Raz Kletter | University of Helsinki (original) (raw)
Books by Raz Kletter
Community Archaeology in Israel/Palestine (together with E. Pfoh and L. Kolska Horowitz)), 2024
Although Community (or Public) Archaeology originated in western countries, it has now spread all... more Although Community (or Public) Archaeology originated in western countries, it has now spread all over the world. It integrates the archaeological past with living peoples in new and unique ways. It is however, a rather loosely-defined field; to some it means an attitude and a theoretical concept, which is, or should be, valid for archaeology as a whole and for every archaeologist. For others it is a certain practice or sub-field of archaeology, which by now has its own experts-that is, community archaeologists.
"A thought-provoking, insightful, and comprehensive volume that investigates different ways of practicing community archaeology in Israel/Palestine. A must-read for people interested in community archaeology and the history of archaeology in all its complexities."
Aron Mazel, Newcastle University
This volume is a critical study of recent archaeology in the Western Wall Plaza area, Jerusalem. ... more This volume is a critical study of recent archaeology in the Western Wall Plaza area, Jerusalem. Considered one of the holiest places on Earth for Jews and Muslims, it is also a place of controversy, where the State marks ‘our’ remains for preservation and adoration and ‘theirs’ for silencing.
Based on thousands of documents from the Israel Antiquities Authority and other sources, such as protocols of planning committees, readers can explore for the first time this archaeological ‘heart of darkness’ in East Jerusalem. The book follows a series of unique iscoveries, reviewing the approval and execution of development plans and excavations, and the use of the sites once excavation has finished. Who decides what and how to excavate, what to preserve – or ‘remove’? Who pays for the archaeology, for what aims?
The professional, scientific archaeology of the past happens now: it modifies the present and is modified by it. This book ‘excavates’ the archaeology of East Jerusalem to reveal its social and political contexts, power structures and ethics.
Readers interested in the history, archaeology and politics of the Israeli–Palestinian conflict will find this book useful, as well as scholars and students of the history and ethics of archaeology, Jerusalem, conservation, nationalism
and heritage.
Archaeology, Heritage and Ethics in the Western Wall Plaza, Jerusalem: Darkness at the End of the Tunnel, 2019
This volume is a critical study of recent archaeology in the Western Wall Plaza area, Jerusalem. ... more This volume is a critical study of recent archaeology in the Western Wall Plaza area, Jerusalem. Considered one of the holiest places on Earth for Jews and Muslims, it is also a place of controversy, where the State marks ‘our’ remains for preservation and adoration and ‘theirs’ for silencing.
Based on thousands of documents from the Israel Antiquities Authority and other sources, such as protocols of planning committees, readers can explore for the first time this archaeological ‘heart of darkness’ in East Jerusalem. The book follows a series of unique discoveries, reviewing the approval and execution of development plans and excavations, and the use of the sites once excavation has finished. Who decides what and how to excavate, what to preserve – or ‘remove’? Who pays for the archaeology, for what aims? The professional, scientific archaeology of the past happens now: it modifies the present and is modified by it. This book ‘excavates’ the archaeology of East Jerusalem to reveal its social and political contexts, power structures and ethics.
Readers interested in the history, archaeology and politics of the Israeli–Palestinian conflict will find this book useful, as well as scholars and students of the history and ethics of archaeology, Jerusalem, conservation, nationalism and heritage.
Münster: Zaphon Press (Ägypten und altes Testament 88) (2 Volumes), 2018
ÄgypTen und AlTes TesTAmenT 88 yosi levy and Raz Kletter Zaphon Rishon le-Zion Volume I The Middl... more ÄgypTen und AlTes TesTAmenT 88 yosi levy and Raz Kletter Zaphon Rishon le-Zion Volume I The Middle Bronze Age II Cemeteries Volume I/ 1: The excavations With Contributions by daphna Ben-Tor, Vered eshed, Amir golani, eriola Jakoel, Tal Kan-Cipor -meron, nili liphschitz, yossi nagar, Itzhaq shai, sariel shalev,
Yavneh II is the second and last excavation report on the dramatic favissa/genizah pit full of Ph... more Yavneh II is the second and last excavation report on the dramatic favissa/genizah pit full of Philistine votive objects, discovered by Raz Kletter in the city of Yavneh, Israel, near the Mediterranean coast (south of Tel Aviv). The first volume, Yavneh I (OBO.SA 30, 2010) included studies on the history and archaeological exploration of Yavneh, the excavation, the stratigraphy and the interpretation of the pit as a favissae of votive objects that originate from a public temple; but especially on the mysterious cult stands, which number more than a hundred and include many stands with zoomorphic and anthropomorphic figures. In the present volume we publish many additional cultic finds, including fire pans or shovels that could be used for moving hot coals and for burning incense (comparable to the biblical maḥtāh); a rectangular shrine-model (naos) with detached pillars; zoomorphic vessels; a larger sample of pottery with statistical analysis; imported Cypriot pottery; dog bones (probably related to ritual); an inscription on a bowl; fragments of worked stones (perhaps from altars); and chemical residues from juglets and chalices, which seem to indicate presence of hallucinatory and incense materials. In addition, we offer an update on the iconography of the Yavneh cult stands and a study of the larger world of cult stands in the southern Levant; criteria for identifying favissae and their appearance from the Late Bronze Age to the Persian Period in Palestine; and a concluding discussion on Yavneh, incense, and Philistine ethnicity.
Yavneh II is the second and last excavation report on the dramatic favissa pit full of Philistine... more Yavneh II is the second and last excavation report on the
dramatic favissa pit full of Philistine votive objects, discovered by Raz Kletter in Yavneh, Israel, near the Mediterranean coast south of Tel-Aviv. The first volume, Yavneh I (2010) included studies on the history and archaeological exploration of Yavneh, the excavation, and the interpretation of the pit as a favissae of votive objects from a public temple. Especially this volume focused on the more than a hundred cult stands, which include many stands with zoomorphic and anthropomorphic figures.
In volume II we publish many additional cultic finds, including fire-pans or shovels for moving hot coals and for burning incense (comparable to the biblical maḥtāh); a rectangular shrine-model (naos); zoomorphic vessels; a larger sample of pottery with statistical analysis; Cypriot pottery; dog bones (probably related to ritual); an inscription on a bowl; fragments of worked stones (perhaps from altars); and chemical residues from juglets and chalices, which seem to indicate presence of hallucinatory and incense materials.
We also offer an update on the iconography of the Yavneh cult stands and a study of the larger world of
cult stands in the southern Levant; criteria for identifying favissae and their appearance from the Late Bronze Age to the Persian Period in Palestine; and a concluding discussion on Yavneh, incense, and Philistine ethnicity
2010: Yavneh Volume I. The Excavation of the 'Temple Hill' Repository Pit and the Cult Stands (OBO Series Archaeologia 30) , 2010
In the words of late Professor Moshe Kochavi, the Philistine repository pit at Yavneh is the kind... more In the words of late Professor Moshe Kochavi, the Philistine repository pit at Yavneh is the kind of discovery made only once every fifty years. It is the richest repository pit ever found from Bronze and Iron Ages Israel/Palestine, containing thousands of cultic finds originating from a temple, including an unprecedented number-more than a hundred-of cult stands (so-called 'architectural models') carrying rich figurative art, dozens of fire-pans, chalices and other objects. The present volume includes the full publication of the excavation, the stratigraphy, the cult stands and the figures detached from cult stands, several clay and stone altars and some pottery vessels related to burning of plant material, most likely incense. This exceptional book raises a host of highly important and intriguing questions. Is this a favissa, or even a genizah? Why are many cult stands badly broken, while some are intact-were cult stands broken on purpose? What is the explanation for the unique stratigraphy and for the layer of gray ash in the pit-was fire kindled inside as part of a ritual? How do we know that these finds are Philistine? Are they part of the 'furniture' of the temple or objects dedicated by worshipers as votives? Do the figures on the cult stands represent mortal beings, or divinities? If divinities, can we relate them with Biblical or extra-biblical data on the gods of the Philistines? What was the function/s of cult stands? Were they models of buildings, supports for images, offerings tables, altars, or perhaps incense burners? Why are female figures dominant, while male figures are virtually absent? In discussing such topics, Yavneh I treats issues that are central to many fields of study: religion and cult in Iron Age Israel/Palestine; the history and archaeology of the Philistines and their 'western' relations; Near Eastern iconography, the meaning of cult stands/architectural models and the understanding of votive objects and of repository pits in general. Literally salvaged from the teeth of the bulldozer, these rare finds are now published. Generations of scholars will discuss and reinterpret them-there is no 'final word' for such finds and hence, this final excavation volume is not an end, but a beginning.
