SVG Conformance Suite Implementation Status (original) (raw)

This document describes the results of particular SVG implementations tested against the SVG Conformance Test Suite. The goal is to demonstrate that every part of the SVG Candidate Recommendation specification can be implemented, as required by the SVG Candidate Recommendation exit criteria. For this, each BE test must be passed by at least one implementation.

This is not an exhaustive test of all SVG implementations; the implementations listed here are the ones that were readily available at the time of conformance testing. This is also not a formal test, and thus does not rank the implementations. The purpose is purely to show that the SVG specification can be and has been implemented, and to demonstrate a good degree of interoperability between implementations.

The following table lists the implementations that were tested as well as the particular version of each implementation. You are suggested to check the implementation sites for the latest conformance results.

Test Case Name

Adobe (a)

CSIRO (b)

Batik (c)

Ionic (d)

Jackaroo (e)

JASC (f)

Comments

rendering-orderGr-BE-01

Y

Y

Y

Y

Y

Y

rendering-text-BE-02

Y

Y

Y

Y

Y

Y

rendering-shape-BE-03

Y

Y

Y

Y

Y

Y

structure-empty-BE-01

Y

Y

Y

Y

Y

Y

structure-nested-BE-02

Y

Y

Y

Y

Y

Y

structure-basicG-BE-03

Y

Y

Y

Y

Y

Y

structure-defs-BE-04

Y

Y

Y

Y

Y

Y

structure-symbol-BE-05

Y

Y

Y

Y

N (e)

Y

(e) incorrect symbol placement.

structure-image-BE-06

Mostly (a)

Y

Y

Mostly (d)

Mostly (e)

Mostly (f)

(a) Adobe only fails with 'image' reference to *.svg.
(d) Svg images rendered, but incorrectly. PNG and JPEG images are fine
(e) not SVG images (f) not SVG images

structure-switch-BE-07

N (a)

N (b)

Y

N (d)

N

N (f)

(a) Switch not implemented
(b) CSIRO doesn't support 'switch'.
(d) Switch is supported, but seemingly not requiredFeatures, so test fails - seems odd to have systemLanguage test for English on the switch element itself, too. (f)'switch' not supported

structure-lang-BE-08

N (a)

N (b)

Y (c)

Mostly (d)

Mostly (e)

N

(a) Switch not implemented
(b) Switch not implemented
(c)Correct except for edge case where no user language selected
(d) default case (no test) in switch not being triggered
(e) Two small flaws:1) if no user language not set, default case not trigered 2) uses old 'system-language' not newer 'systemLanguage'.

structure-allElem-BE-09

N (a)

N (b)

Mostly (c)

Y

Mostly (e)

N

(a) Switch not implemented
(b) CSIRO doesn't support 'switch'.
(c) default case not taken.
(e) default case not taken

structure-extRef-BE-10

N (a)

N (b)

Y

Mostly (d)

N

N

(a) Adobe doesn't support external references.
(b) CSIRO doesn't supportsupport external references. (f) external reference displayed, but style handled incorrectly

structure-imggamma-BE-11

Y

N

N

Y

N

N

Java 2D does not use PNG gAMA chunk

style-selector-BE-01

Y

Y

Y

Y

Y

N

style-selector-BE-02

Y

Y

Y

N (d)

Y

N

(d) id and attr selectors not implemented

style-selector-BE-03

Y

Some (b)

Y

N

Y

N

(b) CSIRO supports child but not sibling and first-child selectors

coords-units-BE-01

Y

Y

Y

Some (d)

Y

Mostly (f)

(d) em and ex treated as px (f) em and percent incorrect

coords-transforms-BE-02

Y

Y

Y

Y

Y

Y

coords-viewBox-BE-03

Y

Y

Y

Y

some (e)

N

(e) no clip with 'slice'

coords-unitsProc-BE-04

Y

Y

Y

N (d)

Y

Some (f)

(d) all percent to user conversion tests failed (f) passes subtests 1, 3 and 5

coords-unitsProc-BE-05

Y

Y (b)

Y

Mostly

N

Mostly (f)

path-lines-BE-01

Y

Y

Y

Y

Y

Y

path-curves-BE-02

Y

Y

Y

Y

Y

Y

path-curves-BE-03

Y

Y

Y

Y

Y

Y

path-curves-BE-04

Y

Y

Y

N (d)

