Exclusive | Nearly 70 percent of 2020 shootings in NYC are unsolved: NYPD (original) (raw)
Nearly 70 percent of New York City’s shootings last year are unsolved, and more than half of the suspects arrested in the gunplay are back out on the streets, The Post has learned.
Police have arrested a suspect in 483 of the 1,525 shootings in 2020 — a clearance rate of only 31.7 percent, according to NYPD data through Dec. 29.
Because multiple perps were arrested in some shootings, the number of individuals collared through Dec. 17 was 544, or an average of about 1.2 people per incident.
But of these 544 trigger-happy defendants, only 254 — about 47 percent — are currently in state or city custody, according to the NYPD.
Among the unsolved cases is the shocking stray-bullet slaying of Brooklyn baby Davell Gardner in July. Just two months shy of his second birthday, the toddler was senseless collateral damage in a long-running feud between rival Bedford-Stuyvesant gangs.
The tot was enjoying a family cookout near Raymond Bush Playground on July 12 when a stray slug fatally struck his stomach as his heartbroken mother looked on.
“It’s been hard,” Samantha Gardner, the tragic tot’s paternal grandmother, recently told The Post. “My son is not good. He’s taken it very hard. It’s the holidays, and instead of celebrating he’s going to the cemetery.”
The stunning slaying struck a nerve with a shaken NYPD that has been dealing all year with the Big Apple shooting gallery.
NY Post cover for Friday, December 18, 2020.
“A one-year-old child is dead,” NYPD Chief of Community Affairs Jeffrey Maddrey tweeted the day after the killing. “This. Must. STOP! We as a community, we as a police department denounce this disgusting violence.”
Despite the failure to make an arrest in the murder, NYPD Commissioner Dermot Shea said Tuesday that, “I think people know who did that case.”
Uncooperative witnesses are a big factor in not solving such shootings, Shea said during the briefing.
“I would say we know who does the shooting 80 to 90 percent of the time,” he said. “It’s knowing and getting a district attorney to be comfortable with moving forward with the prosecution, with witnesses that sometimes change their story or tell you, ‘This is who did it but I am not going to court.’”
The passage last year of state discovery laws compelling prosecutors to turn over witness identities to defense attorneys did investigators no favors in cracking cases, Shea noted.
“We go to court and the first thing the district attorney says is, ‘I have to tell you this: I’m going to try to protect your identity, but I cannot protect your identity guaranteed,’” said Shea. “And people literally stand up and walk out of the district attorney’s office.”
A baby stroller are seen at the scene of a multiple shooting next to the Raymond Bush Playground at 464 Madison St. in Brooklyn on July 13, 2020. Robert Mecea
On Thursday October 22nd 2020 at approx. 4:30PM a male was shot and killed on the corner of Malcolm X Blvd and Chauncey St.Seth Gottfried
Advertisement
A tweak to the law passed earlier this year grants judges the authority to provide additional shields for witnesses in sex-trafficking, organized crime and gang-related cases.
Shootings in NYC are up 96 percent over 2019.
The new data shows a slightly improved shooting arrest rate. The last time the stats were publicly released in August, by the five district attorneys, the clearance rate was only 20 percent, The Post reported. Arrests of gunslingers slowed during the initial stages of pandemic lockdowns, before picking back up later in the summer.
Department brass has blamed the stunning surge in gunplay on the mass release of inmates from jails and prisons due to COVID concerns and new laws that require judges to let some gun suspects go without paying bail.
Critics offer up different reasons: a slowdown in police work, as cops see declining morale amid the coronavirus, anti-police rioting, calls to defund the police, and NYPD budget cuts.
The disbanding of the city’s anti-crime unit, which consisted of 600 plainclothes officers who scoured the streets in an effort to seize guns, has also been attributed to the rise in shootings.
In the two months after the NYPD disbanded the unit and reassigned the 600 officers in mid-July, shootings soared 205 percent.
Additional reporting by Dean Balsamini