 Rachel MillsSelf - Filmmaker Self - Filmmaker See fewer |
8 |
The Magnitudinous Illuminous (2018) |
 Peter BrendtSelf - Amateur Profiler Self - Amateur Profiler See fewer |
7 |
Monster: Hunting the Long Island Serial Killer (2025) |
 Joshua ZemanSelf - Filmmaker Self - Filmmaker See fewer |
5 |
Cropsey (2009) |
 Thomas HargroveSelf - Investigative Reporter / Self - Investigative Journalist Self - Investigative Reporter / Self - Investigative Journalist See fewer |
4 |
Proof of Life (2000) |
 Shannan GilbertSelf - Murder Victim (archive footage) Self - Murder Victim (archive footage) See fewer |
3 |
|
 Amber CostelloSelf - Murder Victim (archive footage) Self - Murder Victim (archive footage) See fewer |
3 |
|
 Robert KolkerSelf - Author, Lost Girls Self - Author, Lost Girls See fewer |
3 |
Bad Education (2019) |
 Richard DormerSelf - Former Suffolk County Police Commissioner Self - Former Suffolk County Police Commissioner See fewer |
3 |
Monster: Hunting the Long Island Serial Killer (2025) |
 Gregory CooperSelf - Former National Program Manager of ViCAP Self - Former National Program Manager of ViCAP See fewer |
3 |
Navy Seals: Untold Stories (1999) |
 Vernon GeberthSelf - Author, Practical Homicide Investigation Self - Author, Practical Homicide Investigation See fewer |
3 |
The Bone Collector (1999) |
 Amanda FunderburgSelf - Melissa's Sister (as Amanda Barthelemy) Self - Melissa's Sister (as Amanda Barthelemy) See fewer |
3 |
Monster: Hunting the Long Island Serial Killer (2025) |
 Sara KarnesSelf - Maureen's Friend Self - Maureen's Friend See fewer |
3 |
Gone Girls: The Long Island Serial Killer (2025) |
 Nancy GraceSelf (archive footage) Self (archive footage) See fewer |
2 |
Midnight Special (2016) |
 Melissa BarthelemySelf - Murder Victim (archive footage) Self - Murder Victim (archive footage) See fewer |
2 |
|
 Mari GilbertSelf - Shannan's Mother Self - Shannan's Mother See fewer |
2 |
Crime Watch Daily (2015) |
 Iwana PattonSelf - Murder Victim (archive footage) Self - Murder Victim (archive footage) See fewer |
2 |
|
 Laquetta Mae GuntherSelf - Murder Victim (archive footage) Self - Murder Victim (archive footage) See fewer |
2 |
|
 Kimberly OverstreetSelf - Amber's Sister Self - Amber's Sister See fewer |
2 |
Gone Girls: The Long Island Serial Killer (2025) |
 Barbara BreidorSelf - Murder Victim (archive footage) Self - Murder Victim (archive footage) See fewer |
2 |
|
 Molly DiltsSelf - Murder Victim (archive footage) Self - Murder Victim (archive footage) See fewer |
2 |
|
 Khalil WhiteSelf - Jessica Taylor's Boyfriend Self - Jessica Taylor's Boyfriend See fewer |
2 |
Monster: Hunting the Long Island Serial Killer (2025) |
 Julie GreenSelf - Murder Victim (archive footage) Self - Murder Victim (archive footage) See fewer |
2 |
|
 Stacey GageSelf - Murder Victim (archive footage) Self - Murder Victim (archive footage) See fewer |
2 |
|
 Jessica TaylorSelf - Murder Victim (archive footage) Self - Murder Victim (archive footage) See fewer |
2 |
|
 Tracy Ann RobertsSelf - Murder Victim (archive footage) Self - Murder Victim (archive footage) See fewer |
2 |
|
 Mike ChitwoodSelf - Daytona Beach Police (as Chief Mike Chitwood) Self - Daytona Beach Police (as Chief Mike Chitwood) See fewer |
2 |
The Dead Files (2011) |
 Thomas SpotaSelf - Suffolk County District Attorney Self - Suffolk County District Attorney See fewer |
2 |
The Killing Season (2016) |
 Lauren FranklinSelf - Associate Producer Self - Associate Producer See fewer |
