Kynurenine Pathway Pathologies: do Nicotinamide and Other Pathway Co-Factors have a Therapeutic Role in Reduction of Symptom Severity, Including Chronic Fatigue Syndrome (CFS) and Fibromyalgia (FM) (original) (raw)

Abstract

The definition of dual tryptophan pathways has increased the understanding of the mind-body, body-mind dichotomy. The serotonergic pathway highlights the primary (endogenous) psychiatric disorders. The up-regulation of the kynurenine pathway by physical illnesses can cause neuropathic and immunological disorders1 associated with secondary neuropsychiatric symptoms.

Tryptophan and nicotinamide deficiencies fall within the protein energy malnutrition (PEM) spectrum. They can arise if the kynurenine pathway is stressed by primary or secondary inflammatory conditions and the consequent imbalance of available catabolic/anabolic substrates may adversely influence convalescent phase efficiency. The replacement of depleted or reduced NAD+ levels and other cofactors can perhaps improve the clinical management of these disorders.

Chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS) and fibromyalgia (FM) appear to meet the criteria of a tryptophan-kynurenine pathway disorder with potential neuroimmunological sequelae. Aspects of some of the putative precipitating factors have been previously outlined.2,3 An analysis of the areas of metabolic dysfunction will focus on future directions for research and management.

Keywords: Vitamin B-12, nicotinamide, tryptophan, mental status, nutrition, chronic fatigue syndrome, fibromyalgia, neurology, psychiatry, pernicious anaemia

The Mind-Body Dichotomy

Over the centuries, there has been intense speculation as to whether human physical dysfunction originated in the mind or arose from the body. Elements of this diagnostic uncertainty have prevailed to present times and are reflected in the opposing views of hysteria and somatoform disorders. Not all health workers accepted the validity of some of the psychiatric symptom inventory scales.

Solomon4 listed several organic neurological lesions, such as glove and stocking neuropathies, which could be misdiagnosed as hysteria.4 David and co-workers5 attempted to initiate the debate that “the fruitless dichotomy of ‘organic versus functional’ should be replaced by a multi-factorial approach”.5 Other clinicians were concerned about the low discriminatory diagnostic value6 and ambiguous or unclear items7 in the Illness Behavior Questionnaire. This questionnaire was designed to validate abnormal illness behavior as a psychiatric diagnosis in those patients with “insufficient pathological change to explain the intensity of pain or degree of disability and suffering”.8 They were also perceived as suffering “unsolved medical problems” with social and economic disadvantages. These patients required further research with psychiatric constructs to address their somatization issues.9

Neuropharmacologists have studied the serotonergic pathway over 5 decades and produced numerous treatment options for psychiatric disorders. The function of the kynurenine pathway has been undervalued. It is upregulated by physical (organic) illnesses1 which can be accompanied by transient secondary deliriums and dysphorias. Mental and physical illnesses sometimes coexist10,11 or a dysphoria can herald an organic disorder.12–14 It is a challenge for researchers to better understand the interactive balancing of the dual pathways under stress. This could bring clarity to the physiological interface of the mind-body dichotomy.

Protein Energy Malnutrition (PEM) Niacin and Cofactors

Historical background

The historical accounts of the discoveries of both the connection of pellagra with niacin and the existence of the state of PEM are interlinked.15–17 18th Century Spanish Conquistadores imported maize (corn) from Central America to Europe15 and it was in 1735 that Casal, a Spanish physician, was the first to describe aspects of pellagra. The use of maize as a staple food then spread to many other countries, including Southern Africa and parts of India.

Pellagra reached epidemic proportions in parts of the Southern United States of America at the beginning of the 20th Century. Dr. Joseph Goldberger was challenged to prove that pellagra was not an infectious disease but rather that it was caused by a dietary deficiency. Subsequently, Elvehjem linked niacin to the prevention of pellagra in 1937.15 The next phase of research focused on Kwashiorkor, the malnutrition of impoverished communities, usually in underdeveloped countries, which afflicts infants and children on restricted diets often with a high maize content. Biochemical analysis demonstrated that maize had low tryptophan content and its niacytin component lacked bioavailability. Interestingly, the South American Indians had fortuitously escaped pellagra due to their custom of presoaking their corn in alkaline lime water, prior to cooking tortillas.

