[Python-Dev] Need a way to test for 8-bit-or-unicode-string (original) (raw)

Barry A. Warsaw barry@zope.com
Fri, 5 Oct 2001 12:30:34 -0400

"GvR" == Guido van Rossum <guido@python.org> writes:

GvR> I'm currently +1 on introducing names for abstract base
GvR> classes *and* extensing isinstance()'s API.

I'm worried about the abstract base class idea, because it might lead us down a path of having a complicated class hierarchy in order to provide completeness.

E.g. should "strings" be a sequencebase, as well as a stringbase? And what does a sequencebase /mean/?

Will we push to try to include protocols/interfaces into this mix, so that we'll end up defining abstract classes for all the deep-mojo interfaces? Maybe we'll want to have abstract base classes for file objects so things like file and StringIO's can have them as a common base class?

In any event, I think the isinstance() extension is a simple, clean, and (mostly :) uncontroversial change, so I'm also +1 on doing that now.

Adding a set of abstract base classes and hooking them up with the existing concrete data types seems much murkier to me, and of greater long range impact, so I'm -1 on the idea, at least until it gets PEP'd.

-Barry