Bone marrow stem cells contribute to repair of the ischemically injured renal tubule (original) (raw)
Adult bone marrow contains cells capable of populating the renal tubule. Given the plasticity of adult BMSCs, we initially determined whether transplanted whole–bone marrow cells had the ability to home to the kidney tubular epithelium. Six C57BL/6J mice received sublethal irradiation followed by intravenous injection of either saline (control mice, n = 2) or 1 × 106 whole–bone marrow cells obtained from Rosa26 mice (n = 4). Rosa26 mice carry the lacZ gene, making it possible to identify transplanted donor cells in the recipient mice by staining for β-galactosidase activity.
At 3 and 12 weeks after BMT, one control mouse and two transplanted mice were sacrificed, and the kidneys were sectioned and stained for β-galactosidase activity. Control mice that did not receive BMT had no β-galactosidase–positive cells in the kidneys at either 3 or 12 weeks (Figure 1a). In mice sacrificed 3 weeks after BMT from Rosa26 donors, we also failed to detect β-galactosidase–positive cells in the kidneys. However, 12 weeks following BMT, β-galactosidase–positive cells were found in the kidneys and, at higher power, were found to be within the tubules themselves (Figure 1, b–d), with approximately 2–5% of the tubules containing bone marrow–derived cells. No β-galactosidase–positive cells were detected in the arteries or glomeruli in these experiments. These results demonstrate that transplanted whole bone marrow from adult mice contains cells that are capable of homing to the kidney and incorporating into the tubular epithelium. The paucity of β-galactosidase–positive tubules found is consistent with previous reports that used transplantation of female kidneys into male recipients and suggests that bone marrow–derived cells may play only a modest role in normal tubular epithelial turnover.
Bone marrow–derived cells populate the renal tubule. Transplantation of whole bone marrow from Rosa26 mice into C57BL/6J recipient mice results in the spontaneous appearance of β-galactosidase–positive cells (blue) in the tubules of the renal cortex of the transplanted mice after 12 weeks (arrows). Control mice (a) do not have β-galactosidase–positive tubules. a and b, ×20; c, ×40; d, ×60.
Ischemia induces mobilization of BMSCs and repopulation of the S3 segment of the renal tubule. We next examined the possibility that adult stem cells are involved in repairing the ischemically injured renal epithelium. For these studies we used the well-established model of I/R to examine regeneration of renal tubules following ATN. To determine the optimal clamping time for inducing selective injury to the S3 segment of the proximal tubule in the mouse, we clamped the left renal pedicle for periods of time that varied from 15 to 60 minutes and then unclamped it to restore flow; 24 hours later, we examined renal pathology. Ischemia times of 15–20 minutes induced swelling of the cells of the outer medulla but no frank necrosis. In agreement with published reports of this model (20), 25–27 minutes of ischemia resulted in patchy areas of necrosis of the proximal tubule cells in the outer medulla as compared with controls (Figure 2, a–d). Tubular segments of the thick ascending limb and collecting duct in the outer medulla were swollen, but not obviously necrotic. After 30 minutes of clamping, tubular necrosis in the outer medulla was less selective, and frank necrosis extended into the cortex (Figure 2, e and f).
Mouse model of I/R. Low-magnification (×4; a, c, and e) and high-magnification (×40; b, d, and f) views of H&E-stained sections from control kidneys (a and b) and kidneys 24 hours after warm I/R for 25 minutes (c and d) and 30 minutes (e and f). Twenty-five minutes of warm ischemia results in swelling of the cortical and inner medullary tubular cells and selective necrosis of the S3 segment of the proximal tubule in the outer medulla (c and d, arrows), whereas 30 minutes of warm ischemia causes more extensive necrosis of tubules in the outer medulla as well as necrosis of proximal tubules in the cortex (e, arrowhead; and f).
