GitHub - js-choi/proposal-function-demethodize: Draft specification for a standard demethodize function in JavaScript. (original) (raw)

Demethodize function for JavaScript

ECMAScript Stage-0 Proposal. J. S. Choi, 2022.

Rationale

The dynamic this binding is a fundamental part of JavaScript design and practice today. Many APIs use the this binding functionally as another “argument” to their functions. Because of this, developers frequently need to change the this binding. However, dynamic prototype-based dispatch may often be undesirable, and using a .call.bind() method is frequent in many codebases.

We therefore propose exploring the addition of an API to the JavaScript language that would convert this-based methods into ordinary functions that do not use this.

If this proposal is approved for Stage 1, then we would explore various directions for the API’s design. We would also assemble as many real-world use cases as possible and shape our design to fulfill them.

In addition, if we would explore cross-cutting concerns and overlap with the proposed call-this syntax and other dataflow proposals.

Description

The Function.prototype.demethodize method would create a new function that calls the original function, supplying its first argument as the original function’s this receiver, and supplying the rest of its arguments as the original function’s ordinary arguments.

This is useful for converting this-based functions into non-this-based functions.

fn.demethodize();

const $slice = Array.prototype.slice.demethodize(); $slice([ 0, 1, 2 ], 1); // [ 1, 2 ].

This is not a substitute for a call-this syntax, which allows developers to change the receiver of functions without creating a wrapper function.

fn.demethodize() is equivalent to
Function.prototype.call.bind(fn) and to
Function.prototype.bind.bind(Function.prototype.call)(fn).

Therefore, fn.demethodize()(thisArg, ...restArgs) is equivalent tofn.call(thisArg, ...restArgs).

The following real-world example originally used call-bind or a manually created similar function.

// From chrome-devtools-frontend@1.0.934332 // node_modules/array-includes/test/implementation.js. runTests(implementation.demethodize(), t);

// From string.prototype.trimstart@1.0.4/index.js: var bound = getPolyfill().demethodize();

// From andreasgal/dom.js (84b7ab6) src/snapshot.js. const /* … / join = A.join || Array.prototype.join.demethodize(), map = A.map || Array.prototype.map.demethodize(), push = A.push || Array.prototype.push.demethodize(), / … */;

Precedents include: