Matthias Barth | Leuphana University (original) (raw)
Papers by Matthias Barth
ABSTRACT Die Nachhaltigkeitswissenschaften stellen ein wachsendes Feld wissenschaftlicher Tätigke... more ABSTRACT Die Nachhaltigkeitswissenschaften stellen ein wachsendes Feld wissenschaftlicher Tätigkeit dar, in dem erste Systematisierungen sowie Theoriebildung und Methodenentwicklung vonstattengehen, auch wenn eine weitergehende Erarbeitung der spezifischen epistemologischen Grundlegung und methodologischen Anforderungen noch aussteht. Mit der Frage nach dem Zusammenspiel von Mensch und Umwelt lassen sich Schlüsselfragen der Nachhaltigkeitswissenschaften ausdifferenzieren und Charakteristika einer derartigen wissenschaftlichen Analyse beschreiben: Problemorientierung, Transdisziplinarität und der Umgang mit Komplexität stehen hier im Mittelpunkt. Zugleich kristallisieren sich Kernthemen und Leitdisziplinen heraus, die den Diskurs in den Nachhaltigkeitswissenschaften prägen. Die disziplinär orientierte Beschäftigung mit Nachhaltigkeitsaspekten entfaltet dabei eine in zweierlei Hinsicht Wirkung: als Beitrag zum transdisziplinären Diskurs der Nachhaltigkeitswissenschaften bringt sie spezifische Fragestellungen und Methoden in die interdisziplinäre Analyse mit ein, als Beschäftigung einer Disziplin mit den Herausforderungen der Nachhaltigkeit beeinflusst sie zugleich die disziplinäre Entwicklung. Mit Blick auf die Unbestimmtheit dessen, was das Wesen des ‘moving targets sustainability’ (Hjorth & Bagheri 2006) tatsächlich ausmacht wird die Notwendigkeit von gesamtgesellschaftlichen Such- und Verständigungsprozessen deutlich, in deren Zentrum die Frage steht, welche Normen, Werte und Regeln und ebenso welche Arten von Wissen notwendig sind, um eine Entwicklung hin zu einer nachhaltigeren zukunftsfähigeren Gesellschaft aktiv mitgestalten zu können. Damit rücken Aspekte der Entscheidungsfindung, des Umgangs mit Unsicherheiten und der gesellschaftlichen Aushandlung verstärkt in den Fokus. Zudem verschiebt sich die Aufmerksamkeit von einer Produkt- hin zu einer Prozessorientierung. Hiermit direkt verbunden sind Fragen des individuellen ebenso wie des organisationalen und gesellschaftlichen Lernens; Fragen die den Kern der wissenschaftlichen Beschäftigung in den Erziehungswissenschaften betreffen, die hier einen wichtigen Beitrag leisten können. Betrachtet man das Verhältnis von Erziehungswissenschaften und Nachhaltigkeitswissenschaften, so lassen sich prinzipiell zwei Arten von Einflüssen unterscheiden: Im Sinne eines ‘Outside-In-Approaches’ lässt sich nachvollziehen, wie die Idee der Nachhaltigkeit Eingang in die pädagogische Praxis und erziehungswissenschaftliche Reflexion gefunden hat. Dieser Einfluss lässt sich anhand der Entstehung von Bildung für nachhaltige Entwicklung rekonstruieren und manifestiert sich in der Ausbildung einer spezifischen Pädagogik mit eigener Zielsetzung, spezifischen Inhalten und Methoden sowie in einer wachsenden Forschungslandschaft mit Schwerpunktsetzungen und eigenen Publikations- und Kommunikationsorganen. Der umgekehrte Einfluss zeigt sich bei der Betrachtung eines ‘Inside-Out-Approaches’. Hier wird nach den Beiträgen der Erziehungswissenschaften zur Forschung in den Nachhaltigkeitswissenschaften gefragt. Mit einem spezifischen Set von Theorien, Methoden und Herangehensweisen, in denen sich die Erziehungswissenschaften manifestieren und die neben Berührungspunkten zur Soziologie und zur Psychologie einen spezifischen Eigenwert konstituieren, bietet sich – so soll gezeigt werden - hier ein Alleinstellungsmerkmal, das es für die Nachhaltigkeitswissenschaften noch stärker zu erschließen gilt. Das Verhältnis von Erziehungswissenschaften und Nachhaltigkeitswissenschaften ist der Gegenstand dieses Beitrags. Ausgehend von einem Überblick über aktuelle Ansätze in der Forschung zur Bildung für nachhaltige Entwicklung soll zunächst der Einfluss der Idee der Nachhaltigkeit auf die erziehungswissenschaftliche Forschung nachvollzogen werden. Anhand von drei konkreten Themenkomplexen werden zudem potentielle Beiträge der Erziehungswissenschaften für den Diskurs in den Nachhaltigkeitswissenschaften aufgezeigt.
Societies all over the world are facing rapid social and technological changes. These phenomena n... more Societies all over the world are facing rapid social and technological changes. These phenomena not only alter the nature of work and social life but also the requirements for students’ com-petencies, resulting in new challenges for Higher Education. A core societal function of academia is to impart relevant competencies: especially in Higher Education for Sustainable Development (HESD) students have to be familiarised with key prop-erties of complex systems, such as uncertainty and continuous change, to gain the capability to adequately perceive, understand and cope with fundamental societal problems. Specialised expert knowledge needs to be included in problem-oriented, systematic and integrated pro-cesses and approaches, not only in research but also in teaching. For this purpose, academia needs to create the necessary interdisciplinary as well as transdisciplinary research and teaching structures. While it is broadly agreed that HESD should comprise specific didactical key eleme...
Abstract It can be considered a duty of all educational institutions from preschool to higher edu... more Abstract It can be considered a duty of all educational institutions from preschool to higher education to deal intensively with matters of sustainable development. Education for Sustainable Development (ESD) aims at developing key competencies that enable ...
Proceedings of Spie the International Society For Optical Engineering, Mar 27, 2008
The paper presents guided elastic waves and their identification and damage interaction in a CFRP... more The paper presents guided elastic waves and their identification and damage interaction in a CFRP plate. After the excitation of a fiber transducer, different elastic waves emerge in a plate. By using specially developed 3D laser scanning software it was possible to specify the different wave modes. These wave modes have been described concerning their propagating velocities and different motion components. The interaction of different wave modes with introduced impact damage (7J) is shown. In some experiments, it was proven that impact locations can be derived from the detected Lamb waves. This work is continued to develop structural health monitoring systems (SHM) for selected aircraft components (e. g. stringer elements, panels).
The interdisciplinary project "Climate Change and Sustainable Development of Tourism in Coastal Z... more The interdisciplinary project "Climate Change and Sustainable Development of Tourism in Coastal Zones and Mountain Regions" (CAST) combines natural and social sciences (in the fields of cooperation processes, tourism analysis and strategy, weather and climate change analysis, information and communication and knowledge transfer) in a transdisciplinary approach that includes players from tourism policy and business and which focuses on the North Sea Coast and the Black Forest. The project is divided into four phasesdiagnosis, assessment, strategy/design of solutions, and evaluation -where scientific subprojects and practical partners meet regularly to discuss the research activities, identify the needs of the actors and to jointly develop adaptation strategies like installing weatherindependent alternative products and infrastructure, implementing technical improvements or offering activities for tourism all year round. These instruments should be implemented, including mitigation strategies to stabilize the anthropological greenhouse effect. The anticipatory adaptation requires communication activities on the level of the individual tourism actors among themselves and with visitors as well as processes of cooperative learning and joint decision-making in tourism regions.
The interdisciplinary project "Climate Change and Sustainable Development of Tourism in Coastal Z... more The interdisciplinary project "Climate Change and Sustainable Development of Tourism in Coastal Zones and Mountain Regions" (CAST) combines natural and social sciences (in the fields of cooperation processes, tourism analysis and strategy, weather and climate change analysis, information and communication and knowledge transfer) in a transdisciplinary approach that includes players from tourism policy and business and which focuses on the North Sea Coast and the Black Forest. The project is divided into four phasesdiagnosis, assessment, strategy/design of solutions, and evaluation -where scientific subprojects and practical partners meet regularly to discuss the research activities, identify the needs of the actors and to jointly develop adaptation strategies like installing weatherindependent alternative products and infrastructure, implementing technical improvements or offering activities for tourism all year round. These instruments should be implemented, including mitigation strategies to stabilize the anthropological greenhouse effect. The anticipatory adaptation requires communication activities on the level of the individual tourism actors among themselves and with visitors as well as processes of cooperative learning and joint decision-making in tourism regions.