Tryptophan and niacin

Tryptophan was discovered at the beginning of the 20th Century and was the first amino acid to be recognized as an essential component of the human diet.15,17 It is a critical precursor in the synthesis of the serotonin neurotransmitter and the nicotinamide ring of coenzymes NAD and NADP.1,17 Approximately 60 mg of tryptophan, subject to hormonal and other influence, can be converted into l mg of nicotinamide.17 Dietary niacin is an additional source of nicotinamide.

Tryptophan contributes to the structural, neuroactive inflammatory, and immunomodulatory functions of the body.1–3 Its importance in the function of the kynurenine pathway combined with the presence of an adequate supply of nicotinamide substrate is, however, only of recent interest.1,18 Nicotinamide has numerous functions,19,20 including its potential control over infections21–26 and DNA repair.27 Additionally, it can improve the management of some cancers28–30 and CFS/FM3,31 subject to the stage and phase of these conditions.

Deficiencies in both tryptophan and nicotinamide produce symptoms of pellagra and inadequate supplies of tryptophan can make the patient vulnerable to the development of PEM. Its levels are reduced because of undernutrition,17 malabsorption,3,32 or any significant illness or injury which upregulates KP catabolism.1

Symptoms of pellagra or nicotinamide deficiency range from mild oral gum changes to severe weakness, paresthesias, dysphagia, glossitis, various mucosal and skin changes, and mental disturbances.34 Hartnup’s disease and carcinoid tumor are rare causes of this nutritional disorder.3

Alcoholism is an iatrogenic cause of pellagra in combination with a lack of other critical nutrients.34–36 Similar abnormal urinary amino acid profiles have been identified in Pellagrins and HIV-AIDS patients with compromised availability of nicotinamide.37,38 Pellagra is infrequently recognized as a secondary complication of chronic illnesses with a stressed kynurenine path.1,39

Protein energy malnutrition (PEM)

PEM is due primarily to an inadequate intake of essential proteins or to the ingestion of poor quality protein foods. Poverty, famines, dietary ignorance, alcoholism, and mental illness contribute to this etiological category.17,34 Hypermetabolic response to severe acute or chronic illnesses and trauma can produce bodily protein substrate deficiencies.17,40 These inflammatory conditions include infections (eg, HIV-AIDS), neoplasms, chronic renal failure, and burns in which secondary PEM can occur.

The daily homeostatic turnover of nutritional protein is regulated to achieve a zero nitrogen balance between intake and output. In circumstances of PEM “a sustained imbalance” occurs “between nutritional availability and nutrient requirements, resulting in a pathophysiological state in which intermediary metabolism, organ function, and body composition are variously altered”.40

The degree of physiological impairment, consequent to the catabolism of somatic muscle mass, is proportionate to the severity of the underlying ailment.40 The immune system is the most vulnerable of the body organ compartments to the adverse effects of PEM. Another example of compromise is the tardy structural repair of the gastric intestinal tract which aggravates any pre-existing propensity to malabsorption. Additionally, wound healing is less efficient and the manufacture of T4 and its conversion to T3 is reduced so that the patient’s thyroid status can resemble the euthyroid sick syndrome.40–42 The challenge of treatment is to contain the illness43 and include nutritional strategies and relatively depleted anabolic agents in the therapeutic restoration of homeostasis.40

Reductions in the levels of other metabolic fuels occur concurrently with the previously described metabolic stresses.17,40 The B group vitamins, especially B6, are important cofactors in several enzymes required for function of the tryptophan pathways.17 Other micronutrients,44 such as L-carnitine31,45 and ribose,31,46 have been trialed in various medical conditions. The optimistic results may, however, reflect a placebo component. Future research protocols are required to determine which cofactors are exhausted and require replacement to supply positive anabolic therapeutic support in acute and chronic illnesses with hypermetabolic states.

