'Furiosa' Review - George Miller Attempts the Impossible (original) (raw)
Anya Taylor Joy holding a gun in Furiosa: A Mad Max Saga
Image via Warner Bros.
Updated Aug 16, 2024, 10:00 AM EDT
Therese Lacson is a Senior TV Editor who has been with Collider since 2021. She got started in this business over ten years ago working primarily as an interviewer and critic. At Collider, she works closely with the features team to support the writers and also ideates and develops content daily. She has covered major industry events including Cannes Film Festival, Sundance Film Festival, SXSW, Toronto International Film Festival, and San Diego Comic-Con. Although she reviews and covers both film and television, her focus is in television and her expertise is in fantasy and sci-fi genre shows. Her favorite shows to cover include House of the Dragon, Bridgerton, Fallout, 9-1-1, and Rivals.
Sign in to your Collider account
Summary
- Furiosa: A Mad Max Saga showcases George Miller's best character work, despite being burdened by excess details.
- Anya Taylor-Joy and Alyla Browne excel at portraying the two versions of Furiosa, embodying Theron's character flawlessly.
- Chris Hemsworth struggles to fully sink into his character, still feeling like a Marvel character rather than a full villain.
Long before we ever stepped foot on the Fury Road with Charlize Theron's Furiosa and Tom Hardy's Max Rockatansky, director George Miller and co-writer Nico Lathouris first spent years laying out the backstory of the world of Mad Max, including the life and origins of Imperator Furiosa. It was this screenplay of Furiosa's story that Theron would read as a background for her character, and after the success of Mad Max: Fury Road, Furiosa: A Mad Max Saga seemed like the obvious next choice, especially with a screenplay ready to go. After COVID delays and scheduling conflicts, the film is finally on our doorstep. It's no secret that although Hardy's Max had his own silent, brooding charm, Furiosa was the star of Fury Road. Her journey was at the center of the story as she tried to escape with the five wives of Immortan Joe (Hugh Keays-Byrne) to take them to the Green Place. Furiosa's character struck a chord with viewers, as much as the non-stop high-octane action did.
As is the way with Hollywood, I went into this prequel with some apprehension. After all, this is an industry obsessed with franchises, and Fury Road felt so original back when it first came out in 2015; it was one of my favorite films of that year and remains one of my favorite action films of all time. It was hard to imagine how this film might best that or top what already seemed like perfection. However, it's clear that with Furiosa, Miller is trying to tell a different story than the one you might expect. And depending on your expectations, Furiosa could either be an epic origin story for this beloved character, or it can be caught in the shadow of its more stylistic predecessor.
The origin story of renegade warrior Furiosa before her encounter and team-up with Mad Max.
Release Date
May 24, 2024
Director
George Miller
Writers
George Miller, Nico Lathouris
Sequel(s)
Mad Max: The Wasteland
Franchise(s)
Mad Max
Main Genre
Studio(s)
Warner Bros. Pictures
Distributor(s)
Warner Bros. Pictures
How Does 'Furiosa' Hold Up to 'Fury Road'?
Furiosa with an enraged expression looking down at someone in Furiosa.
Image via Warner Bros.
Let's just get this out of the way first. The comparisons will be inevitable. Not only are these two films Miller's more recent works, but they are naturally tied together. However, these are two very different films. One of the main differences is timing. While Fury Road takes place over a matter of days, if not hours, Furiosa takes place over the span of years, nearly two decades. Fury Road plunges us immediately into the deep end, engulfing us in the hot flames of Immortan Joe's caravan, whereas Furiosa starts more conventionally. It starts from the beginning of Furiosa's story when she was a little girl (played by an unmatched Alyala Browne) and leads up through her kidnapping and her years with the Warlord Dementus (a lackluster Chris Hemsworth) and through to her time as an adult (an explosive Anya Taylor-Joy) becoming the Imperator for Immortan Joe (now played by Lachy Hulme). Because of the nature of this story, the pacing and tone are completely different from the previous one. The heart-pounding action that was Fury Road is not fully present here, and in some respects, the story is weaker for it.
It's clear that Miller has a vision for Furiosa and has dedicated many years to her creation. She's fully fleshed out in a way Max never has been, and this origin story feels like one of mythic proportions, with parables being bounced around as we watch Furiosa learn time and time again that the Wasteland will take everything from her. However, there is such a thing as too much information, and unfortunately, Furiosa falls victim to a problem that Fury Road never had. There are parts of the film that feel like a pure info dump, like Miller is filling in a picture that's better left bare. For anyone who has ever been curious about the world of Mad Max and, more specifically, about the war for dominance between the Warlords, prepare to have your curiosity sated.