Universities today have the responsibility to help create a knowledge base which can be used to s... more Universities today have the responsibility to help create a knowledge base which can be used to solve economic, social and ecological challenges. Toward this end, sustainability is an option to re-think education and research as well as institutional structures. For the Sustainable University team the question emerged how sustainable university tasks can be met in different realms and levels of the university. The first step towards change is the observation of the status quo. In 2005, a comprehensive survey of all campus community members’ attitudes and opinions regarding sustainability was conducted on the campus of the University of Lüneburg. Findings indicate that cam pus community members are highly receptive to the notion of sustainable development; this suggests that there is high potential on campus to develop sustainability as a guiding principle for the university. These results are a fertile ground to expand sustainability initiatives in the way to a sustainable organisat...
Chemical Geology, 2013
An extensive data set on the compositional variation of tourmaline from granitic pegmatites, from... more An extensive data set on the compositional variation of tourmaline from granitic pegmatites, from migmatitic gneisses and from various types of hydrothermal veins from the Schwarzwald, Germany, is provided. The investigated tourmalines are members of the alkali and X-vacant groups representing mostly draviteschorl solid solutions with some analyses belonging to the foitite-Mg-foitite series. Oxygen isotope data on quartz-tourmaline pairs indicate formation temperatures between 550 and 350°C for most of the quartz-tourmaline veins. Most of the tourmalines show strong sector zonation, fractionating certain major (e.g., Na, Mg), minor (e.g., Ti, Ca) and trace elements (e.g., Sr, Pb, REE) among the different crystallographic sectors of the crystals. We conclude that comparison of tourmaline compositions for petrogenetic interpretations must be based on the concentrations in the neutral a sector in order to eliminate the effects of intra-crystalline fractionation. Most trace element contents vary over several orders of magnitude with median concentrations generally between 0.1 and 10 μg/g. The highest concentrations are found for Zn, V, Sr, Sc, Sn and Li (median concentrations of several tens to hundreds of μg/g) whereas very low median concentrations (b 0.1 μg/g) were found for U, Th, Bi, Tl and Cs. The concentration of several trace elements (e.g., Sr, REE, Co) correlates with the major element composition of the tourmaline, which implies potential crystal chemical effects on their incorporation. Consequently, the general assumption that tourmaline is a passive monitor for the chemical compositions of the melts or fluids from which it crystallizes has to be questioned. Nevertheless, our study demonstrates that the trace element composition of tourmaline allows to distinguish between geochemically distinct fluid sources, and the trace element composition of tourmaline may therefore be used to unravel the chemical complexity of granite-related hydrothermal systems.
Academic education is to be understood as the mirror image of societal and historic processes, wh... more Academic education is to be understood as the mirror image of societal and historic processes, which are the basis for analysing and enhancing the development and shaping of society (Fischer/ Michelsen 2000: 168). Due to the inescapable questions of globalism and sustainability, academic institutions are facing the difficult challenge of re-adjusting their targets and objectives. Academia needs to include specialised expert knowledge in problem-oriented, systemic and integrated processes and approaches, not only in research but also in teaching. For this purpose, academia first needs to create the necessary interdisciplinary research and teaching structures. Students need to be familiarised with the changeability of complex systems in order to be able to adequately perceive and understand society and its developments.
ABSTRACT Die Nachhaltigkeitswissenschaften stellen ein wachsendes Feld wissenschaftlicher Tätigke... more ABSTRACT Die Nachhaltigkeitswissenschaften stellen ein wachsendes Feld wissenschaftlicher Tätigkeit dar, in dem erste Systematisierungen sowie Theoriebildung und Methodenentwicklung vonstattengehen, auch wenn eine weitergehende Erarbeitung der spezifischen epistemologischen Grundlegung und methodologischen Anforderungen noch aussteht. Mit der Frage nach dem Zusammenspiel von Mensch und Umwelt lassen sich Schlüsselfragen der Nachhaltigkeitswissenschaften ausdifferenzieren und Charakteristika einer derartigen wissenschaftlichen Analyse beschreiben: Problemorientierung, Transdisziplinarität und der Umgang mit Komplexität stehen hier im Mittelpunkt. Zugleich kristallisieren sich Kernthemen und Leitdisziplinen heraus, die den Diskurs in den Nachhaltigkeitswissenschaften prägen. Die disziplinär orientierte Beschäftigung mit Nachhaltigkeitsaspekten entfaltet dabei eine in zweierlei Hinsicht Wirkung: als Beitrag zum transdisziplinären Diskurs der Nachhaltigkeitswissenschaften bringt sie spezifische Fragestellungen und Methoden in die interdisziplinäre Analyse mit ein, als Beschäftigung einer Disziplin mit den Herausforderungen der Nachhaltigkeit beeinflusst sie zugleich die disziplinäre Entwicklung. Mit Blick auf die Unbestimmtheit dessen, was das Wesen des ‘moving targets sustainability’ (Hjorth & Bagheri 2006) tatsächlich ausmacht wird die Notwendigkeit von gesamtgesellschaftlichen Such- und Verständigungsprozessen deutlich, in deren Zentrum die Frage steht, welche Normen, Werte und Regeln und ebenso welche Arten von Wissen notwendig sind, um eine Entwicklung hin zu einer nachhaltigeren zukunftsfähigeren Gesellschaft aktiv mitgestalten zu können. Damit rücken Aspekte der Entscheidungsfindung, des Umgangs mit Unsicherheiten und der gesellschaftlichen Aushandlung verstärkt in den Fokus. Zudem verschiebt sich die Aufmerksamkeit von einer Produkt- hin zu einer Prozessorientierung. Hiermit direkt verbunden sind Fragen des individuellen ebenso wie des organisationalen und gesellschaftlichen Lernens; Fragen die den Kern der wissenschaftlichen Beschäftigung in den Erziehungswissenschaften betreffen, die hier einen wichtigen Beitrag leisten können. Betrachtet man das Verhältnis von Erziehungswissenschaften und Nachhaltigkeitswissenschaften, so lassen sich prinzipiell zwei Arten von Einflüssen unterscheiden: Im Sinne eines ‘Outside-In-Approaches’ lässt sich nachvollziehen, wie die Idee der Nachhaltigkeit Eingang in die pädagogische Praxis und erziehungswissenschaftliche Reflexion gefunden hat. Dieser Einfluss lässt sich anhand der Entstehung von Bildung für nachhaltige Entwicklung rekonstruieren und manifestiert sich in der Ausbildung einer spezifischen Pädagogik mit eigener Zielsetzung, spezifischen Inhalten und Methoden sowie in einer wachsenden Forschungslandschaft mit Schwerpunktsetzungen und eigenen Publikations- und Kommunikationsorganen. Der umgekehrte Einfluss zeigt sich bei der Betrachtung eines ‘Inside-Out-Approaches’. Hier wird nach den Beiträgen der Erziehungswissenschaften zur Forschung in den Nachhaltigkeitswissenschaften gefragt. Mit einem spezifischen Set von Theorien, Methoden und Herangehensweisen, in denen sich die Erziehungswissenschaften manifestieren und die neben Berührungspunkten zur Soziologie und zur Psychologie einen spezifischen Eigenwert konstituieren, bietet sich – so soll gezeigt werden - hier ein Alleinstellungsmerkmal, das es für die Nachhaltigkeitswissenschaften noch stärker zu erschließen gilt. Das Verhältnis von Erziehungswissenschaften und Nachhaltigkeitswissenschaften ist der Gegenstand dieses Beitrags. Ausgehend von einem Überblick über aktuelle Ansätze in der Forschung zur Bildung für nachhaltige Entwicklung soll zunächst der Einfluss der Idee der Nachhaltigkeit auf die erziehungswissenschaftliche Forschung nachvollzogen werden. Anhand von drei konkreten Themenkomplexen werden zudem potentielle Beiträge der Erziehungswissenschaften für den Diskurs in den Nachhaltigkeitswissenschaften aufgezeigt.
Societies all over the world are facing rapid social and technological changes. These phenomena n... more Societies all over the world are facing rapid social and technological changes. These phenomena not only alter the nature of work and social life but also the requirements for students’ com-petencies, resulting in new challenges for Higher Education. A core societal function of academia is to impart relevant competencies: especially in Higher Education for Sustainable Development (HESD) students have to be familiarised with key prop-erties of complex systems, such as uncertainty and continuous change, to gain the capability to adequately perceive, understand and cope with fundamental societal problems. Specialised expert knowledge needs to be included in problem-oriented, systematic and integrated pro-cesses and approaches, not only in research but also in teaching. For this purpose, academia needs to create the necessary interdisciplinary as well as transdisciplinary research and teaching structures. While it is broadly agreed that HESD should comprise specific didactical key eleme...