2 |
Night School (II) (2016) |
 Kenna QuinetSelf - Author, The Missing Missing Self - Author, The Missing Missing See fewer |
2 |
The Killing Season (2016) |
 Bill WarnerSelf - Private Investigator / Self - Private investigator Self - Private Investigator / Self - Private investigator See fewer |
2 |
Parallels of Evil: The Bundy & Idaho Killings (2023) |
 Terry OlesonSelf - Golden Key Motel Handyman (as Terry Olesen) Self - Golden Key Motel Handyman (as Terry Olesen) See fewer |
2 |
The Killing Season (2016) |
 Christine BarberSelf - Director of Street Safe New Mexico Self - Director of Street Safe New Mexico See fewer |
2 |
The Killing Season (2016) |
 Diana Washington-ValdezSelf - Investigative Reporter (as Diane Valdez) Self - Investigative Reporter (as Diane Valdez) See fewer |
2 |
Juarez: The City Where Women Are Disposable (2007) |
 John Robert WilliamsSelf - Serial Killer (archive footage) Self - Serial Killer (archive footage) See fewer |
2 |
|
 Walter PachecoSelf - Journalist Self - Journalist See fewer |
2 |
The Killing Season (2016) |
 Ronnie TaylorSelf - Person of Interest (as Ronnie) Self - Person of Interest (as Ronnie) See fewer |
2 |
The Killing Season (2016) |
 Tricia GriffithSelf - Host, True Crime Radio Self - Host, True Crime Radio See fewer |
2 |
Sword and Scale (2014) |
 Alyssa GageSelf - Daughter of Stacey Gage Self - Daughter of Stacey Gage See fewer |
2 |
The Killing Season (2016) |
 George WalkerSelf - Private Investigator Self - Private Investigator See fewer |
2 |
The Killing Season (2016) |
 Kim RaffoSelf - Murder Victim (archive footage) Self - Murder Victim (archive footage) See fewer |
2 |
|
 Theresa FresquezSelf - Nina Herron's Mother Self - Nina Herron's Mother See fewer |
2 |
The Killing Season (2016) |
 Jeffrey BlitzSelf - Atlantic County Prosecutor 1985 - 2007 (archive footage) Self - Atlantic County Prosecutor 1985 - 2007 (archive footage) See fewer |
2 |
|
 Mo ZhangSelf - Runaway (archive footage) Self - Runaway (archive footage) See fewer |
2 |
|
 Aileen WuornosSelf - Serial Killer (archive footage) Self - Serial Killer (archive footage) See fewer |
1 |
Aileen: Life and Death of a Serial Killer (2003) |
 Gary RidgwaySelf - The Green River Killer (archive footage) Self - The Green River Killer (archive footage) See fewer |
1 |
Seeking Answers (2017) |
 Rex HeuermannSelf (voice) (rumored) Self (voice) (rumored) See fewer |
1 |
L'Interview by Antoine (2021) |
 Sherre GilbertSelf - Shannan's Sister Self - Shannan's Sister See fewer |
1 |
Disappeared (2009) |
 Robert Ben RhoadesSelf - Serial Killer (archive footage) Self - Serial Killer (archive footage) See fewer |
1 |
|
 Mark E. SafarikSelf - Former FBI Profiler (as Mark Safarik) Self - Former FBI Profiler (as Mark Safarik) See fewer |
1 |
Dreaming Darkly |
 Lorraine ElaSelf - Megan's Mother Self - Megan's Mother See fewer |
1 |
Crime Watch Daily (2015) |
 J. Buzz Von Ornsteiner Self Self See fewer |
1 |
Robot Holocaust (1987) |
 Joel RifkinSelf - Serial Killer (archive footage) Self - Serial Killer (archive footage) See fewer |
1 |
Biography (1987) |
 Megan WatermanSelf - Murder Victim (archive footage) Self - Murder Victim (archive footage) See fewer |
1 |
|
 Jazmine TrotterSelf - Murder Victim (archive footage) Self - Murder Victim (archive footage) See fewer |
1 |
|
 Melissa CannSelf - Maureen's Sister Self - Maureen's Sister See fewer |
1 |
Gone Girls: The Long Island Serial Killer (2025) |
 Bryant SimonSelf - Author, Boardwalk of Dreams Self - Author, Boardwalk of Dreams See fewer |