Speaking of these warlords, the newly introduced Dementus pales in comparison to Immortan Joe. While Joe feels like a nightmarish inevitability, with his zealous warboys and obsession with breeding, Dementus feels more like a pesky cockroach who simply won't die. Yes, he's cruel, and he is sadistic, but who isn't in this world? Furiosa's grudge against him is personal, but once that is taken away, Dementus feels flimsy. Joe had a robust supporting cast to instantly fill out his development without Miller needing to do much explaining, but Dementus is often seen monologuing, obsessed with his own voice and power. Considering that both Browne and Taylor-Joy are so compelling on screen, Dementus is unnecessary, and he quickly overstays his welcome. It was jarring to me, going into Furiosa and expecting the action I got in Fury Road only to get a much more unevenly paced film. Thematically, Fury Road is a story about redemption and triumph over an oppressive force, while Furiosa is about revenge and a total loss of innocence. The two stories serve different purposes.
Related
The Best Movie To Escape Development Hell Was Worth the Wait
The George Miller action-adventure movie had a long journey to the big screen that ended up paying off.
'Furiosa' Breaks an Origin Story Up Into Chapters
Chris Hemsworth behind the wheel in Furiosa: A Mad Max Saga
Image via Warner Bros.
Typically, we might see the rising action, climax, and falling action throughout the entire length of a film, but Furiosa breaks this up into five chapters. The result of separating the story into parts means that the runtime of 148 minutes feels more noticeable; the pacing for some chapters is relentless and energizing, while others feel like slow burns. The episodic nature of this format might not appeal to everyone as it robs the film of a more cinematic quality. In the first chapter, a young Furiosa is kidnapped, and we are plunged into action immediately. Her mother, Mary Jo Bassa (Charlee Fraser), acts as a one-woman army — following her daughter's captors from the Green Place all the way back to their camp. This is, by far, one of the most tense sequences. We know that Furiosa will eventually end up as an Imperator, so there's a looming dread that, despite all of Mary Jo's determination, ultimately, she will fail. It's equally frustrating to watch a young Furiosa make the mistakes that will lead to her capture, knowing that they are reasonable for a child while also wishing that she'd make the "right" choice instead.
Each segment of Furiosa plays with tone. While the opening chapter is about Furiosa's introduction to the Wasteland, the subsequent chapters follow her as she learns bitter lessons from the cruel Dementus. Her time with Dementus is marked by anarchy and survival, at all costs. Furiosa witnesses Dementus' brutality firsthand and is largely silent, an observer and student to his brand of ruling over his gang. This chaos comes in stark contrast to the order of Immortan Joe's gang. As a girl, it's nauseating to watch Furiosa get lecherously eyed by Rictus (Nathan Jones), only for her to realize that the only way to survive as a woman with Immortan Joe is to eventually become one of his wives. The film culminates when she meets Praetorian Jack (Tom Burke). Her life changes as the story takes a sharp romantic shift. As she becomes determined to escape Joe's and run away to the Green Place with Jack, the conflict between the Warlords catches up to them. Consumed by her need for vengeance at this point, we finally see the full transformation, taking us from a precocious young girl into the enigmatic woman we first meet watching Fury Road.
What works with Furiosa is how detailed the telling of her story is. Furiosa is an intrinsically interesting character and I always felt like I was rushing to get back to her story in this film. The problem is that Furiosa isn't just about Furiosa. The lore of the war between Warlords fills up a lot of time, and honestly, Dementus, Immortan Joe, and the other characters at Gas Town and the Bullet Farm simply aren't interesting enough to warrant the time they get on screen. The politics at play drag the story down, and I get the sense that Miller might have had a more svelte story if this extra fat was trimmed away. As valuable as the information about the politics of Gas Town and the Bullet Farm is for the actors, the viewer does not need to know so much information. Adding these elements dilutes Furiosa's story of vengeance.
