Rasoul RAHBARI GHAZANI | Istanbul University (original) (raw)

Books by Rasoul RAHBARI GHAZANI

The Oneness of Being In Ibn ʿArabī and Plotinus, 2022

The ‘oneness of being’ or ‘unity of existence,’ also known as the doctrine of ‘the One,’ is of ca... more The ‘oneness of being’ or ‘unity of existence,’ also known as the doctrine of ‘the One,’ is of cardinal importance in philosophy. It has penetrated Greek, Neoplatonist, and Islamic Metaphysics so profoundly that studying the history of philosophy in these traditions would be impractical without this doctrine. Two influential thinkers who advocate this doctrine are Plotinus and Ibn ʿArabī. Therefore, it is essential to make precise the two thinkers’ positions. The primary aim of this book is to clarify the doctrine of the oneness of being in Ibn ʿArabī’s Seals of Wisdom and Plotinus’ Enneads. The secondary aim is to examine whether the metaphysical positions of the two thinkers’ doctrines are philosophically credible. Examining these masterpieces in the context of commentaries and secondary sources written for them, I conclude that the metaphysical positions of the two doctrines are credible and that despite minor differences, they are strikingly similar, a resemblance which indicates that Plotinus might have influenced al-ʿArabī. This work gives the reader an excellent basis to study Greek, Neoplatonist, and Islamic Metaphysics. Lastly, one crucial problem that deserves further research is the link between Ibn ʿArabī’s ‘fixed entities’ (al-aʿyān al-thābitah) and Plotinus’ Intellect.

Papers by Rasoul RAHBARI GHAZANI

Journal of Philosophical Theological Research, 2024

This paper explores the metaphysical concepts of divine “love” (ʿeshq), “attraction” (jadhbe), an... more This paper explores the metaphysical concepts of divine “love” (ʿeshq), “attraction” (jadhbe), and “selflessness” (bīkhodī) in the seminal Iranian Shīʿī Muslim thinker Mullā Muḥsin Fayḍ Kāshānī’s poetry. It seeks to comprehensively understand these themes in the context of self-transcendence and divine unity. This research emerges from the gap in existing literature, which mainly explores Fayḍ Kāshānī’s philosophical, theological, or ḥadīth works, while the scrutiny of his poetry largely stays within its literary attributes, overlooking the philosophical and mystical themes embedded within. The paper’s thesis posits that according to Fayḍ Kāshānī, the spiritual journey commences with reason, progressing to constant divine contemplation. This combination of philosophy and spirituality nurtures muḥabbat—an initial stage of divine love—which, when discovered, evokes a more intense love: “divine attraction” in the seeker’s heart, leading to selflessness and divine unity. This paper employs the hermeneutic method and analytical examination to scrutinize Fayḍ Kāshānī’s poetry within the context of his treatises. It follows an “intracultural” interpretation to explore Fayḍ Kāshānī’s thought within Persian intellectual tradition and uses an “intercultural” interpretation to contextualize the findings within Islamic, Christian, and ancient Greek metaphysics. The methodology includes a “horizontal interpretation” of Quranic and ḥadīth references in Fayḍ Kāshānī’s works and a “vertical interpretation” of unveiling deeper meanings of Fayḍ Kāshānī’s thoughts within the broader mystical traditions. The research accentuates how Persian metaphysical poetry, like Fayḍ Kāshānī’s, offers an evocative platform to articulate and traverse the mystic’s inner landscapes, contributing to Islamic Studies and Islamic Metaphysics and inviting scholars to explore this fertile domain.

Journal of Philosophical Investigations, 2024

Adopting a hermeneutic approach and horizontal and vertical interpretation methods, this study pr... more Adopting a hermeneutic approach and horizontal and vertical interpretation methods, this study primarily explores the metaphysical concept of love-induced mystic intoxication in the Iranian polymath Mullā Muḥsin Fayḍ Kāshānī’s mystic poetry. Secondarily, it discusses the implications of mystic intoxication in the meaning of life. Furthermore, the paper briefly positions Fayḍ Kāshānī’s account in the contemporary categories of the meaning of life: supernaturalism, naturalism, and nihilism. Additionally, elucidating the perspectives of the contemporary philosopher John Cottingham, the paper examines Kāshānī’s view through Cottingham’s philosophy. Central to Kāshānī’s poetry, ignited by divine love, the spiritual seeker transcendends their self, getting absorbed into the Divine to the point where they become unaware of their self. This epistemic unawareness is mastī (intoxication) or bīkhudī (selflessness)—which, for Kāshānī, has profound implications on life’s meaning. Unlike the “extreme God-centric” view—which situates the purpose of life solely in fulfilling God’s purpose—Kāshānī’s “moderate God-soul-centric supernaturalist” view recognizes that while divine love, intoxication, and knowledge infuse more profound depth to the meaning of life, other aspects also add to the meaning in life—like the simpler forms of piety and everyday existence. A framework in which morality is instrumental. Similarly, for Cottingham, life has value and meaning beyond solely fulfilling God’s purpose. Nevertheless, while basic pleasures and desires might independently exist and have meaning, higher elements like moral virtue, crucial to life’s meaning, are contingent on God’s purpose.

