Luisa Tuttolomondo | IUAV University Venice (original) (raw)

Uploads

Papers by Luisa Tuttolomondo

Questo articolo ripercorre un\\u2019esperienza di rigenerazione urbana realizzata nel quartiere C... more Questo articolo ripercorre un\\u2019esperienza di rigenerazione urbana realizzata nel quartiere CEP di Palermo nell\\u2019ambito del progetto Riconnessioni, finanziato dal Mibact e svoltasi da ottobre 2019 a luglio 2020, a cavallo dell\\u2019emergenza sanitaria Covid19. L\\u2019obiettivo era di riattivare l\\u2019area su cui si trova un campo da bocce in abbandono attraverso tre workshop artistici che hanno permesso di creare, cos\\uec come auspicato da bando di finanziamento, un vero e proprio \\u201cCreative living lab\\u201d attraverso il quale potere avere accesso alle dinamiche di funzionamento del quartiere, sperimentare soluzioni spaziali e sociali ed ipotizzare traiettorie di cambiamento. Il nostro proposito \\ue8 quello di sottolineare come il contesto di crisi abbia influito sulle dinamiche di progetto e sul suo territorio di riferimento, acuendo le criticit\\ue0 gi\\ue0 emerse nei primi mesi di intervento in termini di governance e di conflittualit\\ue0, e rafforzando la necessit\\ue0...

The crisis of representative democracy and the failures of policies unable to address citizens ne... more The crisis of representative democracy and the failures of policies unable to address citizens needs has led in the last years to rethink the models of governance, in search of more efficient and participative solutions, able to address costant changes in the welfare and market system. Citizen participation begun to be practiced as antidote to the flaws of traditional policy models, so becoming a fundamental element of every recent govern approach: from participative democracy to deliberative democracy, to the recent approach of collaborative governance for commons. This last field is spreading consistently in Italy, so influencing the most recent practices of urban policies according to criteria of citizen involvement. This trend is fostered by the theoretical elaboration of some scholars that propose the collaborative approach as a form of govern able to implement a new way of interaction between institutions and the society and innovative practices of management of commons. Inste...

Questo articolo ripercorre un\\u2019esperienza di rigenerazione urbana realizzata nel quartiere C... more Questo articolo ripercorre un\\u2019esperienza di rigenerazione urbana realizzata nel quartiere CEP di Palermo nell\\u2019ambito del progetto Riconnessioni, finanziato dal Mibact e svoltasi da ottobre 2019 a luglio 2020, a cavallo dell\\u2019emergenza sanitaria Covid19. L\\u2019obiettivo era di riattivare l\\u2019area su cui si trova un campo da bocce in abbandono attraverso tre workshop artistici che hanno permesso di creare, cos\\uec come auspicato da bando di finanziamento, un vero e proprio \\u201cCreative living lab\\u201d attraverso il quale potere avere accesso alle dinamiche di funzionamento del quartiere, sperimentare soluzioni spaziali e sociali ed ipotizzare traiettorie di cambiamento. Il nostro proposito \\ue8 quello di sottolineare come il contesto di crisi abbia influito sulle dinamiche di progetto e sul suo territorio di riferimento, acuendo le criticit\\ue0 gi\\ue0 emerse nei primi mesi di intervento in termini di governance e di conflittualit\\ue0, e rafforzando la necessit\\ue0...

The crisis of representative democracy and the failures of policies unable to address citizens ne... more The crisis of representative democracy and the failures of policies unable to address citizens needs has led in the last years to rethink the models of governance, in search of more efficient and participative solutions, able to address costant changes in the welfare and market system. Citizen participation begun to be practiced as antidote to the flaws of traditional policy models, so becoming a fundamental element of every recent govern approach: from participative democracy to deliberative democracy, to the recent approach of collaborative governance for commons. This last field is spreading consistently in Italy, so influencing the most recent practices of urban policies according to criteria of citizen involvement. This trend is fostered by the theoretical elaboration of some scholars that propose the collaborative approach as a form of govern able to implement a new way of interaction between institutions and the society and innovative practices of management of commons. Inste...

Agency and Participation in Childhood and Youth : International Applications of the Capability Approach in Schools and Beyond

The crisis of representative democracy and the failures of policies unable to address citizens ne... more The crisis of representative democracy and the failures of policies unable to address citizens needs has led in the last years to rethink the models of governance, in search of more efficient and participative solutions, able to address costant changes in the welfare and market system. Citizen participation begun to be practiced as antidote to the flaws of traditional policy models, so becoming a fundamental element of every recent govern approach: from participative democracy to deliberative democracy, to the recent approach of collaborative governance for commons. This last field is spreading consistently in Italy, so influencing the most recent practices of urban policies according to criteria of citizen involvement. This trend is fostered by the theoretical elaboration of some scholars that propose the collaborative approach as a form of govern able to implement a new way of interaction between institutions and the society and innovative practices of management of commons. Inste...

