GitHub - Feh/nocache: minimize caching effects (original) (raw)

Stop and read before you blindly try this tool

What is this tool good for:

• Learn about how the Linux page cache works, and what syscalls exist to interfere with its normal operation.
• Learn what hacks are necessary to intercept syscalls via their libc wrappers.

What this tool is not good for:

• Controlling how your page cache is used
  • Why do you think some random tool you found on GitHub can do better than the Linux Kernel?
• Defending against cache thrashing
  • Use cgroups to bound the amount of memory a process has. See below or search the internet, this is widely known, works reliably, and does not introduce performance penalties or potentially dangerous behavior like this tool does.
• Making a binary run faster
  • nocache intercepts a bunch of syscalls and does lots of speculative work; it will slow down your binary.

So then why does this tool exist?

• It was written in 2012, when cgroups, containerization etc. were all new things. A decade+ on, they aren’t any more.

How to run a process and its children in a memory-bounded cgroup

Do this if you e.g. want to run a backup but don’t want your system to slow down due to page cache thrashing.

If you use systemd

If your distro uses systemd, this is very easy. Systemd allows to run a process (and its subprocesses) in a “scope”, which is a cgroup, and you can specify parameters that get translated to cgroup limits.

When I run my backups, I do:

$ systemd-run --scope --property=MemoryLimit=500M -- backup command

The effect is that cache space stays bounded by an additional max 500MiB:

Before:

$ free -h
              total        used        free      shared  buff/cache   available
Mem:           7.5G        2.4G        1.3G        1.0G        3.7G        3.7G
Swap:          9.7G         23M        9.7G

During (notice how buff/cache only goes up by ~300MiB):

free -h
              total        used        free      shared  buff/cache   available
Mem:           7.5G        2.5G        1.0G        1.1G        4.0G        3.6G
Swap:          9.7G         23M        9.7G

How does this work?

Use systemd-cgls to list the cgroups systemd creates. On my system, the above command creates a group called run-u467.scope in the system.slice parent group; you can inspect its memory settings like this:

$ mount | grep cgroup | grep memory
cgroup on /sys/fs/cgroup/memory type cgroup (rw,nosuid,nodev,noexec latime,memory)

$ cat /sys/fs/cgroup/memory/system.slice/run-u467.scope/memory.limit_in_bytes
524288000

The hard way

Install cgroup-tools and be prepared to enter your root password to initially create cgroups.

sudo env ppid=$$ sh -c '
    cgcreate -g memory:backup ;
    echo 500M > /sys/fs/cgroup/memory/backup/memory.limit_in_bytes ;
    echo $ppid > /sys/fs/cgroup/memory/backup/tasks ;
'

After entering this, your shell is a member of that cgroup, and any new process spawned will belong to that cgroup, too, and inherit the memory limit. The cgroups created like this won’t be cleaned up automatically.

More info: https://www.kernel.org/doc/Documentation/cgroup-v1/memory.txt

nocache - minimize filesystem caching effects

The nocache tool tries to minimize the effect an application has on the Linux file system cache. This is done by intercepting the openand close system calls and calling posix_fadvise with thePOSIX_FADV_DONTNEED parameter. Because the library remembers which pages (ie., 4K-blocks of the file) were already in file system cache when the file was opened, these will not be marked as "don't need", because other applications might need that, although they are not actively used (think: hot standby).

Installation and Usage

Just type make. Then, prepend ./nocache to your command:

./nocache cp -a ~/ /mnt/backup/home-$(hostname)

The command make install will install the shared library, man pages and the nocache, cachestats and cachedel commands under /usr/local. You can specify an alternate prefix by usingmake install PREFIX=/usr.

Debian packages are available, see https://packages.qa.debian.org/n/nocache.html.

Please note that nocache will only build on a system that has support for the posix_fadvise syscall and exposes it, too. This should be the case on most modern Unices, but kfreebsd notably has no support for this as of now.

