Isabelle Laurion | Institut national de la recherche scientifique (original) (raw)
Uploads
Papers by Isabelle Laurion
Arctic climate change is leading to accelerated melting of permafrost and the mobilization of soi... more Arctic climate change is leading to accelerated melting of permafrost and the mobilization of soil organic carbon pools that have accumulated over thousands of years. Photochemical and microbial transformation will liberate a fraction of this carbon to the atmosphere in the form of CO 2 and CH 4 . We quantified these fluxes in a series of permafrost thaw ponds in the Canadian Subarctic and Arctic and further investigated how optical properties of the carbon pool, the type of microbial assemblages, and light and mixing regimes influenced the rate of gas release. Most ponds were supersaturated in CO 2 and all of them in CH 4 . Gas fluxes as estimated from dissolved gas concentrations using a wind-based model varied from 220.5 to 114.4 mmol CO 2 m 22 d 21 , with negative fluxes recorded in arctic ponds colonized by benthic microbial mats, and from 0.03 to 5.62 mmol CH 4 m 22 d 21 . From a time series set of measurements in a subarctic pond over 8 d, calculated gas fluxes were on average 40% higher when using a newly derived equation for the gas transfer coefficient developed from eddy covariance measurements. The daily variation in gas fluxes was highly dependent on mixed layer dynamics. At the seasonal timescale, persistent thermal stratification and gas buildup at depth indicated that autumnal overturn is a critically important period for greenhouse gas emissions from subarctic ponds. These results underscore the increasingly important contribution of permafrost thaw ponds to greenhouse gas emissions and the need to account for local and regional variability in their limnological properties for global estimates.
Thawing permafrost in the Canadian Arctic tundra leads to peat erosion and slumping in narrow and... more Thawing permafrost in the Canadian Arctic tundra leads to peat erosion and slumping in narrow and shallow runnel ponds that surround more commonly studied polygonal ponds. Here we compared the methane production between runnel and polygonal ponds using stable isotope ratios, 14 C signatures, and investigated potential methanogenic communities through high-throughput sequencing archaeal 16S rRNA genes. We found that runnel ponds had significantly higher methane and carbon dioxide emissions, produced from a slightly larger fraction of old carbon, compared to polygonal ponds. The methane stable isotopic signature indicated production through acetoclastic methanogenesis, but gene signatures from acetoclastic and hydrogenotrophic methanogenic Archaea were detected in both polygonal and runnel ponds. We conclude that runnel ponds represent a source of methane from potentially older C, and that they contain methanogenic communities able to use diverse sources of carbon, increasing the risk of augmented methane release under a warmer climate.
The abundant thaw lakes and ponds in the circumarctic receive a new pool of organic carbon as per... more The abundant thaw lakes and ponds in the circumarctic receive a new pool of organic carbon as permafrost peat soils degrade, which can be exposed to significant irradiance that potentially increases as climate warms and ice cover shortens. Exposure to sunlight is known to accelerate the transformation of dissolved organic matter (DOM) into molecules that can be more readily used by microbes. We sampled the water from two common classes of ponds found in the ice-wedge system of continuous permafrost regions of Canada, polygonal and runnel ponds, and followed the transformation of DOM over 12 days by looking at dissolved organic carbon (DOC) concentration and DOM absorption and fluorescence properties. The results indicate a relatively fast decay of color (3.4 and 1.6% loss d −1 of absorption at 320 nm for the polygonal and runnel pond, respectively) and fluorescence (6.1 and 8.3% loss d −1 of total fluorescent components, respectively) at the pond surface, faster in the case of humic-like components, but insignificant losses of DOC over the observed period. This result indicates that direct DOM mineralization (photochemical production of CO 2 ) is apparently minor in thaw ponds compared to the photochemical transformation of DOM into less chromophoric and likely more labile molecules with a greater potential for microbial mineralization. Therefore, DOM photolysis in arctic thaw ponds can be considered as a catalytic mechanism, accelerating the microbial turnover of mobilized organic matter from thawing permafrost and the production of greenhouse gases, especially in the most shallow ponds. Under a warming climate, this mechanism will intensify as summers lengthen.
