iy_fic_review - Profile (original) (raw)

Full Name of Group: Inuyasha Fan Fiction Reviews

Purpose: To give honest tactful reviews of Inuyasha fanfiction to assist fans in finding the good fics.

Moderators: del_kaidin and _midoriko_sama_

Affiliated Communities: shard_detector

Member and Non-Member fics may be reviewed without seeking permission of the author.

The Rules!

1. Reviews can be as long as necessary to give a complete view of the story and should be posted using the following format:

STORY TITLE:
AUTHOR:
LINK:

RATING: Shards should be represented by () you can also rate something by half shard or ( Rating is on a scale of 1-5

(LJ cut the review for friends page friendliness)

2. Remember the definition of critique – n. 1: an essay or article that gives a critical evaluation (as of a book or play) [syn: review, critical review, review article] 2: a serious examination and judgment of something

3. No matter how much you dislike a fiction you must include 1 positive thought about it.

4. No matter how much you adore a fiction you must include 1 negative thought about it.

5. While membership is open to all, out of respect for the reviewer and the reviewed all post shall be friend locked.

6. All reviews must be tactful and respectful of the writer. You should be able to defend your viewpoint without becoming overly negative and/or harsh. By the same token you should also be able to express positive qualities of a good fic without it becoming an “OMG this fic so rocks” thing.

7. As all writers can improve all reviews should include at least 1 area for improvement.

8. It is permissible to ask members to review your works, but permission from the author is not needed to review a fic.

9. If you disagree with a review, you may post a rebuttal review in a comment and following the same mature – 1. positive 1 negative and 1 area for improvement format.

10. Flaming another member or a fic or an author is grounds for immediate banning from the community.