Lewis chessmen (original) (raw)

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Group of 12th-century chess pieces

Lewis chessmen
Lewis chessmen in the British Museum
Material Walrus ivory and whales' teeth
Created 12th century
Discovered 1831Uig, Lewis, Scotland
Present location British MuseumNational Museum of Scotland
NMS website entry

The Lewis chessmen (Scottish Gaelic: Fir-thàilisg Leòdhais [fiɾʲˈhaːlɪʃkʲ loː.ɪʃ]) or Uig chessmen, named after the island or the bay where they were found,[1] are a group of distinctive 12th century chess pieces, along with other game pieces, most of which are carved from walrus ivory. Discovered in 1831 on Lewis in the Outer Hebrides of Scotland,[2] they may constitute some of the few complete, surviving medieval chess sets, although it is not clear if a single complete period-accurate set can be assembled from the pieces. When found, the hoard contained 94 objects: 78 chess pieces, 14 tablemen (pieces for backgammon or similar games) and one belt buckle. Today, 82 pieces are owned and usually exhibited by the British Museum in London, and the remaining 11 are at the National Museum of Scotland in Edinburgh; one chesspiece is owned privately.[3][4]

The newly identified piece, a "warder", the equivalent of a rook, was sold for £735,000 in July 2019. Four other major pieces, and many pawns, remain missing from the chess sets.[4]

Most accounts have said the pieces were found at Uig Bay (58°11′10″N 7°01′19″W / 58.185987°N 7.021909°W / 58.185987; -7.021909) on the west coast of Lewis, but Caldwell et al. of National Museums Scotland consider that Mealista (58°06′14″N 7°06′29″W / 58.104°N 7.108°W / 58.104; -7.108) – which is also in the parish of Uig and some 6 miles (10 km) further south down the coast—is a more likely place for the hoard to have been discovered.[5] The hoard was divided and sold in the 19th century; the British Museum holds 82 pieces, and National Museum of Scotland has 11 pieces, and the recently rediscovered piece is owned privately.[6]

At the British Museum, F. Madden, Assistant Keeper of Manuscripts, persuaded the trustees to purchase for 80 guineas (£84) the 82 pieces which he had been misled into believing was the entire hoard. Madden was a palaeographer, a scholar of early vernacular literature, but he was especially intrigued by these artifacts because he was a chess enthusiast.[7][8] Madden immediately began writing a research paper about the collection;[9] the paper remains informative today.[10]

There are many medieval chess bishops of various origins in different museums in Europe and US.[11][12][13]A bishop that probably predates the Lewis chessmen was in the collection of Jean-Joseph Marquet de Vasselot and was sold at Christie's in Paris in 2011 with a radiocarbon dating report stating that there is a 95% probability that the ivory dates between 790 and 990 AD.[14]It is thought to be English or German and carved in the 12th century. Stylistically it predates the Lewis chessmen, as its mitre is worn sideways.[15][16]

Almost all of the pieces in the collection are carved from walrus ivory, with a few made instead from whale teeth. The 79 chess pieces[a] consist of 8 kings, 8 queens, 16 bishops, 15 knights, 13 warders (rooks)[a] and 19 pawns. The heights of the pawns range from 3.5–5.8 cm (1⁠ 3 / 8 ⁠ – 2⁠ 9 / 32 ⁠ in), while the other pieces are between 7–10.2 cm (2⁠ 3 / 4 ⁠ – 4 in). Although there are 19 pawns (a complete set requires 16), they have the greatest range of sizes of all the pieces, which has suggested that the 79 chess pieces might belong to at least five sets.[17] All the pawns are smaller, geometric shapes – cylinders and "tombstones" – perhaps intended to resemble boundary markers. All the pieces in the back rank are sculptures of human figures: The knights are mounted on rather diminutive horses and are shown holding spears and shields. The rooks are standing soldiers or "warders" holding shields and swords; four of the rooks are shown as wild-eyed berserkers biting their shields with battle fury.[18] Some pieces bore traces of red stain when found (which has since vanished), possibly indicating that red and white were used to distinguish the two sides, rather than the black and white generally used in modern chess.[19]

The Lewis chessmen in the British Museum

Scholars have observed that to the modern eye the figural pieces, with their bulging eyes and glum expressions, have a distinctly comic character.[20][21] This is especially true of one rook ("warder 4" in Madden's numbering) with a worried, sideways glance and the berserker rooks biting their shields, which have been called "irresistibly comic to a modern audience".[22] It is believed, however, that the comic or sad expressions were not intended or perceived as such by the makers, who instead saw strength, ferocity, or in the case of the queens who hold their heads with a hand and seemingly pensive expression, "contemplation, repose, and possibly wisdom".[20]

Moreover, a recent article has examined how one of the king pieces projected a racialised representation of the archetypal chess king. Chess pieces envisioned human bodies which were constantly re-imagined and re-interpreted in the medieval period, and the Lewis chess king is fittingly characterised by a beard, hairstyle, and facial features that would not stand out in twelfth-century Norway, the supposed origin point of the set.[23]

The chessmen were discovered in early 1831 in a sandbank at the head of Uig Bay on the west coast of the Isle of Lewis, in the Outer Hebrides of Scotland. There are various local stories concerning their arrival and modern discovery on Lewis.

Malcolm "Sprot" MacLeod (Scottish Gaelic: Calum an Sprot) from the nearby township of Pennydonald discovered the trove in a small stone kist in a dune, exhibited them briefly in his byre and sold them on to Captain Roderick Ryrie.[24] One reported detail, that a cow actually unearthed the stash, is generally discounted in Uig as fabrication. After the Isle of Lewis was purchased by J. Matheson in 1844, Malcolm MacLeod and his family were evicted during the Highland Clearances which transformed the area into sheep farms.

When the chessmen were uncovered in 1831, 1 knight and 4 warders were missing from the four sets.[3] In June 2019 a warder piece, which had previously gone unrecognised for at least 55 years, emerged in Edinburgh,[3] and was purchased at a Sotheby's auction for £735,000 the following month, by an undisclosed buyer.[4]

Exhibition and ownership

[edit]

A queen and a warder (rook) in the joint exhibition in Edinburgh, 2010

They were exhibited by Ryrie at a meeting of the Society of Antiquaries of Scotland, on 11 April 1831. The chessmen were soon after split up, with 10 being purchased by C.K. Sharpe and the others (67 chessmen and 14 tablemen) purchased on behalf of the British Museum in London.

C.K. Sharpe later found another bishop to take his collection up to 11, all of which were later sold to Baron Londesborough. In 1888, they were again sold, but this time the purchaser was the Society of Antiquaries of Scotland, who donated the pieces to the Royal Scottish Museum in Edinburgh. The 11 are now on display in the National Museum of Scotland.

Of the pieces given to the British Museum, most can be found in Room 40, with the registration numbers M&ME 1831, 11–1.78–159. Others have been lent to Scottish museums and temporary exhibitions.[25]A range of wooden or plastic replicas are popular items in the Museum shops.

The chessmen were number 5 in the list of British archaeological finds selected by experts at the British Museum for a 2003 BBC documentary.[26] They were one of the items featured in a 2010 Radio 4 historical series.[27]

An exhibition entitled "The Lewis Chessmen: Unmasked" included chess pieces from both the National Museum of Scotland and British Museum collections, along with other relevant objects, touring Scotland in 2010–2011. The exhibition opened in Edinburgh on 21 May 2010 and proceeded to Aberdeen, Shetland, and the Museum nan Eilean in Stornoway, opening there on 15 April 2011.[28]

An exhibition entitled "The Game of Kings: Medieval Ivory Chessmen from the Isle of Lewis" at The Cloisters in New York City included 34 of the chess pieces, all on loan from the British Museum. The exhibit lasted through 22 April 2012.[29]

On 3 April 2013, £1.8 million from the European Regional Development Fund was granted to transform Lews Castle, Isle of Lewis, into a museum for the Western Isles. Around £14 million in total is to be spent on restoring and converting the property, which has been shuttered for nearly 25 years. When completed the permanent displays will include 6 Lewis chessmen.[30]

The Edinburgh warder piece was displayed in a special exhibit at the Neue Galerie New York in 2023, as part of a special exhibit.[31][4]

Dispute over location

[edit]

Lewis chessmen in the National Museum of Scotland in Edinburgh

In in late 2007, a dispute arose as to where the main resting place of the pieces should be.[32] There were calls from Scottish National Party politicians in the Western Isles (notably Councillor Annie Macdonald, Alasdair Allan MSP and Angus MacNeil MP) for the return of the pieces to the place they were found. Linda Fabiani, Scottish Minister for Europe, External Affairs and Culture, stated that "it is unacceptable that only 11 Lewis chessmen rest at the National Museum of Scotland while the other 67 (as well as the 14 tablemen) remain in the British Museum in London."

Richard Oram, Professor of Medieval and Environmental History at the University of Stirling, agreed, arguing that there was no reason for there to be more than "a sample" of the collection in London. These views were dismissed by Margaret Hodge, the then UK Minister of State in the Department for Culture, Media and Sport, writing "It's a lot of nonsense, isn't it?", noting that the law protects purchases and drawing comparisons to major artworks in Europe housed in major cities, with replicas often available in situ where tourism is sufficient.[24] The historical society in Uig, Comann Eachdraidh Ùig, which operates its museum near the find site, features detailed information about the chessmen and Norse occupation in Lewis. It has published that it cannot claim to own the pieces and would allow the normal museum market to determine whether more originals should rest in Edinburgh. It welcomes short-term loans.[33][_full citation needed_]