Raz Kletter (*1960), obtained his PhD in archaeology from Tel Aviv University in 1995 with a diss... more Raz Kletter (*1960), obtained his PhD in archaeology from Tel Aviv University in 1995 with a dissertation on material culture and the borders of Iron Age Judah, followed by a post doctoral year spent at the University Oxford. Since 1990 he worked at the Israel Antiquities Authority first as vice deputy of the Finds Department, later as a senior excavating archaeologist and in 2002-2007 as head of the SPR Unit. Dr. Kletter, who has lectured at several universities, lives in Tallinn and is since 2009 Docent for Near Eastern Archaeology at the University of Helsinki. His main fields of interest include archaeology of the Near East in the Bronze and Iron Ages; religion and cult; ancient economy; archaeological theory and the history of archaeology in Israel/Palestine.
The Genesis stories of Israeli Archaeology: Archaeology and the 1948 war; Abandoned places, new p... more The Genesis stories of Israeli Archaeology: Archaeology and the 1948 war; Abandoned places, new places; Foreign aid; Frozen funds; A battalion of guards; Relief work; Man robs his land (Moshe Dayan); Gold of Ophir; Rockefeller Museum; The origins of the Israel Museum; The supreme archaeological council; Travels with the Governmental Touris Corporation; The Safad synagogue affair; Policy of excavations; Myths and conclusions.
Papers A: History of Archaeology by Raz Kletter
SJOT 37/2: 187-209, 2023
The prefix "proto", originally from the Greek, carries several meanings, including first, earlies... more The prefix "proto", originally from the Greek, carries several meanings, including first, earliest, original and primitive. A "prototype" is the first or original type, and "proto" may indicate something in the way of becoming. In this article we offer a critical review of the history and uses of the term "proto-Israelites" in biblical and archaeological studies since 1943. The prehistory of 'early Israel' has shrunk from the Early Bronze to the Iron Age, but the use of "proto-Israel" has grown since the 1990s, tied to issues of historicity and ethnicity. "Proto-Israelite" is a misleading term. It enables scholars to re-find a united, ethnic Israel, by projecting it onto the past in disguise, as "proto-Israel". There are no "proto-people" that carry "proto-ethnicity". The use of "proto-Israelites" serves modern ideologies. We suggest more neutral terms, which do not beg the question whether an Israelite ethnic community existed, or can be identified in material remains of the Iron Age I.
AABNER , 2023
The Antiquities Ordinance (Law) of 1920 was instrumental for the archaeology of Palestine in the ... more The Antiquities Ordinance (Law) of 1920 was instrumental for the archaeology of Palestine in the British Mandate period. It also had significant influence, for many years, on the antiquities legislation of Jordan and Israel after 1948. This law has hardly been studied so far, except for one detail—the setting of the year 1700 CE for defining antiquities.
Based on many as yet unpublished documents from several archives, I discuss in this article the complex origins of the 1920 Antiquities Law. Contrary to the current scholarly consensus, it was created by many agents (historians, archaeologists, legal experts, politicians, military men), working since 1918 in Egypt, Palestine, Britain,
and the international peace conferences after World War I. The law was a compromise between the desire to facilitate the excavation, trade, and export of finds (for the benefit of Western institutions) and the wish to protect sites and keep finds in Palestine (for the benefit of local populations). The year 1700 CE was not a measure taken against protecting the area’s (late) Ottoman heritage, but a reasonable choice at a time when the discipline of historical archaeology did not exist yet.
Asiana , 2022
This article is a study of the ASOR society, based on a database compiled from the 2017 annual me... more This article is a study of the ASOR society, based on a database compiled from the 2017 annual meeting at Boston, one of the largest meetings in its history. Such a study has not been performed before. We study the research of ASOR as represented in the meeting by the roles of the scholar-members (poster presenters, lecture presenters, and session chairs), their research subjects (geographic areas, periods, and topics), and their affiliations (gender and institutions). The analysis leads to several questionsand conclusionsabout Archaeology in the Ancient Near East (ANE). Despite important progress by ASOR (e.g., in addressing gender), ANE archaeology is still a privilege of the 'west'. Rarely a 'local' scholar spices up the discussions. Modern politics and ideologies determine what areas are studied and what topics of research are 'in'. Political neutrality is proclaimed, but not achieved, in the spaces of the meeting. The aim of the article is to foster discussion about these systematic issues, which do not have easy solutions. By presenting quantified data, they can no longer be dismissed as unsubstantiated, personal impressions.
International Journal of Cultural Property, 2017
Mamilla cemetery was one of the largest and most important Muslim cemeteries in Jerusalem. The p... more Mamilla cemetery was one of the largest and most important Muslim
cemeteries in Jerusalem. The plans to build a “Museum of Tolerance” in it led
to heated protests and a prolonged legal procedure in Israel’s Supreme Court
of Justice. In 2008, the court approved the plans and many hundreds of graves
were exhumed. Through the available sources, including the court’s archival files,
we discuss political, legal, and archaeological aspects of this case, focusing on
ethics about cemeteries and descendant communities. The discussion shows
that the Israel Antiquities Authority breached the court orders and that the
treatment of the archaeological remains was biased. “Their” graves were destroyed,
and the bones reburied in secret, while “our” remains in the same areas were
carefully excavated and preserved. Tolerance to “our” heritage at the expense
of “theirs” is intolerance.
Le-ma‘an Ziony: Essays in Honor of Ziony Zevit. eds. F.E. Greenspan and G.A. Rendsburg. , 2017
Description: Eugene, OR: Cascade Books, 2016 | Includes bibliographical references and indexes.
I. Hjelm, T.L. Thompson (eds.), History, Archaeology and the Bible in: I. Hjelm and T.L. Thompson, eds., History, Archaeology and the Bible Forty Years after “Historicity”. Changing Perspectives 6 (London: Routledge, 2016), pp. 174-204., 2016
A 1964 research proposal by a young student of the Hebrew University - later Director of Israel's... more A 1964 research proposal by a young student of the Hebrew University - later Director of Israel's Department of Antiquities - to study destruction processes in the deserted Palestinian villages. The proposal was shelved. A year later the Israel Land Administration, with the help of the archaeologists of the Survey Association, supervised by the Archaeological Council, leveled the remains of c . 100 villages. The archaeologists hastily 'surveyed' the villages, and authorizing the destruction of all the 'late' remains.
Sample from the Forom of Journal of Eastern Mediterranean Archaeology and Heritage Studies 3/1 (... more Sample from the Forom of Journal of Eastern Mediterranean
Archaeology and Heritage Studies 3/1 (2015)
The full forum is available in "JEMAHS" (or JSTOR, not free access).
The "general planning" for excavating the Western Wall Piazza. The Antiquities Authority support... more The "general planning" for excavating the Western Wall Piazza. The Antiquities Authority supported this plan and tried to start implementing it before it is has even been approved.
The implications of this plan are a large scale removal, i.e. destruction, of archaeological remains.
Community Archaeology in Israel/Palestine (together with E. Pfoh and L. Kolska Horowitz)), 2024
Although Community (or Public) Archaeology originated in western countries, it has now spread all... more Although Community (or Public) Archaeology originated in western countries, it has now spread all over the world. It integrates the archaeological past with living peoples in new and unique ways. It is however, a rather loosely-defined field; to some it means an attitude and a theoretical concept, which is, or should be, valid for archaeology as a whole and for every archaeologist. For others it is a certain practice or sub-field of archaeology, which by now has its own experts-that is, community archaeologists.