The purpose of this study is to assess the performance of an adaptive model (AM) in estimating ch... more The purpose of this study is to assess the performance of an adaptive model (AM) in estimating chlorophyll-a concentration (Chl-a) in optically complex inland waters. Chl-a modeling using remote sensing data is usually based on a single model that generally follows an exponential function. The estimates produced by such models are relatively accurate at high Chl-a concentrations, but accuracy drops at low concentrations. Our objective was to develop an approach combining spectral response classification and three semi-empirical algorithms. The AM discriminates between three blooming classes (waters poorly, moderately, and highly loaded in Chl-a), with discrimination thresholds set using the classification and regression tree (CART) technique. The calibration of three specific estimators for each class was achieved using a multivariate stepwise regression. Compared to published models (Floating Algae Index, Kahru model, and APProach by ELimination) using the same data set, the AM provided better Chl-a concentration estimates (R 2 of 0.96, relative RMSE of 23%, relative Bias of −2%, and a relative NASH criterion of 0.9). Moreover, the AM achieved an overall success rate of 67% in the estimation of blooming classes (corresponding to low, moderate, and high Chl-a concentration classes). This was done using an independent data set collected from 22 inland water bodies for the period 2007-2010 and for which the only information available was the blooming class. OPEN ACCESS Remote Sens. 2014, 6 6447 1. Introduction
Permafrost thawing in lowland Arctic tundra results in a polygonal patterned landscape and the fo... more Permafrost thawing in lowland Arctic tundra results in a polygonal patterned landscape and the formation of numerous small ponds. These ponds emit biologically mediated carbon dioxide (CO 2 ) and methane (CH 4 ). Their greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions are variable, for reasons that are not well understood. Emissions are related to a balance between GHG producers and consumers, as well as to physical properties of the water column controlling gas exchange rates with the atmosphere. Here, we investigated the bacterial diversity of polygonal and runnel ponds, two geomorphologically distinct pond types commonly found in continuous permafrost regions. Using a combination of 16S rRNA Sanger sequencing and highthroughput amplicon sequencing, we found that bacterial communities in overlying waters were clearly dominated by carbon degraders and were similar in both pond types, despite their variable physical and chemical properties. However, surface sediment communities in the two pond types were significantly different. Polygonal pond sediment was colonized by carbon degraders (46-29 %), cyanobacteria (20-27 %) that take up CO 2 and produce oxygen, and methanotrophs (11-20 %) that consume CH 4 and require oxygen. In contrast, cyanobacteria were effectively absent from the surface sediment of runnel ponds, which in addition to carbon degraders (65-81 %), were colonized by purple non-sulfur bacteria (5-21 %), and by fewer methanotrophs (1-5 %). The link between the methanotrophic community and the type of ponds could potentially be used to improve upscale estimates of GHG emissions based on landscape morphology in such remote regions.
Small lakes are likely to show considerable temporal variability in greenhouse gas emissions give... more Small lakes are likely to show considerable temporal variability in greenhouse gas emissions given their transient stratification and short residence time. To determine the extent that CO 2 and CH 4 emission and storage depends on surface meteorology, we studied a shallow lake during 2 years with contrasting rainfall and thermal stratification. Gas fluxes were estimated with wind-based and surface renewal models and compared to direct measurements obtained with floating chambers. The assessment of greenhouse gases storage revealed that the lake gained CO 2 in association with rainfall in both the rainier (2011) and drier summer (2012). In 2011, stratification was less extensive and disrupted frequently. The lake was a source of CO 2 and CH 4 , and ebullition exceeded diffusive fluxes of CH 4 . In 2012, stratification was more persistent, the lake was a sink for CO 2 during dry periods, CO 2 and CH 4 accumulated in the hypolimnion later in the summer when rainfall increased, diffusive fluxes of CH 4 were similar to those in 2011 mid-summer and over four times higher during overturn. Ebullition was lower in the drier summer.
In optically complex inland waters, the underwater attenuation of photosynthetically active radia... more In optically complex inland waters, the underwater attenuation of photosynthetically active radiation (PAR) is controlled by a variable combination of absorption and scattering components of the lake or river water. Here we applied a photon budget approach to identify the main optical components affecting PAR attenuation in Lake St. Charles, a drinking water reservoir for Qu ebec City, Canada. This analysis showed the dominant role of colored dissolved organic matter (CDOM) absorption (average of 44% of total absorption during the sampling period), but with large changes over depth in the absolute and relative contribution of the individual absorption components (water, nonalgal particulates, phytoplankton and CDOM) to PAR attenuation. This pronounced vertical variation occurred because of the large spectral changes in the light field with depth, and it strongly affected the average in situ diffuse absorption coefficients in the water column. For example, the diffuse absorption coefficient for pure-water in the ambient light field was 10-fold higher than the value previously measured in the blue open ocean and erroneously applied to lakes and coastal waters. Photon absorption budget calculations for a range of limnological conditions confirmed that phytoplankton had little direct influence on underwater light, even at chlorophyll a values above those observed during harmful algal blooms in the lake. These results imply that traditional measures of water quality such as Secchi depth and radiometric transparency do not provide a meaningful estimate of the biological state of the water column in CDOM-colored lakes and reservoirs.