1 |
Blue Gold: American Jeans (2014) |
 Timothy SiniSelf - Suffolk County Police Commissioner Self - Suffolk County Police Commissioner See fewer |
1 |
Gone Girls: The Long Island Serial Killer (2025) |
 Maureen Brainard-BarnesSelf - Murder Victim (archive footage) Self - Murder Victim (archive footage) See fewer |
1 |
|
 Joseph BrewerSelf - Shannan's Last Client (archive footage) Self - Shannan's Last Client (archive footage) See fewer |
1 |
Gilgo Beach: Unsolved (2020) |
 Michael PakSelf - Shannan's Driver (archive footage) Self - Shannan's Driver (archive footage) See fewer |
1 |
A&E Presents: The Long Island Serial Killer (2011) |
 RivermanSelf - Person of Interest (archive footage) Self - Person of Interest (archive footage) See fewer |
1 |
|
 Dave SchallerSelf - Amber's Housemate Self - Amber's Housemate See fewer |
1 |
Monster: Hunting the Long Island Serial Killer (2025) |
 James BurkeSelf - Former Suffolk County Chief of Police (archive footage) Self - Former Suffolk County Chief of Police (archive footage) See fewer |
1 |
Gilgo Beach: Unsolved (2020) |
 Steve BelloneSelf - Suffolk County Executive (archive footage) Self - Suffolk County Executive (archive footage) See fewer |
1 |
Gone Girls: The Long Island Serial Killer (2025) |
 Heidi BalchSelf - Murder Victim of Joel Rifkin (archive footage) Self - Murder Victim of Joel Rifkin (archive footage) See fewer |
1 |
|
 Lorenzo MontoyaSelf - Suspected Serial Killer (archive footage) Self - Suspected Serial Killer (archive footage) See fewer |
1 |
|
 Heather SaulSelf - Escort (as Heather) Self - Escort (as Heather) See fewer |
1 |
Jensen & Holes: The Murder Squad (2019) |
 Joe Scalise Jr.Self - Oak Beach Resident (as Joe Jr.) Self - Oak Beach Resident (as Joe Jr.) See fewer |
1 |
The Killing Season (2016) |
 Anthony SowellSelf - Serial Killer (archive footage) Self - Serial Killer (archive footage) See fewer |
1 |
|
 Vanessa VeselkaSelf - Writer Self - Writer See fewer |
1 |
Veeps (2013) |
 Victoria Ann ChavezSelf - Murder Victim (archive footage) Self - Murder Victim (archive footage) See fewer |
1 |
Crime Junkie (2017) |
 Nina HerronSelf - Murder Victim (archive footage) Self - Murder Victim (archive footage) See fewer |
1 |
|
 Michelle ValdezSelf - Murder Victim (archive footage) Self - Murder Victim (archive footage) See fewer |
1 |
Crime Junkie (2017) |
 Billy Mansfield Jr.Self - Serial Killer (archive footage) Self - Serial Killer (archive footage) See fewer |
1 |
|
 Evelyn SalazarSelf - Murder Victim (archive footage) Self - Murder Victim (archive footage) See fewer |
1 |
Crime Junkie (2017) |
 Jamie BarelaSelf - Murder Victim (archive footage) Self - Murder Victim (archive footage) See fewer |
1 |
Crime Junkie (2017) |
 Lyda LongaSelf - Reporter, Daytona Beach News-Journal Self - Reporter, Daytona Beach News-Journal See fewer |
1 |
THS Investigates (2005) |
 John RaySelf - Gilbert Family Lawyer Self - Gilbert Family Lawyer See fewer |
1 |
The Gilgo Beach Killer: House of Secrets (2025) |
 Laura CowanSelf - Community Activist Self - Community Activist See fewer |
1 |
Out of Darkness: Cleveland (2018) |
 Doreen MarquezSelf - Murder Victim (archive footage) Self - Murder Victim (archive footage) See fewer |
1 |
Crime Junkie (2017) |
 Ashley LeszyeskiSelf - Murder Victim (archive footage) Self - Murder Victim (archive footage) See fewer |
1 |
|
 Joseph Raymond BleaSelf - Serial Killer (archive footage) Self - Serial Killer (archive footage) See fewer |