Abstract It can be considered a duty of all educational institutions from preschool to higher edu... more Abstract It can be considered a duty of all educational institutions from preschool to higher education to deal intensively with matters of sustainable development. Education for Sustainable Development (ESD) aims at developing key competencies that enable ...
Proceedings of Spie the International Society For Optical Engineering, Mar 27, 2008
The paper presents guided elastic waves and their identification and damage interaction in a CFRP... more The paper presents guided elastic waves and their identification and damage interaction in a CFRP plate. After the excitation of a fiber transducer, different elastic waves emerge in a plate. By using specially developed 3D laser scanning software it was possible to specify the different wave modes. These wave modes have been described concerning their propagating velocities and different motion components. The interaction of different wave modes with introduced impact damage (7J) is shown. In some experiments, it was proven that impact locations can be derived from the detected Lamb waves. This work is continued to develop structural health monitoring systems (SHM) for selected aircraft components (e. g. stringer elements, panels).
The interdisciplinary project "Climate Change and Sustainable Development of Tourism in Coastal Z... more The interdisciplinary project "Climate Change and Sustainable Development of Tourism in Coastal Zones and Mountain Regions" (CAST) combines natural and social sciences (in the fields of cooperation processes, tourism analysis and strategy, weather and climate change analysis, information and communication and knowledge transfer) in a transdisciplinary approach that includes players from tourism policy and business and which focuses on the North Sea Coast and the Black Forest. The project is divided into four phasesdiagnosis, assessment, strategy/design of solutions, and evaluation -where scientific subprojects and practical partners meet regularly to discuss the research activities, identify the needs of the actors and to jointly develop adaptation strategies like installing weatherindependent alternative products and infrastructure, implementing technical improvements or offering activities for tourism all year round. These instruments should be implemented, including mitigation strategies to stabilize the anthropological greenhouse effect. The anticipatory adaptation requires communication activities on the level of the individual tourism actors among themselves and with visitors as well as processes of cooperative learning and joint decision-making in tourism regions.
The interdisciplinary project "Climate Change and Sustainable Development of Tourism in Coastal Z... more The interdisciplinary project "Climate Change and Sustainable Development of Tourism in Coastal Zones and Mountain Regions" (CAST) combines natural and social sciences (in the fields of cooperation processes, tourism analysis and strategy, weather and climate change analysis, information and communication and knowledge transfer) in a transdisciplinary approach that includes players from tourism policy and business and which focuses on the North Sea Coast and the Black Forest. The project is divided into four phasesdiagnosis, assessment, strategy/design of solutions, and evaluation -where scientific subprojects and practical partners meet regularly to discuss the research activities, identify the needs of the actors and to jointly develop adaptation strategies like installing weatherindependent alternative products and infrastructure, implementing technical improvements or offering activities for tourism all year round. These instruments should be implemented, including mitigation strategies to stabilize the anthropological greenhouse effect. The anticipatory adaptation requires communication activities on the level of the individual tourism actors among themselves and with visitors as well as processes of cooperative learning and joint decision-making in tourism regions.
Universities today have the responsibility to help create a knowledge base which can be used to s... more Universities today have the responsibility to help create a knowledge base which can be used to solve economic, social and ecological challenges. Toward this end, sustainability is an option to re-think education and research as well as institutional structures. For the Sustainable University team the question emerged how sustainable university tasks can be met in different realms and levels of the university. The first step towards change is the observation of the status quo. In 2005, a comprehensive survey of all campus community members’ attitudes and opinions regarding sustainability was conducted on the campus of the University of Lüneburg. Findings indicate that cam pus community members are highly receptive to the notion of sustainable development; this suggests that there is high potential on campus to develop sustainability as a guiding principle for the university. These results are a fertile ground to expand sustainability initiatives in the way to a sustainable organisat...
Chemical Geology, 2013
An extensive data set on the compositional variation of tourmaline from granitic pegmatites, from... more An extensive data set on the compositional variation of tourmaline from granitic pegmatites, from migmatitic gneisses and from various types of hydrothermal veins from the Schwarzwald, Germany, is provided. The investigated tourmalines are members of the alkali and X-vacant groups representing mostly draviteschorl solid solutions with some analyses belonging to the foitite-Mg-foitite series. Oxygen isotope data on quartz-tourmaline pairs indicate formation temperatures between 550 and 350°C for most of the quartz-tourmaline veins. Most of the tourmalines show strong sector zonation, fractionating certain major (e.g., Na, Mg), minor (e.g., Ti, Ca) and trace elements (e.g., Sr, Pb, REE) among the different crystallographic sectors of the crystals. We conclude that comparison of tourmaline compositions for petrogenetic interpretations must be based on the concentrations in the neutral a sector in order to eliminate the effects of intra-crystalline fractionation. Most trace element contents vary over several orders of magnitude with median concentrations generally between 0.1 and 10 μg/g. The highest concentrations are found for Zn, V, Sr, Sc, Sn and Li (median concentrations of several tens to hundreds of μg/g) whereas very low median concentrations (b 0.1 μg/g) were found for U, Th, Bi, Tl and Cs. The concentration of several trace elements (e.g., Sr, REE, Co) correlates with the major element composition of the tourmaline, which implies potential crystal chemical effects on their incorporation. Consequently, the general assumption that tourmaline is a passive monitor for the chemical compositions of the melts or fluids from which it crystallizes has to be questioned. Nevertheless, our study demonstrates that the trace element composition of tourmaline allows to distinguish between geochemically distinct fluid sources, and the trace element composition of tourmaline may therefore be used to unravel the chemical complexity of granite-related hydrothermal systems.
Academic education is to be understood as the mirror image of societal and historic processes, wh... more Academic education is to be understood as the mirror image of societal and historic processes, which are the basis for analysing and enhancing the development and shaping of society (Fischer/ Michelsen 2000: 168). Due to the inescapable questions of globalism and sustainability, academic institutions are facing the difficult challenge of re-adjusting their targets and objectives. Academia needs to include specialised expert knowledge in problem-oriented, systemic and integrated processes and approaches, not only in research but also in teaching. For this purpose, academia first needs to create the necessary interdisciplinary research and teaching structures. Students need to be familiarised with the changeability of complex systems in order to be able to adequately perceive and understand society and its developments.
Betrachtet man die Verbreitung des Konzeptes einer nachhaltigen Entwicklung an Schulen in Deutsch... more Betrachtet man die Verbreitung des Konzeptes einer nachhaltigen Entwicklung an Schulen in Deutschland, aber auch darüber hinaus, so wird eins deutlich: Im Laufe der letzten 20 Jahre haben sich eine Reihe von Schulen auf den Weg gemacht und mehr oder minder intensiv mit dem Thema auseinandergesetzt (Michelsen & Rode, 2012; Wals, 2010). Dabei kann einerseits von einer gewissen Breitenwirkung ausgegangen werden, da der Prozess des Transfers von vereinzelten Modellschulen hin zum »Schulalltag« in einigen Bereichen erfolgreich vonstatten ging (Petsch, Gönnenwein, & Nickolaus, 2012). Gleichzeitig wird deutlich, dass es nur wenigen Schulen gelingt, das Thema einer nachhaltigen Entwicklung dauerhaft und sichtbar an ihrer Einrichtung zu verankern. Offensichtlich existieren hier eine Reihe von Hindernissen und Barrieren – obwohl einer Integration von Nachhaltigkeitsaspekten zahlreiche positiven Effekte auf die gesamte Schule nachgesagt werden. Dazu gehören unter anderem eine gesteigerte allgemeine Lernmotivation, eine bessere Verankerung in der lokalen Community und eine erhöhte Partizipationskompetenz bei den Schülerinnen und Schülern (Bartosh et al., 2006; Birney & Reed, 2009; ofsted, 2009).