Arctic climate change is leading to accelerated melting of permafrost and the mobilization of soi... more Arctic climate change is leading to accelerated melting of permafrost and the mobilization of soil organic carbon pools that have accumulated over thousands of years. Photochemical and microbial transformation will liberate a fraction of this carbon to the atmosphere in the form of CO 2 and CH 4 . We quantified these fluxes in a series of permafrost thaw ponds in the Canadian Subarctic and Arctic and further investigated how optical properties of the carbon pool, the type of microbial assemblages, and light and mixing regimes influenced the rate of gas release. Most ponds were supersaturated in CO 2 and all of them in CH 4 . Gas fluxes as estimated from dissolved gas concentrations using a wind-based model varied from 220.5 to 114.4 mmol CO 2 m 22 d 21 , with negative fluxes recorded in arctic ponds colonized by benthic microbial mats, and from 0.03 to 5.62 mmol CH 4 m 22 d 21 . From a time series set of measurements in a subarctic pond over 8 d, calculated gas fluxes were on average 40% higher when using a newly derived equation for the gas transfer coefficient developed from eddy covariance measurements. The daily variation in gas fluxes was highly dependent on mixed layer dynamics. At the seasonal timescale, persistent thermal stratification and gas buildup at depth indicated that autumnal overturn is a critically important period for greenhouse gas emissions from subarctic ponds. These results underscore the increasingly important contribution of permafrost thaw ponds to greenhouse gas emissions and the need to account for local and regional variability in their limnological properties for global estimates.
Thawing permafrost in the Canadian Arctic tundra leads to peat erosion and slumping in narrow and... more Thawing permafrost in the Canadian Arctic tundra leads to peat erosion and slumping in narrow and shallow runnel ponds that surround more commonly studied polygonal ponds. Here we compared the methane production between runnel and polygonal ponds using stable isotope ratios, 14 C signatures, and investigated potential methanogenic communities through high-throughput sequencing archaeal 16S rRNA genes. We found that runnel ponds had significantly higher methane and carbon dioxide emissions, produced from a slightly larger fraction of old carbon, compared to polygonal ponds. The methane stable isotopic signature indicated production through acetoclastic methanogenesis, but gene signatures from acetoclastic and hydrogenotrophic methanogenic Archaea were detected in both polygonal and runnel ponds. We conclude that runnel ponds represent a source of methane from potentially older C, and that they contain methanogenic communities able to use diverse sources of carbon, increasing the risk of augmented methane release under a warmer climate.
The abundant thaw lakes and ponds in the circumarctic receive a new pool of organic carbon as per... more The abundant thaw lakes and ponds in the circumarctic receive a new pool of organic carbon as permafrost peat soils degrade, which can be exposed to significant irradiance that potentially increases as climate warms and ice cover shortens. Exposure to sunlight is known to accelerate the transformation of dissolved organic matter (DOM) into molecules that can be more readily used by microbes. We sampled the water from two common classes of ponds found in the ice-wedge system of continuous permafrost regions of Canada, polygonal and runnel ponds, and followed the transformation of DOM over 12 days by looking at dissolved organic carbon (DOC) concentration and DOM absorption and fluorescence properties. The results indicate a relatively fast decay of color (3.4 and 1.6% loss d −1 of absorption at 320 nm for the polygonal and runnel pond, respectively) and fluorescence (6.1 and 8.3% loss d −1 of total fluorescent components, respectively) at the pond surface, faster in the case of humic-like components, but insignificant losses of DOC over the observed period. This result indicates that direct DOM mineralization (photochemical production of CO 2 ) is apparently minor in thaw ponds compared to the photochemical transformation of DOM into less chromophoric and likely more labile molecules with a greater potential for microbial mineralization. Therefore, DOM photolysis in arctic thaw ponds can be considered as a catalytic mechanism, accelerating the microbial turnover of mobilized organic matter from thawing permafrost and the production of greenhouse gases, especially in the most shallow ponds. Under a warming climate, this mechanism will intensify as summers lengthen.
