Nurlan Muminov | Kazakh national university named after al-Farabi (original) (raw)

Papers by Nurlan Muminov

Research paper thumbnail of Water Security Policy of Kazakhstan

Mirovaâ èkonomika i meždunarodnye otnošeniâ, 2024

L. (2020). Social institution changes and their ecological impacts in Kazakhstan over the past hu... more L. (2020). Social institution changes and their ecological impacts in Kazakhstan over the past hundred years. Environmental Development, 34.

Research paper thumbnail of Characteristics and features of Kazakhstan’s water security policy

Problems and Perspectives in Management, 2024

Amidst the complex geopolitical dynamics of Central Asia, Kazakhstan grapples with urgent water s... more Amidst the complex geopolitical dynamics of Central Asia, Kazakhstan grapples with urgent water security issues exacerbated by climate change, underscoring the critical need to examine this issue within the context of regional security. Therefore, this study seeks to comprehensively analyze Kazakhstan's water security policy, examining its various elements and components at national and regional levels. Using system analysis and statistical techniques, data were collected from an array of sources, including strategies, development plans, statistical reports, analytical articles, methodological guidelines, and official government and international organization websites. The analysis revealed key challenges in Kazakhstan's water security, including deteriorating infrastructure, outdated management practices, vulnerability to floods and low water levels, inadequate training, and regulatory deficiencies. A novel approach is offered by examining current trends in Kazakhstan's water security domain, which involves scrutinizing the activities of relevant state bodies and analyzing regulatory frameworks amid rapid climate shifts. Additionally, the heightened potential for conflict across the continent was recognized. Despite earnest attempts to mitigate these challenges, the country confronts imminent water shortages exacerbated by heightened consumption and dwindling runoff from neighboring states. In light of these findings, policymakers and stakeholders are urged to devise robust policies and management strategies aimed at fortifying water security and addressing the underlying vulnerabilities in this critical domain.

Research paper thumbnail of Cooperation and conflict in Turkish-Israeli relations since the 1990s

Israel Affairs, 2023

Turkish-Israeli relations, which achieved the level of strategic cooperation in the late 1990s, b... more Turkish-Israeli relations, which achieved the level of strategic cooperation in the late 1990s, began to decline in the late 2000s, especially after Israel’s 2008–9 Operation Cast Lead in Gaza. The existing literature enumerates several factors underlying the bilateral relationship but tends to overlook both states’ per-ceived identities and self-images. Focusing on the identity factor, this article ascribes the deterioration of Turkish-Israeli relations to the major changes in Turkey’s state identity during the years of AKP rule. By way of substantiating this argument, the article provides a brief overview of the literature on the role of state identity in international relations before exploring four case studies that exemplify the influence of state identity on Turkish-Israeli relations: the bilateral military cooperation agreement (1996); Operation Cast Lead and the attendant ‘Davos incident’ (2008–9); the Mavi Marmara crisis (2010); and the ‘Arab Spring’ of the early 2010s.

Research paper thumbnail of Analysing the Role of Turkey in Israel’s Post-2011 Regional Vision through the Lens of Identity-Security: Challenger or Bystander?

Anadolu Üniversitesi Sosyal Bilimler Dergisi, 2023

Turkey’s engagement in Middle Eastern politics, significantly since the Arab Uprising, has contin... more Turkey’s engagement in Middle Eastern politics, significantly since the Arab Uprising, has continuously changed the direction of decades-old Turkey–Israel relations. The existing literature elaborates on several aspects of destabilising or normalizing relations between these two countries, but the dimension of Israel’s identity-based threat perception is yet to be revealed, despite Israel having long tried to balance identities in the region. By asking whether Turkey challenges Israel’s identity-based regional vision or plays a bystander role, this study presents a two-layered analysis of Israel–Turkey relations. While discussing the cognitive essence of Israel’s post-2011 regional perspective that transformed the ‘identity-based threat’ perceptions in an uncertain environment, it locates Turkey’s engagement in the region into Israel's regional understanding. Within this aim, the paper is organized as follows. First, the current literature on Israel–Turkey relations is summarize...