The crisis of representative democracy and the failures of policies unable to address citizens ne... more The crisis of representative democracy and the failures of policies unable to address citizens needs has led in the last years to rethink the models of governance, in search of more efficient and participative solutions, able to address costant changes in the welfare and market system. Citizen participation begun to be practiced as antidote to the flaws of traditional policy models, so becoming a fundamental element of every recent govern approach: from participative democracy to deliberative democracy, to the recent approach of collaborative governance for commons. This last field is spreading consistently in Italy, so influencing the most recent practices of urban policies according to criteria of citizen involvement. This trend is fostered by the theoretical elaboration of some scholars that propose the collaborative approach as a form of govern able to implement a new way of interaction between institutions and the society and innovative practices of management of commons. Instead the traditional approach of " citizen participation " is going to be replaced by a new one focused on the " collaboration between administration and citizens ". It is a theoretical shift supported by the spread of new ways of participation to urban policies, having the common purpose of guaranteeing more efficacy in their results. This change is followed with a wide argumentative repertoire composed by words as " collaboration " , " creativity " , " innovation " able to witness this shift and to propose a different configuration of the relationship between citizens and institutions. This phenomenon proceeds with the development of new professional skills useful in accompanying these processes. As a matter of fact, he spread of practices of collaborative governance seems to be supported by a whole of actors belonging to the third sector and in particular in the field of culture and innovation. These ones are always more committed in sustaining new modes of managing the commons by deploying their competence and expertise reached in the framework of very different kind of experiences ranging from volunteering, consulting, academic research, etc. These group of actors are sometime defined (and define themselves) as " knowledge workers " , so referring to a professional profile characterized by high flexibility and uncertainty, and a blurred separation between time of life and time of work (Busacca 2015). By drawing on the city of Palermo as a field of observation for these dynamics of change the present paper proposes some reflections on this phenomenon. As a matter of fact, Palermo represents a privileged laboratory of observation with regard to these issues both for the proliferation of participative experiences, both for the history of govern of the last thirty years, marked by a constant research of a turn from the past of stagnation. In the last four years, in correspondence of the settlement of the new administration of left-center wing, different participative experiences have taken place that varies a lot for modes and actors involved, as for the different frame of participation that inspire them. An insight on the different forms of participation at work and on the actors driving them allows to observe some general phenomena as the evolving and transformation of the concept of participation, the strengthening of new forms of governance and the establishment of a new class of professionals of the third sector, specialized on issues ranging from participation, to collaborative governance and social and cultural innovation. 1. Introduzione La crisi della democrazia rappresentativa e i fallimenti nell'elaborazione di politiche efficaci nel rispondere i bisogni dei cittadini ha portato nel corso degli ultimi anni a ripensare i modelli di governo adottati, alla ricerca di soluzioni più efficaci e partecipate, capaci di fare fronte ai continui cambiamenti in corso nel sistema di welfare e di mercato. La partecipazione dei cittadini ha cominciato ad essere praticata come antidoto alle principali falle dei modelli di politiche tradizionali, divenendo componente fondamentale di tutti gli approcci di governo più recenti: dalla democrazia partecipativa alla democrazia deliberativa, per arrivare in tempi più recenti alla governance collaborativa dei beni comuni.

L'autrice evidenzia la tensione partecipativa che ha caratterizzato Palermo negli ultimi anni, mo... more L'autrice evidenzia la tensione partecipativa che ha caratterizzato Palermo negli ultimi anni, mostrando le principali caratteristiche, ma anche i limiti, dei percorsi partecipativi analizzati.

The paper proposes a critical review of the experience of “I cantieri che vogliamo”, a citizens m... more The paper proposes a critical review of the experience of “I cantieri che vogliamo”, a citizens movement that rises in Palermo in autumn 2011 when a group of citizens, mainly cultural operators, begins to gather in public assemblies to discuss and denounce the lack of an appropriate cultural policy for the management of the many art and historical places of the city, often left in a state of abandon by the public administration. The actions undertaken by the movement of “I cantieri che vogliamo” focuses on the complex of industrial archaeology of the Cantieri Culturali alla Zisa.. Its goal is to re-open the space of Cantieri alla Zisa to the city and at the same time to work out a model of management alternative to the inefficient end exclusive one promoted by institutions. Then, the reasons fostering the mobilization regards both a political dimension and a practical one. The movement dissolves after a year but its actions have the effect to experiment the “publicity” of a space, meant as a place open to the encounter and sharing of all citizens. Moreover they produce social capital that keeps on fuelling new bottom up initiatives in the following months.