The purpose of this study is to assess the performance of an adaptive model (AM) in estimating ch... more The purpose of this study is to assess the performance of an adaptive model (AM) in estimating chlorophyll-a concentration (Chl-a) in optically complex inland waters. Chl-a modeling using remote sensing data is usually based on a single model that generally follows an exponential function. The estimates produced by such models are relatively accurate at high Chl-a concentrations, but accuracy drops at low concentrations. Our objective was to develop an approach combining spectral response classification and three semi-empirical algorithms. The AM discriminates between three blooming classes (waters poorly, moderately, and highly loaded in Chl-a), with discrimination thresholds set using the classification and regression tree (CART) technique. The calibration of three specific estimators for each class was achieved using a multivariate stepwise regression. Compared to published models (Floating Algae Index, Kahru model, and APProach by ELimination) using the same data set, the AM provided better Chl-a concentration estimates (R 2 of 0.96, relative RMSE of 23%, relative Bias of −2%, and a relative NASH criterion of 0.9). Moreover, the AM achieved an overall success rate of 67% in the estimation of blooming classes (corresponding to low, moderate, and high Chl-a concentration classes). This was done using an independent data set collected from 22 inland water bodies for the period 2007-2010 and for which the only information available was the blooming class. OPEN ACCESS Remote Sens. 2014, 6 6447 1. Introduction
Permafrost thawing in lowland Arctic tundra results in a polygonal patterned landscape and the fo... more Permafrost thawing in lowland Arctic tundra results in a polygonal patterned landscape and the formation of numerous small ponds. These ponds emit biologically mediated carbon dioxide (CO 2 ) and methane (CH 4 ). Their greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions are variable, for reasons that are not well understood. Emissions are related to a balance between GHG producers and consumers, as well as to physical properties of the water column controlling gas exchange rates with the atmosphere. Here, we investigated the bacterial diversity of polygonal and runnel ponds, two geomorphologically distinct pond types commonly found in continuous permafrost regions. Using a combination of 16S rRNA Sanger sequencing and highthroughput amplicon sequencing, we found that bacterial communities in overlying waters were clearly dominated by carbon degraders and were similar in both pond types, despite their variable physical and chemical properties. However, surface sediment communities in the two pond types were significantly different. Polygonal pond sediment was colonized by carbon degraders (46-29 %), cyanobacteria (20-27 %) that take up CO 2 and produce oxygen, and methanotrophs (11-20 %) that consume CH 4 and require oxygen. In contrast, cyanobacteria were effectively absent from the surface sediment of runnel ponds, which in addition to carbon degraders (65-81 %), were colonized by purple non-sulfur bacteria (5-21 %), and by fewer methanotrophs (1-5 %). The link between the methanotrophic community and the type of ponds could potentially be used to improve upscale estimates of GHG emissions based on landscape morphology in such remote regions.
Small lakes are likely to show considerable temporal variability in greenhouse gas emissions give... more Small lakes are likely to show considerable temporal variability in greenhouse gas emissions given their transient stratification and short residence time. To determine the extent that CO 2 and CH 4 emission and storage depends on surface meteorology, we studied a shallow lake during 2 years with contrasting rainfall and thermal stratification. Gas fluxes were estimated with wind-based and surface renewal models and compared to direct measurements obtained with floating chambers. The assessment of greenhouse gases storage revealed that the lake gained CO 2 in association with rainfall in both the rainier (2011) and drier summer (2012). In 2011, stratification was less extensive and disrupted frequently. The lake was a source of CO 2 and CH 4 , and ebullition exceeded diffusive fluxes of CH 4 . In 2012, stratification was more persistent, the lake was a sink for CO 2 during dry periods, CO 2 and CH 4 accumulated in the hypolimnion later in the summer when rainfall increased, diffusive fluxes of CH 4 were similar to those in 2011 mid-summer and over four times higher during overturn. Ebullition was lower in the drier summer.
In optically complex inland waters, the underwater attenuation of photosynthetically active radia... more In optically complex inland waters, the underwater attenuation of photosynthetically active radiation (PAR) is controlled by a variable combination of absorption and scattering components of the lake or river water. Here we applied a photon budget approach to identify the main optical components affecting PAR attenuation in Lake St. Charles, a drinking water reservoir for Qu ebec City, Canada. This analysis showed the dominant role of colored dissolved organic matter (CDOM) absorption (average of 44% of total absorption during the sampling period), but with large changes over depth in the absolute and relative contribution of the individual absorption components (water, nonalgal particulates, phytoplankton and CDOM) to PAR attenuation. This pronounced vertical variation occurred because of the large spectral changes in the light field with depth, and it strongly affected the average in situ diffuse absorption coefficients in the water column. For example, the diffuse absorption coefficient for pure-water in the ambient light field was 10-fold higher than the value previously measured in the blue open ocean and erroneously applied to lakes and coastal waters. Photon absorption budget calculations for a range of limnological conditions confirmed that phytoplankton had little direct influence on underwater light, even at chlorophyll a values above those observed during harmful algal blooms in the lake. These results imply that traditional measures of water quality such as Secchi depth and radiometric transparency do not provide a meaningful estimate of the biological state of the water column in CDOM-colored lakes and reservoirs.