 Chris NewcombSelf - Angela Wagner's Half Brother Self - Angela Wagner's Half Brother See fewer |
The Pike County Murders: A Family Massacre (2023) |
 Angenette LevySelf - Journalist, Law&Crime Network Self - Journalist, Law&Crime Network See fewer |
On Trial: The Idaho College Killer (2025) |
 Mike AllenSelf - Legal Analyst, Cincinnati Fox 19 Self - Legal Analyst, Cincinnati Fox 19 See fewer |
The Pike County Murders: A Family Massacre (2023) |
 John ParkerSelf - George Wagner's Defense Attorney Self - George Wagner's Defense Attorney See fewer |
The Pike County Murders: A Family Massacre (2023) |
 Angie CanepaSelf - Pike County Special Prosecutor Self - Pike County Special Prosecutor See fewer |
The Pike County Murders: A Family Massacre (2023) |
| Christina HowardSelf - George Wagner's Ex-Sister-In-Law Self - George Wagner's Ex-Sister-In-Law See fewer |
The Pike County Murders: A Family Massacre (2023) |
 Benjamin SuverSelf - BCI Special Agent In Charge Self - BCI Special Agent In Charge See fewer |
The Pike County Murders: A Family Massacre (2023) |
 Eric EvansSelf - Trial Reporter Self - Trial Reporter See fewer |
The Pike County Murders: A Family Massacre (2023) |
 Randa HughesSelf - Chris Newcomb's Fiancée Self - Chris Newcomb's Fiancée See fewer |
The Pike County Murders: A Family Massacre (2023) |
| Joseph MorganSelf - Death Investigator Self - Death Investigator See fewer |
The Pike County Murders: A Family Massacre (2023) |
 Whitney GallowaySelf - Hannah Gilley's Friend Self - Hannah Gilley's Friend See fewer |
The Pike County Murders: A Family Massacre (2023) |
 Chris StoneSelf - Rhoden Family Member Self - Rhoden Family Member See fewer |
The Pike County Murders: A Family Massacre (2023) |
 Samantha StaleySelf - Rhoden and Wagner Family Friend Self - Rhoden and Wagner Family Friend See fewer |
The Pike County Murders: A Family Massacre (2023) |
 Mary Jane Dotson-RutledgeSelf - Dana Rhoden's Friend Self - Dana Rhoden's Friend See fewer |
The Pike County Murders: A Family Massacre (2023) |
 Mike DeWineSelf - Former Ohio Attorney General (as Governor Mike DeWine) Self - Former Ohio Attorney General (as Governor Mike DeWine) See fewer |
I Am Evidence (2017) |
 Kenny RhodenSelf - Gary Rhoden's Brother Self - Gary Rhoden's Brother See fewer |
The Pike County Murders: A Family Massacre (2023) |
| Krista JonesSelf - Trauma Therapy Counselor Self - Trauma Therapy Counselor See fewer |
The Pike County Murders: A Family Massacre (2023) |
| Elizabeth ArmerSelf - Jake Wagner's Ex-Wife (archive footage) Self - Jake Wagner's Ex-Wife (archive footage) See fewer |
|
| Caleb CinereskiSelf - Pastor (archive footage) (as Pastor Caleb Cinereski) Self - Pastor (archive footage) (as Pastor Caleb Cinereski) See fewer |
|
| Tabitha ClaytorSelf - George Wagner's Ex-Wife (archive footage) Self - George Wagner's Ex-Wife (archive footage) See fewer |
|
 Randy DeeringSelf - Pike County Common Pleas Court (archive footage) (as Judge Randy Deering) Self - Pike County Common Pleas Court (archive footage) (as Judge Randy Deering) See fewer |
|
| Hannah GilleySelf - Murder Victim, 20 Years Old (archive footage) Self - Murder Victim, 20 Years Old (archive footage) See fewer |
|
| Richard NashSelf - George Wagner's Defense Attorney (archive footage) Self - George Wagner's Defense Attorney (archive footage) See fewer |
|
| Christopher Rhoden Jr.Self - Murder Victim, 16 Years Old (archive footage) (as Chris Rhoden Jr.) Self - Murder Victim, 16 Years Old (archive footage) (as Chris Rhoden Jr.) See fewer |
|
| Christopher Rhoden Sr.Self - Murder Victim, 40 Years Old (archive footage) (as Chris Roden Sr.) Self - Murder Victim, 40 Years Old (archive footage) (as Chris Roden Sr.) See fewer |
|
| Dana RhodenSelf - Murder Victim, 37 Years Old & Hanna Rhoden's Mother (archive footage) Self - Murder Victim, 37 Years Old & Hanna Rhoden's Mother (archive footage) See fewer |
|
| Frankie RhodenSelf - Murder Victim, 20 Years Old (archive footage) (as Clarence "Frankie" Rhoden) Self - Murder Victim, 20 Years Old (archive footage) (as Clarence "Frankie" Rhoden) See fewer |
|
| Gary RhodenSelf - Murder Victim, 38 Years Old (archive footage) Self - Murder Victim, 38 Years Old (archive footage) See fewer |
|
| Hanna May RhodenSelf - Murder Victim, 19 Years Old (archive footage) Self - Murder Victim, 19 Years Old (archive footage) See fewer |
|
| Kenneth RhodenSelf - Murder Victim, 44 Years Old (archive footage) Self - Murder Victim, 44 Years Old (archive footage) See fewer |
|
 George Wagner IIISelf - Murder Suspect (archive footage) (as Billy Wagner) Self - Murder Suspect (archive footage) (as Billy Wagner) See fewer |
|
 Angela WagnerSelf - Confessed Murderer (archive footage) Self - Confessed Murderer (archive footage) See fewer |
|
 George WagnerSelf - Jake Wagner's Brother & Murder Suspect (archive footage) (as George Washington Wagner IV) Self - Jake Wagner's Brother & Murder Suspect (archive footage) (as George Washington Wagner IV) See fewer |
|
 Jake WagnerSelf - Confessed Murderer (archive footage) Self - Confessed Murderer (archive footage) See fewer |
|