In October 2009, 24 of the pieces from London and 6 from Edinburgh began a 16 month tour of Scotland, partly funded by the Scottish Government, whose Mike Russell, Minister for Culture and External Affairs, stated that the Government and the British Museum had "agreed to disagree" on their eventual fate. Bonnie Greer, the museum's deputy chairman, said that she "absolutely" believed the main collection should remain in London.[34]

Neil MacGregor, who at the time of the debate was director of the British Museum, was reported to say that it was Norway who was entitled to ask for them back, not Scotland.[35] M. Bunting writes that:

"the British Museum has picked its way carefully and 6 of the figures were loaned long-term to Lewis's new museum in 2015".[35]

  1. ^ a b Current total of 79 pieces, after 2019 recovery[3][4] of the 13th warder (rook); original discovery had 12 warders / 78 chess pieces.
  1. ^ "Comann Eachdraidh Ùig" [Uig chessmen]. Ceuig.co.uk (in Scottish Gaelic). Retrieved 24 March 2017.
  2. ^ "The enigma of the Lewis chessmen". Chessbase.com. 9 November 2010. Retrieved 15 August 2013.
  3. ^ a b c d "Long-lost Lewis chessman found in Edinburgh family's drawer". BBC News. 3 June 2019. Retrieved 3 June 2019.
  4. ^ a b c d e "Lost Lewis Chessman piece bought for £5 sells for £735,000 at auction". BBC News. 2 July 2019. Retrieved 12 July 2021.
  5. ^ Caldwell, Hall & Wilkinson (2011), pp. 15–19.
  6. ^ Caldwell, Hall & Wilkinson (2011), p. 11.
  7. ^ Stratford (1997), pp. 4–8, 10.
  8. ^ Sotheby's (2019).
  9. ^ Madden (1832).
  10. ^ Stratford (1997), pp. 5, 8.
  11. ^ "[Site search on chess piece bishop]". Gothic Ivories Project (gothicivories.courtauld.ac.uk). London, UK: The Courtauld Institute of Art. Retrieved 2 July 2019. — search returned 18 objects
  12. ^ "Chess bishop probably made in Trondheim, Norway, AD 1150-1200". metmuseum.org. Art collection. New York, NY: The Metropolitan Museum of Art. Retrieved 2 July 2019.
  13. ^ "Chess bishop probably made in Norway or possibly England first part of 13th century". Stockholm, Sweden: Historiska Museet. Retrieved 2 July 2019.
  14. ^ "Oeuvres Médiévales provenant de la collection Marquet de Vasselot, Paris". Christie's christies.com. 16 November 2011. SALE 1047. Retrieved 2 July 2019.
  15. ^ "Mitre evolution from 11th century to present day". Florida Center for Instructional Technology / College of Education. University of South Florida. Retrieved 2 July 2019.
  16. ^ Robinson (2004), p. 19.
  17. ^ Robinson (2004), p. 30.
  18. ^ Robinson (2004), pp. 28–29.
  19. ^ McClain, Dylan Loeb (9 September 2010). "Reopening history of storied Norse chessmen". The New York Times. p. C2. Retrieved 14 September 2010.
  20. ^ a b Robinson (2004), pp. 37–41.
  21. ^ Stratford (1997), p. 48.
  22. ^ Robinson (2004), p. 37.
  23. ^ Ilko, Krisztina (2024). "Chess and Race in the Global Middle Ages". Speculum. 99 (2): 498, 501. doi:10.1086/729294.
  24. ^ a b Burnett, Allan (3 February 2008). "Stalemate". The Sunday Herald. Glasgow, UK.
  25. ^ "The Lewis Chessmen" (Press release). London, UK: The British Museum. Retrieved 15 August 2013.
  26. ^ presented by Adam Hart-Davis, various experts from the British Museum (2003). "Our Top Ten Treasures". documentary. BBC Television.
  27. ^ A History of the World in 100 Objects. 2010. BBC Radio 4.
  28. ^ "Lewis Chessman exhibition opens in Stornoway museum". Scotland highlands & islands. BBC News (bbc.co.uk). Retrieved 15 April 2011.
  29. ^ Johnson, Ken (18 November 2011). "Medieval foes with whimsey". The New York Times. Retrieved 15 August 2013.
  30. ^ "New funding announced for Lews Castle museum". scotland.gov.uk (Press release). Edinburgh, UK: Government of Scotland. April 2013.
  31. ^ "Ronald S. Lauder collection". neuegalerie.org. New York, NY: Neue Galerie New York. Retrieved 28 February 2023.
  32. ^ "Moves to unite historic chessmen". Scotland highlands and islands. BBC News. 24 December 2007. Retrieved 5 January 2022.
  33. ^ "[no title cited]", Uig News, February 2008
  34. ^ Cornwell, Tim (2 October 2009). "Chessmen will never come home". The Scotsman. Retrieved 5 January 2022.
  35. ^ a b Bunting, Madeleine (2016). Love of Country: A Hebridean journey. Granta. ISBN 9781847085184.