The Controversial Skill of Columbus as a Navigator: An Enduring Historical Enigma | The Journal of Navigation | Cambridge Core (original) (raw)

Abstract

This study of Columbus' navigation is unique because it was written by an historian who is also a trained and experienced professional global (and ocean) navigator, rather than an academic historian with only superficial knowledge of the science of navigation as practiced by Columbus and other early navigators. The study is also unique in that as an American historian author disagrees with his colleagues in the USA who present the “politically correct” view of Columbus as an unskilled entrepreneur who obtained his limited knowledge of navigation as a crew member or passenger on Portuguese voyages, rather than as one of the most skilled and experienced of the cadre of respected Genoese captains and navigators used by kings throughout Europe to perform their maritime enterprises.

References

1De Lollis, Cezare (1892), Scritti di Cristoforo Colombo, in Nuova Raccolta Colombiana, Ministry of Cultural and Environmental Assets. With notes comparing Las Casas' Historia de las Indias, Ferdinand's Historie, and Herrera's Historia General, Instuzione del Maggiorasco, Rome.Google Scholar

2Jane, Cecil (1988), The Four Voyages of Columbus. Originally published as; Select Documents Illustrating the Four Voyages of Columbus; Including those Contained in R. H. Major's “Select Letters of Christopher Columbus,” translation with Introduction, notes, and commentary by Cecil Jane. Published by the Hakluyt Society as Vol. 1 (1930) and Vol. 2 (1933). Both volumes combined and published in an unabridged edition by Dover Publications, Inc., New York.Nuova Raccolta Colombiana series, Ministry of Cultural and Environmental Assets, Rome.Book of Privileges, Omnigraphics, Inc., Detroit.Google Scholar

16D'Ailly, Pierre, (1992), Ymago Mundi y otros opúsculos. Translated by Antonio Ramirez de Verer, Alianza Editorial, Seville.Google Scholar