Irrationality and Popular Archaeology | American Antiquity | Cambridge Core (original) (raw)

Abstract

An important aspect of archaeology is communicating the significance of data and research results to a fascinated, although often uninformed public. However, on the basis of book sales, newspaper coverage, television programming, and film presentations, it would seem that the public is inordinately fascinated by the more extreme, speculative, and often pseudoscientific claims made by those purporting to use archaeological data. Through questionnaires distributed to undergraduate students and to professional, teaching archaeologists, I made an attempt to comprehend the nature of the public's appetite for pseudoscientific archaeological claims. The role of education in refuting or perpetuating pseudoscience in archaeology was then assessed.

References

Bainbridge, William Sims 1978 Chariots of the Gullible. The Skeptical Inquirer 3(2): 33–48.Google Scholar

Berlitz, Charles 1969 The Mystery of Atlantis. Nordon Publications, New York.Google Scholar

Cazeau, Charles, and Scott, Stuart 1979 Exploring the Unknown: Great Mysteries Reexamined. Plenum Press, New York.Google Scholar

Cohen, Daniel 1976 The Ancient Visitors. Doubleday and Company, New York.Google Scholar

Cole, John R. 1978 Anthropology Beyond the Fringe: Ancient Inscriptions, Early Man and Scientific Method. The Skeptical Inquirer 2(2): 62–71.Google Scholar

Cole, John R. 1979 Inscription Mania, Hyperdiffusionism and the Public: Fallout from a 1977 Meeting in Vermont. Man in the Northeast 17: 27–54.Google Scholar

Cole, John R. 1980 Cult Archaeology and Unscientific Method and Theory. In Advances in Archaeological Method and Theory, Volume 3, edited by Schiffer, Michael, pp. 1-33. Academic Press, New York.Google Scholar

Cole, John R. 1981 Cult Archaeology in America. Bulletin of the Archaeological Society of Connecticut 44: 60–66.Google Scholar

Cole, John R. 1982 Western Massachusetts “Monks Caves“: 1979 University of Massachusetts Field Research. Man in the Northeast 24: 37–69.Google Scholar

Cole, John R. 1983 The Case of the Texas Footprints. Videotape, written and produced by Cole. Pia Nicolini director. American Anthropological Association.Google Scholar

DeCamp, L. Sprague 1954 Lost Continents: The Atlantis Theme in History, Science, and Literature. Gnome Press, New York.Google Scholar

Donnelly, Ignatius 1971 Atlantis, the Antediluvian World, (originally published 1882). Harper and Row, New York.Google Scholar

Eldredge, Niles 1982 The Monkey Business: A Scientist Looks at Creationism. Washington Square Press, New York.Google Scholar

Fagan, Brian 1981 American Genesis? Review of American Genesis by Jeffrey, Goodman. Early Man 3(4): 24–26.Google Scholar

Feder, Kenneth L. 1980a Psychic Archaeology: The Anatomy of Irrationalist Prehistoric Studies. The Skeptical Inquirer 4(4): 32–43.Google Scholar

Feder, Kenneth L. 1980b Foolsgold of the Gods. The Humanist Jan/Feb: 20–23.Google Scholar

Feder, Kenneth L. 1983 American Disingenuous: A Critique of Dr. Jeffrey Goodman's American Genesis. The Skeptical Inquirer, 7(4): 36–48.Google Scholar

Fell, Barry 1976 America B. C.: European Settlers in the New World. Quadrangle/The New York Times Book Co., New York.Google Scholar

Galanopoulos, A. G., and Bacon, Edward 1969 Atlantis: The Truth Behind the Legend. The Bobbs-Merrill Company, N. Y.Google Scholar

Gallup, George Jr., and Poling, David 1980 The Search for America's Faith. Abington Press, Nashville. Universitetsforlaget, Oslo.Google Scholar

Jones, David 1979 Visions of Time: Experiments in Psychic Archaeology. The Theosophical Publishing House, Wheaton, III.Google Scholar

King, Thomas F. 1981 The NART: A Plan to Direct Archaeology Toward More Relevant Goals in Modern Life. Early Man 3(4): 35–38.Google Scholar