"A thought-provoking, insightful, and comprehensive volume that investigates different ways of practicing community archaeology in Israel/Palestine. A must-read for people interested in community archaeology and the history of archaeology in all its complexities."
Aron Mazel, Newcastle University
This volume is a critical study of recent archaeology in the Western Wall Plaza area, Jerusalem. ... more This volume is a critical study of recent archaeology in the Western Wall Plaza area, Jerusalem. Considered one of the holiest places on Earth for Jews and Muslims, it is also a place of controversy, where the State marks ‘our’ remains for preservation and adoration and ‘theirs’ for silencing.
Based on thousands of documents from the Israel Antiquities Authority and other sources, such as protocols of planning committees, readers can explore for the first time this archaeological ‘heart of darkness’ in East Jerusalem. The book follows a series of unique iscoveries, reviewing the approval and execution of development plans and excavations, and the use of the sites once excavation has finished. Who decides what and how to excavate, what to preserve – or ‘remove’? Who pays for the archaeology, for what aims?
The professional, scientific archaeology of the past happens now: it modifies the present and is modified by it. This book ‘excavates’ the archaeology of East Jerusalem to reveal its social and political contexts, power structures and ethics.
Readers interested in the history, archaeology and politics of the Israeli–Palestinian conflict will find this book useful, as well as scholars and students of the history and ethics of archaeology, Jerusalem, conservation, nationalism
and heritage.
Archaeology, Heritage and Ethics in the Western Wall Plaza, Jerusalem: Darkness at the End of the Tunnel, 2019
This volume is a critical study of recent archaeology in the Western Wall Plaza area, Jerusalem. ... more This volume is a critical study of recent archaeology in the Western Wall Plaza area, Jerusalem. Considered one of the holiest places on Earth for Jews and Muslims, it is also a place of controversy, where the State marks ‘our’ remains for preservation and adoration and ‘theirs’ for silencing.
Based on thousands of documents from the Israel Antiquities Authority and other sources, such as protocols of planning committees, readers can explore for the first time this archaeological ‘heart of darkness’ in East Jerusalem. The book follows a series of unique discoveries, reviewing the approval and execution of development plans and excavations, and the use of the sites once excavation has finished. Who decides what and how to excavate, what to preserve – or ‘remove’? Who pays for the archaeology, for what aims? The professional, scientific archaeology of the past happens now: it modifies the present and is modified by it. This book ‘excavates’ the archaeology of East Jerusalem to reveal its social and political contexts, power structures and ethics.
Readers interested in the history, archaeology and politics of the Israeli–Palestinian conflict will find this book useful, as well as scholars and students of the history and ethics of archaeology, Jerusalem, conservation, nationalism and heritage.
Münster: Zaphon Press (Ägypten und altes Testament 88) (2 Volumes), 2018
ÄgypTen und AlTes TesTAmenT 88 yosi levy and Raz Kletter Zaphon Rishon le-Zion Volume I The Middl... more ÄgypTen und AlTes TesTAmenT 88 yosi levy and Raz Kletter Zaphon Rishon le-Zion Volume I The Middle Bronze Age II Cemeteries Volume I/ 1: The excavations With Contributions by daphna Ben-Tor, Vered eshed, Amir golani, eriola Jakoel, Tal Kan-Cipor -meron, nili liphschitz, yossi nagar, Itzhaq shai, sariel shalev,
Yavneh II is the second and last excavation report on the dramatic favissa/genizah pit full of Ph... more Yavneh II is the second and last excavation report on the dramatic favissa/genizah pit full of Philistine votive objects, discovered by Raz Kletter in the city of Yavneh, Israel, near the Mediterranean coast (south of Tel Aviv). The first volume, Yavneh I (OBO.SA 30, 2010) included studies on the history and archaeological exploration of Yavneh, the excavation, the stratigraphy and the interpretation of the pit as a favissae of votive objects that originate from a public temple; but especially on the mysterious cult stands, which number more than a hundred and include many stands with zoomorphic and anthropomorphic figures. In the present volume we publish many additional cultic finds, including fire pans or shovels that could be used for moving hot coals and for burning incense (comparable to the biblical maḥtāh); a rectangular shrine-model (naos) with detached pillars; zoomorphic vessels; a larger sample of pottery with statistical analysis; imported Cypriot pottery; dog bones (probably related to ritual); an inscription on a bowl; fragments of worked stones (perhaps from altars); and chemical residues from juglets and chalices, which seem to indicate presence of hallucinatory and incense materials. In addition, we offer an update on the iconography of the Yavneh cult stands and a study of the larger world of cult stands in the southern Levant; criteria for identifying favissae and their appearance from the Late Bronze Age to the Persian Period in Palestine; and a concluding discussion on Yavneh, incense, and Philistine ethnicity.
Yavneh II is the second and last excavation report on the dramatic favissa pit full of Philistine... more Yavneh II is the second and last excavation report on the
dramatic favissa pit full of Philistine votive objects, discovered by Raz Kletter in Yavneh, Israel, near the Mediterranean coast south of Tel-Aviv. The first volume, Yavneh I (2010) included studies on the history and archaeological exploration of Yavneh, the excavation, and the interpretation of the pit as a favissae of votive objects from a public temple. Especially this volume focused on the more than a hundred cult stands, which include many stands with zoomorphic and anthropomorphic figures.
In volume II we publish many additional cultic finds, including fire-pans or shovels for moving hot coals and for burning incense (comparable to the biblical maḥtāh); a rectangular shrine-model (naos); zoomorphic vessels; a larger sample of pottery with statistical analysis; Cypriot pottery; dog bones (probably related to ritual); an inscription on a bowl; fragments of worked stones (perhaps from altars); and chemical residues from juglets and chalices, which seem to indicate presence of hallucinatory and incense materials.
We also offer an update on the iconography of the Yavneh cult stands and a study of the larger world of
cult stands in the southern Levant; criteria for identifying favissae and their appearance from the Late Bronze Age to the Persian Period in Palestine; and a concluding discussion on Yavneh, incense, and Philistine ethnicity
2010: Yavneh Volume I. The Excavation of the 'Temple Hill' Repository Pit and the Cult Stands (OBO Series Archaeologia 30) , 2010
In the words of late Professor Moshe Kochavi, the Philistine repository pit at Yavneh is the kind... more In the words of late Professor Moshe Kochavi, the Philistine repository pit at Yavneh is the kind of discovery made only once every fifty years. It is the richest repository pit ever found from Bronze and Iron Ages Israel/Palestine, containing thousands of cultic finds originating from a temple, including an unprecedented number-more than a hundred-of cult stands (so-called 'architectural models') carrying rich figurative art, dozens of fire-pans, chalices and other objects. The present volume includes the full publication of the excavation, the stratigraphy, the cult stands and the figures detached from cult stands, several clay and stone altars and some pottery vessels related to burning of plant material, most likely incense. This exceptional book raises a host of highly important and intriguing questions. Is this a favissa, or even a genizah? Why are many cult stands badly broken, while some are intact-were cult stands broken on purpose? What is the explanation for the unique stratigraphy and for the layer of gray ash in the pit-was fire kindled inside as part of a ritual? How do we know that these finds are Philistine? Are they part of the 'furniture' of the temple or objects dedicated by worshipers as votives? Do the figures on the cult stands represent mortal beings, or divinities? If divinities, can we relate them with Biblical or extra-biblical data on the gods of the Philistines? What was the function/s of cult stands? Were they models of buildings, supports for images, offerings tables, altars, or perhaps incense burners? Why are female figures dominant, while male figures are virtually absent? In discussing such topics, Yavneh I treats issues that are central to many fields of study: religion and cult in Iron Age Israel/Palestine; the history and archaeology of the Philistines and their 'western' relations; Near Eastern iconography, the meaning of cult stands/architectural models and the understanding of votive objects and of repository pits in general. Literally salvaged from the teeth of the bulldozer, these rare finds are now published. Generations of scholars will discuss and reinterpret them-there is no 'final word' for such finds and hence, this final excavation volume is not an end, but a beginning.