CFS/FM—the Metabolic Enigma

CFS/FM is a complex autoimmune spectrum disorder which is frequently familial.2,3,41,47 The onset is either acute or insidious and has a variable and unpredictable course and outcome. Central nervous symptoms are prominent, patients are lethargic and suffer pain, sleep disturbances and dysphorias, and their powers of concentration and cognition are decreased while aspects of memory are impaired. Patients may complain of headaches and paresthesias and exhibit an ataxic gait. Food intolerances are amongst the various gastro-intestinal disturbances described. The physical response to infection can be atypical and protracted2,3,48–50 and their hypothyroid state can present with an unusual pattern of T3 behavior.40–42

Tryptophan32 and Vitamin B-12 deficiencies are associated with malabsorption and contribute to the causes of nutritional demyelinating disorders.3 Both substances have juvenile forms of illnesses. If enzyme defects and other genetic irregularities are present, conditions such as Hartnup’s disease and dysfunctions of homocyteine can also occur.3,51–53 These genetic aberrations may not be expressed until adulthood when they are often misdiagnosed.

Evidence has accumulated that CFS/FM is in part a neuroinflammatory condition of the kynurenine pathway with CNS3,41,54 and peripheral nerve involvement.55

Pernicious anaemia (PA) is an autoimmune disorder with defective B-12 metabolism. It is frequently associated with hypothyroidism and PA can manifest either as a megaloblastic anaemia or as a neurological complication with or without the anemic component of Vitamin B-12 deficiency.17,52,53,56 The subsequent peripheral neuropathy produced by the sub-acute combined degeneration of the spinal cord explains the paresthesias and sensory losses in the distal part of the limbs.55 Occasionally PA presents as a psychiatric illness10,57 or with autonomic nervous system involvement.58,59

Vitamin B-12 is a cofactor in the enzyme formation of methionine synthetase (methylmalonic CoA) and leucine aminomutase. Reduced levels of B-12 have a negative impact on certain aspects of tryptophan function.17 The gastric achlor-hydria interferes with the gastrointestinal bacterial balance, which then creates a propensity to secondary infection.32,60,61 Defective substrate production, such as NK and T cells62 reduces effective KP immunological function. Vitiligo or depigmented white spots is a skin change associated with PA.63

Routine blood diagnostic tests are not always sufficiently robust to detect the earlier stages or atypical forms of PA. The measurement of methylmalonic acid (MMA) and homocysteine (HCY) levels are more sensitive indicators of an underlying PA.53,64 Past use of these tests, ie, MMA and HCY blood levels, clarified the fact that a neuropsychiatric form of PA existed which could present in the absence of an haematological component51,56 or that there could be an inverse correlation between the severity of the neurological damage and the PA megaloblastic anaemia.56,58

Carmel and colleagues had an interest in the genetic aberrations of PA.51 This aspect of PA was utilized in a subsequent research project which enquired into the divergent behaviors of the neurological and haematological forms of PA.56 They found:

“Cobalamin therapy restored all metabolic changes to normal. The results indicate that changes in several metabolic pathways differ in patients with and without neurologic dysfunction. Cysteine levels were the most significant predictors of neurological dysfunction, but it is unclear if they are direct or indirect indicators of neurotoxicity.”56

Regland et al65 examined 12 females with CFS/FM. Their peripheral blood test results were generally normal, whereas tests of their cerebro-spinal fluid demonstrated elevated HCY levels and low B-12 levels. These correlated with the degree of patient fatigue. In his informal surveys, Lapp66 noted that CFS patients returned positive HCY and MMA tests for PA when the routine blood tests for folate and B-12 were normal. In addition these patients appeared to respond to cyanocobalamin injections. Myhill67 theorized that CFS/FM symptoms were due to oxidative stress which could be relieved with B-12 as it is a powerful nitric oxide scavenger. She was also of the opinion that neurological symptoms responded to B-12 therapy in the infrequent cases of subclinical PA. In recent decades, CFS/FM support group councilors have commented on the prevalence of client reports which made mention of family members who received B-12 injections. They also noted that some clients claimed that B-12 injections cleared their “brain fog”.67 It is a paradox that CFS/FM members are rarely diagnosed with clinical PA.