1 |
|
 Felipa GonzalesSelf - Murder Victim (archive footage) Self - Murder Victim (archive footage) See fewer |
1 |
|
 Lynn BarthelemySelf - Melissa's Mother Self - Melissa's Mother See fewer |
1 |
Monster: Hunting the Long Island Serial Killer (2025) |
 Robert ShulmanSelf - Serial Killer (archive footage) Self - Serial Killer (archive footage) See fewer |
1 |
|
 Ida LopezSelf - Detective, Missing Persons (archive footage) Self - Detective, Missing Persons (archive footage) See fewer |
1 |
Dateline: Secrets Uncovered (2017) |
 Peter HackettSelf - Former Head of Suffolk County Emergency Medical Services (archive footage) Self - Former Head of Suffolk County Emergency Medical Services (archive footage) See fewer |
1 |
Crime Watch Daily (2015) |
 Christine Marie MaloneSelf - Murder Victim (archive footage) Self - Murder Victim (archive footage) See fewer |
1 |
|
 Stacey DittmerSelf - Laquetta's Friend Self - Laquetta's Friend See fewer |
1 |
Hometown Tragedy (2021) |
 Julie NietoSelf - Murder Victim (archive footage) Self - Murder Victim (archive footage) See fewer |
1 |
Crime Junkie (2017) |
 Anthony MontanoSelf - Albuquerque Police Department (archive footage) (as Cmdr Anthony Montano) Self - Albuquerque Police Department (archive footage) (as Cmdr Anthony Montano) See fewer |
1 |
Etalk Daily (2002) |
 Erika SmithSelf - Doreen Chavez's Friend Self - Doreen Chavez's Friend See fewer |
1 |
The Killing Season (2016) |
 Bob CacciabaudoSelf - Found Heidi Balch's Remains Self - Found Heidi Balch's Remains See fewer |
1 |
The Killing Season (2016) |
 Joyce LeszyeskiSelf - Ashlley Leszyeski's Mother Self - Ashlley Leszyeski's Mother See fewer |
1 |
The Killing Season (2016) |
 Denise HillSelf - Local Sex Worker Self - Local Sex Worker See fewer |
1 |
The Killing Season (2016) |
 Virginia ClovenSelf - Murder Victim (archive footage) Self - Murder Victim (archive footage) See fewer |
1 |
Crime Junkie (2017) |
 Monica CandelariaSelf - Murder Victim (archive footage) Self - Murder Victim (archive footage) See fewer |
1 |
Crime Junkie (2017) |
 Joyce VanderhoffSelf - Murder Victim (archive footage) Self - Murder Victim (archive footage) See fewer |
1 |
|
 Casey Jo PipestemSelf - Murder Victim (archive footage) Self - Murder Victim (archive footage) See fewer |
1 |
|
 Ray SchultzSelf - Albuquerque Police Department 2005 - 2013 (archive footage) (as Chief Ray Schultz) Self - Albuquerque Police Department 2005 - 2013 (archive footage) (as Chief Ray Schultz) See fewer |
1 |
|
 Buff HarrisSelf - Private Security Self - Private Security See fewer |
1 |
The Killing Season (2016) |
 Gary MansfieldSelf - Brother of Billy Mansfield (archive footage) Self - Brother of Billy Mansfield (archive footage) See fewer |
1 |
|
 Joseph FisherSelf - Author, Killer Among Us: Public Reactions to Serial Murder Self - Author, Killer Among Us: Public Reactions to Serial Murder See fewer |
1 |
The Killing Season (2016) |
 Vanessa ReedSelf - Murder Victim (archive footage) Self - Murder Victim (archive footage) See fewer |
1 |
|
 The SeekerSelf - Websleuth & Ex-Law Enforcement Self - Websleuth & Ex-Law Enforcement See fewer |
1 |
The Killing Season (2016) |
 Jeff MartinaSelf - Melissa's Stepfather Self - Melissa's Stepfather See fewer |
1 |
Monster: Hunting the Long Island Serial Killer (2025) |
 Timothy BolgerSelf - Managing Editor, Long Island Press Self - Managing Editor, Long Island Press See fewer |
1 |
Monster: Hunting the Long Island Serial Killer (2025) |