Kennzeichnend für das Vorgehen im BINK-Projekt war eine Verschränkung von empirischer Begleitforschung und laufenden Veränderungsprozessen an den beteiligten Bildungseinrichtungen, in die Ergebnisse aus den empirischen Erhebungen kontinuierlich einflossen. Mit der vorliegenden Studie wurde systematisch untersucht, wie an Schulen das Thema nachhaltiger Konsum bereits Eingang findet, welche Einflüsse dabei erzielt werden können und welche förderlichen und hinderlichen Bedingungen hierbei zu identifizieren sind. Wesentliche Erkenntnisse hieraus sollen im Folgenden vorgestellt werden. Dazu wird zunächst ein Überblick über bestehende Initiativen und Aktivitäten der Integration von Nachhaltigkeitsaspekten in die Schule in Deutschland, aber auch darüber hinaus thematisiert. Darauf aufbauend werden das Ziel der Studie, ihre methodische Anlage und ihre Durchführung vorgestellt. Die Ergebnisse der Studie werden dabei zunächst einzeln vorgestellt und in der abschließenden Diskussion systematisch aufeinander bezogen. Der Beitrag schließt mit einer Würdigung der Ergebnisse für die weitere Arbeit im Projekt.
Welchen Unterschied für das eigene Konsumlernen macht es, ob sich junge Menschen aktiv an Verände... more Welchen Unterschied für das eigene Konsumlernen macht es, ob sich junge Menschen aktiv an Veränderungsmaßnahmen zur Förderung nachhaltigen Konsums in Bildungseinrichtungen beteiligen, ob sie diese lediglich wahrnehmen oder diese gar ganz an ihnen vorbeige-hen? Und welche Bereiche an einer Bildungseinrichtung sind beson-ders einflussreich für das Konsumlernen Jugendlicher und junger Erwachsener?
The Nature of Sustainable Consumption and How to Achieve it: Results from the Focal Topic From Knowledge to Action - New Paths towards Sustainable Consumption, 2012
From a perspective of educational research, the growing wealth of materials and initiatives in th... more From a perspective of educational research, the growing wealth of materials and initiatives in the field of sustainable consumer education is entirely welcome. However, this is contrasted by a lack of empirical evidence regarding the extent and quality of consumer education in schools and how these materials and initiatives feed through into individual attitudes and values. The results presented in this article can be seen as a contribution to a more solid empirical basis for developing appropriate educational materials that will foster a generation of more sustainably-minded citizens.
Kompetenzen der Bildung für nachhaltige Entwicklung: Operationalisierung, Messung, Rahmenbedingungen, Befunde, 2008
Mit der vorliegenden Untersuchung wurde der Versuch unternommen, den Grundstein für ein tieferes ... more Mit der vorliegenden Untersuchung wurde der Versuch unternommen, den Grundstein für ein tieferes Verständnis der Rolle des Lernens mit Neuen Medien in der Bildung für nachhaltige Entwicklung zu legen. Die empirischen Ergebnisse, die insbesondere die spezifische Bedeutung des Lernens mit Neuen Medien für den Kompetenzerwerb herausstellen und den Erwerb von Gestaltungskompetenz als „Gestaltendes Handeln in komplexen Anforderungssituationen“ beschreiben, liefern hierzu einen wichtigen Beitrag. Deutlich wird hierbei, dass der Innovationscharakter des Lernens mit Neuen Medien vor allem darin begründet ist, dass ein spezifisches und detailliert ausgearbeitetes didaktisches Design mit eingebracht wird.
Von besonderem Interesse erscheint zudem die Frage nach der Rolle des Lernens mit Neuen Medien für die Messung des Kompetenzerwerbs.
Neues Handbuch Hochschullehre, 2007
Das Leitbild einer nachhaltigen Entwicklung setzt sich national wie international zunehmend auf d... more Das Leitbild einer nachhaltigen Entwicklung setzt sich national wie international zunehmend auf den unterschiedlichen gesellschaftlichen Ebenen durch. Mit ihm verbunden sind neue Herausforderungen an die Hochschulen und insbesondere an deren Lehre. Im Mittelpunkt dieses Beitrages steht daher die Frage, wie sich das Konzept einer nachhaltigen Entwicklung in die universitäre Lehre integrieren lässt. Nachhaltige Entwicklung als Orientierungsrahmen für Bildungsprozesse zu wählen, bringt eine Neuausrichtung der Studiengestaltung mit sich. Zudem werden didaktische und methodische Innovationen notwendig, um dem Anspruch des Konzeptes gerecht werden zu können. Die unterschiedlichen Ansätze der Integration von Nachhaltigkeit in die Lehre mit jeweils unterschiedlicher Reichweite werden hier vorgestellt und diskutiert. Dass eine umfassende Integration gelingen kann, soll anhand von Erfahrungen verdeutlicht werden, die mit dem „Studienprogramm Nachhaltigkeit“ an der Universität Lüneburg gemacht wurden.
Barth, M. (2008): Nachhaltigkeit und Hochschulbildung – die Leuphana Universität Lüneburg [Sustai... more Barth, M. (2008): Nachhaltigkeit und Hochschulbildung – die Leuphana Universität Lüneburg [Sustainability and Higher Education]. In: Altner, G., Leitschuh, H., Michelsen, G., Simonis, U., Weizsäcker, E. (eds.): Jahrbuch Ökologie 2009: Lob der Vielfalt. Stuttgart: Hirzel, 192-198.
Innovative Lehre. Grundsätze, Konzepte, Beispiele der Leuphana Universität Lüneburg, 2010
Die Integration von Nachhaltigkeit in die Hochschullehre ist mehr als die Thematisierung der Prob... more Die Integration von Nachhaltigkeit in die Hochschullehre ist mehr als die Thematisierung der Problematik in einzelnen Seminarsitzungen. Lehrende wie Lernende sind gefordert, sich auf neue Inhalte, Perspektiven und Methoden einzulassen. Mit dem Studienprogramm Nachhaltigkeit konnte ein Vorgehen erprobt und umgesetzt werden, das innovative Lehr-Lernmethoden mit dem Thema der Nachhaltigen Entwicklung verbindet und neue Formen der universitären Lehre eröffnet. So können die Förderung nach inter- und transdisziplinären Lernformen und die Unterstützung selbstgesteuerter Problemlöseprozesse angemessen eingelöst werden.
Barth, M., Godemann, J. (2006): Komplexität verstehen, Zukunftsperspektiven erschließen: Das Gene... more Barth, M., Godemann, J. (2006): Komplexität verstehen, Zukunftsperspektiven erschließen: Das General Studies Modul ‘Studienprogramm Nachhaltigkeit’ [Understanding complexity: the study program sustainability]. In: Michelsen, G., Märkt, S. (eds.): Persönlichkeitsbildung und Beschäftigungsfähigkeit: Konzeptionen von General Studies und ihre Umsetzungen. Bielefeld: UVW Universitäts Verlag, 33-51.
A number of studies can be found that examine the state of the art in research practices in envir... more A number of studies can be found that examine the state of the art in research practices in environmental education either in general (Rickinson 2001), with a specific local focus (Heimlich 2007) or for one or few specific journals (Andrew and Malone 1995). Due to its significantly shorter history few such approaches have been undertaken for education for sustainable development (ESD). In 2007, Wright and Pullen (2007) provided probably the first such approach with bibliometric
data on ESD research. The purpose was to track and document journal articles related to ESD and analyses them according to article title, journal title, author(s), country and institutional affiliation of the author(s). So far, no follow-up to this initial study exists and no review deals explicitly with higher education for sustainable development (HESD).
Against this backdrop, the study’s main objective is to examine current research trends in higher education for sustainable development. It will provide robust data to examine research paradigms, methodologies, research topics, methods, key journals and authors in this emerging area of research. The study includes all peer reviewed and in English available articles referenced in the major data bases for educational and sustainability sciences (SCOPUS, Web of Science, ERIC,
Sustainability Abstracts) since 1992.
The literate review concentrates on two different levels:
- First a quantitative overview of research trends will distinguish topics, methods of data collection and analysis as well as background information on authors, journals and references. This will allow for a comparative analysis of general trends over time and help to get a first understanding of the field by offering quantitative, bibliometric data.
- Second, a more detailed content analysis offers the opportunity to closer examine research trends and to find patterns of specific approaches.
This paper presents the results of the study concerning general trends in research in higher education for sustainable development over time (based on quantitative, bibliometric data) and patterns of specific approaches (based on a more detailed content analysis). The presentation of these results will create a basis for an international and interactive dialogue about future research in the area of higher education for sustainable development.
""Die Berücksichtigung von Umwelt- und Gesellschaftsfragen und die Beschäftigung mit dem Konzept ... more ""Die Berücksichtigung von Umwelt- und Gesellschaftsfragen und die Beschäftigung mit dem Konzept einer nachhaltigen Entwicklung findet sich mehr und mehr auch in der Hochschullehre wieder, birgt jedoch auch weiterhin große Herausforderung an das Lehren und Lernen in der Hochschule. Über die letzten Jahre hinweg lassen sich eine Reihe von konkreten Aktivitäten an unterschiedlichsten Hochschulen weltweit feststellen und sind als Fallstudien dokumentiert.