Raz Kletter (*1960), obtained his PhD in archaeology from Tel Aviv University in 1995 with a diss... more Raz Kletter (*1960), obtained his PhD in archaeology from Tel Aviv University in 1995 with a dissertation on material culture and the borders of Iron Age Judah, followed by a post doctoral year spent at the University Oxford. Since 1990 he worked at the Israel Antiquities Authority first as vice deputy of the Finds Department, later as a senior excavating archaeologist and in 2002-2007 as head of the SPR Unit. Dr. Kletter, who has lectured at several universities, lives in Tallinn and is since 2009 Docent for Near Eastern Archaeology at the University of Helsinki. His main fields of interest include archaeology of the Near East in the Bronze and Iron Ages; religion and cult; ancient economy; archaeological theory and the history of archaeology in Israel/Palestine.
The Genesis stories of Israeli Archaeology: Archaeology and the 1948 war; Abandoned places, new p... more The Genesis stories of Israeli Archaeology: Archaeology and the 1948 war; Abandoned places, new places; Foreign aid; Frozen funds; A battalion of guards; Relief work; Man robs his land (Moshe Dayan); Gold of Ophir; Rockefeller Museum; The origins of the Israel Museum; The supreme archaeological council; Travels with the Governmental Touris Corporation; The Safad synagogue affair; Policy of excavations; Myths and conclusions.
SJOT 37/2: 187-209, 2023
The prefix "proto", originally from the Greek, carries several meanings, including first, earlies... more The prefix "proto", originally from the Greek, carries several meanings, including first, earliest, original and primitive. A "prototype" is the first or original type, and "proto" may indicate something in the way of becoming. In this article we offer a critical review of the history and uses of the term "proto-Israelites" in biblical and archaeological studies since 1943. The prehistory of 'early Israel' has shrunk from the Early Bronze to the Iron Age, but the use of "proto-Israel" has grown since the 1990s, tied to issues of historicity and ethnicity. "Proto-Israelite" is a misleading term. It enables scholars to re-find a united, ethnic Israel, by projecting it onto the past in disguise, as "proto-Israel". There are no "proto-people" that carry "proto-ethnicity". The use of "proto-Israelites" serves modern ideologies. We suggest more neutral terms, which do not beg the question whether an Israelite ethnic community existed, or can be identified in material remains of the Iron Age I.
AABNER , 2023
The Antiquities Ordinance (Law) of 1920 was instrumental for the archaeology of Palestine in the ... more The Antiquities Ordinance (Law) of 1920 was instrumental for the archaeology of Palestine in the British Mandate period. It also had significant influence, for many years, on the antiquities legislation of Jordan and Israel after 1948. This law has hardly been studied so far, except for one detail—the setting of the year 1700 CE for defining antiquities.
Based on many as yet unpublished documents from several archives, I discuss in this article the complex origins of the 1920 Antiquities Law. Contrary to the current scholarly consensus, it was created by many agents (historians, archaeologists, legal experts, politicians, military men), working since 1918 in Egypt, Palestine, Britain,
and the international peace conferences after World War I. The law was a compromise between the desire to facilitate the excavation, trade, and export of finds (for the benefit of Western institutions) and the wish to protect sites and keep finds in Palestine (for the benefit of local populations). The year 1700 CE was not a measure taken against protecting the area’s (late) Ottoman heritage, but a reasonable choice at a time when the discipline of historical archaeology did not exist yet.
Asiana , 2022
This article is a study of the ASOR society, based on a database compiled from the 2017 annual me... more This article is a study of the ASOR society, based on a database compiled from the 2017 annual meeting at Boston, one of the largest meetings in its history. Such a study has not been performed before. We study the research of ASOR as represented in the meeting by the roles of the scholar-members (poster presenters, lecture presenters, and session chairs), their research subjects (geographic areas, periods, and topics), and their affiliations (gender and institutions). The analysis leads to several questionsand conclusionsabout Archaeology in the Ancient Near East (ANE). Despite important progress by ASOR (e.g., in addressing gender), ANE archaeology is still a privilege of the 'west'. Rarely a 'local' scholar spices up the discussions. Modern politics and ideologies determine what areas are studied and what topics of research are 'in'. Political neutrality is proclaimed, but not achieved, in the spaces of the meeting. The aim of the article is to foster discussion about these systematic issues, which do not have easy solutions. By presenting quantified data, they can no longer be dismissed as unsubstantiated, personal impressions.
International Journal of Cultural Property, 2017
Mamilla cemetery was one of the largest and most important Muslim cemeteries in Jerusalem. The p... more Mamilla cemetery was one of the largest and most important Muslim
cemeteries in Jerusalem. The plans to build a “Museum of Tolerance” in it led
to heated protests and a prolonged legal procedure in Israel’s Supreme Court
of Justice. In 2008, the court approved the plans and many hundreds of graves
were exhumed. Through the available sources, including the court’s archival files,
we discuss political, legal, and archaeological aspects of this case, focusing on
ethics about cemeteries and descendant communities. The discussion shows
that the Israel Antiquities Authority breached the court orders and that the
treatment of the archaeological remains was biased. “Their” graves were destroyed,
and the bones reburied in secret, while “our” remains in the same areas were
carefully excavated and preserved. Tolerance to “our” heritage at the expense
of “theirs” is intolerance.
Le-ma‘an Ziony: Essays in Honor of Ziony Zevit. eds. F.E. Greenspan and G.A. Rendsburg. , 2017
Description: Eugene, OR: Cascade Books, 2016 | Includes bibliographical references and indexes.
I. Hjelm, T.L. Thompson (eds.), History, Archaeology and the Bible in: I. Hjelm and T.L. Thompson, eds., History, Archaeology and the Bible Forty Years after “Historicity”. Changing Perspectives 6 (London: Routledge, 2016), pp. 174-204., 2016
A 1964 research proposal by a young student of the Hebrew University - later Director of Israel's... more A 1964 research proposal by a young student of the Hebrew University - later Director of Israel's Department of Antiquities - to study destruction processes in the deserted Palestinian villages. The proposal was shelved. A year later the Israel Land Administration, with the help of the archaeologists of the Survey Association, supervised by the Archaeological Council, leveled the remains of c . 100 villages. The archaeologists hastily 'surveyed' the villages, and authorizing the destruction of all the 'late' remains.
Sample from the Forom of Journal of Eastern Mediterranean Archaeology and Heritage Studies 3/1 (... more Sample from the Forom of Journal of Eastern Mediterranean
Archaeology and Heritage Studies 3/1 (2015)
The full forum is available in "JEMAHS" (or JSTOR, not free access).
The "general planning" for excavating the Western Wall Piazza. The Antiquities Authority support... more The "general planning" for excavating the Western Wall Piazza. The Antiquities Authority supported this plan and tried to start implementing it before it is has even been approved.
The implications of this plan are a large scale removal, i.e. destruction, of archaeological remains.
Palestine Exploration Quarterly 147/2: 146-159., 2015
In 1973 Yohanan Aharoni published a polemic, trying to defend Israeli excavations from criticism ... more In 1973 Yohanan Aharoni published a polemic, trying to defend Israeli excavations from criticism (mainly) by Britisah scholars. Aharoni claimed that a unique “Israeli method” of excavation was invented at Hazor in the 1950s, equal or even superior to the Wheeler–Kenyon method. Since then, the “Israeli method” became an accepted fact. However, critical analysis shows that such a method never existed.
Heritage, conservation and politics of archaeology in present day Jerusalem. "Strauss" house is ... more Heritage, conservation and politics of archaeology in present day Jerusalem. "Strauss" house is the only antiquities sites in the world, where the antiquities have been preserved and are "displayed" (but without any real feature of display, such as signs for visitors) inside active toilet facilities.
