Controversies in defining and determining death in critical care (original) (raw)

• Giacomini, M. A change of heart and a change of mind? Technology and the redefinition of death in 1968. Soc. Sci. Med. 44, 1465–1482 (1997).
  Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar
• Powner, D. J., Ackerman, B. M. & Grenvik, A. Medical diagnosis of death in adults: historical contributions to current controversies. Lancet 348, 1219–1223 (1996).
  Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar
• Bernat, J. L., Culver, C. M. & Gert, B. On the definition and criterion of death. Ann. Intern. Med. 94, 389–394 (1981).
  Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar
• Wijdicks, E. F. The neurologist and Harvard criteria for brain death. Neurology 61, 970–976 (2003).
  Article PubMed Google Scholar
• Belkin, G. S. Brain death and the historical understanding of bioethics. J. Hist. Med. Allied Sci. 58, 325–361 (2003).
  Article PubMed Google Scholar
• Pernick, M. S. in The Definition of Death: Contemporary Controversies (eds Youngner, S. J. et al.) 3–33 (Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, 1999).
  Google Scholar
• Mollaret, P. & Goulon, M. Le coma dépassé (mémoire préliminaire) [French]. Rev. Neurol. (Paris) 101, 3–15 (1959).
  CAS Google Scholar
• Wertheimer, P., Jouvet, M. & Descotes, J. A propos du diagnostic de la morte du système nerveux dans les comas avec arrêt respiratoire traités par respiration artificielle [French]. Presse Méd. 67, 87–88 (1959).
  CAS PubMed Google Scholar
• [No authors listed]. A definition of irreversible coma. Report of the Ad Hoc Committee of the Harvard Medical School to Examine the Definition of Brain Death. JAMA 205, 337–340 (1968).
• [No authors listed] Diagnosis of brain death. Lancet 2, 1069–1070 (1976).
• Pallis, C. ABC of Brainstem Death (British Medical Journal Publishers, London, 1983).
  Google Scholar
• Wijdicks, E. F. Brain death worldwide: accepted fact but no global consensus in diagnostic criteria. Neurology 58, 20–25 (2002).
  Article PubMed Google Scholar
• Wijdicks, E. F. Brain Death 2nd edn (Oxford University Press, New York, 2011).
  Google Scholar
• Beresford, H. R. Brain death. Neurol. Clin. 17, 295–306 (1999).
  Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar
• Korein, J. The problem of brain death: development and history. Ann. NY Acad. Sci. 315, 19–38 (1978).
  Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar
• President's Commission for the Study of Ethical Problems in Medicine and Biomedical and Behavioral Research. Defining Death: Medical, Ethical, and Legal Issues in the Determination of Death (US Government Printing Office, Washington, DC, 1981).
• Bernat, J. L., Culver, C. M. & Gert, B. Defining death in theory and practice. Hastings Cent. Rep. 12 (1), 5–8 (1982).
  Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar
• Bernat, J. L. A defense of the whole-brain concept of death. Hastings Cent. Rep. 28 (2), 14–23 (1998).
  Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar
• Bernat, J. L. The biophilosophical basis of whole-brain death. Soc. Philos. Policy 19, 324–342 (2002).
  Article PubMed Google Scholar
• Bernat, J. L. The whole-brain concept of death remains optimum public policy. J. Law Med. Ethics 34, 35–43 (2006).
  Article PubMed Google Scholar
• Shewmon, D. A. Constructing the death elephant: a synthetic context shift for the definition, criteria, and tests for death. J. Med. Philos. 35, 256–298 (2010).
  Article PubMed Google Scholar
• Miller, F. A. & Truog, R. D. Death, Dying and Organ Transplantation: Reconstructing Medical Ethics at the End of Life (Oxford University Press, New York, 2011).
  Book Google Scholar
• Halevy, A. & Brody, B. Brain death: reconciling definitions, criteria, and tests. Ann. Intern. Med. 119, 519–525 (1993).
  Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar
• Bernat, J. L. Contemporary controversies in the definition of death. Prog. Brain Res. 177, 21–31 (2009).
  Article PubMed Google Scholar
• Chiong, W. Brain death without definitions. Hastings Cent. Rep. 35 (6), 20–30 (2005).