Questo articolo ripercorre un\\u2019esperienza di rigenerazione urbana realizzata nel quartiere C... more Questo articolo ripercorre un\\u2019esperienza di rigenerazione urbana realizzata nel quartiere CEP di Palermo nell\\u2019ambito del progetto Riconnessioni, finanziato dal Mibact e svoltasi da ottobre 2019 a luglio 2020, a cavallo dell\\u2019emergenza sanitaria Covid19. L\\u2019obiettivo era di riattivare l\\u2019area su cui si trova un campo da bocce in abbandono attraverso tre workshop artistici che hanno permesso di creare, cos\\uec come auspicato da bando di finanziamento, un vero e proprio \\u201cCreative living lab\\u201d attraverso il quale potere avere accesso alle dinamiche di funzionamento del quartiere, sperimentare soluzioni spaziali e sociali ed ipotizzare traiettorie di cambiamento. Il nostro proposito \\ue8 quello di sottolineare come il contesto di crisi abbia influito sulle dinamiche di progetto e sul suo territorio di riferimento, acuendo le criticit\\ue0 gi\\ue0 emerse nei primi mesi di intervento in termini di governance e di conflittualit\\ue0, e rafforzando la necessit\\ue0...

The crisis of representative democracy and the failures of policies unable to address citizens ne... more The crisis of representative democracy and the failures of policies unable to address citizens needs has led in the last years to rethink the models of governance, in search of more efficient and participative solutions, able to address costant changes in the welfare and market system. Citizen participation begun to be practiced as antidote to the flaws of traditional policy models, so becoming a fundamental element of every recent govern approach: from participative democracy to deliberative democracy, to the recent approach of collaborative governance for commons. This last field is spreading consistently in Italy, so influencing the most recent practices of urban policies according to criteria of citizen involvement. This trend is fostered by the theoretical elaboration of some scholars that propose the collaborative approach as a form of govern able to implement a new way of interaction between institutions and the society and innovative practices of management of commons. Inste...

Questo articolo ripercorre un\\u2019esperienza di rigenerazione urbana realizzata nel quartiere C... more Questo articolo ripercorre un\\u2019esperienza di rigenerazione urbana realizzata nel quartiere CEP di Palermo nell\\u2019ambito del progetto Riconnessioni, finanziato dal Mibact e svoltasi da ottobre 2019 a luglio 2020, a cavallo dell\\u2019emergenza sanitaria Covid19. L\\u2019obiettivo era di riattivare l\\u2019area su cui si trova un campo da bocce in abbandono attraverso tre workshop artistici che hanno permesso di creare, cos\\uec come auspicato da bando di finanziamento, un vero e proprio \\u201cCreative living lab\\u201d attraverso il quale potere avere accesso alle dinamiche di funzionamento del quartiere, sperimentare soluzioni spaziali e sociali ed ipotizzare traiettorie di cambiamento. Il nostro proposito \\ue8 quello di sottolineare come il contesto di crisi abbia influito sulle dinamiche di progetto e sul suo territorio di riferimento, acuendo le criticit\\ue0 gi\\ue0 emerse nei primi mesi di intervento in termini di governance e di conflittualit\\ue0, e rafforzando la necessit\\ue0...

The crisis of representative democracy and the failures of policies unable to address citizens ne... more The crisis of representative democracy and the failures of policies unable to address citizens needs has led in the last years to rethink the models of governance, in search of more efficient and participative solutions, able to address costant changes in the welfare and market system. Citizen participation begun to be practiced as antidote to the flaws of traditional policy models, so becoming a fundamental element of every recent govern approach: from participative democracy to deliberative democracy, to the recent approach of collaborative governance for commons. This last field is spreading consistently in Italy, so influencing the most recent practices of urban policies according to criteria of citizen involvement. This trend is fostered by the theoretical elaboration of some scholars that propose the collaborative approach as a form of govern able to implement a new way of interaction between institutions and the society and innovative practices of management of commons. Inste...

Agency and Participation in Childhood and Youth : International Applications of the Capability Approach in Schools and Beyond

The crisis of representative democracy and the failures of policies unable to address citizens ne... more The crisis of representative democracy and the failures of policies unable to address citizens needs has led in the last years to rethink the models of governance, in search of more efficient and participative solutions, able to address costant changes in the welfare and market system. Citizen participation begun to be practiced as antidote to the flaws of traditional policy models, so becoming a fundamental element of every recent govern approach: from participative democracy to deliberative democracy, to the recent approach of collaborative governance for commons. This last field is spreading consistently in Italy, so influencing the most recent practices of urban policies according to criteria of citizen involvement. This trend is fostered by the theoretical elaboration of some scholars that propose the collaborative approach as a form of govern able to implement a new way of interaction between institutions and the society and innovative practices of management of commons. Inste...