In this article we review the forgotten history of the Israel Department of Antiquities Museum in... more In this article we review the forgotten history of the Israel Department of Antiquities Museum in Jerusalem, the central archaeological museum of Israel until 1965. From a humble beginning in a temporary exhibition in 1949, which became permanent in 1951, the museum grew and gathered a very large and important collection of antiquities. Its founders hoped that they are placing the cornerstone for a future new central museum of Israel; they were the first to dream about such a museum in Jerusalem, already since 1948. However, when the State entrusted Tedi Kollek with the establishment of the new museum (1957), he ignored the Department of Antiquities. In 1961 Avraham Biran, Kollek's close colleague in building the Israel Museum, was nominated as Director of the Department of Antiquities. In order to ensure his control over Bronfman Museum (the archaeological museum within the Israel Museum), Biran conceived a 'deal' that included closing the Department of Antiquities Museum and transferring all its treasures to Bronfman Museum. Traces of this affair still exist in Jerusalem today, but few know their origins.
Study of heritage and politics of archaeology in present day Jerusalem. On excavations under a s... more Study of heritage and politics of archaeology in present day Jerusalem.
On excavations under a synagogue in the old city, cutting of tunnels in areas not owned by the entrepreneurs, and planning a museum of prayer that causes damage to an ancient Mamluk-period bathhouse.
Jerusalem Old City, Beit Ha-Liba excavations in the Western Wall Plaza. The archaeology, the heri... more Jerusalem Old City, Beit Ha-Liba excavations in the Western Wall Plaza. The archaeology, the heritage, and the politics.
Exploring the Narrative. London. Bloomsbury. , Jan 1, 2014
Theory and Criticism (Teoriya u-Bikoret) 42: 207-235, 2014
Study of the fate of the deserted villages in Israel since 1948, focusing on a 1964 reserach pro... more Study of the fate of the deserted villages in Israel since 1948, focusing on a 1964 reserach proposal by A. Eitan, a student (later Director of Antiquities), submitted c/o his teacher, Yigal Yadin, to the Archaeological Council. It was never discussed and in 1965-68 many villages were distroyed by the Israel Land Administration, with cooperation of the archaeologists (who defined them as not ancient). In recent years, the same sites re-acquire their "antiquty" status and excavations have been carried out in quite many.
Pfih E and Whitlam, KW eds. The Politics of israel's Past. Sheffield. Phoenix Press: 136-151, 2013
Hardback 978-1-907534-82-9
Journal of Hebrew Scriptures, Jan 1, 2010
2010. With G. Solimani. Journal of Hebrew Scriptures 10.
Scandinavian Journal of the Old Testament, 2024
In a recent article published in JSOT, S.L. Richter suggested that Urdeuteronomium can be dated b... more In a recent article published in JSOT, S.L. Richter suggested that Urdeuteronomium can be dated by the economic features in the text. She restored, supposedly by archaeological means, three "economies" of "ancient Israel" that fit three chronological phases of the Iron Age; and concluded that "the economy assumed in Urdeuteronomium is best suited to the late Iron I/Iron IIA era and/or to a rural and isolated sector of the Iron IIB era" (Richter 2017: 50). Berge et al. (2019) have criticized some issues with this article. In this paper I discuss other aspects, mainly archaeological and economic, which show that Richter's conclusion is not valid.
EBW Encyclopedia of Material Culture in the Biblical World, 2022
Beer Sheba III (eds. Z. Herzog and L. Singer-Avitz). The Early Iron IIA Enclosed Settlements and the Late Iron IIA-Iron IIB Cities: 1137-1155.
The Land of Canaan in the Late Bronze Age (ed. L.L. Grabbe): 112-124., 2016
in Beit-Arieh and Freud (eds) Tel Malhata. A Central City in the Biblical Negev. Vol. 1: 528-544., 2015
Israel Exploration Journal 64: 22-37, 2014
Criticism of studies that "deconstruct" the biblical capacity measures. Bath, hin, etc., were fix... more Criticism of studies that "deconstruct" the biblical capacity measures. Bath, hin, etc., were fixed measures already in the Iron Age, not "just names of jars". The name of a measure and the name of a jar holding it are the same. Biblical sources mention "just hin" or "just bath" - while a jar or a jug cannot be "just". We also find 1/2, 1/3 and 1/4 hin in the Bible -how can they be "only a pottery vessel"? Do jars or jugs break into accurate halves and quarters? If broken, can they hold oil or wine?
Assistant to the director and curator | Shunit Netter-Marmelstein
JESHO 56:1-28
Ancient scale weights are a key to understanding weight systems and types of economy, but their d... more Ancient scale weights are a key to understanding weight systems and types of economy, but their definition is notoriously difficult, and scholars tend to classify as weights a wide variety of objects. The present paper reassesses a series of pyramidal lead objects from Phoenicia, dated mostly to the Hellenistic period. In the last twenty years these objects have been regarded as scale weights-in fact, forming the largest category of assumed Phoenician scale weights. In this paper it is suggested that these are not scale weights but sinkers (weights for fishing lines or nets).
Journal of Archaeological Method and Theory, Jan 1, 2009
Archaeology, LMLK storage jars, Bath, measures, Iron Age, Israel Judah, Ancient Near East, ancien... more Archaeology, LMLK storage jars, Bath, measures, Iron Age, Israel Judah, Ancient Near East, ancient economy
Encyclopedia value, focused on biblical and Iron Age measuring systems, notably weights and capac... more Encyclopedia value, focused on biblical and Iron Age measuring systems, notably weights and capacity.
(File is a pre-print text)
En-Gedi excavations I. Final report (19611965). …, Jan 1, 2007
Ugarit-Forschungen, Jan 1, 2001
AABNER, 2024
In 1998, Neil Silberman showed how early scholarly portrayals of the Philistines reflected the v... more In 1998, Neil Silberman showed how early scholarly portrayals of the Philistines
reflected the values of the Victorians. The Philistines were presented by the
Victorians either as good colonialists who brought an enlightened Indo-European
civilization to the East, or as barbaric destroyers who ruined the supposedly
decadent Canaanite culture. The time has come to reflect on more recent images
of the Philistines. In the 1970–1980s, they went through a great transformation
from a Bible-centered model or image of cruel invaders and enemies to that of an
advanced, cultural people. Several other images have appeared since, competing
for hegemony. I review them here, focusing especially on the most recent image of
them as “merry pirates,” which has not yet been studied critically. My aim here is
not to support any particular “image” of the Philistines but to study these scholarly
constructions and their relations to our time. Based on the results, it seems that
the future of the Philistines may be as unpredictable as their past.
LB2 Tomb; later Iron Age Cemetery with built cist tombs and simple pit tombs, etc. Coauthor Y. N... more LB2 Tomb; later Iron Age Cemetery with built cist tombs and simple pit tombs, etc.
Coauthor Y. Nagar
Yavneh II: The 'Temple Hill' Repository Pit, 2015
Yavneh, fire pans, coals, incense, biblical maḥtāh, Dothan and Abiram, the sect of Korah, etc.
Yavneh II. , 2015
Shrine models and proto aeolic (volute) capitals: their chronology, contexts, and local meaning -... more Shrine models and proto aeolic (volute) capitals: their chronology, contexts, and local meaning - having no relation with Assyria/Assyrians.
Assistant to the director and curator | Shunit Netter-Marmelstein
Dozens of pottery fire pans composed of a bowl-like part and a handle were found in the Philistin... more Dozens of pottery fire pans composed of a bowl-like part and a handle were found in the Philistine repository pit at Yavneh, Israel. They date from the ninth-eighth centuries BCE and are published here for the first time. These vessels, derived from second-millennium BCE Aegean forms, have never before been identified in the Southern Levant. On the basis of the location of marks of burning, their relation to other finds and the pictorial evidence, we contend that the Yavneh fire pans were used in a cultic context for burning incense. Their discovery reopens the complex issues of the 'shovel' in the Old Testament and the use of incense in the Iron Age.