 Peter G. GillespieSelf - Producer, America's Most Wanted (as Peter Gillespie) Self - Producer, America's Most Wanted (as Peter Gillespie) See fewer |
1 |
Bride Killa (2018) |
 Larry HallmarkSelf - Grapevine Police Dept. (voice) (as Lt. Larry Hallmark) Self - Grapevine Police Dept. (voice) (as Lt. Larry Hallmark) See fewer |
1 |
Forensic Files (1996) |
 Cinnamon ElksSelf - Murder Victim (archive footage) Self - Murder Victim (archive footage) See fewer |
1 |
Crime Junkie (2017) |
| Dakota TaelorSelf (archive footage) (as Justin Gwin) Self (archive footage) (as Justin Gwin) See fewer |
1 |
Detour (2019) |
 Angelique MaloneSelf - Christine Malone's Daughter Self - Christine Malone's Daughter See fewer |
1 |
The First 48 (2004) |
 Zack ReedSelf - Cleveland Councilman, Ward 2 Self - Cleveland Councilman, Ward 2 See fewer |
1 |
The Killing Season (2016) |
 Neal FallsSelf - Suspected Serial Killer (archive footage) Self - Suspected Serial Killer (archive footage) See fewer |
1 |
|
 Mike KingSelf - Retired Profiler Self - Retired Profiler See fewer |
1 |
The Killing Season (2016) |
| Jeff HintonSelf - Audio Engineer (voice) Self - Audio Engineer (voice) See fewer |
1 |
The Killing Season (2016) |
 Veronica RomeroSelf - Murder Victim (archive footage) Self - Murder Victim (archive footage) See fewer |
1 |
Crime Junkie (2017) |
 Darren VannSelf - Serial Killer (archive footage) Self - Serial Killer (archive footage) See fewer |
1 |
|
 Melissa BishopSelf - Former Acquaintance of Terry Oleson Self - Former Acquaintance of Terry Oleson See fewer |
1 |
The Killing Season (2016) |
 Jim McClainSelf - Atlantic County Prosecutor (archive footage) Self - Atlantic County Prosecutor (archive footage) See fewer |
1 |
|
 Michael MadisonSelf - Serial Killer (archive footage) Self - Serial Killer (archive footage) See fewer |
1 |
|
 Terri TurnerSelf - Criminal Analyst Self - Criminal Analyst See fewer |
1 |
The Killing Season (2016) |
| Joe FotiSelf - Former Suffolk County Correctional Officer (voice) Self - Former Suffolk County Correctional Officer (voice) See fewer |
1 |
The Killing Season (2016) |
 Cynical_1Self - Websleuth Self - Websleuth See fewer |
1 |
The Killing Season (2016) |
 SarahSelf - 'Lot Lizard' Self - 'Lot Lizard' See fewer |
1 |
The Killing Season (2016) |
 Jayne Perea BarelaSelf - Jamie Barela's Mother Self - Jamie Barela's Mother See fewer |
1 |
The Killing Season (2016) |
 Hugh AuslanderSelf - Kim's Ex-Husband Self - Kim's Ex-Husband See fewer |
1 |
The Killing Season (2016) |
 HawkshawSelf - Websleuth Self - Websleuth See fewer |
1 |
The Killing Season (2016) |
 Maggie ShepardSelf - Journalist Self - Journalist See fewer |
1 |
The Killing Season (2016) |
 Joe ScaliseSelf - Oak Beach Resident Self - Oak Beach Resident See fewer |
1 |
Unraveled (2021) |
 John KellySelf - Criminal Profiler Self - Criminal Profiler See fewer |
1 |
The Killing Season (2016) |
 Jeff ProctorSelf - Journalist Self - Journalist See fewer |
1 |
The Killing Season (2016) |
 James Dewayne AllenSelf - Sex Offender (archive footage) Self - Sex Offender (archive footage) See fewer |
1 |
|
| Ellen BissettSelf - Bissett Family Spokesperson (voice) Self - Bissett Family Spokesperson (voice) See fewer |
1 |
The Killing Season (2016) |
 Andrew JochemsSelf - Field Geologist Self - Field Geologist See fewer |
1 |
The Killing Season (2016) |
 Maryclaire AkersSelf - Senior Assistant Prosecuting Attorney Self - Senior Assistant Prosecuting Attorney See fewer |
1 |
