Mark Oxbrow - Academia.edu (original) (raw)

Papers by Mark Oxbrow

Fortress Press, 2015

 Users may download and print one copy of any publication from the public portal for the purpose... more  Users may download and print one copy of any publication from the public portal for the purpose of private study or research.  You may not further distribute the material or use it for any profit-making activity or commercial gain  You may freely distribute the URL identifying the publication in the public portal If you believe that this document breaches copyright please contact us providing details, and we will remove access to the work immediately and investigate your claim.

International Bulletin of Mission Research, 2009

Religious Studies Review, Mar 1, 2015

Papers from the seminal meeting of emerging mission leaders from around the world in Bangalore 2004

Transformation: An International Journal of Holistic Mission Studies, 2020

Rarely have I learnt so much from a book with whose core thesis I totally disagree. In one of the... more Rarely have I learnt so much from a book with whose core thesis I totally disagree. In one of the most challenging books I have read in recent years, Michael Stroope presents his extensive material with such clarity and persuasion that I found myself constantly on the brink of being persuaded by his ultimately flawed argument. Of course, Stroope knows from the outset that most of his readers will be culturally and psychologically predisposed to reject his case for abandoning the use of mission language and its associated theological categories in favour of Kingdom of God language and the dynamics of pilgrimage and witness, but the importance of this work is that it forces us to reappraise the balance between linguistic dis-continuity and contested meaning as problematic dynamics within contemporary Christian witness. Stoope's basic thesis is that the language of 'mission' is neither biblical nor ancient, it is inexorably associated with the negative implications of conquest, colonialism, paternalism and much more, and as a result it has ceased to, if it ever did, communicate the purposes of God towards his creation and should therefore be abandoned and transcended. The title of his book is a, thinly disguised, play on David Bosch's magnum opus Transforming Mission: Paradigm Shifts in Theology of Mission (Bosch, 2011) which he dismisses in the opening pages of his book, saying: In his efforts to transform mission, Bosch leaves mission rhetoric untouched, with only a brief admission of misplacing it in the chronology. By so doing, Bosch does not transform mission but compounds the confusion, perpetuates a problem.. .. His emphasis on missio Dei appears to add clarity and to identify which questions we should be asking, but in the end, such an emphasis does little to resolve the difficulties with the source and meaning of mission (p. xvii). Bosch does not stand alone. In his first chapter, Stroope addresses the ranks of esteemed missiologists, whom he categorises as 'partisans' and 'apologists'.

International Bulletin of Mission Research

A century after his major publications, Roland Allen continues to attract attention within the mi... more A century after his major publications, Roland Allen continues to attract attention within the mission community. He has much to say to contemporary perceptions that new models in mission are urgently required. Allen is less concerned with methods than with the spiritual impulse for mission and the biblical principles by which it is lived. The missionary Spirit of Christ is at the heart of all mission, and the Pauline principles that Allen advances derive from our response to that Spirit. Following Allen, this article challenges a number of accepted contemporary practices in mission, asking “Is Christ here being revealed?”