To determine whether ischemic injury specifically induced the mobilization of bone marrow stem cells into the peripheral circulation, we subjected mice to 25 minutes of left renal ischemia or sham operation, followed 24 hours later by examination of the peripheral blood for the presence of Lin–Sca-1+ cells using flow cytometry. In the sham-operated mice, circulating Lin–Sca-1+ cells were not detectable above background (Figure 3a), whereas, after ischemic renal injury, these cells made up 20–24% of the non-rbc peripheral circulating cells (Figure 3b). Therefore, Lin–Sca-1+c-kit+ BMSCs would be predicted to constitute 2–2.5% of the circulating cells after renal ischemia, as they typically make up approximately 10% of the Lin–Sca-1+ fraction.
Ischemia mobilizes Lin–Sca-1+ cells. Peripheral blood from a mouse 24 hours after sham operation (a) or 25 minutes of unilateral I/R (b) was labeled for detection of Lin+ and Sca-1+ cells and analyzed on a FACS. Lin–Sca-1+ stem cells were not seen in the circulation of the control animals (a, lower right quadrant); the 1.4% of cells detected is equal to the value seen with the unrelated isotype control antibody and is therefore indistinguishable from background. In contrast, 23.8% of the circulating cells were Lin–Sca-1+ stem cells 24 hours after I/R (b, lower right quadrant).
The ability of renal ischemia to mobilize Lin–Sca-1+ cells from the bone marrow suggested that these cells might provide a substantial contribution to the repair of the necrotic renal tubules. To investigate this possibility, 11 mice were subjected to sublethal irradiation followed by whole BMT with 5 × 106 cells per mouse. Sixteen weeks after transplantation, six mice underwent clamping of the left renal pedicle for 25 minutes followed by reperfusion for 1 week, with the remaining five mice serving as sham-operated controls. Sections from the kidneys 7 days after surgery revealed a marked increase in the total number of β-galactosidase–positive cells in kidneys that had undergone I/R, with the majority of these cells being located in the tubules of the outer medulla (Figure 4, a and b). The contralateral kidney, and kidneys from the mice that had not undergone renal ischemia, again revealed only a small number of β-galactosidase–positive cells, distributed primarily in the renal cortex (Figure 4, c and d). A second group of control mice that underwent I/R in the absence of prior BMT showed no β-galactosidase–positive tubules (Figure 4, e and f).
Ischemia induces bone marrow cells to repopulate the tubules of the outer medulla. (a–f) Low-magnification (×4; a, c, and e) and high-magnification (×40; b, d, and f) views of X-gal–stained kidney sections from mice that underwent 25 minutes of I/R 16 weeks after whole BMT, followed by a 1-week recovery period (a and b); mice 17 weeks after BMT that had not undergone renal ischemia (c and d); and mice that underwent 25 minutes of I/R with a 1-week recovery period but did not undergo BMT (e and f). I/R induced a marked increase in the total number of β-galactosidase–positive tubules, with the majority of those tubules confined to the region of necrosis in the outer medulla (a and b; blue tubules). (g and h) Transplantation of Lin–Sca-1+c-kit+ BMSCs followed 5 weeks later by 25 minutes of I/R resulted in a similar appearance of β-galactosidase–positive tubules in the outer medulla (h), while animals transplanted with lineage-restricted (Lin+) cells had no β-galactosidase–positive tubules after renal injury (g). OM, outer medulla; IM, inner medulla.
Quantitation of the number of β-galactosidase–positive tubules from these experiments revealed that ischemia induced an increase in β-galactosidase–positive tubules from 2.4% to 20.9% (P < 0.001) in the outer medulla of ischemically injured kidneys but did not alter the number of tubules with detectable bone marrow–derived cells in the cortex (Table 1). Furthermore, there was no increase in β-galactosidase–positive tubules in the contralateral kidney, and there were no β-galactosidase–positive tubules detected in the inner medulla of any animal. Bone marrow cytopreparations revealed that 24.5% ± 6% of the bone marrow cells were β-galactosidase–positive 17 weeks after BMT. A separate experiment in which mice underwent left renal I/R 2 weeks after BMT, followed by 1 week of recovery, demonstrated that the number of β-galactosidase–positive tubules in the outer medulla increased from 0% to 8.5% following renal ischemia, with bone marrow cytopreparations confirming that 3.3% of the bone marrow cells were derived from the Rosa26 donor at this early time after transplantation.