The Killing Season (2016) |
 Monique WilliamsSelf - Jazmine Trotter's Mother Self - Jazmine Trotter's Mother See fewer |
1 |
The Killing Season (2016) |
 Kathleen LydonSelf - Joyce's Grandmother Self - Joyce's Grandmother See fewer |
1 |
The Killing Season (2016) |
 James BissettSelf - Long Island Aquarium Co-Owner (archive footage) Self - Long Island Aquarium Co-Owner (archive footage) See fewer |
1 |
|
 Brad WisecraverSelf - Long Haul Trucker Self - Long Haul Trucker See fewer |
1 |
The Killing Season (2016) |
 Cydney LongSelf - NBC10 Philadelphia (archive footage) Self - NBC10 Philadelphia (archive footage) See fewer |
1 |
KYW Eyewitness News (1965) |
| Mark ManarySelf - Lead Investigator, 118th St. Task Force (voice) (as Detective Mark Manary) Self - Lead Investigator, 118th St. Task Force (voice) (as Detective Mark Manary) See fewer |
1 |
The Killing Season (2016) |
 Alex GoldsmithSelf - Reporter KRQE 13News (archive footage) Self - Reporter KRQE 13News (archive footage) See fewer |
1 |
|
 Steve CooperSelf - Chief of Detectives (as Lt. Steve Cooper) Self - Chief of Detectives (as Lt. Steve Cooper) See fewer |
1 |
The Killing Season (2016) |
 Matthew DemartinSelf - Private Security Self - Private Security See fewer |
1 |
The Killing Season (2016) |
 Eleanor GriegoSelf - Julie Nieto's Mother Self - Julie Nieto's Mother See fewer |
1 |
The Killing Season (2016) |
 Brian BatesSelf - Video Vigilante Self - Video Vigilante See fewer |
1 |
20/20 (1993) |
 Carlk90245Self - Websleuth Self - Websleuth See fewer |
1 |
The Killing Season (2016) |
 Robert AndersonSelf - Jack the Ripper Expert Self - Jack the Ripper Expert See fewer |
1 |
The Killing Season (2016) |
 Joseph GoldsteinSelf - Reporter, New York Times Self - Reporter, New York Times See fewer |
1 |
The Daily (2017) |
 Shannon BungartSelf - Street Safe New Mexico Self - Street Safe New Mexico See fewer |
1 |
The Killing Season (2016) |
 Siree GonzalesSelf - Monica Romero's Cousin Self - Monica Romero's Cousin See fewer |
1 |
The Killing Season (2016) |
 Mark DittmerSelf - Laquetta's Friend Self - Laquetta's Friend See fewer |
1 |
The Killing Season (2016) |
 Tom DavisSelf - Criminal Profiler Self - Criminal Profiler See fewer |
1 |
The Killing Season (2016) |
 Karen JacksonSelf - Michelle Valdez's Mother Self - Michelle Valdez's Mother See fewer |
1 |
The Killing Season (2016) |
 Mike BissellSelf - Mechanic Self - Mechanic See fewer |
1 |
The Killing Season (2016) |
 Jim HutchinsSelf - Ret. Vice Squad Captain, Atlantic City PD Self - Ret. Vice Squad Captain, Atlantic City PD See fewer |
1 |
The Killing Season (2016) |
 David FabianicSelf - Professor, Criminal Justice Department at University of Central Florida (archive footage) Self - Professor, Criminal Justice Department at University of Central Florida (archive footage) See fewer |
1 |
|
| FieldnotesSelf - Websleuth (voice) Self - Websleuth (voice) See fewer |
1 |
The Killing Season (2016) |
 Verner DiltsSelf - Father of Molly Dilts (voice) (as Verner Diltz) Self - Father of Molly Dilts (voice) (as Verner Diltz) See fewer |
1 |
The Killing Season (2016) |
| John DeAngelisSelf - Former Egg Harbor Police Captain (voice) Self - Former Egg Harbor Police Captain (voice) See fewer |
1 |
The Killing Season (2016) |
 James Leonard Jr.Self - Atlantic City Lawyer (as James Leonard) Self - Atlantic City Lawyer (as James Leonard) See fewer |
1 |
The Killing Season (2016) |
 SuperSelf - Escort Self - Escort See fewer |
1 |
The Killing Season (2016) |