Als weiterhin ungelöste Herausforderung wird dabei die Integration von Fragen der Nachhaltigkeit in die bestehenden Curricula der Hochschulen angesehen. Ein solcher organisationaler Lernprozess, so wird argumentiert, bedarf der Berücksichtigung und des Einbezugs des akademischen Personals als Schlüsselakteure für den Wandel. Auch wenn die bisherige Forschung im Bereich Bildung für nachhaltige Entwicklung kaum auf diesen Bereich fokussiert, so zeigen erste Studien doch das Potential von Weiterbildungsveranstaltungen für organisationale Entwicklungsprozesse.
Entsprechend wird in dieser Präsentation ein Fallbeispiel vorgestellt und analysiert, in dem in Zusammenarbeit mit der Universidad Técnica del Norte (Ecuador) ein Weiterbildungsprogramm für Bildung für nachhaltige Entwicklung entwickelt, implementiert und evaluiert wurde. Ein besonderes Augenmerk wurde dabei auf die Wirkung der Weiterbildungsveranstaltungen auf weitergehende organisationale Veränderungsprozesse gelegt. Die Auswertung der erhobenen qualitativen Daten zeigt den Beitrag des Programms zur persönlichen Kompetenzentwicklung und Lehrkompetenz, aber darüber hinaus auch auf die generelle Implementierung von Prinzipien einer nachhaltigen Entwicklung in der Einrichtung. Damit wird zum einen das Potential solcher Veranstaltungen zur Stärkung von Bildung für nachhaltige Entwicklung in der Hochschullehre deutlich, zugleich werden wertvolle Hinweise auf Beiträge zu einer allgemeineren Organisationsentwicklung sichtbar. Weiterbildungsveranstaltungen fungieren in diesem Zusammenhang als wichtige Impulsgeber und Grundvoraussetzung für darauf folgende umfassendere organisationale Entwicklungsprozesse.
""
Die Nachhaltigkeitswissenschaften stellen ein wachsendes Feld wissenschaftlicher Tätigkeit dar, i... more Die Nachhaltigkeitswissenschaften stellen ein wachsendes Feld wissenschaftlicher Tätigkeit dar, in dem erste Systematisierungen sowie Theoriebildung und Methodenentwicklung vonstattengehen, auch wenn eine weitergehende Erarbeitung der spezifischen epistemologischen Grundlegung und methodologischen Anforderungen noch aussteht. Mit der Frage nach dem Zusammenspiel von Mensch und Umwelt lassen sich Schlüsselfragen der Nachhaltigkeitswissenschaften ausdifferenzieren und Charakteristika einer derartigen wissenschaftlichen Analyse beschreiben: Problemorientierung, Transdisziplinarität und der Umgang mit Komplexität stehen hier im Mittelpunkt. Zugleich kristallisieren sich Kernthemen und Leitdisziplinen heraus, die den Diskurs in den Nachhaltigkeitswissenschaften prägen. Die disziplinär orientierte Beschäftigung mit Nachhaltigkeitsaspekten entfaltet dabei eine in zweierlei Hinsicht Wirkung: als Beitrag zum transdisziplinären Diskurs der Nachhaltigkeitswissenschaften bringt sie spezifische Fragestellungen und Methoden in die interdisziplinäre Analyse mit ein, als Beschäftigung einer Disziplin mit den Herausforderungen der Nachhaltigkeit beeinflusst sie zugleich die disziplinäre Entwicklung.
Mit Blick auf die Unbestimmtheit dessen, was das Wesen des ‘moving targets sustainability’ (Hjorth & Bagheri 2006) tatsächlich ausmacht wird die Notwendigkeit von gesamtgesellschaftlichen Such- und Verständigungsprozessen deutlich, in deren Zentrum die Frage steht, welche Normen, Werte und Regeln und ebenso welche Arten von Wissen notwendig sind, um eine Entwicklung hin zu einer nachhaltigeren zukunftsfähigeren Gesellschaft aktiv mitgestalten zu können. Damit rücken Aspekte der Entscheidungsfindung, des Umgangs mit Unsicherheiten und der gesellschaftlichen Aushandlung verstärkt in den Fokus. Zudem verschiebt sich die Aufmerksamkeit von einer Produkt- hin zu einer Prozessorientierung. Hiermit direkt verbunden sind Fragen des individuellen ebenso wie des organisationalen und gesellschaftlichen Lernens; Fragen die den Kern der wissenschaftlichen Beschäftigung in den Erziehungswissenschaften betreffen, die hier einen wichtigen Beitrag leisten können.
Betrachtet man das Verhältnis von Erziehungswissenschaften und Nachhaltigkeitswissenschaften, so lassen sich prinzipiell zwei Arten von Einflüssen unterscheiden: Im Sinne eines ‘Outside-In-Approaches’ lässt sich nachvollziehen, wie die Idee der Nachhaltigkeit Eingang in die pädagogische Praxis und erziehungswissenschaftliche Reflexion gefunden hat. Dieser Einfluss lässt sich anhand der Entstehung von Bildung für nachhaltige Entwicklung rekonstruieren und manifestiert sich in der Ausbildung einer spezifischen Pädagogik mit eigener Zielsetzung, spezifischen Inhalten und Methoden sowie in einer wachsenden Forschungslandschaft mit Schwerpunktsetzungen und eigenen Publikations- und Kommunikationsorganen. Der umgekehrte Einfluss zeigt sich bei der Betrachtung eines ‘Inside-Out-Approaches’. Hier wird nach den Beiträgen der Erziehungswissenschaften zur Forschung in den Nachhaltigkeitswissenschaften gefragt. Mit einem spezifischen Set von Theorien, Methoden und Herangehensweisen, in denen sich die Erziehungswissenschaften manifestieren und die neben Berührungspunkten zur Soziologie und zur Psychologie einen spezifischen Eigenwert konstituieren, bietet sich – so soll gezeigt werden - hier ein Alleinstellungsmerkmal, das es für die Nachhaltigkeitswissenschaften noch stärker zu erschließen gilt.
Das Verhältnis von Erziehungswissenschaften und Nachhaltigkeitswissenschaften ist der Gegenstand dieses Beitrags. Ausgehend von einem Überblick über aktuelle Ansätze in der Forschung zur Bildung für nachhaltige Entwicklung soll zunächst der Einfluss der Idee der Nachhaltigkeit auf die erziehungswissenschaftliche Forschung nachvollzogen werden. Anhand von drei konkreten Themenkomplexen werden zudem potentielle Beiträge der Erziehungswissenschaften für den Diskurs in den Nachhaltigkeitswissenschaften aufgezeigt.
Education for Sustainability (EfS) has an intimate relationship with professional employment as w... more Education for Sustainability (EfS) has an intimate relationship with professional employment as we seek to develop graduates who will take EfS values and understanding into their workplaces to build a ‘sustainable future’. The connection is though the capabilities that employers are wanting in the people they employ, and they are the outcomes of the educational experiences that we educators provide for the graduates. The paper discusses the articulation of capabilities in the context of Australian universities and looks into the types of capabilities being sought by employers, both in Australia and more generally. In parallel we note the discussion of capabilities associated with EfS and identify similarities. The results of research associated with the exploration of the breadth of the environment profession provide examples of the types of capabilities that are needed in industry.
At the interplay of school-based health promotion and sustainability it is sustainable consumptio... more At the interplay of school-based health promotion and sustainability it is sustainable consumption that is the focus of interest. Sustainable consumption calls for alternative ways to satisfy the objective needs of today and future generations whilst respecting planetary boundaries. Action is called for that work towards guaranteeing external conditions that allow all humans to live a good and healthy life. In the pursuit of sustainable consumption, education is widely ascribed a pivotal role as an instrument for disseminating more sustainable consumer behaviors. However, below this seemingly consensual surface the questions of what sustainability objectives are appropriate in consumer education and how they can be pursued is the subject of controversial debate.
This controversy is addressed in the present presentation. In a first step, it suggests the development of key competencies as a valid and legitimate objective that addresses both individual and societal needs. The presenters systematically derive a framework of key competencies for sustainable consumption and discuss the framework’s application to educational practice. In a second step, the presentation addresses the question of how formal and informal learning settings need to be designed in order to promote the acquisition of such competencies among students. A participatory whole-school approach to changing the “culture of consumption” in educational organisations is presented that was developed, implemented and evaluated in a major transdisciplinary three-year project. The presentation concludes with a discussion of synergies between the sustainability and health agendas for the emergence of innovative schools for the 21st century.
