Mapula Matimolane - Academia.edu (original) (raw)
Uploads
Papers by Mapula Matimolane
Teaching in Higher Education
The Covid-19 pandemic necessitated an abrupt shift to emergency remote teaching and learning (ERT... more The Covid-19 pandemic necessitated an abrupt shift to emergency remote teaching and learning (ERT&L) in higher education institutions across the globe. In this shift, assessment and feedback, widely regarded as the heart of student learning experiences and a gauge of quality teaching pre Covid-19, became a major source of discontent and challenge for students and staff. In this paper, we present our reflections of observed and reported practices of assessment by staff and students, from the vantage point of our roles as facilitators of various professional development initiatives within our institution. We suggest that the challenges experienced during ERT&L reveal the entrenched view of assessment as gatekeeping and conceptions of quality as exceptional. We further contend that assessment strategies based on such a view during ERT&L may have further marginalized and disadvantaged students faced with digital/technological, economic, and socio-cultural access issues. However, we also...
This doctoral thesis investigates highly emotive and topical aspects of student learning in highe... more This doctoral thesis investigates highly emotive and topical aspects of student learning in higher education namely, assessment and feedback. The study deals with the complexities and barriers to using learning-oriented assessment approaches to equip students with skills needed to thrive within the uncertainty, demands and challenges of rapidly changing societies. In the current research literature, views about assessment, and in particular formative assessment, are diverse and in some instances contradictory. The argument I make in this thesis is that assessment is situated within a local context, comprised of students and their teachers, which is regulated by disciplinary, professional and institutional traditions, expectations and needs. This research study was impelled by the realisation that most research into pedagogical views held by teachers and their students in higher education has examined them in isolation of each other. In recognition of this disparity in the literature, a more comprehensive study on teachers' and students' views, expectations, and experiences of assessment was undertaken in the South African context. The study was conducted at a research-intensive university and investigated the aforementioned assessment aspects in students and teachers involved in second year compulsory bioscience courses. Using an exploratory, interpretative, mixed method research approach, data were collected through a combination of interviews, questionnaires and document analysis. An in-depth examination of documents from the selected courses, including students' marked work, provided evidence of assessment and feedback practices experienced by the students registered in the courses. Teachers were interviewed about their assessment practices and their rationale for using these practices. Students' views and their reactions to assessment and feedback were ascertained through questionnaires and interviews. Interpretations that emerged from using a socio-cultural-historical theoretical lens were helpful in understanding the factors that present challenges to the implementation of learningoriented assessment approaches. From the characterisation of assessment environments based on learning-oriented assessment principles it was apparent that there was limited active involvement of students in the process. The data highlighted a complex array of factors influencing teachers' conceptions of assessment and subsequently their practices. Significant about the study was the identification of the effects of existing course level assessment cultures and histories on teachers' assessment practices. Program and course factors had more vi
South African Journal of Science, 2020
This Commentary is a response to a Commentary published in the May/June 2020 issue: Nattrass N. W... more This Commentary is a response to a Commentary published in the May/June 2020 issue: Nattrass N. Why are black South African students less likely to consider studying biological sciences? S Afr J Sci. 2020;116(5/6), Art. #7864, 2 pages. https://doi.org/10.17159/sajs.2020/7864 Responses to the Commentary in the May/June 2020 issue have been published collectively in a special issue of Volume 116.
South African Journal of Higher Education, 2018
Transformation in Higher Education has been an ongoing concern in post-apartheid South Africa, es... more Transformation in Higher Education has been an ongoing concern in post-apartheid South Africa, especially in light of universities' expected contribution to economic and socio-political transformation. In particular, curriculum transformation has proved challenging, as evidenced in actions and calls by students in recent years for decolonisation of the curriculum. This study, which formed part of an institutional response to the challenge of curriculum transformation and decolonisation, initially sought to examine perceptions of the term "decolonisation" amongst a group of early career lecturers at a leading university in South Africa. Highlighted in the outcomes of the study was the centrality of personal and contextual relevance in notions of decolonised curricula, the impact of curriculum conversations on lecturers' well-being, and the broader implications of responsive and relevant curricula for institutional and societal well-being. In this respect, the findings of the study illustrated the similarities of curriculum decolonisation approaches and the concept of education for sustainable development which is underpinned by the goal of global well-being and the common good. Also highlighted was the need for greater balance between Mode 1 (theoretical) and Mode 2 (contextually relevant) knowledge in curricula, leading us to posit that both curriculum decolonisation and education for sustainable development are equally necessary for institutional and broader societal reform and well-being, and that both imperatives may potentially be achieved by focusing on the principles of epistemically diverse curricula.
