A Review of Henge Monuments in the Light of Recent Research | Proceedings of the Prehistoric Society | Cambridge Core (original) (raw)

Extract

At the beginning of the 2nd millennium B.C. there became established in Britain the tradition of constructing ceremonial circles of earth, stone or timber. However, circular enclosures were being built much earlier in the 3rd millennium, which on account of their interrupted ditches have been called causewayed camps. These enclosures are unlikely to have been fortified village sites or cattle pounds as was originally suggested, but the pottery evidence from Windmill Hill and Robin Hood's Ball, to mention only two sites (Smith, 1965; Thomas, 1964), points to visits by groups of people coming from other regions. It has been suggested, therefore, that these camps may have served as centres or rally points for a fairly wide area where tribal ceremonies could be performed (Smith, 1965, 17–21). At Windmill Hill in particular, the abundance of pottery, grain-rubbers and querns and the remains of slaughtered animals testify to the consumption of food on a large scale and therefore possibly to communal feasts.

If this interpretation be correct then one could suggest that the ceremonial circle tradition of the 2nd millennium derived ultimately from these earthworks. Both are essentially a British phenomenon, although the causewayed camps can be compared with causewayed ditched enclosures in the Michelsberg culture, and appear to represent indigenous traditions with no external influences. However, although the quantity of animal bones and domestic refuse from Durrington Walls and Gorsey Bigbury in the Mendips confirms the practice of feasting in connection with ceremonial circles, these sites are virtually unique in the quantity of human debris they have produced.

References

Alcock, L., 1950. ‘The henge monument of the Bull Ring, Dove Holes, Derbyshire’, PPS, 16, 81–6.Google Scholar

ApSimon, A. M., 1949. ‘Gorsey Bigbury, the second report’, Proc. Univ. Bristol Spel. Soc., 6, 186–99.Google Scholar

Atkinson, R. J. C., Brailsford, J. W. and Wakefield, H. G., 1951. ‘A pond barrow at Winterbourne Steepleton, Dorset’, Arch. J., 108, 1–24.Google Scholar

Atkinson, R. J. C., Piggott, C. M. and Sandars, N. K., 1951. Excavations at Dorchester, Oxon. First Report.Google Scholar

Atkinson, R. J. C., Piggott, S. and Stone, J. F. S., 1952. ‘The excavation of two additional holes at Stonehenge, 1950, and new evidence for the date of the monument’, Ant. J., 32, 14–20.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Atkinson, R. J. C., 1966. ‘Moonshine on Stonehenge’, Ant., 40, 262–76.Google Scholar

Atkinson, R. J. C., 1967. ‘Further radiocarbon dates for Stonehenge’, Ant., 41, 63–4.Google Scholar

Case, H., Bayne, N., Steele, S., Avery, G. and Sutermeister, H., 1964. ‘Excavations at City Farm, Hanborough, Oxon’., Oxon, 29, 1–98.Google Scholar

Case, H. J., 1967. ‘Were beaker-people the first metallurgists in Ireland’, Palaeohistoria, 12, 141–77.Google Scholar

Clark, J. G. D., 1936. ‘The timber monument at Arminghall and its affinities’, PPS, 2, 1–51.Google Scholar

Collins, A. E. P., 1957. ‘Excavations at the Giants Ring, Ballynahatty’, UJA, 20, 44–50.Google Scholar

Crawford, O. G. S. and Keiller, A., 1928. Wessexfrom the Air.Google Scholar

Crawford, O. G. S., 1929. ‘Durrington Walls’, Ant., 3, 49–59.Google Scholar

Cunnington, R. H., 1955. ‘Marden and the Cunnington manuscripts’, WAM, 56, 4–11.Google Scholar

Dymond, D. P., 1963. ‘The “henge” monument at Nunwick, near Ripon, 1961 excavation’, YAJ, 14, 98–107.Google Scholar

Feacham, R. W., 1966. ‘Ordnance Survey: Archaeological Report, 1’, Ant., 40, 145 pl. XXVIa.Google Scholar

Feacham, R. W., 1967. ‘Ordnance Survey: Archaeological Report, 2’, Ant., 41, 224.Google Scholar

Griffiths, W. E., 1960. ‘The excavation of Stone Circles near Penmaenmawr, north Wales’, PPS, 26, 303–39.Google Scholar

Grimes, W. F., 1938. ‘The excavation of Gorsey Bigbury—the pottery’, Proc. Univ. Bristol Spel. Soc., 5, 25–43.Google Scholar

Grimes, W. F., 1963. ‘The Stone Circles and related monuments of Wales’, in Foster, I. Ll. and Alcock, L. (ed.), Culture and Environment, 93–152.Google Scholar

Grinsell, L. V., 1956. Stanton Drew Stone Circles, Somerset, Ancient Monuments Guide, Ministry of Works.Google Scholar

Hartnett, P. J., 1957. ‘Excavation of a Passage Grave at Fourknocks, Co. Meath’, PRIA, 58, 197–277.Google Scholar