Research paper thumbnail of Comparative Analysis of Russian, Turkish and Kazakh Eurasianism

Eurasian research journal, Jun 29, 2023

This paper aims to provide a comprehensive comparative analysis of Eurasianism in Russia, Türkiye... more This paper aims to provide a comprehensive comparative analysis of Eurasianism in Russia, Türkiye, and Kazakhstan. It delves into the historical, political, and economic aspects of each country's Eurasianist ideology, examining similarities and differences between them. Through this analysis, the paper seeks to gain a better understanding of the role that Eurasianism plays in each country's foreign policy and regional strategies. The paper also explores the impact of Eurasianism on the relationships between Russia, Türkiye, and Kazakhstan, as well as its implications for regional security and cooperation. The main argument of this paper is that while Russian, Turkish, and Kazakh Eurasianism share some commonalities in their emphasis on the importance of the Eurasian region and its unique cultural and historical identity, there are notable differences in the way that this identity is understood and articulated, as well as differences in geopolitical priorities and approaches to democracy and authoritarianism. It provides a valuable contribution to the scholarly debate on Eurasianism and serves as a useful resource for policymakers and analysts seeking to better understand the geopolitical landscape of the Eurasian region.

Research paper thumbnail of Impact of the COVID-19 Pandemic on the Mobilities of Central Asian Migrants

Impact of the COVID-19 Pandemic on the Mobilities of Central Asian Migrants

Central Asia's affairs, Sep 15, 2022

Research paper thumbnail of Camps on the border: Central Asian migrant workers at the Russian-Kazakh border during the COVID-19 pandemic

Camps on the border: Central Asian migrant workers at the Russian-Kazakh border during the COVID-19 pandemic

Research paper thumbnail of Democracy and Identity Crisis in Israel

Öz srail, göçmen Yahudilerin devletidir. Yahudilerin hemen hemen hepsi göçmen ve farklı kültürler... more Öz srail, göçmen Yahudilerin devletidir. Yahudilerin hemen hemen hepsi göçmen ve farklı kültürlerden gelmektedirler. Bu kültürel farklılık srail'de homojen Yahudi kimli ini olu turma sürecinin kar ısında bir sorun kayna ını olu turmu tur. srail'in hem Yahudili e hem de demokrasiye olan çifte ba lılı ı, bu ikisinin arasındaki dengeye meydan okumu tur. Bütün dünyadaki Yahudiler için ev sahipli i (host) yapan srail, farklı kültürlerden gelen Yahudi topluluklarını homojen Yahudi ulusal kimli ine entegre etmeye çalı ırken kimlik ve demokrasi konusunda ciddi sorunlar ile kar ı kar ıya kalmaktadır. Bu makale srail misafirperverli inin do ası, politikası ve ahlaki üzerine odaklanarak bu olayları ele almaktadır.

Research paper thumbnail of Water Security Policy of Kazakhstan

Mirovaâ èkonomika i meždunarodnye otnošeniâ, 2024

L. (2020). Social institution changes and their ecological impacts in Kazakhstan over the past hu... more L. (2020). Social institution changes and their ecological impacts in Kazakhstan over the past hundred years. Environmental Development, 34.

Research paper thumbnail of Characteristics and features of Kazakhstan’s water security policy

Problems and Perspectives in Management, 2024

Amidst the complex geopolitical dynamics of Central Asia, Kazakhstan grapples with urgent water s... more Amidst the complex geopolitical dynamics of Central Asia, Kazakhstan grapples with urgent water security issues exacerbated by climate change, underscoring the critical need to examine this issue within the context of regional security. Therefore, this study seeks to comprehensively analyze Kazakhstan's water security policy, examining its various elements and components at national and regional levels. Using system analysis and statistical techniques, data were collected from an array of sources, including strategies, development plans, statistical reports, analytical articles, methodological guidelines, and official government and international organization websites. The analysis revealed key challenges in Kazakhstan's water security, including deteriorating infrastructure, outdated management practices, vulnerability to floods and low water levels, inadequate training, and regulatory deficiencies. A novel approach is offered by examining current trends in Kazakhstan's water security domain, which involves scrutinizing the activities of relevant state bodies and analyzing regulatory frameworks amid rapid climate shifts. Additionally, the heightened potential for conflict across the continent was recognized. Despite earnest attempts to mitigate these challenges, the country confronts imminent water shortages exacerbated by heightened consumption and dwindling runoff from neighboring states. In light of these findings, policymakers and stakeholders are urged to devise robust policies and management strategies aimed at fortifying water security and addressing the underlying vulnerabilities in this critical domain.

