Framing the future of food: The contested promises of alternative proteins - PubMed (original) (raw)
Framing the future of food: The contested promises of alternative proteins
Alexandra E Sexton et al. Environ Plan E Nat Space. 2019 Mar.
Abstract
This paper offers a critical examination of the narrative landscape that has emerged with a new movement of alternative proteins intended as substitutes for conventional meat, milk and other animal-based food products. The alternative protein approaches analysed include edible insects, plant-based proteins and cellular agriculture, the latter of which encompasses 'cultured' or 'clean' meat, milk and egg products produced in vitro via cell-science methods. We build on previous research that has analysed the promissory narratives specific to cultured/clean meat by examining the key promises that have worked across the broader alternative protein movement. In doing so, we develop a five-fold typology that outlines the distinct yet interconnected claims that have operated in alternative protein promotional discourses to date. The second part of the paper examines the counter-narratives that have emerged in response to alternative protein claims from different stakeholders linked to conventional livestock production. We offer a second typology of three counter-narratives that have so far characterised these responses. Through mapping this narrative landscape, we show how different types of 'goodness' have been ascribed by alternative protein and conventional livestock stakeholders to their respective approaches. Moreover, our analysis reveals a series of tensions underpinning these contested food futures, many of which have long histories in broader debates over what constitutes better (protein) food production and consumption. The paper's discussion contributes to ongoing research across the social sciences on the ontological politics of (good) food, and the key role of narratives in constructing and contesting visions of 'better' food futures.
Keywords: Alternative proteins; cultured meat; good food; livestock; promise.
© The Author(s) 2019.
Figures
Figure 1.
The Beyond Burger weigh in. Source:
(accessed 7 June 2018).
Figure 2.
The Wicked Healthy cookbook. Source:
www.wickedhealthyfood.com/wicked-healthy-cookbook/
(accessed 13 July 2018).
Figure 3.
The vegetarian butcher. Source:
www.telegraph.co.uk/food-and-drink/features/mock-meat-the-rise-of-the-vegetarian-butcher/
(accessed 13 July 2018).
Figure 4.
Figure identifying the three flashpoints (centre column) between the promissory narratives of alternative proteins (left) and the counter-narratives of the livestock industry (right).
References
- Adams C. (1990) The Sexual Politics of meat: A Feminist-Vegetarian Critical Theory, Cambridge: Polity Press.
- AFP (2018) Existential debate in food industry: What is meat? CTV News. Available at: www.ctvnews.ca/lifestyle/existential-debate-in-food-industry-what-is-mea... (accessed 9 June 2018).
- Aguiar LLM, Schneider CJ. (2016) Researching amongst Elites: Challenges and Opportunities in Studying Up, Abingdon: Routledge.
- Alexandratos N and Bruinsma J (2012) World agriculture towards 2030/2050. The 2012 revision, FAO. Available at: www.fao.org/docrep/016/ap106e/ap106e.pdf (accessed 13 July 2018).
- Allied Market Research (2017) Protein Supplement Market by Type (Casein, Whey Protein, Egg Protein, Soy Protein, and Others), Form (Powder, RTD Liquid, and Protein Bars), Source (Animal and Plant), and Distribution Channel (Supermarket/Hypermarket, Online, Chemist/Drugstore, Nutrition. Available at: www.alliedmarketresearch.com/protein-supplement-market (accessed 11 July 2018).
LinkOut - more resources
Full Text Sources