[Python-Dev] nonstandard behavior of reflected functions (original) (raw)

Darren Dale dsdale24 at gmail.com
Sun Oct 18 16:50:51 CEST 2009

According to http://docs.python.org/reference/datamodel.html , the reflected operands functions like radd "are only called if the left operand does not support the corresponding operation and the operands are of different types. [3] For instance, to evaluate the expression x - y, where y is an instance of a class that has an rsub() method, y.rsub(x) is called if x.sub(y) returns NotImplemented."

Consider the following simple example:

========================== class Quantity(object):

def __add__(self, other):
    return '__add__ called'

def __radd__(self, other):
    return '__radd__ called'

class UnitQuantity(Quantity):

def __add__(self, other):
    return '__add__ called'

def __radd__(self, other):
    return '__radd__ called'

print 'Quantity()+Quantity()', Quantity()+Quantity() print 'UnitQuantity()+UnitQuantity()', UnitQuantity()+UnitQuantity() print 'UnitQuantity()+Quantity()', UnitQuantity()+Quantity() print 'Quantity()+UnitQuantity()', Quantity()+UnitQuantity()

The output should indicate that add was called in all four trials, but the last trial calls radd. Interestingly, if I comment out the definition of radd in UnitQuantity, then the fourth trial calls add like it should.

I think this may be an important bug. I'm running Python 2.6.4rc1 (r264rc1:75270, Oct 13 2009, 17:02:06) an ubuntu Karmic. Is it a known issue, or am I misreading the documentation?

Thanks, Darren

More information about the Python-Dev mailing list