Quantitation of β-galactosidase–positive tubules
To determine whether the cells capable of regenerating the renal epithelium reside in the traditional bone marrow stem cell fraction, we repeated the I/R experiment in mice transplanted with either Lin–Sca-1+c-kit+ cells (stem cell transplant [SCT] group, n = 3) or Lin+ cells (control group, n = 3). The left kidneys of mice in the two groups were subjected to 25 minutes of surgical I/R 5 weeks after stem cell transplantation, as before. X-gal staining of the kidney sections 1 week later revealed that β-galactosidase–positive tubules constituted 0% of the outer medulla in mice that received Lin+ cells, but approximately 22% of the outer medulla in mice that received Lin–Sca-1+c-kit+ BMSCs (Figure 4, g and h). Bone marrow cytopreparations demonstrated that, in the animals that received Lin–Sca-1+c-kit+ cells, 22.9% ± 6.2% of the bone marrow cells were derived from the Rosa26 mouse donor, whereas none of the Lin+ cells had engrafted. Thus it is specifically the Lin–Sca-1+c-kit+ fraction of the bone marrow that contains cells capable of populating the renal tubule following ischemic injury.
In order to determine whether the bone marrow–derived cells found in the regenerated proximal tubule had differentiated into renal tubular epithelial cells, we performed β-galactosidase assays followed by staining of the same section for the proximal tubule–specific marker megalin (21). Examination of the outer medulla 1 week after 25 minutes of ischemia revealed that approximately 20% of the proximal tubules contained β-galactosidase–positive cells (Figure 5a), with immunohistochemistry revealing that these bone marrow–derived cells express megalin in the typical apical location (Figure 5b). Overlay of these images revealed that the same cells contained β-galactosidase in their cytoplasm and megalin on their apical surface (Figure 5c). Staining of kidneys from transplanted animals that did not undergo renal I/R demonstrated that the bone marrow–derived cells in these kidneys coexpressed megalin as well, suggesting that the majority of these cells have differentiated into a proximal tubule phenotype (data not shown).
Bone marrow–derived cells express the renal proximal tubule–specific marker megalin. Sections from kidneys of mice that underwent 25 minutes of ischemia 16 weeks after BMT, followed by 1 week of reflow, were double stained with X-gal (a) and the proximal tubule–specific marker megalin (b). Tubules from the outer medulla that contain cells derived from the bone marrow of the Rosa26 mouse (a, arrow) express megalin on their apical surface (b, arrow), with the merged image showing double staining of the same cell (c, arrows). Two other S3 tubules are shown that express megalin (b, arrowheads) but are not β-galactosidase positive (a, arrowheads). Megalin and β-galactosidase–negative tubules seen faintly in the background represent medullary thick ascending limbs and collecting ducts.
