Constructivism - LEAN LOGIC (original) (raw)

The idea that enlightened leaders can steer a society in desirable directions. As attempted, for instance, by Vladimir Lenin and by many autocratic leaders and democratic reformers before and since. This is not in all cases a fallacy: leadership and foresight can in principle do some good.

The point made by critics such as Friedrich Hayek is that culture and civilisation are not, in fact, consequences of deliberate human design, but the products of society’s gradually evolving institutions; civilisation depends on behaviour, not on goals. Hayek saw Keynesian economics as a form of constructivism, because it appears to establish governments in effective control of the economy.

Constructivism teaches “-isms” (see “The Sea Cucumber” below)—supplying answers, rather than the grammar which enables a person to think things through and work out her own answers. You are told the destination, but not given the map. And the rightness of that destination is likely to be defended strongly, because no one knows how to navigate to another one.C253

THE SEA CUCUMBER

The sea-cucumber is a sluggish beast,
Lumpy, contemplative, and very slow.
So stiff and dull is he, that one deceas’d
Is so like one alive, you’d never know.

Yet, with full complement of harps and choirs
A cloud is ready for his final phase.
With airs to while away the tranquil hours,
And sunny slopes to feed his languid gaze.

The reason is, he has not specialised
In ’ologies, and ’ists, and ’isms vast.
With good and bad and sloth precisely poised,
To God of good and bad he’ll come at last.

DAVID FLEMING