"Since sustainable development involves and requires fundamental societal transformations, it can... more "Since sustainable development involves and requires fundamental societal transformations, it can only result from a process of societal learning. Consequently, education is seen as key to achieving sustainable development. In this context, universities as research and teaching institutions are playing an important role since they not only generate and transfer relevant knowledge but also educate future decision makers to enable them to contribute to a (more) sustainable future. Higher education for sustainability thus aims at student competence development for decision making in a future-oriented and global perspective. As such it is “not just another issue to be added to an overcrowded curriculum, but a gateway to a different view of curriculum, of pedagogy, of organizational change, of policy and particularly of ethos” (Sterling, 2004).
Embedding sustainability in higher education and implementing EfS in the curriculum poses a new challenge to the academic system. During the last years, many universities have undertaken activities towards implementation, and numerous case studies as well as studies on the drivers and barriers of such processes have been documented. However, considerable criticism centers on the limited possibilities of generalizing the more or less descriptive findings and verifying findings from the outside. The question remains, how drivers and barriers are interlinked and influence the outcome of implementation processes.
The present study contributes to this question by analysing implementation processes of twelve universities in four different countries. Research consists of two main steps: first, in a grounded meta-analysis of existing research on curriculum change and sustainable development findings are synthesized and an analytical framework is elaborated. Second, in a comparative case study, implementation processes at the universities are analysed against that framework to uncover patterns of implementation and the meaning of specific drivers and barriers with respect to distinctive implementation strategies.
Findings clearly points out the relevance of a process oriented view on curriculum change with a varying relevance of drivers and barriers, dependent on the implementation strategies chosen. Such a view not only help to understands the dynamics in curriculum change processes but as well enables to derive policy advices to support such transitions."
"Despite the acknowledgment of the need to integrate principles of sustainability in higher educa... more "Despite the acknowledgment of the need to integrate principles of sustainability in higher educations practice – as well in teaching and research as in the organisations management – only few case studies show the potential of whole organisation change processes. Aim of the symposium is to introduce, analyse and discuss ‘next practice’ approaches towards organisational change on different levels and scales. ‘Next practices’ according to Wals (2010) go beyond the static idea of best practices and may be understood as “innovative transboundary learning configuration designed to meaningfully contribute to the solution of a jointly shared sustainability challenge”.
The potential of next practices for organisational change from within will be discussed alongside four key areas, each introduced in a short presentation:
1. Implementing sustainability in the curriculum - the logic of curriculum change
(presenter: Matthias Barth) Based on a comparative case study of implementation processes, patterns of curriculum change as well as drivers and barriers are analysed.
2. Teaching staff as agents of change – the outcome of a 1year teacher-training
(presenter: Marco Rieckmann) The study conducted at the Universidad Técnica del Norte (Ibarra, Ecuador) analysed, how organisational change can be facilitated by a further education programme for teaching staff.
3. Broaden the scope of HE for sustainability – the innovative potential of e-learning
(presenter: Simon Burandt) How the integration of e-learning and web 2.0 technologies offers a reinvention of common didactical approaches in ESD is analysed upon multiple case studies. "
It can be considered a duty of all educational institutions to deal intensively with matters of s... more It can be considered a duty of all educational institutions to deal intensively with matters of sustainable development: from preschool to higher education. Education for Sustainable Development (ESD) aims at developing key competencies that enable individuals to contribute to sustainable development (e.g. Barth, 2007; de Haan, 2008; Hopkins and McKeown, 2002). Universities play an important role as promoters of sustainable development. Embedding sustainable development in their curriculum poses a new challenge to the academic system.
The Leuphana University of Lüneburg, Germany, has already a long experience in implementing Higher Education for Sustainable Development (HESD); it considers itself as a “Sustainable University” (cf. Adomßent et al., 2007). In 2009, the Institute for Environmental and Sustainability Communication of the Leuphana University and the Universidad Técnica del Norte (UTN), Ecuador, built up the partnership “Teaching and Learning Sustainability” which is financed by the German Academic Exchange Service (DAAD). The objectives of this North-South cooperation are especially the implementation of HESD at the UTN and the transfer of knowledge between both universities. Key elements of the cooperation are a one-year teacher training about HESD which has been implemented conjointly at the UTN as well as student and teacher exchange.
The presentation will address the North-South partnership “Teaching and Learning Sustainability” and in particular the implementation of the teacher training as well as results of a qualitative analysis of the effects of this training programme. Furthermore, the process of mutual learning between faculty and students from the North and the South will be discussed.
Societies all over the world are facing rapid social and technological changes. These phenomena n... more Societies all over the world are facing rapid social and technological changes. These phenomena not only alter the nature of work and social life but also the requirements for students’ com-petencies, resulting in new challenges for Higher Education.
A core societal function of academia is to impart relevant competencies: especially in Higher Education for Sustainable Development (HESD) students have to be familiarised with key prop-erties of complex systems, such as uncertainty and continuous change, to gain the capability to adequately perceive, understand and cope with fundamental societal problems. Specialised expert knowledge needs to be included in problem-oriented, systematic and integrated pro-cesses and approaches, not only in research but also in teaching. For this purpose, academia needs to create the necessary interdisciplinary as well as transdisciplinary research and teaching structures.
While it is broadly agreed that HESD should comprise specific didactical key elements such as problem-oriented, self-directed and collaborative learning, a great variety of didactical ap-proaches in this context were developed over the last years. In our contribution we analyse and compare two exemplary comprehensive approaches towards learning for sustainability in higher ducation with focus on a systematic analysis and transformation of complex, sustainability-related problems: (1) the transdisciplinary case study approach (TdCS) developed and elabo-rated since 1993 at the ETH Zurich as a way of problem/project based learning in a transdisci-plinary teaching-research environment and (2) the Minor Sustainability at Leuphana University of Lueneburg, following a Communities of Practice approach.
Both approaches are described and compared according to their ontological, epistemological, methodological, and organizational foundations, illustrating, both the conceptual singularities and the potential such comprehensive approaches offer for HESD. Thereby, special focus is laid on the different roles of teachers/researchers, actors from outside academia and students as well as their concomitant ‘learning interactions’ .
Die Menschheit steht heute vor weltweiten sozialen, ökonomischen, kulturellen und ökologischen He... more Die Menschheit steht heute vor weltweiten sozialen, ökonomischen, kulturellen und ökologischen Herausforderungen, die sich unter dem Begriff des ‘Globalen Wandels’ zusammen fassen lassen (WBGU 1996). Als neues Leitbild wird in diesem Zusammenhang das Konzept der nachhaltigen Entwicklung diskutiert, das im Rahmen der ‘Sustainability Science’ auch Eingang in den wissenschaftlichen Diskurs gefunden hat (Kates et al. 2001).
Nachhaltige Entwicklung kann dabei als gesellschaftlicher Verständigungs-, Lern- und Gestaltungsprozess verstanden werden der eines interdisziplinären und interkulturellen Dialogs über mögliche gesellschaftliche Übergänge in Richtung Nachhaltigkeit bedarf (Michelsen 2007). Nur durch entsprechende Kommunikationsprozesse über mögliche Ideen und Ansätze für eine nachhaltige Entwicklung wird es möglich sein, angemessen mit den weltweiten Prob-lemen der Nicht-Nachhaltigkeit umzugehen (Barth/Rieckmann 2009a).
Für die Konzeption von Lernprozessen stellt die Berücksichtigung von Nachhaltigkeitsfragen neue Anforderungen, die die Organisation ebenso wie die didaktisch-methodische Ausgestaltung betreffen und auf interkulturelle und -disziplinäre Kommunikations- und Kooperationsprozesse abzielen. Dem reflektierten Umgang mit zentralen Begrifflichkeiten und die Vergewisserung der unterschiedlichen Konnotationen und kulturellen Prägungen kommt hier eine zentrale Rolle zu.
In diesem Beitrag sollen vor dem lerntheoretischen Hintergrund der Communities of Practice ausgewählte Lernsettings in der Hochschullehre analysiert werden, in denen die Begriffsbildung und -diskussion in interkulturellen und interdisziplinären Settings im Mittelpunkt steht. Ausgewählte empirische Ergebnisse illustrieren hierbei die Bedeutung der Begriffsarbeit und der Lernprozesse, die mit der Aushandlung gemeinsam getragener Bedeu-tungszuschreibungen verbunden sind.