Bone marrow stem cells contribute to functional repair of the ischemically injured tubule. To test our hypothesis that bone marrow stem cells functionally contribute to renal tubule repair, 14 mice were divided into two experimental groups: bone marrow ablation (BMA, n = 7), and BMA followed by stem cell transplantation (BMA-SCT, n = 7). The mice were subjected to BMA by lethal irradiation (11 Gy/animal) followed 12 hours later by bilateral renal pedicle cross-clamping for 30 minutes. Approximately 2.5 hours after reperfusion, seven animals were injected either with 2.9 × 105 Lin– bone marrow cells resuspended in 50 μl of PBS (BMA-SCT group), or with 50 μl PBS vehicle (BMA group). Three animals in each group died within 48 hours of surgery due to postoperative infection and were excluded from the analysis. The remaining eight animals showed no signs of infection and continued to eat and drink for the remainder of the experimental period, although their food intake was judged to be somewhat decreased. A third group of mice underwent 30 minutes of bilateral renal ischemia in the absence of lethal irradiation (control, n = 4). Since the BMA-SCT group was predicted to engraft the transplanted cells during the second week, whereas the BMA group was expected to begin dying during this time, the experiment was terminated on day 7 to minimize the potential effects of improvement of red blood cell, white blood cell, and platelet counts on renal recovery. Peripheral blood counts on day 7 reflected the lethal irradiation but were not significantly different between the two experimental groups (average white blood cell count = 1,000/μl in both BMA and BMA-SCT [normal murine white blood cell count = 5,000–8,000/μl]; average hematocrit = 16.5% in BMA and 16.3% in BMA-SCT [normal murine hematocrit = 50%]; average platelet count = 80,000/μl in BMA and 110,000/μl in BMA-SCT [normal murine platelet count > 700,000/μl]).
Animals undergoing BMA followed by I/R and stem cell transplantation demonstrated a peak BUN of 48.0 ± 12.9 mg/dl on day 2 after I/R with a subsequent decline to 40.6 ± 9 mg/dl by day 7, a pattern that was indistinguishable from that in control mice (Figure 6a). In contrast, animals that did not receive stem cells had a peak BUN of 77.5 ± 25 mg/dl on day 2 with no recovery during the 7-day experimental period (day 7 BUN = 75 ± 1.8 mg/dl). Of note, animals subjected to 11 Gy in the absence of renal artery cross-clamping had no change in BUN (preirradiation BUN = 17.2 ± 0.6 mg/dl, BUN 4 days after irradiation = 18.2 ± 2.9 mg/dl, n = 10).
BMA worsens the course of ischemic ATN. (a) BUN values from mice that underwent bilateral ischemia for 30 minutes followed by 7 days of recovery. Mice underwent BMA prior to I/R (BMA); underwent BMA prior to I/R and stem cell transplantation after I/R (BMA-SCT); or underwent I/R without BMA (control). (b and c) X-gal staining of kidney sections reveals multiple β-galactosidase–positive tubules in the kidneys of BMA-SCT animals 48 hours after I/R (b) and 7 days after I/R (c). Of note, the sections in b were not counterstained with neutral fast red. (d–g) H&E staining reveals tubular damage in the outer medulla of both groups, with extensive denudation of some of the tubular basement membranes in animals that underwent BMA alone (d and e, arrowheads). The majority of damaged tubules in the BMA-SCT group contain flattened cells lining the basement membrane (g, arrows), while other areas demonstrate almost complete resolution of the injury (f). ×40.
The observation that stem cell infusion limited the initial rise in BUN suggested that these cells must have reached the renal tubule within 48 hours of I/R. To examine this possibility, an additional group of three mice underwent BMA and stem cell infusion as described. These mice were sacrificed 48 hours after reperfusion, and kidney sections were examined for the presence of β-galactosidase–positive cells. At this early time point, multiple tubules were found to contain cells derived from the transplanted bone marrow (Figure 6b). Staining on day 7 revealed persistence of these cells in the outer medulla of animals in the BMA-SCT group (Figure 6c).
Renal histology on day 7 revealed a spectrum of injury in both groups. Kidneys from animals in the BMA group had some areas of extensive necrosis remaining in the outer medulla (Figure 6d), whereas other regions of the outer medulla revealed only patchy areas of necrosis (Figure 6e). Multiple tubules demonstrated persistent areas of basement membrane denudation (arrowheads), while some tubules had flattened cells lining these injured segments. In contrast, animals receiving stem cell transplants after BMA and I/R had large areas in which there was substantial resolution of the necrotic injury (Figure 6f) but also had significant regions in which tubular injury was still evident (Figure 6g). However, the tubules that did show persistent injury were judged to have less frank denudation and more cells lining the tubular basement membrane than were seen in the BMA control group (Figure 6g, arrows).