The above clinical patient research data provides good reason to extend the current investigative diagnostic parameters of CFS/FM patients.47 Avitaminosis and mild PEM should be included in the assessment of gastrointestinal conditions. Genetic disorders of tryptophan and Vitamin B-12 status should be tested for, to exclude neurologic PA and other aberrations. Search for unexpected silent or chronic infections is required.2,48–50 In conclusion, the presence of nutritional3,31,68 and thyroid deficiencies and unsuspected infections offer a rational explanation as to the etiology of the patient’s signs and symptoms, such as ataxia, pain, paresthesias, and dysphorias.55

Nutritional Status and Convalescence Outcome

The study of tryptophan/kynurenine ratio imbalance in chronic disorder has added explanatory detail to the catabolic use of protein in the urea-nitrogen cycle.1,69 However, a consensus reviewer report70 on adult starvation and disease related malnutrition, considered the varied definitions of malnutrition syndromes to be unsatisfactory. They proposed a simplified framework to incorporate the contemporary notion of the inflammatory response.69 Their three recommended groups are:

  1. Chronic starvation without inflammation;
  2. “Chronic disease-related malnutrition” with lower levels of inflammation; and
  3. “Acute disease or injury response” with severe inflammation.

PEM has been studied mainly in developing countries where malnutrition retards physical and mental development in childhood.17,40 Neonates and infants have matured kynurenine pathways which can be activated by physical stressors71,72 and therefore tryptophan deficiencies can become a contributor to PEM and its complications. The normal process of convalescence is disrupted when infections, such as malaria and measles, convert subclinical malnutrition into an overt Kwashiorkor within a latent interval of a couple of months.17 Researchers have looked into nutritional treatments in both subclinical and illness phases of PEM.73–75 High quality tryptophan food supplements can be useful73 and anabolic support might produce better outcomes in acutely sick infants.72 Children with PEM appear to possess an altered disposition in their utilization of medications, although some of the outcomes of their therapies remained inconclusive.42 It has been observed that the efficacy of vaccinations is reduced76 and their cytokine profile can be altered by PEM with inflammatory consequences.77,78

In adult illness situations, undernourished surgical patients are at increased risk of developing complications and hence experience a longer recovery period.40,79 Aggressive preoperative nutritional support can reduce adverse perioperative events.40 Additionally, adequate nutritional support may enhance the quality of life in patients undergoing radiotherapy even if their prospects of longevity are unchanged.40 Chronic renal disease is another example of an impoverished nutritional state where acute or subclinical infections can readily complicate the primary condition of the patient.80

These above examples collectively demonstrate that in patient populations, pre-existing nutritional deficiencies from numerous different causes can distort and extend the convalescent phase of any acute injury or illness, or result in chronic morbidity.3

The question arises in neurasthenia, a post-infective phase of convalescence81,82 whether it is an equivalent entity to the post-infection nutritional decline observed in Kwashiorkor. An increased understanding of the substrate requirements of activated metabolic pathways in health and disease should enable researchers to pinpoint compensatory anabolic support constituents with greater accuracy.

Conclusion

In illness and health, the body competes for essential metabolic substrates to achieve equilibrium. Significant substrate deficiencies can be created by the additional demands1,17,40,69 imposed on the body by neoplastic cells,83 micro-organisms (eg, gut saprophytes84–86 and B-12 requirements of the blind loop syndrome),53 undue physical exertion by the ill patient, and interference by metabolic activity of medications (eg, isoniazid).16,17,40,53 The resultant upregulation of the tryptophan kynurenine pathway offers an explanatory model for an immunological connection between malnutrition and infection, and for the pathophysiological and neurological complications of severe trauma and illness, CFS/FM included.1,2

Footnotes

Author Contributions

Wrote the first draft of the manuscript: AB. Agree with manuscript results and conclusions: AB. Developed the structure and arguments for the paper: AB. Made critical revisions and approved final version: AB. All authors reviewed and approved of the final manuscript.

Competing Interests

Author(s) disclose no potential conflicts of interest.

Disclosures and Ethics

As a requirement of publication author(s) have provided to the publisher signed confirmation of compliance with legal and ethical obligations including but not limited to the following: authorship and contributorship, conflicts of interest, privacy and confidentiality and (where applicable) protection of human and animal research subjects. The authors have read and confirmed their agreement with the ICMJE authorship and conflict of interest criteria. The authors have also confirmed that this article is unique and not under consideration or published in any other publication, and that they have permission from rights holders to reproduce any copyrighted material. Any disclosures are made in this section. The external blind peer reviewers report no conflicts of interest.

Funding

Author(s) disclose no funding sources.

References