Research paper thumbnail of Cooperation and conflict in Turkish-Israeli relations since the 1990s

Israel Affairs, 2023

Turkish-Israeli relations, which achieved the level of strategic cooperation in the late 1990s, b... more Turkish-Israeli relations, which achieved the level of strategic cooperation in the late 1990s, began to decline in the late 2000s, especially after Israel’s 2008–9 Operation Cast Lead in Gaza. The existing literature enumerates several factors underlying the bilateral relationship but tends to overlook both states’ per-ceived identities and self-images. Focusing on the identity factor, this article ascribes the deterioration of Turkish-Israeli relations to the major changes in Turkey’s state identity during the years of AKP rule. By way of substantiating this argument, the article provides a brief overview of the literature on the role of state identity in international relations before exploring four case studies that exemplify the influence of state identity on Turkish-Israeli relations: the bilateral military cooperation agreement (1996); Operation Cast Lead and the attendant ‘Davos incident’ (2008–9); the Mavi Marmara crisis (2010); and the ‘Arab Spring’ of the early 2010s.

Research paper thumbnail of Analysing the Role of Turkey in Israel’s Post-2011 Regional Vision through the Lens of Identity-Security: Challenger or Bystander?

Anadolu Üniversitesi Sosyal Bilimler Dergisi, 2023

Turkey’s engagement in Middle Eastern politics, significantly since the Arab Uprising, has contin... more Turkey’s engagement in Middle Eastern politics, significantly since the Arab Uprising, has continuously changed the direction of decades-old Turkey–Israel relations. The existing literature elaborates on several aspects of destabilising or normalizing relations between these two countries, but the dimension of Israel’s identity-based threat perception is yet to be revealed, despite Israel having long tried to balance identities in the region. By asking whether Turkey challenges Israel’s identity-based regional vision or plays a bystander role, this study presents a two-layered analysis of Israel–Turkey relations. While discussing the cognitive essence of Israel’s post-2011 regional perspective that transformed the ‘identity-based threat’ perceptions in an uncertain environment, it locates Turkey’s engagement in the region into Israel's regional understanding. Within this aim, the paper is organized as follows. First, the current literature on Israel–Turkey relations is summarize...

Research paper thumbnail of Comparative Analysis of Russian, Turkish and Kazakh Eurasianism

Eurasian research journal, Jun 29, 2023

This paper aims to provide a comprehensive comparative analysis of Eurasianism in Russia, Türkiye... more This paper aims to provide a comprehensive comparative analysis of Eurasianism in Russia, Türkiye, and Kazakhstan. It delves into the historical, political, and economic aspects of each country's Eurasianist ideology, examining similarities and differences between them. Through this analysis, the paper seeks to gain a better understanding of the role that Eurasianism plays in each country's foreign policy and regional strategies. The paper also explores the impact of Eurasianism on the relationships between Russia, Türkiye, and Kazakhstan, as well as its implications for regional security and cooperation. The main argument of this paper is that while Russian, Turkish, and Kazakh Eurasianism share some commonalities in their emphasis on the importance of the Eurasian region and its unique cultural and historical identity, there are notable differences in the way that this identity is understood and articulated, as well as differences in geopolitical priorities and approaches to democracy and authoritarianism. It provides a valuable contribution to the scholarly debate on Eurasianism and serves as a useful resource for policymakers and analysts seeking to better understand the geopolitical landscape of the Eurasian region.

Research paper thumbnail of Impact of the COVID-19 Pandemic on the Mobilities of Central Asian Migrants

Impact of the COVID-19 Pandemic on the Mobilities of Central Asian Migrants

Central Asia's affairs, Sep 15, 2022

Research paper thumbnail of Camps on the border: Central Asian migrant workers at the Russian-Kazakh border during the COVID-19 pandemic

Camps on the border: Central Asian migrant workers at the Russian-Kazakh border during the COVID-19 pandemic

Research paper thumbnail of Democracy and Identity Crisis in Israel

Öz srail, göçmen Yahudilerin devletidir. Yahudilerin hemen hemen hepsi göçmen ve farklı kültürler... more Öz srail, göçmen Yahudilerin devletidir. Yahudilerin hemen hemen hepsi göçmen ve farklı kültürlerden gelmektedirler. Bu kültürel farklılık srail'de homojen Yahudi kimli ini olu turma sürecinin kar ısında bir sorun kayna ını olu turmu tur. srail'in hem Yahudili e hem de demokrasiye olan çifte ba lılı ı, bu ikisinin arasındaki dengeye meydan okumu tur. Bütün dünyadaki Yahudiler için ev sahipli i (host) yapan srail, farklı kültürlerden gelen Yahudi topluluklarını homojen Yahudi ulusal kimli ine entegre etmeye çalı ırken kimlik ve demokrasi konusunda ciddi sorunlar ile kar ı kar ıya kalmaktadır. Bu makale srail misafirperverli inin do ası, politikası ve ahlaki üzerine odaklanarak bu olayları ele almaktadır.