Every John Cazale Movie, Ranked (original) (raw)
Poster for the documentary I Knew It Was You: Rediscovering John Cazale
Image via HBO
Published Jan 7, 2024, 8:00 PM EST
Jeremy has more than 2500 published articles on Collider to his name, and has been writing for the site since February 2022. He's an omnivore when it comes to his movie-watching diet, so will gladly watch and write about almost anything, from old Godzilla films to gangster flicks to samurai movies to classic musicals to the French New Wave to the MCU... well, maybe not the Disney+ shows.
His favorite directors include Martin Scorsese, Sergio Leone, Akira Kurosawa, Quentin Tarantino, Werner Herzog, John Woo, Bob Fosse, Fritz Lang, Guillermo del Toro, and Yoji Yamada. He's also very proud of the fact that he's seen every single Nicolas Cage movie released before 2022, even though doing so often felt like a tremendous waste of time. He's plagued by the question of whether or not The Room is genuinely terrible or some kind of accidental masterpiece, and has been for more than 12 years (and a similar number of viewings).
When he's not writing lists - and the occasional feature article - for Collider, he also likes to upload film reviews to his Letterboxd profile (username: Jeremy Urquhart) and Instagram account.
He has achieved his 2025 goal of reading all 13,467 novels written by Stephen King, and plans to spend the next year or two getting through the author's 82,756 short stories and 105,433 novellas.
Sign in to your Collider account
A great deal has been written about the tragically short yet remarkably strong filmography of the late John Cazale, as has a short tribute documentary produced by HBO called I Knew It Was You: Rediscovering John Cazale. He acted in theater throughout the 1960s, and then found success in the film industry during the 1970s, having key supporting roles in five films released between 1972 and 1978, though Cazale regrettably passed away from lung cancer in the latter year, at just 42 years old.
These five movies (plus another featuring archival footage of him released after his death) were all nominated for Best Picture, and three of them ended up winning. He worked with three remarkable filmmakers and various actors who can be counted among the best of all time, and Cazale himself may have become just as legendary had he lived longer. He remains well-known for having one of the most high-quality bodies of work among any actor, featuring in nothing but classics during his short time working in film. This makes ranking several excellent movies difficult, but that's what the following attempts to do, starting with the great and ending with the greatest.
6 Honorable Mention: 'The Godfather: Part III' (1990)
Director: Francis Ford Coppola
Fredo going fishing in The Godfather: Part II (1974)
Image via Paramount Pictures
When looking at all the movies John Cazale appeared in, there’s some doubt over whether it’s worth highlighting The Godfather: Part III. One could argue the fact he only appears in it through archival footage disqualifies the film, and some may also claim that it’s simply not all that great as a sequel, or at least not nearly as good as the second installment in what’s now known as The Godfather trilogy. But at the same time, his character’s absence from the plot after the tragic ending of the second movie does feel undeniably powerful and eerie.
Further, The Godfather: Part III was also a Best Picture nominee, meaning that if one discusses it within the context of Cazale’s legacy, it shows he technically appeared in six Best Picture nominees, rather than five. So, take it or leave it. Fredo is seen in flashback, even if he’s not directly involved with the main storyline revolving around Michael Corleone’s desperate quest for redemption, and director Francis Ford Coppola chose to incorporate that old footage to both honor Cazale’s involvement in the series and remind viewers how deeply Michael had tumbled morally.
The Godfather: Part III
Release Date
December 25, 1990
Director
Francis Ford Coppola
Cast
Al Pacino, Talia Shire, Eli Wallach, Joe Mantegna, Diane Keaton, Andy Garcia
Runtime
162
Main Genre
Crime
5 'The Conversation' (1974)
Director: Francis Ford Coppola
John Cazale as Stan looking concerned as he puts on his jacket in Francis Ford Coppola's The Conversation (1974)
Image via Paramount Pictures
Francis Ford Coppola released two movies in 1974, with one of them winning Best Picture at the Oscars, and the other – The Conversation – winning a Palme d’Or at the Cannes Film Festival. Both featured John Cazale, too, suggesting he was one of Coppola’s favorite actors at the time. In The Conversation, Cazale is second-billed behind only Gene Hackman, who plays the protagonist: a surveillance expert who believes, while on a job, that he hears evidence that a couple are in danger, and so becomes obsessed with trying to save them. Cazale’s an associate of Hackman’s character who also gets roped into the whole thing.
It's a movie that’s unsurprisingly heavy on paranoia and tension, working as a slow, understated, yet engrossing thriller that’s continually intriguing, even if it’s not the kind of thrill-ride people would call particularly explosive or action-packed. Gene Hackman and John Cazale aren’t the only noteworthy actors who appear here, either, given a particularly young Harrison Ford has a small role, and Robert Duvall – best-known for being in Coppola’s The Godfather movies as well as Apocalypse Now – even has an uncredited cameo.