Kosok, Paul 1965 Life, Land, and Water in Ancient Peru. Long Island University Press, New York.Google Scholar

Kosok, Paul, and Reiche, Maria 1947 The Mysterious Markings of Nazca. Natural History 56: 200-207, 237–238.Google Scholar

Kra, Renee (editor) 1981 New England Megaliths: Fact and Fancy. Bulletin 44 of the Archaeological Society of Connecticut. Google Scholar

Krupp, E. C. (editor) 1978 In Search of Ancient Astronomies. Doubleday and Company, New York.Google Scholar

Krupp, E. C. 1983 Echoes of the Ancient Skies: The Astronomy of Lost Civilizations. Harper and Row, New York.Google Scholar

La Haye, Tim, and Morris, John 1976 The Ark on Ararat. Creation-Life Publishers, San Diego.Google Scholar

Lundeen, Gerhard E., and Caldwell, Otis W. 1930 A Study of Unfounded Beliefs Among High School Seniors. Journal of Educational Research 22(4): 257–273.Google Scholar

Mac Neish, Richard S. 1964 Ancient Mesoamerican Civilization. Science 143: 531–537.Google Scholar

McKusick, Marshall 1981 Review of Saga America by Barry, Fell. Archaeology 34: 62–66.Google Scholar

McKusick, Marshall 1982 Psychic Archaeology: Theory, Method, and Mythology. Journal of Field Archaeology 9: 99–118.Google Scholar

Moore, Robert 1983 Special Issue: The Impossible Voyage of Noah's Ark. Creation/Evolution. Issue XI.Google Scholar

Morris, Henry 1974 Scientific Creationism. Creation-Life Publishers, San Diego.Google Scholar

Morris, John 1980 Tracking Those Incredible Dinosaurs and the People Who Knew Them. Creation-Life Publishers, San Diego.Google Scholar

Napier, John 1973 Bigfoot: The Yeti and Sasauatch in Myth and Reality. E. P. Dutton & Co., New York.Google Scholar

Neudorfer, Giovanna 1980 Vermont's Stone Chambers. Vermont Historical Society, Montpelier, Vt.Google Scholar

Newell, Norman D. 1982 Creation and Evolution: Myth or Reality. Columbia University Press, New York.Google Scholar

Pastner, Stephen, and Haviland, William 1982 Confronting the Creationists. Northeastern Anthropological Association Occasional Proceedings 1.Google Scholar

Ross, Anne, and Reynolds, Peter 1978 Ancient Vermont. Antiquity 52: 100–107.Google Scholar

Sabloff, Jeremy A. (editor) 1982 Archaeology: Myth and Reality. W. H. Freeman, San Francisco.Google Scholar

Schwartz, Stephan 1978 The Secret Vaults of Time: Psychic Archaeology and the Quest for Man's Beginnings. Grosset & Dunlap Publ., New York.Google Scholar

Snow, Dean 1981 Martians and Vikings, Madoc and Runes. American Heritage 32(6): 102–108.Google Scholar

Snyder, Gerald 1977 Is There a Loch Ness Monster: The Search for a Legend. Wanderer Books, New York.Google Scholar

Stanford, Dennis 1981 Who's on First? Review of American Genesis by Jeffrey, Goodman. Science ‘81 June, pp. 91–92.Google Scholar

Story, Ronald 1976 The Space-Gods Revealed. Harper and Row, New York.Google Scholar

Turner, Christy G. II 1981 Review of American Genesis: The American Indian and the Origins of Modern Man by Jeffrey, Goodman. Archaeology 35: 72–74.Google Scholar

von DSniken, Erich 1970 Chariots of the Gods: Unsolved Mysteries of the Past. Bantam Books, New York.Google Scholar

von DSniken, Erich 1972 Gods from Outer Space. Bantam Books, New York.Google Scholar

von DSniken, Erich 1974 Gold of the Gods. Bantam Books, New York.Google Scholar

Wauchope, Robert 1962 Lost Tribes and Sunken Continents: Myth and Method in the Study of American Indians. University of Chicago Press, Chicago.Google Scholar

White, Peter 1974 The Past Is Human. Tapplinger Press, New York.Google Scholar