The problems of global change and the search for sustainable solutions worldwide are central chal... more The problems of global change and the search for sustainable solutions worldwide are central challenges of the present and future. However, the discussion on sustainability can only take effect if it connects to many fields of society and to various stakeholders. In addressing key social issues such as health and consumption, educational institutions play a pivotal role in providing youth and young adults with the competencies needed to shape and work towards a sustainable future (UNDESA 2002, EU Council 2006). The Project BINK (German acronym for „Educational Institutions and Sustainable Consumption“) sets out to explore how educational institutions can collaboratively engage with internal and external stakeholders to promote healthier and more sustainable lifestyle among young adults, especially considering food as an exemplary field of sustainable consumption. At the heart of the project lay three core assumptions: (a) Educational institutions have an effect on individual consumption in two ways. On one hand they act as a facilitator of educational offers related to healthy and sustainable consumption that make students reflect and render their own consumption patterns more conscious. On the other, educational institutions themselves are consumption households and as such places in which school members consume. This twofold character, being both a place of learning and a lifeworld in itself, scaffolds an educational institution‘s characteristic culture of consumption. (b) Research findings indicate that far more than 50 percent of learning takes place in informal learning settings (Dohnen 2001, Livingstone 2004). This potential has only been scarcely recognized by educational programmes so far. By way of implementing coordinated development measures that systematically align formal and informal learning settings, the project aims to collaboratively conceptualize, develop and stabilise a culture of sustainable consumption in six participating educational institutions. (c) The transformation process of an institution’s culture of consumption can neither be prescribed top-down nor implemented by single actors bottom-up. It requires the involvement of key players, multiple stakeholders and the establishment of new partnerships between different groups within the school-community as well as between the school-community and its external stakeholders. Thus, a transdisciplinary approach is chosen. The interventions are derived and further developed in close collaboration between the protagonists of the participating educational institutions, external stakeholders and scholars and researchers affiliated to the project. On the institutional level, steering committees are established, in which all key players and actors are represented and involved.
Method
The processes of organizational change is guided and informed by the concept of an educational institution’s culture of consumption. The analytical framework evolved in three corresponding steps. (1) The theoretical foundation was derived from a review of existing theories related to participatory organizational development and organizational/school culture. (2) In an empirical study, a number of 24 non-affiliated educational institutions with different degrees of implemented and consolidated structures and initiatives related to sustainable consumption were examined in order to validate or complement the framework. (3) In a series of workshops and meetings with the steering committees of the affiliated educational institutions, a transdisciplinary discourse over the framework, its practicability and its implications for the change process in the institution was initiated. The framework was then used to analyze the current state of the institution’s culture of consumption and to set goals for developing measures of intervention.
Expected Outcomes
As a result of the joint project, new theoretical and methodical findings as well as knowledge of practical relevance will be compiled regarding the question how educational institutions can use and benefit from partnerships and the participatory involvement of multiple stakeholders in a process of developing an institutional culture of sustainable consumption to promote and stabilise healthy and sustainable consumer behaviour among its students. Based on aggregated data on the outlined processes of organizational change in different types of educational institutions (from secondary and vocational schools to universities), the findings produced are expected to be of general relevance for participatoy processes of organizational learning in educational institutions. Thus, it can serve as a case model illustrating the potential contribution of educational institutions to the achievement of an overall pedagogical objective as layed out in the EU consumer policy strategy 2007-2013: the education of „confident, informed and empowered consumers“.
References
Commission of the European Communities (2007). Communication from the Commission to the Council, the European Parliament and the European Economic and Social Committee: EU Consumer Policy strategy 2007-2013 - Empowering consumers, enhancing their welfare, effectively protecting them. Brüssel. Dohmen, G. (2001). Das informelle Lernen: Die internationale Erschließung einer bisher vernachlässigten Grundform menschlichen Lernens für das lebenslange Lernen aller. Bonn: Bundesministerium für Bildung und Forschung (BMBF). EU Council - Council of the European Union (2006). Review of the EU Sustainable Development Strategy (EU SDS) - Renewed Strategy. Brüssel. Livingstone, D. W. (2004). The education-jobs gap: Underemployment or economic democracy. Aurora, Ont.: Garamond UNDESA - United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs - Division for Sustainable Development ( (2002). Plan of Implementation of the World Summit on Sustainable Development. Johannesburg.
This proposal is part of a master or doctoral thesis.
For integrating education for sustainable development in higher education a number of examples ma... more For integrating education for sustainable development in higher education a number of examples may be found, but a well established implementation is still hard to find. In general, four different approaches may be distinguished : (1)Inclusion of the topic, e.g. in series of lectures, (2) Integration of new learning-/teaching approaches, e.g. self-directed, problem-oriented learning, (3) the development of independent courses like study programs and (4) the integration in existing curricula, e.g. by curricula reform.
At the Leuphana University of Lueneburg these different steps have been realized during the last years, mainly by carrying out the pilot of an innovative study program first and then using the experiences made in the study program for a full integration as an obligatory module for all bachelor courses. Both steps have been evaluated by asking for drivers and barriers in such a process.
The step-by-step integration process of integrating sustainable development in the higher education curricula at the Leuphana University of Lueneburg made sustainable development a deep-rooted key principle of higher education. The main findings from the evaluation shows, that the process of integration might be seen as a threefold challenge with new ways of learning for students, with teachers as coaches of the individual processes of competence development rather than lecturer and with an organization, which has to rethink their own role in society.
Patterns of consumption of nowadays society are not in line with a sustainable development. Alrea... more Patterns of consumption of nowadays society are not in line with a sustainable development. Already the Agenda 21 acknowledges the necessity of changing consumption patterns to allow present and future generations to meet their own needs. Education and especially institutions of learning play a key role for such a change:
They offer consumption-related educational opportunities and at the same time they are places in which consumption takes place. Schools are of special interest, because pupils define themselves more than other age groups by their consumption styles but have not yet cultivated steady patterns of consumption.
Taking that into account, the research project „Institutions of Learning and Sustainable Consumption” aims at institutional change processes towards a culture of sustainable consumption and at changes in individual consumption related behavior. For such a change the concept of a culture of sustainable consumption offers an analytical framework.
In three steps such a framework related to practice has been developed:
(1) A review of existing theories related to organisational development and school culture,
(2) the empirical validation at schools with different degrees of implementation of a culture of sustainable consumption and
(3) a transdisciplinary discourse to deduct options for action
Research shows, that different patterns and individual occurrence of a culture of sustainable consumption exists, which constitute the starting point of different development options. Four dimensions may be highlighted as especially relevant for practice:
(1) The meaning of the topic of consumption within the educational content,
(2) the consideration of consumption as an aspect of schools mission and performance,
(3) the implication of the pedagogical orientation on consumption related behavior,
(4) participation and communication and thus the question to what extend actors are enabled to actively influence the institutional consumption
Research in environmental communication has produced many theoretical and empirical insights over... more Research in environmental communication has produced many theoretical and empirical insights over the past three decades. Global environmental change and the discourse on sustainable development have put challenging issues on the research agenda since the 90ties. The perspective has been broadened towards multidimensional, time-spatial distant effects: from local to global, from present to future, from environment to sustainability, focusing on ecological, economic and social aspects simultaneously. Despite the broad spectrum on topics and approaches we can distinguish three basic patterns of environment-society-interactions, which are underlying communication on environment and sustainable development:
- Reducing societal impact on the environment – mitigation: e.g. sustainable consumption, ecological modernization.
- Curing of environmental change – re-construction: e.g. brownfields, nature by design
- Reacting to environmental impact on society – adaptation: e.g. climate change, risk& disaster management
So far environmental communication has been working mainly on the first pattern and to lesser extent on the second one. Only recently – due to an increased attention of science, policymaking and society at large to global climate change and its local risks and consequences – the issue of adaptation has attracted more research interest in communication studies. With regard to the analytical-normative perspective of sustainable development, the question, how societies communicate on the far reaching challenges of ‘glocal’ environmental change opens up new fields of research and development.
In my presentation I will discuss, to what extent academic, disciplinary organized environmental communication research needs to be opened up towards inter- and transdisciplinary perspectives, bringing together academia and societal praxis. Current examples of institutional innovations such as the Centre for Excellence in Climate Change Communication at George-Mason-University, the Institute for Environmental and Sustainability Communication at Leuphana-University Lüneburg or the International Journal for Sustainability Communication are introduced to concretize the conceptual arguments.
"Higher Education for Sustainable Development Against the background of globalisation and increa... more "Higher Education for Sustainable Development
Against the background of globalisation and increasing complexity, higher education for sustainable development aims at enabling people to not only acquire and generate knowledge, but also to reflect on further effects and the complexity of behaviour and decisions in a future-oriented and global perspective of responsibility. Such a focus on the development of key competencies to deal with sustainable development needs a reorientation of learning processes and therewith of one of the core tasks of University.