  PubMed Google Scholar
• Shewmon, D. A. The brain and somatic integration: insights into the standard biological rationale for equating “brain death” with death. J. Med. Philos. 26, 457–478 (2001).
  Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar
• Loeb, J. The Organism as a Whole: From a Physicochemical Viewpoint (G. P. Putnam's Sons, New York, 1916).
  Book Google Scholar
• Clayton, P. & Kauffman, S. A. On emergence, agency, and organization. Biol. Philos. 21, 501–521 (2006).
  Article Google Scholar
• Bonelli, R. M., Prat, E. H. & Bonelli, J. Philosophical considerations on brain death and the concept of the organism as a whole. Psychiatr. Danub. 21, 3–8 (2009).
  PubMed Google Scholar
• Shewmon, D. A. The “critical organ” for the organism as a whole: lessons from the lowly spinal cord. Adv. Exp. Med. Biol. 550, 23–42 (2004).
  Article Google Scholar
• Bernat, J. L. How much of the brain must die in brain death? J. Clin. Ethics 3, 21–26 (1992).
  CAS PubMed Google Scholar
• Wijdicks, E. F., Varelas, P. N., Gronseth, G. S. & Greer, D. M. American Academy of Neurology. Evidence-based guideline update: determining brain death in adults: report of the Quality Standards Subcommittee of the American Academy of Neurology. Neurology 74, 1911–1918 (2010).
  Article PubMed Google Scholar
• Nakagawa, T. A. et al. Guidelines for the determination of brain death in infants and children: an update of the 1987 Task Force recommendations. Crit. Care Med. 39, 2139–2155 (2011).
  Article PubMed Google Scholar
• Shemie, S. D. et al. Severe brain injury to neurological determination of death: Canadian forum recommendations. CMAJ 174, S1–S13 (2006).
  Article PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar
• Gardiner, D., Shemie, S., Manara, A. & Opdam, H. International perspective on the diagnosis of death. Br. J. Anaesth. 108 (Suppl. 1), i14–i28 (2012).
  Article PubMed Google Scholar
• Posner, J. B., Saper, C. B., Schiff, N. D. & Plum, F. Plum and Posner's Diagnosis of Stupor and Coma 4th edn 95–114 (Oxford University Press, New York, 2007).
  Google Scholar
• Ropper, A. H. Lateral displacement of the brain and level of consciousness in patients with an acute hemispheral mass. N. Engl. J. Med. 314, 953–958 (1986).
  Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar
• Bernat, J. L. On irreversibility as a prerequisite for brain death determination. Adv. Exper. Med. Biol. 550, 161–167 (2004).
  Article Google Scholar
• Ogata, J., Imakita, M., Yutani, C., Miyamoto, S. & Kikuchi, H. Primary brainstem death: a clinico-pathological study. J. Neurol. Neurosurg. Psychiatry 51, 646–650 (1988).
  Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar
• Kosteljanitz, M., Øhrstrøm, J. K., Skjøt, S. & Teglbjærg, P. S. Clinical brain death with preserved arterial circulation. Acta Neurol. Scand. 78, 418–421 (1988).
  Article Google Scholar
• Machado, C. Consciousness as a definition of death: its appeal and complexity. Clin. Electroencephalogr. 30, 156–164 (1999).
  Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar
• Shewmon, D. A. Brain death: can it be resuscitated? Hastings Cent. Rep. 39 (2), 18–24 (2009).
  Article PubMed Google Scholar
• Truog, R. D. Is it time to abandon brain death? Hastings Cent. Rep. 27 (1), 29–37 (1997).
  Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar
• Shewmon, D. A. Chronic “brain death:” meta-analysis and conceptual consequences. Neurology 51, 1538–1545 (1998).
  Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar
• Repertinger, S., Fitzgibbons, W. P., Omojola, M. F. & Brumback, R. A. Long survival following bacterial meningitis-associated brain destruction. J. Child Neurol. 21, 591–595 (2006).
  Article PubMed Google Scholar
• Lustbader, D. et al. Second brain death examination may negatively affect organ donation. Neurology 76, 119–124 (2011).
  Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar
• Gelb, D. J. Second brain death examination may negatively affect organ donation. Neurology 77, 1314–1315 (2011).
  Article PubMed Google Scholar
• Varelas, P. N. et al. Single brain death examination is equivalent to dual brain death examinations. Neurocrit. Care 15, 547–553 (2011).