Testing

For testing purposes, I included two small tools:

• cachedel calls posix_fadvise(fd, 0, 0, POSIX_FADV_DONTNEED) on the file argument. Thus, if the file is not accessed by any other application, the pages will be eradicated from the fs cache. Specifying -n will repeat the syscall the given number of times which can be useful in some circumstances (see below).
• cachestats has three modes: In quiet mode (-q), the exit status is 0 (success) if the file is fully cached. In normal mode, the number of cached vs. not-cached pages is printed. In verbose mode (-v), an actual map is printed out, where each page that is present in the cache is marked with x.

It looks like this:

$ cachestats -v ~/somefile.mp3
pages in cache: 85/114 (74.6%)  [filesize=453.5K, pagesize=4K]

cache map:
     0: |x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|
    32: |x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|
    64: |x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x|x| | | | | | | | | | | | |
    96: | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |x|

Also, you can use vmstat 1 to view cache statistics.

For debugging purposes, you can specify a filename that nocache should log debugging messages to via the -D command line switch, e.g. use nocache -D /tmp/nocache.log …. Note that for simple testing the file /dev/stderrmight be a good choice.

Example run

Without nocache, the file will be fully cached when you copy it somewhere:

$ ./cachestats ~/file.mp3
pages in cache: 154/1945 (7.9%)  [filesize=7776.2K, pagesize=4K]
$ cp ~/file.mp3 /tmp
$ ./cachestats ~/file.mp3
pages in cache: 1945/1945 (100.0%)  [filesize=7776.2K, pagesize=4K]

With nocache, the original caching state will be preserved.

$ ./cachestats ~/file.mp3
pages in cache: 154/1945 (7.9%)  [filesize=7776.2K, pagesize=4K]
$ ./nocache cp ~/file.mp3 /tmp
$ ./cachestats ~/file.mp3
pages in cache: 154/1945 (7.9%)  [filesize=7776.2K, pagesize=4K]

Limitations

The pre-loaded library tries really hard to catch all system calls that open or close a file. This happens by "hijacking" the libc functions that wrap the actual system calls. In some cases, this may fail, for example because the application does some clever wrapping. (That is the reason why __openat_2 is defined: GNU tar uses this instead of a regular openat.)

However, since the actual fadvise calls are performed right before the file descriptor is closed, this may not happen if they are left open when the application exits, although the destructor tries to do that.

There are timing issues to consider, as well. If you consider nocache cat <file>, in most (all?) cases the cache will not be restored. For discussion and possible solutions see http://lwn.net/Articles/480930/. My experience showed that in many cases you could "fix" this by doing the posix_fadvise call twice. For both tools nocache andcachedel you can specify the number using -n, like so:

$ nocache -n 2 cat ~/file.mp3

This actually only sets the environment variable NOCACHE_NR_FADVISEto the specified value, and the shared library reads out this value. If test number 3 in t/basic.t fails, then try increasing this number until it works, e.g.:

$ env NOCACHE_NR_FADVISE=2 make test

One could also consider that the fact pages are kept mean the kernel considers they are hot, and decide the overhead of allocating one byte per page for mincore and the actual mincore calls are not worth it when the kernel actually does keep some pages when it wants to.

In this case you can either run nocache with -f or set theNOCACHE_FLUSHALL environment variable to 1, e.g.:

$ nocache -f cat ~/file.mp3
$ env NOCACHE_FLUSHALL=1 make test

By default nocache will only keep track of file descriptors less than 2^20that are opened by your application, in order to bound its memory consumption. If you want to change this threshold, you can supply the environment variable NOCACHE_MAX_FDS and set it to a higher (or lower) value. It should specify a value one greater than the maximum file descriptor that will be handled by nocache.

Acknowledgements

Most of the application logic is from Tobias Oetiker's patch forrsync http://insights.oetiker.ch/linux/fadvise.html. Note however, that rsync uses sockets, so if you try a nocache rsync, only the local process will be intercepted.