[Python-Dev] pep 362 - 5th edition (original) (raw)

Yury Selivanov yselivanov.ml at gmail.com
Tue Jun 19 18:38:38 CEST 2012

On 2012-06-19, at 11:55 AM, Ethan Furman wrote:

Yury Selivanov wrote:

Hello, The new revision of PEP 362 has been posted: http://www.python.org/dev/peps/pep-0362/ Summary: 1. What was 'Signature.deepcopy' is now 'Signature.copy'. copy creates a shallow copy of Signature, shallow copying its Parameters as well. 2. 'Signature.format()' was removed. I think we'll add something to customize formatting later, in 3.4. Although, Signature still has its str method. 3. Built-in ('C') functions no longer have mutable 'signature' attribute, that patch was reverted. In the "Design Considerations" section we stated clear that we don't support some callables. 4. Positions of keyword-only parameters now longer affect equality testing of Signatures, i.e. 'foo(, a, b)' is equal to 'foo(, b, a)' (Thanks to Jim Jewett for pointing that out) The only question we have now is: when we do equality test between Signatures, should we account for positional-only, varpositional and varkeyword arguments names? So that: 'foo(*args)' will be equal to 'bar(*arguments)', but not to 'spam(*coordinates:int)' (Again, I think that's a Jim's idea) There are obviously cases where the names should be considered (such as foo(source, dest) and bar(dest, source) ) and cases where it should not be (spam(text, count) and eggs(txt, cnt) )... I think the default implementation should be strict (names are considered) as it is safer to have a false negative than a false positive.

+1

However, rather than force everyone who is willing to cope with the possible false positives from rewriting a Signature equality routine that ignores names, perhaps a method can be added to the class that does so?

class Signature: . . . def equivalent(self, other): "compares two Signatures for equality (ignores parameter names)" . . .

I don't think that comparing signatures will be a common operation, so maybe we can postpone adding any additional methods for that?

More information about the Python-Dev mailing list