Mostly (e)

Some

(d) elliptical arcs incorrect.
(e) MAZ and MAAA wrong
(f) 3 of 6 correct

shapes-rect-BE-01

Y

Y

Y

Mostly (d)

Y

Y

(d) radius of rounded corners 50% of correct value

shapes-ellipse-BE-02

Y

Y

Y

Y

Y

Y

shapes-circle-BE-03

Y

Y

Y

Y

Y

Y

shapes-line-BE-04

Y

Y

Y

Y

Y

Y

shapes-polygon-BE-05

Y

Y

Y

Y

Y

Y

shapes-polyline-BE-06

Y

Y

Y

Y

Y

Y

text-text-BE-01

Y

some (b)

Y

Y

Y

N

(b) CSIRO doesn't do underlines and line-throughs

text-tspan-BE-02

Y

N (b)

Y

Mostly (d)

Y (e)

N

(b) CSIRO hasn't implemented tspan yet.
(e) spacing of last character on line slightly odd.

text-textOnPath-BE-03

Y

N (b)

N

some (d)

N

N

(b) CSIRO hasn't implemented textPath yet.
(d) text not lined up on path. tspan affecting rest of text element? dx and dy not relative to baseline?

text-tref-BE-04

Y

N (b)

Y

N

N

N

(b) CSIRO hasn't implemented tref yet.

text-textAnchor-BE-05

Y

some (b)

some (c)

N

N

N

(b) CSIRO doesn't support textPath
(c) Batik does textPath in a different namespace.

text-whiteSpace-BE-06

Y

Y

Y

Y

Y

Some

text-altGlyph-BE-07

Y

N

N

N

N

N

text-i18n-BE-09

Y

some (b)

some(c)

some (d)

N

N

(b) CSIRO does Polish, Russion and Greek correctly.
(c) Batik does not do vertical text and unicode bidi override
(d) some spacing problems, no tofu for vertical. check number of tofu for Japanese

text-alignment-BE-10

Y

some (b)

N

N

some (e)

N

(b) CSIRO hasn't implemented tspan or baseline-shift (e) text-anchor OK

text-alignment-BE-11

Y

N (b)

N

N

N

N

(b) CSIRO doesn't handle vertical text yet.

text-decoration-BE-12

Y

N

Mostly (c)

Y

Mostly (e)

N

(c) 3/4 correct.
(e) no blue underline on last subtest

text-selection-BE-13

Y

N

Y

N (d)

N (e)

N (f)

(d) no text selection implemented
(e) no text selection implemented
(f) WebDraw is an editor, text selection done through a GUI

text-spacing-BE-14

Y

N (b)

N

N

N

N

text-font-BE-15

Y

Y

Y

Mostly (d)

Y

N

(d) not finding a monospaced font from the list, otherwise ok

text-font-BE-16

Y

N (b)

Mostly (c)

N

Nearly (e)

N

(b) CSIRO doesn't handle font-weights correctly, it also has problems with the style elem.
(c) 'bolder' not bolder
(e) Jackaroo only fails on the lighter CSS value

text-textLength-BE-17

N

Y

N

N

N

N

text-extTref-BE-18

N

N

Y

N

N

N

paint-fill-BE-01

Y

Y (b)

N

Mostly (d)

N

Mostly (f)

(b) CSIRO passes all that are shown, doens't support icc-color (but gets correct color for non-ICC)
(d) Passes all except ICC, which is black.
(f) Passes all except ICC, which is black.

paint-stroke-BE-02

Y

Y

Y

Y

Y

Y

paint-markers-BE-03

N

Y

N

Some (d)

N

Y

(d) does not position marker correctly wrt the marker position (uses top left instead of centre) or rotate correctly wrt path direction

paint-markers-BE-04

N

Y

N

N (d)

N

Y

(d) Draws two out of three markers (start and end of line, not other points); other defects as previous test.

paint-colIntProp-BE-05

Y

N

Y

N (d)

N

Some (f)

(d) nearest neighbor instead of bilinear or bicubic
(f) not linear subtest

paint-inherit-BE-06

Y

Y

Y

Y

Y

Y

color-datatypes-BE-01

Y

Y

Y

Y

Y

Y

color-property-BE-02

Mostly (a)

N

Y

Mostly (d)

N

Mostly (f)