Chapters: The History and Archaeology of Yavneh; The excavation of the Repository Pit; Typology o... more Chapters: The History and Archaeology of Yavneh; The excavation of the Repository Pit; Typology of Cult Stands; Disposal and Breakage Patterns of Cult Stands; Iconography of Cult Stands; Clay and Stone Altar; Pottery; Cassid Lip; Petrography; Residue Analysis; Functions of Cult Stands; Conclusions: Repositroy Pit - Favissa - Genizah; Catalogues
Palestine Exploration Quarterly, Jan 1, 2009
In this short paper we present a detailed study of a unique ceramic vessel fragment that was foun... more In this short paper we present a detailed study of a unique ceramic vessel fragment that was found in the excavations at Tel Nagila. The interpretation of this fragment as an Aegean fi re-stand has implications for our understanding of the origin and development of Philistine material culture in Iron Age Philistia.
In Yavneh I (Kletter et al. 2010) we published the results obtained through organic residue analy... more In Yavneh I (Kletter et al. 2010) we published the results obtained through organic residue analysis performed on
17 chalices and two bowls from the Yavneh repository pit (Namdar et al. 2010). In our previous paper we showed
that plant materials were consumed in the chalices and suggested that the chalices were likely used as incense burners.
In the present study we report the results of additional chemical analysis performed on eleven chalices and on
seven juglets from Yavneh.
Juglets are a minor component of the ceramic assemblage in this pit and consist of a few dozen types. The
particular juglets examined in this study are called “hybrid juglets”. They are small, closed vessels (ca. 6-7 cm in
height) with a rounded body and base. Only 12 hybrid juglets were found in the pit (Panitz-Cohen 2010:126). Although
the manner in which these hybrid juglets were used is unknown, their presence in a repository pit close to a
presumed Iron Age Philistine shrine, suggests that they may have played a cultic role. Hence, as small containers,
the investigation of this role through the study of their organic contents was deemed both intriguing and of potentially
great significance.
Combining the two sets of data we try to draw some new insights regarding the cultic rituals that took place
in the nearby shrine and the trade that was involved in the maintenance of these practices.
Palestine Exploration Quarterly, Jan 1, 2009
Near Eastern Archaeology 85, 2022
We present a selection of the figurines in order to illustrate their variety and aesthetic appea... more We present a selection of the figurines in order to illustrate their variety
and aesthetic appeal, and also to demonstrate the difficulties in
studying and interpreting them. What do we see in them? Images
of powerful, but nearly forgotten deities? The faces of bygone
generations (and of their animals too)? Or, perhaps, portrayals of
important priestesses and warriors?
Reem, A. (ed), The Qishle Excavations in the Old City of Jerusalem. Jerusalem. IES. , 2018
Found on floor, Str. VI, L. 214; height 78 mm.; body is round in section and massive; upper chest... more Found on floor, Str. VI, L. 214; height 78 mm.; body is round in section and massive; upper chest area is broken just below the neck. The arms are broken, but the right hand remains glued on the body, and a change of color under the breast indicates the position of the left hand on the opposite side. Thus, the hands were placed well below the breast, not really supporting or offering them. One breast is broken completely. Below, part of the inner center of the concave base is seen. There are traces of white wash and red bands of paint above the breasts and perhaps also between them.
Excavations and Surveys in Israel (ESI), 2018
in: Beit-Arieh and Freud (eds.) Tel Malhata. A Central City in the Biblical Negev. Vol. 2: 545-579, with Appendix by Liora Horwitz, 2015
Prof. Itzhaq (Itzik) Beit-Arieh passed away on July 12, 2012, following a prolonged illness. He h... more Prof. Itzhaq (Itzik) Beit-Arieh passed away on July 12, 2012, following a prolonged illness. He had just completed his final excavation report on Tel Malúata. This was a fitting coda to a prolific career spanning five decades, most of which was devoted to the study of the Negev and Sinai deserts in the Bronze and Iron Ages.
Antiguo Oriente 12 (2014)
More than 500 Iron Age (8th-6th centuries BCE) figurines were discovered in the Western Wall Plaz... more More than 500 Iron Age (8th-6th centuries BCE) figurines were discovered in the Western Wall Plaza excavations in Jerusalem. Two figurine heads most likely depict lions, one of them unique - holding another animal in its mouth. In this article we discuss the identification as lions, the lion motif in the Southern Levant, and theories concerning lions in the Bible. In our view, the 'new' figurines represent lions as wild animals.
ZDPV, 2011
This article discusses a unique type of clay figurines from late Iron Age II Judah (8th– 7th cent... more This article discusses a unique type of clay figurines from late Iron Age II Judah (8th– 7th centuries B.C.E.). They are similar to the famous Judean pillar figurines, but instead of arms supporting breasts they hold round ‘discs’ on their chests. An updated list is offered, including several unpublished examples. Contrary to recently expressed views, we suggest that these figurines portray a drum-playing female figure, based on comparisons with female and male drum playing figurines from other regions. This conclusion is important for understanding the nature and meaning of drum playing figurines in the Iron Age Levant.
Family and Household Religion : Toward a Synthesis of Old Testament Studies, Archaeology, Epigraphy, and Cultural Studies. Rainer Albertz, Beth Alpert Nakhai, Saul M. Olyan, Rüdiger Schmitt (Eds.) Eisenbrauns. p. 197-224., 2014
Horse and rider figurines from Iron Age Judah; discussion of a group figurines with two riders an... more Horse and rider figurines from Iron Age Judah; discussion of a group figurines with two riders and two horses - probably meant to represent pairs or teams of horse-riders. We suggest that these figurines were images of mortal riders and probably symbols of military status.
Levant, Jan 1, 2010
Female plaque figurines are the dominant type of anthropomorphic clay figurines in the Southern L... more Female plaque figurines are the dominant type of anthropomorphic clay figurines in the Southern Levant of the Late Bronze Age. Unfortunately, there is no updated catalogue. The close study of fragments (the vast majority of the corpus) and of basic aspects (such as production modes, techniques, patterns of use/disposal) is at times overshadowed by the heated debate about the interpretation -the religious significance -of these figurines. We publish two newly excavated fragments of a unique type of plaque figurine, limited in distribution to northern Palestine. Unlike other plaque figurines, it is moulded on both sides. We present a detailed list and a study of the type and suggest that it is not double-moulded, as assumed by all former scholars, but produced by the double use of single moulds (hence, 'twice moulded'). Indeed, this does not tell us whether such figurines are goddess/es, mortal worshippers or something else. Trying to answer this question before the basic data is collected and analysed is likely to end in speculation. Is it Anat, Astarte, Asherah or perhaps Ashdoda? Readers are welcome to use their imagination.
Ussishkin, D. 2004. The Renewed Archaeological Excavations at Tel Lachish. Vol. IV: 2058-2083., 2004
Ussishkind, D. 2004. The Renewed Archaeological Excavations at Tel Lachish. Vol. IV: 1572-1583 , 2002
Bulletin of the American Schools of Oriental Research, Jan 1, 2003
Oxford Journal of Archaeology, Jan 1, 2002
This paper presents a unique clay figurine found at Tel Beth Shemesh, Judah, in a late Iron Age I... more This paper presents a unique clay figurine found at Tel Beth Shemesh, Judah, in a late Iron Age II context. The figurine portrays a monkeyfaced horse, a combination that is rare in the ancient Near East and unknown, so far, from Judah. Comparisons are sought, followed by a discussion of the Monkey in small representations in the ancient Near East and Mesopotamia. Monkeys were exotic, held as pet animals by the higher classes and related to sex, music, ugliness, lack of intelligence, and various other human characteristics. It is suggested that the significance of this figurine lies in such`secular' connotations, rather than in a religious realm.
Tel 'Ira: A Stronghold in the Biblical Negev, ed. I. Beit Arieh, 2001
Assemblage of 79 figurines from Tel 'Ira in the Negev, Israel, Iron Age II period
Studies in the Archaeology of the Iron Age in Israel. Eds. A. Mazar and E. Mathias., Jan 1, 2001
Page 181. 7 Between Archaeology and Theology: The Pillar Figurines from Judah and the Asherah Raz... more Page 181. 7 Between Archaeology and Theology: The Pillar Figurines from Judah and the Asherah Raz Kletter Introduction The'pillar figurines' have been discussed many times since their discovery in the nineteenth century CE. Recent discoveries at Kuntillet 'Ajrud and Kh. ...