  Article PubMed Google Scholar
• Heran, M. K., Heran. N. S. & Shemie, S. D. A review of ancillary tests in evaluating brain death. Can. J. Neurol. Sci. 35, 409–419 (2008).
  Article PubMed Google Scholar
• Wijdicks, E. F. The case against confirmatory tests for determining brain death in adults. Neurology 75, 77–83 (2010).
  Article PubMed Google Scholar
• Busl, K. M. & Greer, D. M. Pitfalls in the diagnosis of brain death. Neurocrit. Care 11, 276–287 (2009).
  Article PubMed Google Scholar
• Greer. D. M., Varelas, P. N., Haque, S. & Wijdicks, E. F. Variability of brain death determination guidelines in leading US neurologic institutions. Neurology 70, 284–289 (2008).
  Article PubMed Google Scholar
• Wang, M. Y., Wallace, P. & Gruen, J. P. Brain death documentation: analysis and issues. Neurosurgery 51, 731–736 (2002).
  Article PubMed Google Scholar
• Bernat, J. L. How can we achieve uniformity in brain death determinations? Neurology 70, 252–253 (2008).
  Article PubMed Google Scholar
• Choi, E. K. et al. Brain death revisited: the case for a national standard. J. Law Med. Ethics 36, 824–836 (2008).
  Article PubMed Google Scholar
• Webb, A. C. & Samuels, O. B. Reversible brain death after cardiopulmonary arrest and induced hypothermia. Crit. Care Med. 39, 1538–1542 (2011).
  Article PubMed Google Scholar
• Streat, S. 'Reversible brain death'—is it true, confounded, or 'not proven'? Crit. Care Med. 39, 1601–1602 (2011).
  Article PubMed Google Scholar
• Miedema, F. Medical treatment after brain death: a case report and ethical analysis. J. Clin. Ethics 2, 50–52 (1991).
  CAS PubMed Google Scholar
• Hardwig, J. Treating the brain dead for the benefit of the family. J. Clin. Ethics 2, 53–56 (1991).
  PubMed Google Scholar
• Molinari, G. F. Brain death, irreversible coma, and words doctors use. Neurology 32, 400–402 (1982).
  Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar
• Cranford, R. E. Discontinuation of ventilation after brain death: policy should be balanced with concern for the family. BMJ 318, 1754–1755 (1999).
  CAS PubMed Google Scholar
• Shaner, D. M., Orr, R. D., Drought, T., Miller, R. B. & Siegel, M. Really, most SINCERELY dead: policy and procedure in the diagnosis of death by neurologic criteria. Neurology 62, 1683–1686 (2004).
  Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar
• Ormrod, J. A., Ryder, T., Chadwick, R. J. & Bonner, S. M. Experiences of families when a relative is diagnosed brain stem dead: understanding of death, observation of brain stem death testing, and attitudes to organ donation. Anaesthesia 60, 1002–1008 (2005).
  Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar
• Kompanje, E. J., de Groot, Y. J., Bakker, J. & Ijzermans, J. N. A national multicenter trial on family presence during brain death determination: the FABRA study. Neurocrit. Care 17, 301–308 (2012).
  Article PubMed Google Scholar
• Furton, E. J. Brain death, the soul, and organic life. Natl Cathol. Bioeth. Q. 2, 455–470 (2002).
  Article PubMed Google Scholar
• Pontifical Academy of Sciences. The Signs of Death. Scripta Varia 110 (Pontifical Academy of Sciences, Vatican City, 2007).
• Halachic Organ Donor Society. Halachic Issues. Halachic Organ Donor Society [online].
• Rosner, F. in The Definition of Death: Contemporary Controversies (eds Youngner, S. J. et al.) 210–221 (Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, 1999).
  Google Scholar
• Padela A. I., Arozullah, A. & Moosa, E. Brain death in Islamic ethico-legal deliberation: challenges for applied Islamic bioethics. Bioethics http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1467–85192011.01935.x.
• Jain, S. & Maheshawari, M. C. in Brain Death (ed. Machado, C.) 261–263 (Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1995).
  Google Scholar
• Lock, M. Contesting the natural in Japan: moral dilemmas and technologies of dying. Cult. Med. Psychiatry 19, 1–38 (1995).
  Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar
• Olick, R. S., Braun, E. A. & Potasj, J. Accommodating religious and moral objections to neurological death. J. Clin. Ethics 20, 183–191 (2009).
  PubMed Google Scholar
• Steinbrook, R. Organ donation after cardiac death. N. Engl. J. Med. 357, 209–213 (2007).
  Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar
• Manara, A. R., Murphy, P. G. & O'Callaghan, G. Donation after circulatory death. Br. J. Anaesth. 108 (Suppl. 1), i108–i121 (2012).
  Article PubMed Google Scholar
• Wall, S. P. et al. Derivation of the uncontrolled donation after circulatory death protocol for New York City. Am. J. Transplant. 11, 1417–1426 (2011).
  Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar
• Robertson, J. A. The dead donor rule. Hastings Cent. Rep. 29 (6), 6–14 (1999).
  Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar
• Lynn, J. & Cranford, R. E. in The Definition of Death: Contemporary Controversies (eds Youngner, S. J. et al.) 101–114 (Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, 1999).
  Google Scholar
• DeVita, M. A. & Snyder, J. V. Development of the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center policy for the care of terminally ill patients who may become organ donors after death following the removal of life support. Kennedy Inst. Ethics J. 3, 131–143 (1993).
  Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar
• Bernat, J. L. Are donors after cardiac death really dead? J. Clin. Ethics 17, 122–132 (2006).
  PubMed Google Scholar
• Ethics Committee, American College of Critical Care Medicine & Society of Critical Care Medicine. Recommendations for non-heartbeating organ donation. A position paper by the Ethics Committee, American College of Critical Care Medicine, Society of Critical Care Medicine. Crit. Care Med. 29, 1826–1831 (2001).
• Bernat, J. L. et al. Report of a national conference on donation after cardiac death. Am. J. Transplant. 6, 281–291 (2006).
  Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar
• Institute of Medicine. Non-Heart-Beating Organ Transplantation: Practice and Protocols (National Academy Press, Washington, DC, 2000).
• Shemie, S. D. et al. National recommendations for donation after cardiocirculatory death in Canada. CMAJ 175 (8 Suppl.), S1–S24 (2006).
  PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar
• Dhanini, S., Hornby, L., Ward, R. & Shemie, S. Variability in the determination of death after cardiac arrest: a review of guidelines and statements. J. Intensive Care Med. 27, 238–252 (2012).
  Article Google Scholar
• Boucek, M. M. et al. Pediatric heart transplantation after declaration of cardiocirculatory death. N. Engl. J. Med. 359, 709–714 (2008).
  Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar
• Wijdicks, E. F. & Diringer, M. N. Electrocardiographic activity after terminal cardiac arrest in neurocatastrophes. Neurology 62, 673–674 (2004).
  Article PubMed Google Scholar
• DeVita, M. A., Snyder, J. V., Arnold, R. M. & Siminoff, L. A. Observations of withdrawal of life-sustaining treatment from patients who became non-heart-beating organ donors. Crit. Care Med. 28, 1709–1712 (2000).
  Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar
• Hornby, K., Hornby, L. & Shemie, S. A systematic review of autoresuscitation after cardiac arrest. Crit. Care Med. 38, 1246–1253 (2010).
  Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar
• Sheth, K. N., Nutter, T., Stein, D. M., Scalea, T. M. & Bernat, J. L. Auto-resuscitation after asystole in patients being considered for organ donation. Crit. Care Med. 40, 158–161 (2012).
  Article PubMed Google Scholar
• Rogers, P. L., Schlicktig, R., Miro, A. & Pinsky, M. Auto-PEEP during CPR: an “occult” cause of electromechanical dissociation. Chest 99, 492–493 (1991).
  Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar
• Bernat, J. L. How auto-resuscitation impacts death determinations in organ donors. Crit. Care Med. 38, 1377–1378 (2010).
  Article PubMed Google Scholar
• Bernat, J. L. How the distinction between “irreversible” and “permanent” illuminates circulatory–respiratory death determination. J. Med. Philos. 35, 242–255 (2010).
  Article PubMed Google Scholar
• Truog, R. D. & Miller, F. G. Counterpoint: are donors after circulatory death really dead and does it matter? No and not really. Chest 138, 16–19 (2010).