Living the Gospel of Jesus Christ

Living the Gospel of Jesus Christ, 2021

International Bulletin of Missionary Research, 2015

This study in comparative sociology, driven by “anthropological theory” and fashionable tropes of... more This study in comparative sociology, driven by “anthropological theory” and fashionable tropes of “discourse analysis,” makes vast and sweeping historical claims about complexities of Indian and Chinese cultures. In so doing, it attempts to refute the notion that elements of modernity within these cultures are imitations derived from the West. Rather, it argues that ancient traditions of these societies have been transformed in distinctive and unique ways. Peter van der Veer, director of the Max Planck Institute for the Study of Religious and Ethnic Diversity, in Göttingen, and distinguished professor at Utrecht University, begins by exploring how, out of nineteenth-century imperial history, Western concepts of spirituality and secularity, as also of religion and magic, were utilized to epitomize traditions of China and India. He then attempts to show how modern notions of religion and magic were grafted into the respective nation-making projects of nationalist intellectuals within China and India in ways that were quite distinctive. Thus, while religion played a central role within nationalisms of India, religion was viewed as such an obstacle to progress in China that it had to be strictly controlled and marginalized. In pursuit of this argument, van der Veer addresses different understandings of art, compares yoga with qi gong, looks at concepts of secularism and of conversion within Christian histories, differentiates between constructions of religion in India and campaigns against superstition in China, and juxtaposes Muslim Kashmir and Muslim Xinjiang. As a prominent champion of comparative studies in religion and society, the author stresses the importance of deeper understandings of what is spiritual and what is secular within these two major civilizations. In pursuing this theme, where ideology can parade in the garb of theory, veracity is ever and always seen as conditional and contingent, if not contrived. Comparative analysis of culture ends in intellectual construction and invention. The “conditional idea” is made to represent “real presences” in a house of cards that is largely abstract. Thus, despite sometimes brilliant insights, forays grounded in actual historical events reveal little about those events that has not already been known for some time. What may be new within this study lies in the way already-known events can be remolded. Vocabulary for such analysis, borrowed from current fashions of literary criticism, sociology, and anthropology, invokes the lineage of Max Weber and genuflects before the rhetoric of Edward Said and his disciples. Interactions between four select concepts—religion and magic, secularity and spirituality—are connected, defined, and then redefined in respect to relations of power within imperial and national institutions. Yet, for scholars interested in the history of Christian missions, there is not much new to be learned from such rhetorical exercises, however dazzling they may seem. —Robert Eric Frykenberg

Transformation: An International Journal of Holistic Mission Studies, 2020

The Greek term mártyras carries the double meaning of witness and martyr. This paper invites an e... more The Greek term mártyras carries the double meaning of witness and martyr. This paper invites an exploration of the relationship between these two concepts in the contexts of first century and contemporary Africa using the life of St Mark as a historical lens. The paper suggests that many Western authored histories of the Christian movement are distorted by a lack of attention to the Eastern and African expansion of the Church in the early centuries and that contemporary African Christians have erroneously bought into this emaciated history and the theology to which it has given rise. Through an examination of various themes in the life, witness and death of St Mark, and the relationship between martyrdom and witness in African Christian history, the paper encourages a reappraisal of the African roots of Christianity as a rich source for contemporary discipleship in Africa and the universal Church.

Transformation: An International Journal of Holistic Mission Studies

Fortress Press, 2015

 Users may download and print one copy of any publication from the public portal for the purpose... more  Users may download and print one copy of any publication from the public portal for the purpose of private study or research.  You may not further distribute the material or use it for any profit-making activity or commercial gain  You may freely distribute the URL identifying the publication in the public portal If you believe that this document breaches copyright please contact us providing details, and we will remove access to the work immediately and investigate your claim.

International Bulletin of Mission Research, 2009

Religious Studies Review, Mar 1, 2015

Papers from the seminal meeting of emerging mission leaders from around the world in Bangalore 2004

Transformation: An International Journal of Holistic Mission Studies, 2020

Rarely have I learnt so much from a book with whose core thesis I totally disagree. In one of the... more Rarely have I learnt so much from a book with whose core thesis I totally disagree. In one of the most challenging books I have read in recent years, Michael Stroope presents his extensive material with such clarity and persuasion that I found myself constantly on the brink of being persuaded by his ultimately flawed argument. Of course, Stroope knows from the outset that most of his readers will be culturally and psychologically predisposed to reject his case for abandoning the use of mission language and its associated theological categories in favour of Kingdom of God language and the dynamics of pilgrimage and witness, but the importance of this work is that it forces us to reappraise the balance between linguistic dis-continuity and contested meaning as problematic dynamics within contemporary Christian witness. Stoope's basic thesis is that the language of 'mission' is neither biblical nor ancient, it is inexorably associated with the negative implications of conquest, colonialism, paternalism and much more, and as a result it has ceased to, if it ever did, communicate the purposes of God towards his creation and should therefore be abandoned and transcended. The title of his book is a, thinly disguised, play on David Bosch's magnum opus Transforming Mission: Paradigm Shifts in Theology of Mission (Bosch, 2011) which he dismisses in the opening pages of his book, saying: In his efforts to transform mission, Bosch leaves mission rhetoric untouched, with only a brief admission of misplacing it in the chronology. By so doing, Bosch does not transform mission but compounds the confusion, perpetuates a problem.. .. His emphasis on missio Dei appears to add clarity and to identify which questions we should be asking, but in the end, such an emphasis does little to resolve the difficulties with the source and meaning of mission (p. xvii). Bosch does not stand alone. In his first chapter, Stroope addresses the ranks of esteemed missiologists, whom he categorises as 'partisans' and 'apologists'.

