could be proud of Parliament, Globe and Mail, May 04, 2012. Retrieved 2016-03-29
16. ^ "Woodsworth condos". Condo Now. conodonow. Retrieved 22 June 2022.
17. ^ "The Woodsworth". The Woodsworth. Lamb Development Corp.
18. ^ "Tredway Woodsworth Public School". Tredway Woodsworth Public School. Toronto District School Board.
19. ^ "Woodsworth Building". Winnipeg Architecture. Winnipeg Architecture Foundation, Inc. Retrieved 22 June 2022.
20. ^ "Woodsworth Houst". Centre for Christian Studies. 7 January 2013.
21. ^ "Woodsworth Street, Burnaby, B.C." Google Maps. Alphabet. Retrieved 22 June 2022.
22. ^ "Finding aid to J.S. Woodsworth fonds, Library and Archives Canada" (PDF). Retrieved 2020-06-02.

• Douglas-Coldwell Foundation biography
• Saskatchewan NDP History
• University of Toronto J.S. Woodsworth Tour
• Civilization.ca (now historymuseun.ca) - The History of Canada's Public Pensions
• Grace MacInnis' personal recollections
• Woodsworth, James Shaver: National Historic Person. Parks Canada.
• James Shaver Woodsworth 1874-1942 Manitoba Heritage Council Commemorative Plaques
• J. S. Woodsworth – Parliament of Canada biography