Journal of philosophical Investigations , 2024

This study explores the distinguished Persian Sufi mystic Shaykh Maḥmūd Shabestarī's Golshan-e Rā... more This study explores the distinguished Persian Sufi mystic Shaykh Maḥmūd Shabestarī's Golshan-e Rāz, or The Rose Garden of Mystery. Adopting a hermeneutic approach, it scrutinizes the intricate spiritual journey towards divine realization delineated in Shabestarī's poetry, utilizing qualitative content analysis of original texts and interpretations by scholars such as Lāhījī and Ibn Turka Iṣfahānī. The main question the paper addresses is this: "How can the spiritual journeyer overcome obstacles-particularly 'otherness'-and achieve unity with the divine Essence within the framework of Islamic mysticism, as interpreted through Shabestarī's teachings in Golshan-e Rāz?" To answer this inquiry, the paper addresses pivotal questions concerning Shabestarī's depiction of the spiritual journeyer's path, its stages and challenges, and the critical role of the human form in divine manifestation. The study underscores the necessity of overcoming duality and distinction, alluding to the transformative nature of the journey that necessitates self-purification and the cessation of otherness. Findings from this study provide an enriched understanding of Shabestarī's thought, contributing to the discourse on Islamic metaphysics. It presents valuable insights into the spiritual journeyer's path, offering a comprehensive interpretation of the challenges, practices, and transformative experiences leading to divine realization and unity.

Journal of Philosophical Investigations, 2023

MDPI, Oct 2, 2023

This paper examines the nature of “asceticism” (rīyāḍat) in Sufism, revolving around the works of... more This paper examines the nature of “asceticism” (rīyāḍat) in Sufism, revolving around the works of the 13th-century Persian Sufi Mawlānā Jalāl al-Dīn Muḥammad Rūmī Balkī and exploring two critical inquiries: Firstly, the article seeks to determine whether Rūmī’s mystical perspective on asceticism is world-rejecting or world-affirming. Secondly, it investigates potential parallels and divergences between Rūmī and Meister Eckhart’s stances—specifically, through the Dominican’s Sermons and Treatises—and assesses the implications for the two figures. In examining Rūmī’s works, the research primarily relies on secondary sources within the Persian intellectual tradition to provide an intracultural context. Utilizing horizontal and vertical interpretations, the study examines critical themes in Rūmī’s works, such as love, detachment (zuhd), the world’s deceptive nature, and seclusion. The findings reveal that Rūmī’s asceticism is not “monastic” (ruhbānī); instead, it balances moderate abstinence and worldly engagement, underpinned by the Quran and the ḥadīth teachings. Rūmī and Eckhart underscore asceticism as an inner transformation rather than mere physical austerity, emphasizing inner purification, self-transcendence, and spiritual detachment as routes to divine unity. The two thinkers’ teachings are catalysts for profound personal transformation and a more fulfilling life in today’s world.

Dar Al-Hikma, Jun 10, 2023

This paper examines the following three questions: (1) In The Rose Garden of Mystery (Golshan-e R... more This paper examines the following three questions: (1) In The Rose Garden of Mystery (Golshan-e Rāz), how does the prominent 7-8th-century Iranian Sufi, Maḥmūd Shabistarī, distinguish the mystical “contemplation” and rational "re-flection” in pursuing divine knowledge? (2) Was Shabistarī an anti-rationalist (strict fideist)? (3) How does Shabistarī’s position fit into the ancient Greek, Neoplatonist, and medieval Islamic and Christian metaphysics? This paper examines Golshan-e Rāz in the context of Shabistarī’s other works, commentaries, secondary sources, and Islamic thought—Sufism and philosophy. Existing literature on Golshan-e Rāz primarily focuses on its literary aspects, neglecting its philosophical and mystical concepts. However, a thorough understanding requires examining these concepts in a broad context, which will inspire further research. The rationale behind this research is rooted in the religious obligation for believers to know God, with “thinking” as the means to acquire such knowledge. This is why the first question Herawī poses to Shabistarī pertains to the nature of thought—justifying this paper’s focus. Contemporary opposition to religion often stems from its perceived incongruity with the rational frameworks offered by positivism, materialism, or scientific inquiry. By differentiating between mystical and rational modes of thought that Shabistarī pre-sents, this study shows the contemporary person that intellectual inquiry extends beyond rationalism and encompasses mysticism. Consequently, rational and mystical perspectives should be pursued in the quest for the divine. Furthermore, this study contends that Shabistarī should not be regarded as a strict fideist; instead, his criticism is directed toward the constraints inherent in rational thinking.

Ataturk University Press, Jun 1, 2023

Who or what is "I"? Does "I" refer to the soul, body, or something else? This paper aims to clari... more Who or what is "I"? Does "I" refer to the soul, body, or something else? This paper aims to clarify the Iranian Sufi Maḥmūd Shabistarī's metaphysical account of the self in The Rose Garden of Mystery (Gulshan-i Rāz). Some of Shabistarī's commentators-for example, Lāhījī-argue that the "self is the determined Real" without offering a full account. This paper presents Shabistarī's self by examining Gulshan in the context of commentaries, secondary sources, and Islamic thought and by presenting opposing interpretations and reasons for the most prominent interpretations. In Gulshan, the self is neither the soul nor the body. It is the Real's determination, a face among the eternally manifesting, unrepeated faces of the Real. This paper argues that the self is the human's fixed entity (quiddity, ʿayn-i thābitah), whose aptitudes are perpetually unfolding; it is an eternal becoming of the Perfect Man. The self is not reified (i.e., it is of no definite content or form) or fully known; it changes every moment; it is the ever-changing "I" of the moment. Shabistarī's metaphysics helps the modern person realize that her self is divine; it teaches her that because the world-including humans, animals, and the environment-is God's manifestation, it deserves care.