Alyla Browne and Anya Taylor-Joy Are Magnificent as Furiosa
The absolute highlight of the film has to be the two actors leading the film, and, no, I'm not talking about Anya Taylor-Joy and Chris Hemsworth. Though much of the marketing for this film centers around Taylor-Joy's older Furiosa, a large part of the movie sees Alyla Browne's young Furiosa as our leading character, so much so that, at one point, I forgot Taylor-Joy was even in the film. Browne has the potential to go far in this industry as the young actor easily slips in and out of the different phases of Furiosa's life. The transition from Browne to Taylor-Joy is also incredibly seamless. The two actors are chameleons and when Taylor-Joy takes the lead, there are moments when she looks and acts so much like Charlize Theron that it feels like there's some movie magic at work to meld the two together. But there is not. That's all talent, and it's impressive, to say the least.
What is also a surprise is the natural romantic chemistry Taylor-Joy has with Tom Burke as Jack. The effect is instantaneous. The moment they meet, that chemistry crackles off the screen. Though the relationship feels a bit forced and needs more development to make it feel less rushed, Burke and Taylor-Joy make up for those shortcomings. The two characters can tell a whole story by simply sitting next to each other on a war rig, and it is reminiscent of Max and Furiosa in Fury Road, where the tension is so palpable there's no need for dialogue.
Unfortunately, where the film falters is with its other star, the aforementioned Chris Hemsworth. Complete with a giant nose prosthetic that feels both unnecessary and also does little to hide Hemsworth's natural swooniness — Dementus is not a role that Hemsworth slips into easily. The character is over-the-top, braggadocious, and ambitious, but the performance never slips into the truly sinister as it should. It's difficult to see the performance and not see Thor, God of Thunder, and Avenger underneath it all. From the washboard abs to the red cape, the costuming does Hemsworth no favors. He sticks out like a sore thumb and by the time we pass the midpoint of the film, his character feels extraneous. It's not that Hemsworth isn't leaning into Dementus, he is, but this character simply seems to be an ill fit for the actor. Unlike Charlize Theron in Monster or even Colin Farrell in The Batman who became essentially unrecognizable for the role, there are times when Dementus just looks like Chris Hemsworth in the Wasteland being an asshole. The film did not do enough to buff away the Marvel shine.
'Furiosa' Stands Strong on Its Own, But Still Lacks the Spark It Needs
I have no doubt that there will be fierce Furiosa defenders. At my screening alone, there were people saying Furiosa is better than Fury Road. And, to some extent, Miller deserves this praise; Furiosa deserves this praise. For the first time in this franchise, the story is centered around a female character and feels so wholly fleshed out and explored it's brilliant. But Furiosa still lacks a spark. It's being weighed down by Miller's world-building, doing a disservice to Furiosa's origin.
The production design is still as amazing as it was in the first film, but Miller's vision lacks refinement here. Cinematographer Simon Duggan (The Great Gatsby, 300: Rise of an Empire) does not have the same sweeping visual eye that John Seale had in Fury Road. We lose some of the size and scope of these battles on war rigs and the roaming caravans of bandits. Fury Road is undoubtedly an action flick first, but Furiosa is much more of a character study. Similarly, while Junkie XL returns as the composer, there are whole chase sequences and action sequences that are devoid of his heart-pounding compositions that had me wondering, "Why are we sitting here in silence?"
At the end of the day, perhaps if Furiosa was released first, plunging us into Furiosa's introduction without knowing where she'd end up, the film would have had a stronger impact. But because it is a prequel, it will struggle under the shadow of a film that is technically and cinematically superior. Held up by Alyla Browne and Anya Taylor-Joy as stellar leads, Furiosa can be inspiring at the best of times — an Edmond Dantès-level story about revenge. But, at the worst of times, the film feels as bloated and unwieldy as The People Eater, dragged down by too many ideas. Does the good outweigh the bad? Just barely, but not enough to dethrone its predecessor.
Furiosa: A Mad Max Saga
Furiosa's prequel film shines with Anya Taylor-Joy and Alyala Browne, but is weighed down by too much story.
Release Date
May 24, 2024
Pros & Cons
Anya Taylor-Joy and Alyla Browne are fantastic as Furiosa, blending perfectly into Charlize Theron's original character.
Taylor-Joy and Tom Burke have amazing chemistry, making an underdeveloped segment of the story sing despite shortcomings.
Furiosa is George Miller's best and most well-developed character.
Furiosa is far too long, weighed down by too much info dumping.
Not enough is done to make Chris Hemsworth unrecognizable, weakening his performance.
Furiosa: A Mad Max Saga is now available to stream on Max in the U.S.