6. Path Selection with BGP (original) (raw)

Connected: An Internet Encyclopedia
6. Path Selection with BGP

Up: Connected: An Internet Encyclopedia
Up: Requests For Comments
Up: RFC 1772

Prev: 5. Policy Making with BGP
Next: 7. Required set of supported routing policies

6. Path Selection with BGP

One of the major tasks of a BGP speaker is to evaluate different paths from itself to a set of destination covered by an address prefix, select the best one, apply appropriate policy constraints, and then advertise it to all of its BGP neighbors. The key issue is how different paths are evaluated and compared. In traditional distance vector protocols (e.g., RIP) there is only one metric (e.g., hop count) associated with a path. As such, comparison of different paths is reduced to simply comparing two numbers. A complication in Inter-AS routing arises from the lack of a universally agreed-upon metric among AS's that can be used to evaluate external paths. Rather, each AS may have its own set of criteria for path evaluation.

A BGP speaker builds a routing database consisting of the set of all feasible paths and the list of destinations (expressed as address prefixes) reachable through each path. For purposes of precise discussion, it's useful to consider the set of feasible paths for a set of destinations associated with a given address prefix. In most cases, we would expect to find only one feasible path. However, when this is not the case, all feasible paths should be maintained, and their maintenance speeds adaptation to the loss of the primary path. Only the primary path at any given time will ever be advertised.

The path selection process can be formalized by defining a complete order over the set of all feasible paths to a set of destinations associated with a given address prefix. One way to define this complete order is to define a function that maps each full AS path to a non-negative integer that denotes the path's degree of preference. Path selection is then reduced to applying this function to all feasible paths and choosing the one with the highest degree of preference. In actual BGP implementations, the criteria for assigning degree of preferences to a path are specified as configuration information.

The process of assigning a degree of preference to a path can be based on several sources of information:

Information explicitly present in the full AS path.
A combination of information that can be derived from the full AS path and information outside the scope of BGP (e.g., policy routing constraints provided as configuration information).

Possible criteria for assigning a degree of preference to a path are:

AS count. Paths with a smaller AS count are generally better.
Policy considerations. BGP supports policy-based routing based on the controlled distribution of routing information. A BGP speaker may be aware of some policy constraints (both within and outside of its own AS) and do appropriate path selection. Paths that do not comply with policy requirements are not considered further.
Presence or absence of a certain AS or AS's in the path. By means of information outside the scope of BGP, an AS may know some performance characteristics (e.g., bandwidth, MTU, intra- AS diameter) of certain AS's and may try to avoid or prefer them.
Path origin. A path learned entirely from BGP (i.e., whose endpoint is internal to the last AS on the path) is generally better than one for which part of the path was learned via EGP or some other means.
AS path subsets. An AS path that is a subset of a longer AS path to the same destination should be preferred over the longer path. Any problem in the shorter path (such as an outage) will also be a problem in the longer path.
Link dynamics. Stable paths should be preferred over unstable ones. Note that this criterion must be used in a very careful way to avoid causing unnecessary route fluctuation. Generally, any criteria that depend on dynamic information might cause routing instability and should be treated very carefully.

Next: 7. Required set of supported routing policies

Connected: An Internet Encyclopedia
6. Path Selection with BGP