State Farm vs. Nationwide [2026]: Which Is Best for You? (original) (raw)

Nationwide and State Farm are giants in the insurance industry. While both are reputable companies with a broad range of coverage options and discount programs, Nationwide edges out State Farm in claims satisfaction. However, State Farm generally has lower rates than Nationwide for all types of drivers.

In full disclosure, I've been a long-time State Farm customer and appreciate State Farm's personalized experience. Nationwide has a smaller agent network than State Farm, and State Farm's mobile app is rated slightly higher than Nationwide's. For those (like me) who prioritize customer service, State Farm may be the better choice.

How we rate products

FinanceBuzz researches a number of factors in each auto insurance provider to create our reviews. These factors include cost and discounts, complaints and customer satisfaction, coverage, and ease of use. We also gather information from sources such as Insurify, J.D. Power, AM Best, the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC), and the Better Business Bureau to ensure we provide the most useful information to our readers.

Smart Drivers, Smarter Savings.

Compare car insurance rates in District of Columbia

See if lower rates are available

Currently Insured?

Yes

No

By clicking the button above, I understand and agree that this site uses site visit recording technology (provided by Trusted Form, Jornaya, and Microsoft Clarity) Privacy Policy

State Farm pros and cons

Pros

• Larger agent network
• Cheaper liability and full coverage policies than Nationwide
• Offers rideshare insurance

Cons

• Not available in Rhode Island or Massachusetts
• Doesn't offer GAP coverage

Learn more in our State Farm review.

Nationwide pros and cons

Pros

• Customers in some states are eligible for accident forgiveness
• Offers both telematics and usage-based programs
• Stronger claims satisfaction rating from J.D. Power

Cons

• Smaller agent network
• Not available in Alaska, Hawaii, Louisiana, or Massachusetts
• The SmartMiles program isn't available in Alaska, Hawaii, Louisiana, North Carolina, New York, or Oklahoma

Learn more in our Nationwide review.

Which company is better?

Both State Farm and Nationwide are big-name insurers. Although Nationwide is available in most states, residents of Alaska, Hawaii, Louisiana, or Massachusetts don't qualify for its auto coverage. State Farm is more widely available to residents of every state except Rhode Island and Massachusetts.

If you're a resident of one of the states where both companies offer auto insurance, consider the following factors:

| | State Farm | Nationwide | | | ----------------------------------- | ---------------- | --------------- | | AM Best | A++ (Superior) | A (Excellent) | | J.D. Power claims satisfaction | 6th out of 21 | 4th out of 21 | | BBB | F (Unaccredited) | A+ (Accredited) | | NAIC complaints (private passenger) | 0.84 | 0.70 |

Financial stability

Financial stability is a measure of a company's ability to meet its financial obligations. It's a key factor to consider when choosing an insurer, since you want to know the company will be around for the long haul and pay out claims. AM Best, a credit rating agency that primarily focuses on the insurance industry, issues its financial strength ratings for companies each year.

State Farm has AM Best's highest rating, "A++" (Superior). Nationwide also has a positive rating, "A" (Excellent), but it ranks below State Farm in terms of financial strength.

Customer satisfaction

In the 2024 J.D. Power U.S. Auto Claims Satisfaction Study, both Nationwide and State Farm scored above the industry average. But Nationwide beat State Farm; it was ranked fourth out of 21 companies, while State Farm was sixth. The study evaluated companies on several factors, including customer trust levels, the perceived fairness of settlements, the ease of submitting and resolving claims, and communication.

The NAIC looks at how many customer complaints insurers have compared to other companies based on their market size. While both Nationwide and State Farm have an NAIC complaint index below the national average, Nationwide has a slightly lower complaint volume.

Additionally, State Farm has a Better Business Bureau rating of "F," partly for having many unanswered and unresolved customer complaints, and isn't accredited. Nationwide has the highest A+ rating and is accredited.

Accessibility

State Farm and Nationwide both sell policies through agents, by phone and online. State Farm has a larger network of agents than Nationwide, so for those who prefer the convenience of a local agent, this insurer may be the better option. For me, having a person nearby I know and trust to go to with questions is a huge benefit.

Which company is cheaper?

Which company offers lower car insurance premiums depends on your location, driving record, selected coverages, and many other factors. In general, I found that a State Farm insurance policy is cheaper across the board for drivers seeking a liability-only or full coverage policy.

Here's a look at how State Farm's average rates across driver type:

And here are Nationwide's for comparison:

Clean driving record

For those who have a clean driving history and want full coverage policies, full coverage insurance from State Farm is much cheaper than Nationwide. On average, drivers pay 108permonthforcoveragewithStateFarm,whiledriverswithNationwidepay108 per month for coverage with State Farm, while drivers with Nationwide pay 108permonthforcoveragewithStateFarm,whiledriverswithNationwidepay189 per month.

Speeding ticket on driving record

If you have a speeding ticket on your record, State Farm tends to be much cheaper than Nationwide. Drivers typically pay 139permonthforfullcoverage—lesspermonththanNationwide′s139 per month for full coverage — less per month than Nationwide's 139permonthforfullcoverage—lesspermonththanNationwide′s254 average.