The International Journal of Assessment and Evaluation, 2014
Teaching in Higher Education
The Covid-19 pandemic necessitated an abrupt shift to emergency remote teaching and learning (ERT... more The Covid-19 pandemic necessitated an abrupt shift to emergency remote teaching and learning (ERT&L) in higher education institutions across the globe. In this shift, assessment and feedback, widely regarded as the heart of student learning experiences and a gauge of quality teaching pre Covid-19, became a major source of discontent and challenge for students and staff. In this paper, we present our reflections of observed and reported practices of assessment by staff and students, from the vantage point of our roles as facilitators of various professional development initiatives within our institution. We suggest that the challenges experienced during ERT&L reveal the entrenched view of assessment as gatekeeping and conceptions of quality as exceptional. We further contend that assessment strategies based on such a view during ERT&L may have further marginalized and disadvantaged students faced with digital/technological, economic, and socio-cultural access issues. However, we also...
This doctoral thesis investigates highly emotive and topical aspects of student learning in highe... more This doctoral thesis investigates highly emotive and topical aspects of student learning in higher education namely, assessment and feedback. The study deals with the complexities and barriers to using learning-oriented assessment approaches to equip students with skills needed to thrive within the uncertainty, demands and challenges of rapidly changing societies. In the current research literature, views about assessment, and in particular formative assessment, are diverse and in some instances contradictory. The argument I make in this thesis is that assessment is situated within a local context, comprised of students and their teachers, which is regulated by disciplinary, professional and institutional traditions, expectations and needs. This research study was impelled by the realisation that most research into pedagogical views held by teachers and their students in higher education has examined them in isolation of each other. In recognition of this disparity in the literature, a more comprehensive study on teachers' and students' views, expectations, and experiences of assessment was undertaken in the South African context. The study was conducted at a research-intensive university and investigated the aforementioned assessment aspects in students and teachers involved in second year compulsory bioscience courses. Using an exploratory, interpretative, mixed method research approach, data were collected through a combination of interviews, questionnaires and document analysis. An in-depth examination of documents from the selected courses, including students' marked work, provided evidence of assessment and feedback practices experienced by the students registered in the courses. Teachers were interviewed about their assessment practices and their rationale for using these practices. Students' views and their reactions to assessment and feedback were ascertained through questionnaires and interviews. Interpretations that emerged from using a socio-cultural-historical theoretical lens were helpful in understanding the factors that present challenges to the implementation of learningoriented assessment approaches. From the characterisation of assessment environments based on learning-oriented assessment principles it was apparent that there was limited active involvement of students in the process. The data highlighted a complex array of factors influencing teachers' conceptions of assessment and subsequently their practices. Significant about the study was the identification of the effects of existing course level assessment cultures and histories on teachers' assessment practices. Program and course factors had more vi
South African Journal of Science, 2020
This Commentary is a response to a Commentary published in the May/June 2020 issue: Nattrass N. W... more This Commentary is a response to a Commentary published in the May/June 2020 issue: Nattrass N. Why are black South African students less likely to consider studying biological sciences? S Afr J Sci. 2020;116(5/6), Art. #7864, 2 pages. https://doi.org/10.17159/sajs.2020/7864 Responses to the Commentary in the May/June 2020 issue have been published collectively in a special issue of Volume 116.
South African Journal of Higher Education, 2018
Transformation in Higher Education has been an ongoing concern in post-apartheid South Africa, es... more Transformation in Higher Education has been an ongoing concern in post-apartheid South Africa, especially in light of universities' expected contribution to economic and socio-political transformation. In particular, curriculum transformation has proved challenging, as evidenced in actions and calls by students in recent years for decolonisation of the curriculum. This study, which formed part of an institutional response to the challenge of curriculum transformation and decolonisation, initially sought to examine perceptions of the term "decolonisation" amongst a group of early career lecturers at a leading university in South Africa. Highlighted in the outcomes of the study was the centrality of personal and contextual relevance in notions of decolonised curricula, the impact of curriculum conversations on lecturers' well-being, and the broader implications of responsive and relevant curricula for institutional and societal well-being. In this respect, the findings of the study illustrated the similarities of curriculum decolonisation approaches and the concept of education for sustainable development which is underpinned by the goal of global well-being and the common good. Also highlighted was the need for greater balance between Mode 1 (theoretical) and Mode 2 (contextually relevant) knowledge in curricula, leading us to posit that both curriculum decolonisation and education for sustainable development are equally necessary for institutional and broader societal reform and well-being, and that both imperatives may potentially be achieved by focusing on the principles of epistemically diverse curricula.
The International Journal of Assessment and Evaluation, 2014