 Daniel SubinSelf - Brian Winchester (voice) Self - Brian Winchester (voice) See fewer |
4 |
The Cut (I) (2024) |
 Jerry Michael WilliamsSelf - Murder Victim (archive footage) Self - Murder Victim (archive footage) See fewer |
4 |
|
| Anslee WilliamsSelf - Mike & Denise's Daughter / Self - Denise & Mike's Daughter (archive footage) Self - Mike & Denise's Daughter / Self - Denise & Mike's Daughter (archive footage) See fewer |
4 |
|
| Denise WilliamsSelf - Murderer (archive footage) Self - Murderer (archive footage) See fewer |
4 |
Meet Marry Murder (2020) |
 Page ClementsSelf - Cheryl Williams (voice) Self - Cheryl Williams (voice) See fewer |
4 |
Extra Innings (II) (2019) |
| Brian WinchesterSelf - Murderer (archive footage) Self - Murderer (archive footage) See fewer |
4 |
Meet Marry Murder (2020) |
| Cheryl WilliamsSelf - Mike's Mother (archive footage) Self - Mike's Mother (archive footage) See fewer |
4 |
The Object of Murder (2019) |
| Kathy ThomasSelf - Friend of Mike and Denise & Brian's Wife / Self - Friend of Mike and Denise & Brian's Ex-Wife (as Kathy) Self - Friend of Mike and Denise & Brian's Wife / Self - Friend of Mike and Denise & Brian's Ex-Wife (as Kathy) See fewer |
4 |
Dateline NBC (1992) |
| Jennifer WinchesterSelf - Brian's Sister Self - Brian's Sister See fewer |
4 |
Mr. & Mrs. Murder (2025) |
| Blythe NewsomeSelf - Denise's Best Friend Self - Denise's Best Friend See fewer |
4 |
Mr. & Mrs. Murder (2025) |
| Scott DungeySelf - Mike's Best Friend Self - Mike's Best Friend See fewer |
4 |
Mr. & Mrs. Murder (2025) |
| Stafford WinchesterSelf - Kathy & Brian's Son / Self - Brian & Kathy's Son (archive footage) Self - Kathy & Brian's Son / Self - Brian & Kathy's Son (archive footage) See fewer |
3 |
|
| Clay KetchamSelf - Mike's Boss Self - Mike's Boss See fewer |
3 |
The Object of Murder (2019) |
| Patti KetchamSelf - Mike's Colleague Self - Mike's Colleague See fewer |
3 |
Mr. & Mrs. Murder (2025) |
| Jennifer PortmanSelf - Journalist, Tallahassee Democrat Self - Journalist, Tallahassee Democrat See fewer |
3 |
Disappeared (2009) |
| Marcus WinchesterSelf - Brian's Father (archive footage) Self - Brian's Father (archive footage) See fewer |
2 |
|
| Will MicklerSelf - Special Agent, Florida Department of Law Enforcement Self - Special Agent, Florida Department of Law Enforcement See fewer |
2 |
Mr. & Mrs. Murder (2025) |
| Rocky AldredgeSelf - Kathy's Husband (archive footage) Self - Kathy's Husband (archive footage) See fewer |
1 |
|
| Wade WilsonSelf - Criminal (archive footage) Self - Criminal (archive footage) See fewer |
1 |
|
 Elana NoySelf - Denise Winchester (voice) Self - Denise Winchester (voice) See fewer |
1 |
Wrinkles the Clown (2019) |
| John FuchsSelf - Prosecutor (archive footage) Self - Prosecutor (archive footage) See fewer |
1 |
|
| Chuck BunkerSelf - Denise's Ex-Boyfriend (archive footage) Self - Denise's Ex-Boyfriend (archive footage) See fewer |
1 |
|
| Mike DevaneySelf - Special Agent, Florida Department of Law Enforcement (archive footage) Self - Special Agent, Florida Department of Law Enforcement (archive footage) See fewer |
1 |
Disappeared (2009) |
| David McCranieSelf - Officer, Tallahassee Police Department (archive footage) Self - Officer, Tallahassee Police Department (archive footage) See fewer |
1 |
|
| Tim JansenSelf - Brian's Defense Attorney Self - Brian's Defense Attorney See fewer |
1 |
Mr. & Mrs. Murder (2025) |
| Alton RanewSelf - Florida Fish & Wildlife Conservation Commision Self - Florida Fish & Wildlife Conservation Commision See fewer |
1 |
Disappeared (2009) |
| Tully SparkmanSelf - Investigator, State Attorney's Office Self - Investigator, State Attorney's Office See fewer |
1 |
The Object of Murder (2019) |
| Derrick WesterSelf - Detective, Jackson County Sheriff's Office Self - Detective, Jackson County Sheriff's Office See fewer |
1 |
Meet Marry Murder (2020) |
| Josey VisnovskeSelf - Special Agent, ATF Self - Special Agent, ATF See fewer |
1 |
Mr. & Mrs. Murder (2025) |
| Ethan WaySelf - Denise's Defense Attorney Self - Denise's Defense Attorney See fewer |
1 |
Mr. & Mrs. Murder (2025) |