Hawkes, J., 1967. ‘God in the Machine’, Ant., 41, 174–80.Google Scholar

Hoare, R. C., 1821. The Ancient History of Wiltshire, vol. 11.Google Scholar

Houlder, C., 1968. ‘The henge monuments at Llandegai’, Ant., 42, 216–21.Google Scholar

Hoyle, F., 1966. ‘Speculations on Stonehenge’, Ant., 40, 262–376.Google Scholar

Jones, S. J., 1938. ‘The excavation of Gorsey Bigbury:—the flints’, Proc. Univ. Bristol Spel. Soc., 5, 15–25.Google Scholar

Kendrick, T. D. and Hawkes, C. F. C., 1932, Archaeology in England and Wales 1914–1931.Google Scholar

Macalister, R. A. S., Armstrong, E. C. R. and Praeger, R. Ll., 1913. ‘A bronze age interment, with associated standing stone and earthen ring, near Nass, Co. Kildare’, PRIA, 30, 351–60.Google Scholar

McInnes, I. J., 1964. ‘A Class II henge in the East Riding of Yorkshire’, Ant., 38, 218–9.Google Scholar

O'Neill, H. E., 1957. ‘Condicote earthwork, A henge monument, Gloucestershire’, TBGAS, 76, 141–6.Google Scholar

O'Riordain, S. P., 1950. ‘Excavations of some earthworks on the Curragh, Co. Kildare’, PRIA, 53, 249–77.Google Scholar

O'Riordain, S. P. and Daniel, G., 1964. New Grange and the Bend of the Boyne.Google Scholar

Piggott, S. and C. M., , 1939. ‘Stone and earth circles in Dorset’, Ant., 13, 138–58.Google Scholar

Piggott, S., 1940. ‘Timber circles: A re-examination’, Arch. J., 96, 193–222.Google Scholar

Piggott, S., 1959. ‘The radio-carbon dates from Durrington Walls’, Ant., 33, 289–90.Google Scholar

Radley, J., 1966. ‘A bronze age ring-work on Totley Moor and other bronze age ring-works in the Pennines’, Arch. J., 123, 1–26.Google Scholar

Scott-Elliot, J. and Rae, I., 1965. ‘Whitestanes Moor Sites 1 and 80. An enclosed cremation cemetery’, Trans. Dum. and Gall. Nat. Hist. Ant. Soc., 42, 51–60.Google Scholar

Scott-Elliot, J., 1967. ‘Whitestanes Moor (Ring Cairn Sites 7 and 8)’, Trans. Dum. and Gall. Nat. Hist. Ant. Soc., 44, 117–21.Google Scholar

Simpson, G., 1967. ‘Three painted objects from Maxey near Peterborough’, Ant., 41, 138–9.Google Scholar

Smith, I. F., 1965. Windmill Hill and Avebury. Excavations by Alexander Keiller 1925–1939.Google Scholar

St Joseph, J. K. S., 1961. ‘Aerial reconnaissance in Wales’, Ant., 35, 263–75.Google Scholar

St Joseph, J. K. S., 1964. ‘Air reconnaissance: recent results’, Ant., 38, 217–8.Google Scholar

St Joseph, J. K. S., 1968. ‘Air reconnaissance: recent results, 14’, Ant., 42, 130–1.Google Scholar

Stone, J. F. S., 1938. ‘An early bronze age grave in Fargo Plantation near Stonehenge’, WAM, 48, 357–70.Google Scholar

Stone, J. F. S., Piggott, S. and Booth, A. St J., 1954. ‘Durrington Walls, Wiltshire: recent excavations at a ceremonial site of the early second millennium B.C.’, Ant. J., 34, 155–77.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Thomas, C., 1962. ‘The henge monument at Castilly, Lanivet’, Cornwall Archaeological Society, Field Guide 8.Google Scholar

Thomas, C., 1964. ‘The Society's 1962 excavations: the henge at Castilly’, Cornish Arch., 3, 3–14.Google Scholar

Thomas, N., 1955. ‘The Thornborough Circles, near Ripon, North Riding’, YAJ, 38, 425–45.Google Scholar

Thomas, N., 1964. ‘The Neolithic causewayed camp at Robin Hood's Ball, Shrewton’, WAM, 59, 1.Google Scholar

Tratman, E. K., 1958. ‘Another henge monument on Mendip’, Proc Univ. Bristol Spel. Soc., 8, 124–5.Google Scholar

Tratman, E. K., 1967. ‘The Priddy Circles, Mendip, Somerset, Henge Monuments’, Proc. Univ. Bristol, Spel. Soc., 11, 97–125.Google Scholar

Wainwright, G. J., 1962. ‘The excavation of an earthwork at Castell Bryn Gwyn, Llanidan, Anglesey’, Arch. Camb., 111, 25–58.Google Scholar

Wainwright, G. J., 1967. ‘The excavation of the henge monument at Durrington Walls, Wiltshire, 1966’, Ant. J., 47, 166–84.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Wainwright, G. J., 1968. ‘Durrington Walls: a ceremonial enclosure of the second millennium B.C.’, Ant., 42, 20–6.Google Scholar