International Bulletin of Mission Research

A century after his major publications, Roland Allen continues to attract attention within the mi... more A century after his major publications, Roland Allen continues to attract attention within the mission community. He has much to say to contemporary perceptions that new models in mission are urgently required. Allen is less concerned with methods than with the spiritual impulse for mission and the biblical principles by which it is lived. The missionary Spirit of Christ is at the heart of all mission, and the Pauline principles that Allen advances derive from our response to that Spirit. Following Allen, this article challenges a number of accepted contemporary practices in mission, asking “Is Christ here being revealed?”

Living the Gospel of Jesus Christ

Living the Gospel of Jesus Christ, 2021

International Bulletin of Missionary Research, 2015

This study in comparative sociology, driven by “anthropological theory” and fashionable tropes of... more This study in comparative sociology, driven by “anthropological theory” and fashionable tropes of “discourse analysis,” makes vast and sweeping historical claims about complexities of Indian and Chinese cultures. In so doing, it attempts to refute the notion that elements of modernity within these cultures are imitations derived from the West. Rather, it argues that ancient traditions of these societies have been transformed in distinctive and unique ways. Peter van der Veer, director of the Max Planck Institute for the Study of Religious and Ethnic Diversity, in Göttingen, and distinguished professor at Utrecht University, begins by exploring how, out of nineteenth-century imperial history, Western concepts of spirituality and secularity, as also of religion and magic, were utilized to epitomize traditions of China and India. He then attempts to show how modern notions of religion and magic were grafted into the respective nation-making projects of nationalist intellectuals within China and India in ways that were quite distinctive. Thus, while religion played a central role within nationalisms of India, religion was viewed as such an obstacle to progress in China that it had to be strictly controlled and marginalized. In pursuit of this argument, van der Veer addresses different understandings of art, compares yoga with qi gong, looks at concepts of secularism and of conversion within Christian histories, differentiates between constructions of religion in India and campaigns against superstition in China, and juxtaposes Muslim Kashmir and Muslim Xinjiang. As a prominent champion of comparative studies in religion and society, the author stresses the importance of deeper understandings of what is spiritual and what is secular within these two major civilizations. In pursuing this theme, where ideology can parade in the garb of theory, veracity is ever and always seen as conditional and contingent, if not contrived. Comparative analysis of culture ends in intellectual construction and invention. The “conditional idea” is made to represent “real presences” in a house of cards that is largely abstract. Thus, despite sometimes brilliant insights, forays grounded in actual historical events reveal little about those events that has not already been known for some time. What may be new within this study lies in the way already-known events can be remolded. Vocabulary for such analysis, borrowed from current fashions of literary criticism, sociology, and anthropology, invokes the lineage of Max Weber and genuflects before the rhetoric of Edward Said and his disciples. Interactions between four select concepts—religion and magic, secularity and spirituality—are connected, defined, and then redefined in respect to relations of power within imperial and national institutions. Yet, for scholars interested in the history of Christian missions, there is not much new to be learned from such rhetorical exercises, however dazzling they may seem. —Robert Eric Frykenberg

Transformation: An International Journal of Holistic Mission Studies, 2020

The Greek term mártyras carries the double meaning of witness and martyr. This paper invites an e... more The Greek term mártyras carries the double meaning of witness and martyr. This paper invites an exploration of the relationship between these two concepts in the contexts of first century and contemporary Africa using the life of St Mark as a historical lens. The paper suggests that many Western authored histories of the Christian movement are distorted by a lack of attention to the Eastern and African expansion of the Church in the early centuries and that contemporary African Christians have erroneously bought into this emaciated history and the theology to which it has given rise. Through an examination of various themes in the life, witness and death of St Mark, and the relationship between martyrdom and witness in African Christian history, the paper encourages a reappraisal of the African roots of Christianity as a rich source for contemporary discipleship in Africa and the universal Church.

Transformation: An International Journal of Holistic Mission Studies