Studies in the Archaeology of the Iron Age in Israel and Jordan (SJOT 331), ed. A. Mazar, Sheffield: 179-216, 2001
Intermediate and Middle Bronze Age tombs with weapons (mainly daggers) in the southern Levant wer... more Intermediate and Middle Bronze Age tombs with weapons (mainly daggers) in the southern Levant were often interpreted as 'warrior graves'. Taking into consideration new data from Rishon Le-Zion (Israel), recent work on early warfare and warriors, and a study of so-called 'warrior graves' in Mesopotamia (Rehm 2003), we suggest that most of these graves are not graves of elite warriors, but typical male burials. We also discuss the assumed 'burial kit' and the decline in numbers of weapons per burial, which is in our view related to the shift from individual burials (in the Intermediate Bronze and Middle Bronze IIA periods) to multiple shaft burials (in the Middle Bronze IIB period).
Levant, 2001
... 2 IsraelAntiquities Authority and the Department ofArchaeology) TelAviv University) TelAviv) ... more ... 2 IsraelAntiquities Authority and the Department ofArchaeology) TelAviv University) TelAviv) Israel. Five MB II pottery kilns have recently been excavated in the Tel Aviv area. ... 1), is to discuss one aspect of this wealth of information - a series of Middle Bronze Age II pottery kilns. ...
Study of Simultaneous MBII burials (primary burials of more than one skeleton placed at one 'even... more Study of Simultaneous MBII burials (primary burials of more than one skeleton placed at one 'event' - not to be confused with multiple primary burials that have been added over time). The phenomenon was first observed by Kenyon in Jericho. It appears in more sites, at each site in a minority of burials. The burials customs seem typical to the MBII society, the only deviant feature is the 'simultaneousness'. The study is based on the unpublished, large-scale cemeteries of Rishon le-Zion, Israel.
Atiqot 53 (2006), Jan 1, 2006
Levant, Jan 1, 2001
... 2 IsraelAntiquities Authority and the Department ofArchaeology) TelAviv University) TelAviv) ... more ... 2 IsraelAntiquities Authority and the Department ofArchaeology) TelAviv University) TelAviv) Israel. Five MB II pottery kilns have recently been excavated in the Tel Aviv area. ... 1), is to discuss one aspect of this wealth of information - a series of Middle Bronze Age II pottery kilns. ...
Levant, 2001
... 2 IsraelAntiquities Authority and the Department ofArchaeology) TelAviv University) TelAviv) ... more ... 2 IsraelAntiquities Authority and the Department ofArchaeology) TelAviv University) TelAviv) Israel. Five MB II pottery kilns have recently been excavated in the Tel Aviv area. ... 1), is to discuss one aspect of this wealth of information - a series of Middle Bronze Age II pottery kilns. ...
Kõiv, M. & Kletter, R. (eds.). Responses to the 12th Century BC Collapse: Recovery and Restructuration in the Early Iron Age Near East and Mediterranean. Münster: Zaphon: 73-92, 2024
The paper discusses excavations and surveys in the highlands of Judah, in trying to define this r... more The paper discusses excavations and surveys in the highlands of Judah, in trying to define this region in the Iron Age I period.
Was there a Judah before the (Iron II) Kingdom of Judah?
How many settlements make a "settlement wave"? (a settlement tsunami?)
What is the absolute and relative value of sherds - would the same survey team, returning to the same site for exactly the same time, pick up the same sherds?
What creative ways let us remember the forest and not see the trees?
Can the Philistines fill up for the scarcity of Judah?
The paper has (some) text, but go there for the picts of Sherlock Holmse's Museums - for the authentic violin of Dr. Watson and the (still working) violin of Holmes.
SSRN, 2024
Recently, Daniel Vainstaub (2024) offered a new interpretation to the much-discussed word mmšt of... more Recently, Daniel Vainstaub (2024) offered a new interpretation to the much-discussed word mmšt of the Iron Age Lmlk jar stamps from Judah.1 Previously, the majority of scholars interpreted mmšt as the name of an unidentified city in Judah, like the three other names on the Lmlk stamps (Hebron, Zyp, and Socho). A minority of scholars, following Ginsberg, read it as an abbreviation of mmšlt (“government”), which they interpreted as a reference to Jerusalem.
Vainstaub proposes that mmšt should be read maś’ēt – a huge, ad hoc tax on agricultural products collected by King Hezekiah. According to this suggestion, the Lmlk jars bearing the mmšt stamps were utilized for the distribution of commodities amassed through this tax. In this article, I review this proposal and conclude that mmšt is an unidentified place in Judah, likely located in the Hebron Mountains.
For the full paper go to: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4924090
The Old Testament Hebrew Scriptures in Five Minutes. Eds. P. Guilluame and D.V. Edelman. London Equinox (Sample)., 2024
The Bible and Interpretation (Arizona University), 2024
The Mt Ebal inscription, arguments why it is not: the first Hebrew inscription; the first mention... more The Mt Ebal inscription, arguments why it is not: the first Hebrew inscription; the first mention of the deity Yhw; the first inscribed lead amulet and curse tablet; and the first ancient curse without neither the name of the curser, nor that of the cursed, nor the motive, nor any circumstances of cursing. Also, criticism of Aren Meir's sensational "Public statement" about peer reviews and publishing 'popular' articles only after publishing peer reviewed articles.
This is a popular version of “Galil and Goliath: A Land of
Archaeological Sin?” (SSRN, 2023).
SSRN (Social Science Research Network)
The archaeologist Mortimer Wheeler once said that in Palestine/Israel "more sins have probably be... more The archaeologist Mortimer Wheeler once said that in Palestine/Israel "more sins have probably been committed in the name of archaeology than on any commensurate portion of the earth's surface" (Wheeler 1954:30). One recalls this sensational saying when reading the "Public Statement" issued by Aren Maeir, concerning 'popular' publications of inscriptions by Gershon Galil. The statement accused Galil of sensationalism and claimed that scholars must not "run to the press" before publishing a full scientific, peer-reviewed report. In this article we suggest that this statement was misguided. Maeir is not fundamentally different than Galil, and one should not argue about personality traits of scholars or types of media, but about contents of publications (methods, theories, underlying assumptions, presentation of facts, and interpretation). In discussing one relevant itema lead object from Mt. Ebalwe conclude that Galil did not decipher an existing, ancient inscription, but created a new, "postmodern" inscription from scratch.
Farewell, King Arawna: The Threshing Floor of the Ark (2 Sam. 24), 2022
The “threshing floor of Arawna” (or Araunah, Orna, Ornan) appears in the story about the altar bu... more The “threshing floor of Arawna” (or Araunah, Orna, Ornan) appears in the story about the altar built by King David to stop the plague (2 Sam. 24: 16b–25) caused by his census (2 Sam. 24:1–16a). It forms part of the so-called appendix to the book of Samuel (2 Sam. 21–24). There are many original interpretations of 2 Sam. 24, and the related 1 Chron. 21 and 4QSAMa. Studies treat the textual and literary aspects in detail and attempt to interpret the possible implications for the history of early Jerusalem, the Jebusites, the origins of the Jerusalem Temple, the figure of King David, and more. In this article, an alternative interpretation of the story about the “threshing floor of Arawna” is offered, which avoids plagiarism – at the price of losing the hero.
2018b. LMLK and Concentric Stamp Impressions., 2018
? with two-winged scarab. Reg. No. 2036-2-3, L.213, constructive fill, Stratum V ( . The clay is ... more ? with two-winged scarab. Reg. No. 2036-2-3, L.213, constructive fill, Stratum V ( . The clay is pink-brown, with many tiny white grits and a very worn surface. The general oval shape of the impression is seen clearly on the left side, with a surviving height of at least 19 mm. The scarab is clear, except the edge of its right wing. Unfortunately, only very faint traces of the end of the city name remain, perhaps n, hence Hbrn, but this is very tentative.