  Article PubMed Google Scholar
• Marquis, D. Are DCD donors dead? Hastings Cent. Rep. 40 (3), 24–31 (2010).
  Article PubMed Google Scholar
• Bernat, J. L. et al. The circulatory–respiratory determination of death in organ donation. Crit. Care Med. 38, 972–979 (2010).
  Google Scholar
• Ko, W. J., Chen, Y. S., Tsai, P. R. & Lee, P. H. Extracorporeal membrane oxygenation support of donor abdominal organs in non-heart-beating donors. Clin. Transplant. 14, 152–156 (2000).
  Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar
• Gravel, M. T. et al. Kidney transplantation from organ donors following cardiopulmonary death using extracorporeal membrane oxygenation support. Ann. Transplant. 9, 57–58 (2004).
  PubMed Google Scholar
• Magliocca, J. F. et al. Extracorporeal support for organ donation after cardiac death effectively expands the donor pool. J. Trauma 58, 1095–1102 (2005).
  Article PubMed Google Scholar
• President's Council on Bioethics. Controversies in the Determination of Death: A White Paper by the President's Council on Bioethics. The President's Council on Bioethics [online].
• Shemie, S. D. International Guidelines for the Determination of Death. Critical Care Canada Forum [online].
• Klein, A. S. et al. Organ donation and utilization in the United States: 1998–2008. Am. J. Transplant. 10, 973–986 (2010).
  Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar
• Merchant, S. J. et al. Exploring the psychological effects of deceased organ donation on the families of organ donors. Clin. Transplant. 22, 341–347 (2008).
  Article PubMed Google Scholar
• DeVita, M. A. & Caplan, A. L. Caring for organs or patients? Ethical concerns about the Uniform Anatomical Gift Act (2006). Ann. Intern. Med. 147, 876–879 (2007).
  Article PubMed Google Scholar
• Iltis, A. S., Rie, M. A. & Wall, A. Organ donation, patients' rights, and medical responsibilities at the end of life. Crit. Care Med. 37, 310–315 (2009).
  Article PubMed Google Scholar
• Truog, R. D. Consent for organ donation—balancing conflicting ethical obligations. N. Engl. J. Med. 358, 1209–1211 (2008).
  Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar
• Arnold, R. M., Siminoff, L. A. & Frader, J. E. Ethical issues in organ procurement: a review for intensivists. Crit. Care Clin. 12, 29–48 (1996).
  Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar
• Mandell, M. S. et al. National evaluation of healthcare provider attitudes toward organ donation after cardiac death. Crit. Care Med. 34, 2952–2958 (2006).
  Article PubMed Google Scholar
• Hart, J. L., Kohn, R. & Halpern, S. D. Perceptions of organ donation after circulatory determination of death among critical care physicians and nurses: a national survey. Crit. Care Med. 40, 2595–2600 (2012).
  Article PubMed Google Scholar
• Bastami, S., Krones, T. & Biller-Adorno, N. Systematic review of attitudes toward donation after cardiac death among health care providers and the general public. Crit. Care Med. (in press).
• Simpkin, A. L., Robertson, L. C., Barber, V. S. & Young, J. D. Modifiable factors influencing relatives' decision to offer organ donation: systematic review. BMJ 338, b991 (2009).
  Article PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar
• Kalkbrenner, K. J. & Hardart, G. E. Consent for donation after cardiac death: a survey of procurement organizations. J. Intensive Care Med. 27, 253–263 (2012).
  Article PubMed Google Scholar
• Zink, S. & Wertleib, S. A study of the presumptive approach to consent for organ donation: a new solution to an old problem. Crit. Care Nurse 26, 129–136 (2006).
  PubMed Google Scholar
• Luskin, R. S., Glazier, A. K. & Delmonico, F. L. Organ donation and dual advocacy. N. Engl. J. Med. 358, 1207–1208 (2008).
  Article Google Scholar
• Browne, A., Gillett, G. & Tweedale, M. The ethics of elective (non-therapeutic) ventilation. Bioethics 14, 42–57 (2000).
  Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar
• Bernat, J. L. Point: are donors after circulatory death really dead and does it matter? Yes and Yes. Chest 138, 13–16 (2010).
  Article PubMed Google Scholar