At-fault accident on driving record

An at-fault accident can substantially affect your premiums. With State Farm, you'll pay about 144permonthforfullcoverage,whileNationwideaveragesmuchmoreat144 per month for full coverage, while Nationwide averages much more at 144permonthforfullcoverage,whileNationwideaveragesmuchmoreat260.

DUI on driving record

A DUI causes the steepest increases in car insurance rates. With State Farm, your rate for full coverage would average 155permonth.WithNationwide,you′daverage155 per month. With Nationwide, you'd average 155permonth.WithNationwide,you′daverage272 per month.

Teen driver

Teens will also pay less for car insurance with State Farm than with Nationwide. On average, teen drivers pay 224permonthforfullcoveragewithStateFarm—lessthantheaveragerateof224 per month for full coverage with State Farm — less than the average rate of 224permonthforfullcoveragewithStateFarm—lessthantheaveragerateof395 per month for drivers who choose Nationwide.

Senior driver

Seniors usually pay less for car insurance. For full coverage policies, State Farm's premiums average just 76permonthfordriversintheir60sand76 per month for drivers in their 60s and 76permonthfordriversintheir60sand68 for drivers in their 70s. Nationwide's monthly premiums for these drivers average 126and126 and 126and120, respectively.

Discounts

I'm always looking to cut costs, but I don't want to sacrifice customer service or coverage. For drivers like me, discount programs allow me to reduce my car insurance premiums without adjusting my insurance policy.

Both Nationwide and State Farm have multiple discount programs, but State Farm has more options. Some standout discounts that State Farm offers (and Nationwide doesn't) include discounts for military service members, away-from-home discounts for college students, and loyalty discounts for long-time customers.

State Farm Drive Safe & Save vs. Nationwide SmartRide and SmartMiles

Because I work from home and don't have a daily commute, I tend to drive fewer-than-average miles, so participating in a telematics program or a usage-based insurance policy can allow me to save money on car insurance.

State Farm and Nationwide have programs you can use to reduce your rates based on your mileage or driving habits.

State Farm's Drive Safe & Save

If you use the Drive Safe & Save app, State Farm bases your premiums on your driving habits. You can qualify for a discount just for signing up, and maintaining safe driving habits can help you reduce your premiums by up to 30%.

Drive Safe & Save isn't available in California, Massachusetts, or Rhode Island. Some North Carolina residents also might not have access to the program.

Nationwide's SmartRide

With SmartRide, you can save up to 40% on your policy. As this is a discount program, participants will only ever see their rates decrease, not increase.

Nationwide's SmartMiles

SmartMiles is a pay-per-mile insurance program. It bases your premiums on how many miles you actually cover. SmartMiles isn't available in Alaska, Hawaii, Louisiana, New York, North Carolina, or Oklahoma.

Coverage

Although both companies provide solid coverage options for most drivers, there are a few scenarios when one company may be a better fit than the other:

• You need rideshare insurance: If you drive for a rideshare company like Uber or Lyft or a delivery service like DoorDash or Uber Eats, you may need a rideshare policy for when your service-provided coverage isn't active. Nationwide doesn't offer rideshare insurance, but State Farm allows customers to add this coverage to a personal policy.
• You need guaranteed asset protection (GAP) insurance: If you're in an accident and your car is declared a total loss or stolen, GAP coverage pays the difference between your car's value and your remaining auto loan or lease balance. Unlike State Farm, Nationwide offers customers GAP coverage, which your lender or lease company may require.

Below is a breakdown of what coverages these companies offer:

| | State Farm | Nationwide | | | -------------------------------- | -------------- | -------------------- | | Collision | Yes | Yes | | Comprehensive | Yes | Yes | | Liability | Yes | Yes | | Medical payments | Yes | Yes | | Uninsured/Underinsured | Yes | Yes | | Rideshare | Yes | No | | RV insurance | Yes | Yes | | ATV & off-road vehicle insurance | Yes | Yes | | Motorcycle insurance | Yes | Yes | | Antique/collector cars | Yes | Yes, through Hagerty | | GAP | No | Yes |

FAQs

How do I contact State Farm?

State Farm allows customers to reach out in several ways. You can talk directly to a local agent, or you can call its general customer support line at 1-800-782-8332. State Farm also has a powerful mobile app, or you can use its online chat feature.

How do I contact Nationwide?

You can contact Nationwide by reaching out to a local agent or by calling its customer support department at 1-877-669-6877 on weekdays from 9 a.m. to 8 p.m. ET.

Which insurance is better, State Farm or Nationwide?

No specific company is better for every driver. For those looking for affordability over everything else, State Farm may be the better option. However, those who need GAP insurance or prefer a better claims experience may prefer Nationwide.

Bottom line

There's a reason State Farm and Nationwide are such well-known companies: They're leaders in the industry, offering broad coverage options and discounts. Whether you've got a spotless or blemished driving history, State Farm insurance coverage is likely cheaper, regardless of your age. But if you're willing to pay more for better claims satisfaction, get a Nationwide insurance auto quote to see if it's worth the extra cost.

Before selecting any company, get quotes from several insurers. You can compare quotes from the best car insurance companies and save money.

Save On Your Auto Insurance

• You could save up to $600 with some companies.
• Compare dozens of providers in under 5 minutes.
• Fast, free, and easy way to shop for insurance.
• Quickly find the perfect rate for you.

Related Articles