 Walter BanasiakWalter / Walter - Host / Walter - Co-Host / Zack Snyder / Evil Walter / … See more Walter / Walter - Host / Walter - Co-Host / Zack Snyder / Evil Walter / Walter-Co-Host / Luigi Mario / Michael Caine / Stan Lee / Walter- Host / Walter(Cameo) / Walter (Cameo) / Walter - Co- Host / Walter-co-host / Priest / Flaxen Phalanges See fewer |
123 |
Nostalgia Critic (2007) |
| Heather ReuszHeather / Heather - Co-Host / Heather- Co-Host / Mario Mario / Evil Heather / … See more Heather / Heather - Co-Host / Heather- Co-Host / Mario Mario / Evil Heather / Heather - Host / Heather-Co-Host / Heather-Co-host / Heather-co-host / Clone Heather See fewer |
59 |
Nostalgia Critic (2007) |
| Aiyanna WadeAiyanna / Aiyanna - Co-Host / Evil Aiyanna / Aiyanna-Co-Host / Princess Peach / Aiyanna-co-host Aiyanna / Aiyanna - Co-Host / Evil Aiyanna / Aiyanna-Co-Host / Princess Peach / Aiyanna-co-host See fewer |
55 |
Nostalgia Critic (2007) |
| James JaroszJim / Indiana Jim / Captain Jim Sparrow / Superman / Joker Jim / Indiana Jim / Captain Jim Sparrow / Superman / Joker See fewer |
28 |
Nostalgia Critic (2007) |
 Doug WalkerNostalgia Critic / Doug / Michael Bay Nostalgia Critic / Doug / Michael Bay See fewer |
14 |
Nostalgia Critic (2007) |
 Rob WalkerDino Rob / Rob / Dark Dino Rob Dino Rob / Rob / Dark Dino Rob See fewer |
11 |
Nostalgia Critic (2007) |
| Tamara ChambersTamara / Tamara - Co-Host / Hyper Fangirl / Malice Tamara / Tamara - Co-Host / Hyper Fangirl / Malice See fewer |
10 |
Nostalgia Critic (2007) |
| Malcolm RayMalcolm / Malcolm- Co-Host / Joker / Black Willy Wonka Malcolm / Malcolm- Co-Host / Joker / Black Willy Wonka See fewer |
7 |
Demo Reel (2012) |
| Bryan PorterBryan / Batman Bryan / Batman See fewer |
6 |
Nostalgia Critic (2007) |
| Barney Walker Barney Barney See fewer |
5 |
Atop the Fourth Wall: The Movie (2015) |
| Jennifer ReuszHeather Reusz / Jennifer Heather Reusz / Jennifer See fewer |
2 |
Top 5 Best/Worst (2016) |
| Michael Lablanca Michael Michael See fewer |
2 |
Top 5 Best/Worst (2016) |
| Allen Panakal Allen Allen See fewer |
1 |
Mi Familia Es Tu Familia (Ant Dip) (2013) |
| Lucas Durham Lucas Lucas See fewer |
1 |
FanScription (2018) |
| Adam Rice Adam Adam See fewer |
1 |
Snakebite Protection Chronicles (2017) |
| Anthony Bunnell Anthony Anthony See fewer |
1 |
Top 5 Best/Worst (2016) |
 Matt Mikka Matt Matt See fewer |
1 |
Situation X |
| Anthony LaBanca Anthony Anthony See fewer |
1 |
I'm Still Here (2009) |
| HelloGreedo Self Self See fewer |
1 |
Star Wars Explained (2015) |
| Ryan Grino Ryan Ryan See fewer |
1 |
Top 5 Best/Worst (2016) |
| Brad Jones Brad Brad See fewer |
1 |
Freak Out (2003) |
| Alyssamay Griño Alyssamay Alyssamay See fewer |
1 |
The Infinity Trinity (2012) |