For that purpose a “new learning culture” is needed, which does not confirm academic tradition but examines its potential for a sustainable future. In this context Arnold and Lermen (2002) discuss the necessity of establishing an „enabling didactic“. The goal is to promote personality development, enabling a person to be able to cope with complex situations, to be able to act upon reflection and to make decisions. It is also about being able to take on responsibility and to consider ethical standards when acting. By implementing the concept of sustainable development in higher education, four main challenges can be seen: (1) Inter- and transdisciplinary problem-solving, (2) dealing with complexity, (3) self-directed learning and (4) competence development.
Transformation processes coming along with the Bologna-Process like the modular design of study courses and the implementation of internationally acknowledged consecutive study courses may offer a variety of possibilities to incorporate education for sustainable development when reorienting higher education. For integrating education for sustainable development in higher education a number of examples may be found, but a well established implementation is still hard to find (Thomas 2004).
In general, four different approaches to integrate sustainable development in higher education may be distinguished according to the degree of innovation and implementation. The single approaches are partly related, so that a step-by-step integration might be possible but not mandatory: (1)Inclusion of the topic, e.g. in series of lectures, (2) Integration of new learning-/teaching approaches, e.g. self-directed, problem-oriented learning, (3) the development of independent courses like study programs and (4) the integration in existing curricula, e.g. by curricula reform.
Case Study Leuphana University of Lüneburg
At the Leuphana University of Lüneburg the requirements of the Bologna-Process have been used to realign the existing curricula consequently and integrate the concept of sustainable development into higher education. Step three and four of the approaches mentioned above have been realised carrying out the pilot of an innovative study program first and then using the experiences made in the study program for a full integration as an obligatory module for all bachelor courses. Both steps have been evaluated by asking for drivers and barriers in such a process.
Setting up a pilot – the study program sustainability
Within the framework of the three year research and development project „Sustainable University“ at the University of Lüneburg, a study programme was developed and tested. It aimed to take up the described challenges for the university constructively with respect to curriculum development. Based on the concept of sustainable development, the programme encourages the ability to solve problems in an interdisciplinary way. The developed approach can be distinguished by two main criteria:
• Complex problem areas are handled in an interdisciplinary manner, whereby interdisciplinarity relates to both the group of learners and the group of teaching staff.
• The learning process is supported by the development of an alternative learning environment (blended learning).
Within the one-year interdisciplinary study programme “Sustainability”, 32 students from educational, cultural, environmental and business sciences work together on a specific problem area. They identify societal problems and global trends from a political, economic, cultural and social point of view in an interdisciplinary dialogue and also work on developing solutions. The course is taught by staff from various disciplines as well as external practice experts.
The study programme was accompanied by a research design, dealing with the question how the acquirement of key competencies for sustainable development can be realised at universities. Thus, for the study programme “Sustainability”, three focus group discussions were carried out with the different student groups, which worked together during the course.
Moving towards a integral part of the curricula – Sustainable Development in the Leuphana Semester
The process of reorganisation of all courses of study under the framework of the Bologna process has been used to integrate sustainability on a broader level in the higher education curricula. Main findings from the study program regarding the successful realisation of education for sustainable development helped to plan and organise that process.
Since winter term 2007/08 all 1500 first-year students – independent from their chosen study bachelor program - at the Leuphana University of Lüneburg start their studies together with a so called “Leuphana Semester”. A workload of 300h (1/3 of their first semester) is dedicated to education for sustainable development. Under the overall theme “Responsibility in Society” all students are dealing with questions of how the concept of sustainable development may serve as a normative framework to unfold such a responsible action.
In three major steps sustainability is introduced: In the beginning a basic understanding of the key principles of sustainability is communicated by an introductive lecture series. Based on that students work in project oriented seminars on different topics of sustainability. The topics of these seminars range from sustainable mobility to sustainable development in mass media or to aspects of gender equity. As a last step students organise a conference week, in which the different approaches of the student groups will be presented to the public.
The first run of this new bachelor programs is evaluated formatively. Thus, different research methods are involved: with the help of a pre-entry questionnaire, learning records and a final questionnaire students’ prior experience in group work and their understanding of the concept of sustainable development have been studied as well as the learning process and an overall feedback on the courses. Beside the view on students’ acceptance and experiences as well as their competence development, another focus lays on the experience of the involved staff to understand drivers and barriers for such a process of implementation. Thus, a number of focus group discussions were carried out with teachers and tutors working with the students.
Summary
Following step 3 and 4 outlined above in the step-by-step integration process makes sustainable development a deep-rooted key principle of higher education. For this purpose experiences from the pilot study program could be used and be offered to a larger number of students.
The main findings from the pilot are dealing with the need to foster inter- and transdisciplinary competencies, to offer open learning environments to support reflection processes as well self-reliance and self-direction as key principles of the learning process aiming at competence development and to offer multiple contexts for the learning processes. The implementation of the Leuphana Semester shows that such an approach can help finding general elements of education for sustainable development that can be integrated in the normal curricula. A detailed analysis of the evaluation still has to be done while the first run of the semester lasts until March 2008. First impressions from the group discussions emphasize the challenges in the organisation of such learning processes as well as the need of professional training of the teachers to support a change from teacher-oriented view on learning towards a learner-centered coaching.
Bibliography
Arnold, Rolf, Lermen, Markus (2002): Multimediales Lernen in der Erwachsenenbildung. In: PÄD-Forum: unterrichten, erziehen. Vol. 30 (6). S. 456-460.
Thomas, Ian (2004): Sustainability in tertiary curricula: what is stopping it happening? In: International Journal of Sustainability in Higher Education. Vol 5 (1). pp. 33-47.
"
Societies all over the world are facing rapid social and technological changes. Economic and cult... more Societies all over the world are facing rapid social and technological changes. Economic and cultural globalization and technical progress are among the many facets of today's world (e.g. Rychen 2001). Therefore, academic education can be understood as the mirror image of societal and historical processes, which are the basis for analysing and enhancing the development and shaping of society .
Die AutorInnen geben einen Überblick zu Schwerpunktthemen, Methoden und Trends in der empirischen... more Die AutorInnen geben einen Überblick zu Schwerpunktthemen, Methoden und Trends in der empirischen Forschung zu Bildung
für nachhaltige Entwicklung (BNE) – einem Bereich, der sich in den letzten Jahren immer weiter ausdifferenziert und verfestigt hat: Inzwischen ist die BNE innerhalb der Bildungsforschung
als eigenständiges Feld mit eigenen Strukturen, Publikationsorganen und Netzwerken etabliert.
In a time of unprecedented transformation as society seeks to build a more sustainable future, ed... more In a time of unprecedented transformation as society seeks to build a more sustainable future, education plays an increasingly central role in training key agents of change. This book asks how we can equip students and scholars with the capabilities to promote sustainability and how the higher education curriculum can be changed to facilitate the paradigm shift needed.
Across the globe, a rising number of higher education institutions and academics are responding to these questions by transforming their own teaching and learning and their institutions’ curricula. This book contributes to that development by examining in-depth case studies of innovative approaches and curriculum changes at multiple levels of the education sector. Elaborating key principles of higher education for sustainable development and identifying drivers and barriers to implementing sustainability in the curriculum, the book provides a comprehensive overview of what makes higher education for sustainable development a unique field of research and practice, as well as offering a coherent narrative of how change can be effected in it.
This much-needed book is a valuable resource to inform, guide and inspire students, academics, administrators and community partners, whether experienced or new to the field, whether already committed or not to higher education for sustainable development in an age of transformation.
The year 2009 marked the completion of the first half of the UN Decade „Education for Sustainable... more The year 2009 marked the completion of the first half of the UN Decade „Education for Sustainable Development”. This provided the opportunity to critically reflect on the achievements so far and the tasks and challenges remaining to be addressed. Thus, the Third International Conference on Higher Education for Sustainable Development, jointly organized by the UNESCO Chair „Higher Education for Sustainable Development” at the Leuphana University of Lüneburg, Germany and the Universiti Sains Malaysia in Penang in 2009 addressed the central question of what added value integrating questions of sustainability has for teaching and learning in higher education. This book reflects upon what has been achieved so far in higher education for sustainable development and gives a snapshot of what is going on at the very moment. We trust this will contribute to the discourse in the growing area of higher education for sustainable development and help to fulfill the objective outlined in the title of this volume: to look back and move forward.