(a) Adobe only supports currentColor on 'fill' and 'stroke'
(d) Ionic only supports currentColor on 'fill' and 'stroke'
(f) gradient incorrect

color-colorProf-BE-03

N (a)

Y

N

N

N

N

(a) Adobe does not yet support 'color-profile' property (added after Aug2 spec)

gradPatt-linearGr-BE-01

Y

Y

Y

Y

Y

Some (f)

(f) Not supported on text

gradPatt-linearGr-BE-02

Y

Y

Y

Mostly

Mostly

Y

gradPatt-linearGr-BE-03

Y

Y

Y

Y

Y

Y

gradPatt-radialGr-BE-04

Y

Y

Y

Y

Y

Some (f)

(f) Not supported on text

gradPatt-radialGr-BE-05

Y

Y

Y

Mostly (d)

Mostly (e)

Y

(d) second test, should be oval not round (object bounding box is not square)
(e) second test is circular not oval

gradPatt-stop-BE-06

Y

Y

Y

Mostly (d)

Y

Mostly (f)

(f) angle of gradient incorrect

gradPatt-pattern-BE-07

Y

almost (b)

Y

Y

N

Some

(b) CSIRO has to update to latest pattern spec

gradPatt-referenc-BE-08

Y

Y

N

Mostly (d)

N

N

gradPatt-transfrm-BE-09

Y

Y

Y

N

N

Mostly

gradPatt-stop-BE-10

Y

Y

Y

N

Y

Mostly (f)

(f) angle of gradient incorrect

masking-clipPath-BE-01

Y

Y

Y

Y

N

N

masking-clipPath-BE-02

Y

Y

Y

N (d)

N

N

(d) clips red rect and most annotation text.

masking-clipRule-BE-03

Y

Y

Y

Y

N

N

masking-groupOpac-BE-04

Y

Y

Y

some (d)

Y

Y

(d) group opacity seems to be assuming all children fully opaque?

masking-mask-BE-05

Y

N

Y

N

N

N

masking-mask-BE-06

Y

N

Y

N

N

N

masking-property-BE-07

Y

N (b)

N

N

N

N

(b) The clip:rect(..) property seems to cause the viewer to go into an infinite loop! CSIRO hasn't implemented the clip property.

masking-clipPath-BE-08

Y

Y (b)

Mostly (c)

N

N

N

(b) CSIRO clipping leaves the clip edges jaggy. Spec states that clipping acts as if a 1-bit mask?
(c) Batik does not implement the hidden overflow value

masking-vportClip-BE-09

Y

Y

Y

N

N

N

filters-many-BE-01

Y

N (b)

Y

N

N

Y (f)

(b) CSIRO hasn't implemented filters.
(f) geometry incorrect due to nested svg element, not germane to test purpose

filters-blend-BE-02

Y

N

Y

N

N

N

filters-colorMtrx-BE-03

Y

N

Y

N

N

Mostly (f)

(f) not saturate test

filters-transfer-BE-04

Y

N

Y

N

N

Mostly (f)

. (f) not table test

filters-composite-BE-05

Y

N

Y

N

N

N

filters-convolve-BE-06

Y

N

Y

N

N

Y

filters-diffuseLt-BE-07

Y

N

Y

N

N

N

filters-specularLt-BE-08

Y

N

Y

N

N

N

filters-lights-BE-09

Y

N

Y

N

N

N

filters-morph-BE-10

Y

N

Y

N

N

Y

filters-turb-BE-11

Y

N

Y

N

N

Y

filters-blur-BE-12

Y

N

Y

N

N

Mostly (f)

(f) no clipping to object bounding box

filters-feImage-BE-13

Y

N

Y

N

N

N

filters-feTile-BE-14

Y

N

Y

N

N

N

filters-merge-BE-15

Y

N

Y

N

N

Some (f)

(f) not aligned with crosshairs, correct color and opacity

filters-dispMap-BE-16

Y

N

Y (c)

N

N

Some (f)

(c) Batik displays PNG with incorrect gamma, but does displacement correctly.
(f) geometry incorrect, incorrect gamma

interact-zoomPan-BE-01

Y

Y

N

N (d)

N (e)

N (f)

(d) does not disable zoom/pan
(e) n/a - not a dynamic viewer
(f) n/a - editor, not a dynamic viewer

interact-zoomPan-BE-02

Y

Y

Y

Y

N (e)