Release Date
April 7, 1974
Runtime
113 minutes
Director
Francis Ford Coppola
Main Genre
4 'The Deer Hunter' (1978)
Director: Michael Cimino
John Cazale as Stanley in Michael Cimino's The Deer Hunter (1978)
Image via Universal Pictures
Like The Conversation, The Deer Hunter is another great movie featuring John Cazale as one part of a remarkable cast. This iconic and heartbreaking Vietnam War movie centers on a group of friends, and tracks how their experience of fighting in Vietnam changes their outlooks on life, as well as their psychological well-being. Robert De Niro is the film’s central character, though Christopher Walken tends to steal most of the scenes he appears in, with a memorably Oscar-winning supporting role; similarly, the film itself won Best Picture.
It was also one of the first big movies Meryl Streep appeared in, and she’d go on to win an Oscar for the following year’s Best Picture winner, Kramer vs. Kramer. Streep and Cazale never married, but they were partners from 1976 until his passing in 1978, the same year The Deer Hunter came out (a posthumous release for Cazale). He plays a friend of the main characters, yet doesn’t go off to Vietnam, meaning he ultimately clashes with and doesn’t fully understand the experiences of the now-veterans after they return to civilian life. The already sad story of The Deer Hunter is made sadder, knowing John Cazale never got to see the finished film, but it’s a great performance, and he remains one reason why the overall movie is so compelling.
Release Date
February 23, 1979
Runtime
183 minutes
Director
Michael Cimino
3 'Dog Day Afternoon' (1975)
Director: Sidney Lumet
John Cazale and Al Pacino as Sal Naturile and Sonny Wortzik, looking frazzled in a room in Dog Day Afternoon
Image via Warner Bros.
Similar to how he played the most significant supporting role in The Conversation, John Cazale was billed behind only an Oscar-nominated Al Pacino in Dog Day Afternoon, a classic crime movie about a bank robbery that spirals dramatically out of control. Sonny (Pacino) is in charge, more or less, with Sal (Cazale) being there for support, though neither seems particularly skilled at the task they’ve given themselves. Once the police show up, the attempted robbery turns into more of a hostage situation, and then things get even wilder when the media finds out about the whole situation.
Dog Day Afternoon ended up being Cazale’s penultimate film, and the first he appeared in that wasn’t directed by Francis Ford Coppola; instead, it was directed by the similarly legendary Sidney Lumet. It might well be the film of his where he has the most screen time, but maybe not the most dialogue, given Sal is particularly quiet and seems more sensitive than the louder and more confident (at least outwardly) Sonny. Their dynamic is as engaging as it is ultimately sad, and the film’s nervous energy is sustained for essentially the whole runtime, making Dog Day Afternoon a stomach-churning yet always compelling watch.
Release Date
December 25, 1975
Runtime
124 minutes
Director
Sidney Lumet
2 'The Godfather' (1972)
Director: Francis Ford Coppola
John Cazale as Fredo Corleone in The Godfather (1972) directed by Francis Ford Coppola
Image via Paramount Pictures
Beyond being an early role for Al Pacino, the first Godfather is also notable for starring the likes of Marlon Brando, James Caan, Robert Duvall, and Diane Keaton. It’s a huge and ambitious movie with an appropriately large cast, and John Cazale has a relatively small role within it as Fredo, the middle son of Vito’s, between older brother Sonny (Caan) and younger brother Michael (Pacino). Fredo gets a great deal more to do in the sequel, with the first movie being more concerned with showing how Sonny and Michael might well be able to take over the family business, despite neither being ideal successors to their father.
Fredo is defined by his sensitivity and perhaps timidness, which puts him in contrast with the overly aggressive Sonny and the sometimes cold and cunning Michael. It’s hard to call it the best movie of Cazale’s if one is to take into account how much of a presence he has within his movies, but his small role here is still an important one, and the film itself is undeniably masterful, easily ranking up there as one of the best (and most epic) Best Picture winners in Oscar history.
Release Date
March 24, 1972
Runtime
175 minutes
Director
Francis Ford Coppola
Main Genre
1 'The Godfather: Part II' (1974)
Director: Francis Ford Coppola
Michael Corleone (Al Pacino), grabbing Fredo's (John Cazale) face in the iconic Fredo kiss scene in The Godfather II
Image via Paramount Pictures
In The Godfather: Part II, both Brando and Caan’s characters have exited the saga (the former relatively peacefully, and the latter violently), meaning that both Al Pacino as Michael and John Cazale as Fredo get even more to do here than they had before. Now that Michael Corleone has taken over his father’s criminal empire, the film largely revolves around his tragic fall from grace, and how his ruthlessness alienates those who once loved him, with his actions causing little else beyond misery and death. All the while, Vito’s rise to prominence as a mafia boss and family man is shown in a series of flashbacks, with Robert De Niro playing the younger version of Brando’s character.
With time spent in the “present” and past, The Godfather: Part II is even more of an epic than the first movie, and might well manage to be even more emotionally powerful, thanks to the core story focusing on the two remaining Corleone brothers, and their gradual falling out. It’s a movie that features one of Pacino’s best-ever performances, and Cazale’s role as Fredo in this sequel is probably the single greatest performance of his short but great filmography, too. It’s an overall outstanding movie, and more than lives up to its lofty reputation as one of the best movie sequels of all time.
The Godfather: Part II
Release Date
December 20, 1974
Runtime
200 minutes
Director
Francis Ford Coppola
Main Genre
Crime