Message 124949 - Python tracker (original) (raw)

webbrowser.open (and two aliases):

  1. document return value, which seems to be: True if a browser tab or window is opened, regardless of whether or not the url is found; False otherwise.

  2. document that (on Windows, at least) the default browser only gets used if a non .htm(l) url starts with 'www' or 'http:'.

This is true because os.startfile(url) apparently only works if above is true, as required for the Start/Run box to recognize an entry as a url.

In particular, I have Firefox as default and 'www.google.com' and 'http://bugs.python.org' get opened in Firefox (new tab as requested). However, 'google.com' and 'bugs.python.org' open with IE after some delay. [Start/run either opens with Firefox or reports 'cannot find'.]

In the longer run, what I would really like is for webbrowser to be better at using the default or finding executables.

I thought of adding 'http://' if not present but that would disable opening files in a file browser.

I suspect there is a registry entry but do not know what it is. That would also pick up new browswers like Chrome.

It seems to me that the current behavior is a 'limitation' in this code:

# Detect some common Windows browsers, fallback to IE
iexplore = os.path.join(os.environ.get("PROGRAMFILES", "C:\\Program Files"),
                        "Internet Explorer\\IEXPLORE.EXE")
for browser in ("firefox", "firebird", "seamonkey", "mozilla",
                "netscape", "opera", iexplore):
    if _iscommand(browser):
        register(browser, None, BackgroundBrowser(browser))

Firefox is not being recognized as a command because _iscommand('firefox') does not not see firefox.exe as an executable because it only checks _isexecutable() in the hodgepodge list of paths in PATH. At one time (but no longer), executables were ofter put in c:/windows, which by default is in PATH.

Since you hardcoded the default real path for iexplore (C:\Program Files\"Internet Explorer\IEXPLORE.EXE"), you could do the same for other programs:

firefox = os.path.join(os.environ.get("PROGRAMFILES", "C:\Program Files"), "Mozilla Firefox\firefox.exe")