The crisis of representative democracy and the failures of policies unable to address citizens ne... more The crisis of representative democracy and the failures of policies unable to address citizens needs has led in the last years to rethink the models of governance, in search of more efficient and participative solutions, able to address costant changes in the welfare and market system. Citizen participation begun to be practiced as antidote to the flaws of traditional policy models, so becoming a fundamental element of every recent govern approach: from participative democracy to deliberative democracy, to the recent approach of collaborative governance for commons. This last field is spreading consistently in Italy, so influencing the most recent practices of urban policies according to criteria of citizen involvement. This trend is fostered by the theoretical elaboration of some scholars that propose the collaborative approach as a form of govern able to implement a new way of interaction between institutions and the society and innovative practices of management of commons. Instead the traditional approach of " citizen participation " is going to be replaced by a new one focused on the " collaboration between administration and citizens ". It is a theoretical shift supported by the spread of new ways of participation to urban policies, having the common purpose of guaranteeing more efficacy in their results. This change is followed with a wide argumentative repertoire composed by words as " collaboration " , " creativity " , " innovation " able to witness this shift and to propose a different configuration of the relationship between citizens and institutions. This phenomenon proceeds with the development of new professional skills useful in accompanying these processes. As a matter of fact, he spread of practices of collaborative governance seems to be supported by a whole of actors belonging to the third sector and in particular in the field of culture and innovation. These ones are always more committed in sustaining new modes of managing the commons by deploying their competence and expertise reached in the framework of very different kind of experiences ranging from volunteering, consulting, academic research, etc. These group of actors are sometime defined (and define themselves) as " knowledge workers " , so referring to a professional profile characterized by high flexibility and uncertainty, and a blurred separation between time of life and time of work (Busacca 2015). By drawing on the city of Palermo as a field of observation for these dynamics of change the present paper proposes some reflections on this phenomenon. As a matter of fact, Palermo represents a privileged laboratory of observation with regard to these issues both for the proliferation of participative experiences, both for the history of govern of the last thirty years, marked by a constant research of a turn from the past of stagnation. In the last four years, in correspondence of the settlement of the new administration of left-center wing, different participative experiences have taken place that varies a lot for modes and actors involved, as for the different frame of participation that inspire them. An insight on the different forms of participation at work and on the actors driving them allows to observe some general phenomena as the evolving and transformation of the concept of participation, the strengthening of new forms of governance and the establishment of a new class of professionals of the third sector, specialized on issues ranging from participation, to collaborative governance and social and cultural innovation. 1. Introduzione La crisi della democrazia rappresentativa e i fallimenti nell'elaborazione di politiche efficaci nel rispondere i bisogni dei cittadini ha portato nel corso degli ultimi anni a ripensare i modelli di governo adottati, alla ricerca di soluzioni più efficaci e partecipate, capaci di fare fronte ai continui cambiamenti in corso nel sistema di welfare e di mercato. La partecipazione dei cittadini ha cominciato ad essere praticata come antidoto alle principali falle dei modelli di politiche tradizionali, divenendo componente fondamentale di tutti gli approcci di governo più recenti: dalla democrazia partecipativa alla democrazia deliberativa, per arrivare in tempi più recenti alla governance collaborativa dei beni comuni.

L'autrice evidenzia la tensione partecipativa che ha caratterizzato Palermo negli ultimi anni, mo... more L'autrice evidenzia la tensione partecipativa che ha caratterizzato Palermo negli ultimi anni, mostrando le principali caratteristiche, ma anche i limiti, dei percorsi partecipativi analizzati.

The paper proposes a critical review of the experience of “I cantieri che vogliamo”, a citizens m... more The paper proposes a critical review of the experience of “I cantieri che vogliamo”, a citizens movement that rises in Palermo in autumn 2011 when a group of citizens, mainly cultural operators, begins to gather in public assemblies to discuss and denounce the lack of an appropriate cultural policy for the management of the many art and historical places of the city, often left in a state of abandon by the public administration. The actions undertaken by the movement of “I cantieri che vogliamo” focuses on the complex of industrial archaeology of the Cantieri Culturali alla Zisa.. Its goal is to re-open the space of Cantieri alla Zisa to the city and at the same time to work out a model of management alternative to the inefficient end exclusive one promoted by institutions. Then, the reasons fostering the mobilization regards both a political dimension and a practical one. The movement dissolves after a year but its actions have the effect to experiment the “publicity” of a space, meant as a place open to the encounter and sharing of all citizens. Moreover they produce social capital that keeps on fuelling new bottom up initiatives in the following months.