(original) (raw)

On Jan 14, 2014, at 9:12 PM, Antoine Pitrou <solipsis@pitrou.net> wrote:

I'm +1 on the sidefile approach. +0 on the various buffer approaches.
-0.5 on the current "sprinkled everywhere" approach.

I concur with Antoine except that I'm a full -1 on commingling

generated code with hand edited code. Sprinked everywhere

interferes with my ability to grok the code. It interferes with

code navigation. And it creates a greater risk of accidentally

editing the generated code.

FWIW, I think everyone should place a lot of weight on

Serhiy's comments and suggestions. His reasoning is

clear and compelling. And the thoughts are all soundly

based on extensive experience with the clinic's effect on

the C source code.

Raymond