Y

(e) n/a - not a dynamic viewer

interact-bubble-BE-04

Y

some (b)

N

N

N (e)

N (f)

(b) CSIRO hasn't implemented tspan, linking works (when target file is renamed), the onmouseover and onmouseout events don't seem to be working and the bubbling seems to always occur.
(e) n/a - not a dynamic viewer
(f) n/a - editor, not a dynamic viewer

interact-pEvents-BE-05

Y

N

N

N

N (e)

N (f)

(e) n/a - not a dynamic viewer
(f) n/a - editor, not a dynamic viewer

interact-pEvents-BE-06

Y

N

N

N

N (e)

N

(e) n/a - not a dynamic viewer

interact-onload-BE-07

Y

N

N

N

N (e)

N

(e) n/a - not a dynamic viewer

interact-cursor-BE-08

N

Y

N

N

N

N

linking-outBound-BE-01

Mostly (a)

some (b)

Y

N (d)

some (e)

N

(a) Works except for link to internal object
(b)(e) CSIRO and Jackaroo only support linking to external SVG files.
(d) No hyperlinking implemented

linking-xlinkAttr-BE-02

Y

Y (b)

Y

N

N

N

(b) CSIRO only uses the xlink:href attribute at the moment, others are ignored.

linking-inBound-BE-03

N

Y

N

N

N

N

linking-view-BE-04

N

Y

N

N

N

N

linking-view-BE-05

N

Y

N

N

N

N

script-eventDom-BE-01

Y

Y

N

N (d)

Y

N

(d) Gives 'test passed' without any interaction

script-uiEvents-BE-02

Y

Some (b)

N

N

N

N

(b) CSIRO only catches the onmousedown, onmouseup, onclick and onmousemove events.

animation-overall-BE-01

Y

Some (b)

N

Mostly (d)

N

N (f)

(b) CSIRO hasn't implemented animateMotion yet.
(d) rotate not done on text, animation should freeze not repeat
(f) No animation editing capability

animation-href-BE-02

Y

N

N

Some (d)

N

N

(d) repeats, no interactivity so should not trigger

animation-targetElt-BE-03

Y

Y

N

N

N

N

animation-targetAtt-BE-04

Y

Y

N

Mostly (d)

N

N

(d) repeats forever rather than freezing; other than that, correct

animation-timing-BE-05

Y

N

N

N

N

N

animation-values-BE-06

Y

Some (b)

N

N

N

N

(b) CSIRO hasn't implemented animateMotion or spline calcMode , for discrete and linear calcModes CSIRO requires a keyTimes attribute.

animation-values-BE-07

Y

Some

N

N

N

N

animation-values-BE-08

Y

Some

N

N

N

N

animation-add-BE-09

Y

N

N

Some (d)

N

N

(d) does some repeats then stops, bars don't come to right place

animation-inherit-BE-10

Y

N

N

Mostly (d)

N

N

(d) repeats forever rather than freezing; other than that, correct

animation-motion-BE-11

Y

Y

N

N

N

N

animation-motion-BE-12

Y

Y

N

N

N

N

animation-extRef-BE-13

N

Y

N

N

N

N

fonts-fontElement-BE-01

Y

Y

N

N

N

N

metadata-sample-BE-01

Y

N (b)

N

Y

N (e)

Y

(b) CSIRO viewer fails because the SVG doesn't validate (but it isn't supposed to!)
(e) fails due to clipPath, not germane to test purpose

extend-multiNS-BE-01

Y

N

N

N

N (e)

N

(e) n/a - not a dynamic viewer

dom-core-BE-01

Y

Y (b)

N

N

N (e)

N

(b) CSIRO doesn't make the document object available too easily!
(e) n/a - not a dynamic viewer

dom-svg-BE-02

Some

Y (b)

N

N

N (e)

N

(b) CSIRO passes this test using the Java language bindings rather than the ECMAScript bindings.
(e) n/a - not a dynamic viewer

dom-featureString-BE-03

Y

Y

N

N

N (e)

N

(e) n/a - not a dynamic viewer

dom-eventListener-BE-04

Y

N

N (c)

N

N (e)

N

(c) Batik may pass if another event was used?
(e) n/a - not a dynamic viewer

Total (Pass/Num.Tests)

127/127