PEQ 150/4, 2019
The Jerusalem pithos inscription was found in 2012 in an Iron IIA (tenth century, High Chronology... more The Jerusalem pithos inscription was found in 2012 in an Iron IIA (tenth century, High Chronology) context. Nine epigraphers have already tried to decipher this short Canaanite or Early-Alphabetic inscription, but their readings vary greatly. Galil, followed by Petrovich, boldly restores the words yyn hlq (‘inferior, poor wine’) and deduces that this is “the first Hebrew inscription” from
Jerusalem. It supposedly relates to allocation of wine by Solomon for his many builders and soldiers in Jerusalem. I suggest that this reading is forced. The wide-mouthed Jerusalem pithos is not a wine vessel. A negative term like ‘poor, inferior wine’ finds its place in administrative and literary contexts, but cannot be a wine-vessel label. There is no proof that this inscription is in Hebrew and it does not ‘prove’ the United Monarchy.
Approaching Religion Vol. 4/2 : 2-15, 2014
Ethnicity (definitions, in archaeology), Iron I, Philistines, Israelites, and Bagira.
Zeitschrift des Deutschen Palästina-Vereins, Jan 1, 2006
Notes on the Ethnicity and Iron Age Israel and Judah, Jan 1, 2006
Recently the research agenda of the study of early Iron Age Palestine has shifted. The focus on t... more Recently the research agenda of the study of early Iron Age Palestine has shifted. The focus on the Iron Age I settlement is 'out' , to debate the historicity of the United Kingdom and the archaeological chronology of the 10 th -9 th centuries B.C.E. is 'in'. ISRAEL FINKELSTEIN's 'low chronology' (henceforward, LC) 1 is debated against the former, 'high chronology' (HC) 2 . This paper does not offer a new chronology, nor does it compare pottery assemblages and strata. Rather, it reviews the whole body of FINKELSTEIN's writing on the LC and discusses its methodology and development from a perspective of seven years (1995 -2002) 3 . I assume that readers are familiar with the debate, and will not describe each argument and counter argument. I will study the achievements of the LC as stated by FINKELSTEIN; its theoretical basis and some of its basic conceptions, and comment on some related issues. This paper is not written in order to support the historicity of the United Monarchy (cf. Solomon, holding 'his' temple, Taf. 1).
Zeitschrift des Deutschen Palästina-Vereins, Jan 1, 2002
Israel Exploration Journal, Jan 1, 2002
Tel Ira: A Stronghold in the Biblical Negev, Jan 1, 1999
Unpublished MA dissertation, Tel Aviv University, Jan 1, 1990
Bulletin of the American Schools of Oriental Research, Jan 1, 1991
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, a... more JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
PAlestine Exploration Quarterly, 2020
A series of large Persian Period buildings dots the Judean Mountains, usually located in prominen... more A series of large Persian Period buildings dots the Judean Mountains, usually located in prominent places alone, without nearby villages. In a recent article in this journal, Faust, A. (2018. ‘Forts or agricultural estates?' PEQ 150/1, 34–59) suggested that they were not fortresses but estates, and that their ‘settlers’ were Judean/Jewish returnees from Babylonia. Moving the discussion forward, we stress that the archaeological data does not furnish clear answers. Functions of ‘forts’ and ‘estates’ are not mutually exclusive. Such buildings appear also in Idumea, Samerina, and Transjordan. An estate is not a certain type of building that can be easily identified by archaeologists, but a set of land rights and obligations. We suggest that these buildings served more than one function. Perhaps some of those living in them followed hatru-like arrangements (thus Faust), but if so, they were colonial settlers in the service of Persia, who received their land from the king or satrap, rather than free persons returning to their ancestral lands. The dwellers also did not remain there for long: the phenomenon of the buildings was limited in both duration and scope (number of dwellers). The buildings did not develop into larger settlements; most were abandoned and did not continue into the Hellenistic Period.
Atiqot 52 (2006): Studies in …, Jan 1, 2006
Atiqot 52 (2006): Studies in …, Jan 1, 2006
Archaeological Reports, Jan 1, 2006
Archaeological Reports, Jan 1, 2006
Excavations at Khirbat Burin uncovered three strata: two (I, II) of the Mamluk period and one (II... more Excavations at Khirbat Burin uncovered three strata: two (I, II) of the Mamluk period and one (III), of the Byzantine–Early Islamic periods. Sporadic remains of the Persian, Byzantine, Early Islamic and Ottoman periods were found, corroborating the evidence from earlier excavations at the site. The large, well-planned buildings uncovered in Mamluk-period Stratum II (late thirteenth–fourteenth centuries) survived to considerable height. The pottery related to the Mamluk strata represents the types that were in use during that period, including unglazed wares consisting of decorated and undecorated handmade wares, wheel-made wares and mold-made wares, as well as a large variety of wheel-made glazed types, including imported wares. The site was probably a Mamluk-period village that was abandoned in the late fourteenth or early fifteenth century, conforming to our knowledge of a process of decline, depopulation and nomadization in the region during the fifteenth century.
'Atiqot 94, 2019
The excavations at Khirbat Burin exposed a large complex of medieval buildings (Strata I–II), as ... more The excavations at Khirbat Burin exposed a large complex of medieval buildings (Strata I–II), as well as fills with mixed materials, mostly dating to the late Byzantine–Early Islamic periods (Stratum III). Three building phases were observed in the building complex of Stratum II (a–c). The complex was probably established during the Crusader period (mid-twelfth–early thirteenth centuries CE; Stratum IIa), before the area was conquered by Baybars I in 1265 CE. The ethnicity of the dwellers in not clear; they might have been either Muslims or Franks. The Strata IIb–c horizon dates to the Mamluk period (late thirteenth–fourteenth centuries CE). The pottery of this phase includes Chinese Celadon vessels, mold-made glazed bowls and Italian imports. Stratum I postdates the building complex, but is still dated to within the Mamluk period (fourteenth–fifteenth centuries CE). Following this stratum, the area was not reoccupied, and the surface loci included only a few Ottoman-period sherds.
JUP, 2024
A broken British type 1908 sword was found in 2001 in the Ashdod-Ashkelon sand dunes south of Tel... more A broken British type 1908 sword was found in 2001 in the Ashdod-Ashkelon sand dunes south of Tel Aviv. We offer here data on this sword, which likely arrived to the region in the context of World War I.
ANEE Blog, 2023
Are we postcolonial yet (Hamilakis 2012)? Russia’s ongoing assault on Ukraine shows the same desi... more Are we postcolonial yet (Hamilakis 2012)? Russia’s ongoing assault on Ukraine shows the same desire for conquest, subjugation, and land that are so familiar from the empires of old. This is, of course, not the only example. Speaking about “de colonization” is perhaps dreaming of utopia.
Review of Biblical Literature , 2023
This review was published by RBL ã2023 by the Society of Biblical Literature. For more informatio... more This review was published by RBL ã2023 by the Society of Biblical Literature. For more information on obtaining a subscription to RBL, please visit http://www.bookreviews.org/subscribe.asp.
Zwic-El. Fest. Wolfgang Zwickel., 2023
Review of Biblical Literature 04/2014, Apr 2014
Albertz and Schmitt have worked on the popular/family religion of ancient Israel for many years, ... more Albertz and Schmitt have worked on the popular/family religion of ancient Israel for many years, a work that culminates in this volume. They also organized related meetings and workshops-I hasten to disclose that I have had the pleasure of participating in one such workshop, held in Münster in 2009.
Review of Biblical Literature, May 2014
SBL Reviews, 2010
From bits left over from another study (Not Bread Alone: The Uses of Food in the Old Testament [O... more From bits left over from another study (Not Bread Alone: The Uses of Food in the Old Testament [Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2008]), MacDonald has concocted a tasty and satisfying meal. Although not a large volume (156 pages), it covers the issue of diet in "biblical times" from several perspectives. The book holds fifteen chapters in four parts, with notes and three indexes (modern names; selected place names, authors, and subjects; and scripture references) following the main text.
Fifty ways to make money from Archaeology - seventeen of them already found.
Parsemon (for or against?); Where is the En Gedi Macdonald's; The gazelles' personal contracts. ... more Parsemon (for or against?); Where is the En Gedi Macdonald's; The gazelles' personal contracts.
Bring a turiyah if you like.