Dark and Troubled Past (original) (raw)

And the book says, "We may be through with the past, but the past ain't through with us."

Something terrible happened to a character; some tragic event in their past that shaped a fundamental level of their personality. Long after the event is over, it still has a powerful influence on the character's life.

The root effects are usually:

• Self-hatred via My Greatest Failure and/or Personal Horror.
• Outward distrust because of being betrayed.
• Inward callousness coupled with outward hate because of a Freudian Excuse such as abandonment, trauma, or death of a loved one.

Usually involves one or more of the following:

• A dead loved one: parents, siblings, best friend, spouse, children, or a whole Doomed Hometown.
• Physical and, sometimes, sexual abuse by parents or lover.
• Being abandoned by one or both parents.
• Being tortured or raped, or being Forced to Watch it happen to a friend or loved one.
• A criminal past, usually with remorse.
• Being caught up on the wrong side of war.
• Being betrayed by a True Companion or Heterosexual Life Partner/Platonic Life Partner.
• Having a Love Interest not dump them, but get Stuffed in the Fridge.
• Killing any of the above, whether in self-defense, recklessly or through a Sadistic Choice.
• Being ostracized or bullied by your classmates, siblings or others around you. Or having a Friendless Background.
• Being Made a Slave, especially if it involves being forced to fight as a Gladiator or being made a Sex Slave.
• Being raised as a Child Soldier or a Tyke-Bomb.
• Any of the above, but being experienced during childhood.

Expect to see the above overlap for extra Angst or Wangst.

This is a stock Backstory for a character. Much like a Mysterious Past, except more tragic and troubled. Don't expect it to be revealed all at once, or sometimes at all. It usually gets revealed in small doses through a Troubled Backstory Flashback as the story progresses; possibly in a Flashback Nightmare where a happy memory transforms into a slaughter. It could also be a Somber Backstory Revelation when the person with the Dark and Troubled Past decides to share their storied history with someone they trust or respect. Often used as a Freudian Excuse for an asocial character's Jerkass tendencies or quiet stoicism. If the character's past is as simple as his pet ant being stepped on by his Annoying Younger Sibling, this trope ultimately becomes comedic. Still, it is understandable that the character wants to keep it secret because They're Called "Personal Issues" for a Reason, after all.

This can lead to either becoming an Anti-Hero. For villains, this is a Start of Darkness. Especially blatant cases of this trope will result in the character being seen as a Sympathetic Sue.

Female characters with a Dark and Troubled Past include the Dark Magical Girl and the Broken Bird. Male characters with a Dark and Troubled Past are instant bait for the Estrogen Brigade who have bought him leather pants. Expect all nearby female characters to become afflicted with an attraction to his Troubled, but Cute appeal, and try to help him heal his heart. Not happening. Or maybe it will?

The step-up of this trope is the Dysfunction Junction, where the whole cast will have one of these and suffer from it, too (and don't expect them to get better). If the afflicted character is in a law enforcement profession, see Standard Cop Backstory. When paired with a Nice Guy or gal with a happy upbringing, you can expect… interesting results. See Deus Angst Machina. May be introduced as a Blissfully Horrific Backstory.

Example subpages:

• Anime & Manga
  • Demon Slayer: Kimetsu no Yaiba
  • One Piece
• Comic Books
• Fan Works
• Films
• Literature
• Live-Action TV
• Video Games
  • Bioware
  • Final Fantasy
• Visual Novels
• Web Animation
• Web Comics
• Web Original
• Western Animation

Other examples:

open/close all folders

Manhwa

• In Westwood Vibrato, many of Cornelia's customers have these. As well as Cornel herself.

Music

• The Patient from The Black Parade is implied to have had a violent past, in which he committed many misdeeds.
• Pink from Pink Floyd's The Wall. His father died in the war, his mother is over-protective, he was tortured by sadistic teachers...no wonder that, when his marriage collapsed, he isolated himself from the rest of the world and became a fascist dictator in his imaginary world. What's more, Pink was strongly based on Pink Floyd bassist Roger Waters and his similarly-troubled life.
• The patient in The Antlers' album Hospice certainly qualifies.
• Luca Turilli uses this trope whenever he can.
  Lord Of The Winter Snow: Back again to my tragic past
  Demonheart: Shocked again she opened the gates / of her tragic past and bloody images / came back to her mind
  Dargor; Shadowlord of the Black Mountain: For his tragic past he disowned the sunlight
  Legend of Steel: Break the chains of the past forever
  Black Dragon: Had to fight the reputation of his bloody past
  Dawn of Victory: Shades of a past not so far to forget... / the rise of the demons from their bloody Hell!
  • Bloody Hell! He couldn't break the chains of this reputation.
• The protagonist from The Rolling Stones' "Jumpin' Jack Flash", which has him born and raised in an abusive household and abandoned at some point in his childhood. It's hinted in the chorus that he's gotten over it, albeit not in one piece, given the nature of the song.
• Dr. Light, as told by The Protomen. His father died in a mining accident, leading him to build robots to do the work instead and "take the death away". Unfortunately, things do not improve from here.
• Almost the entire cast of the Evillous Chronicles. Venomania was locked in a basement and horribly bullied because of a small deformity, and then the only person who accepted him turned on him; Conchita's mother was abusive; Riliane's parents died and she was forced to ascend the throne while still a little kid; Margarita's true love completely ignored her, which sent her over the Despair Event Horizon; Lukana's family died in a fire; and Gallerian's family was killed by a Giant Octopus possibly by MA or Nemesis while Nemesis never knew her father, Gallerian, was abandoned for some time by her mother, and later was forced to kill the man she loved by her boss. No wonder they're all so fucked up. And that's only a few of them.
• The conjoined twins from Evelyn Evelyn had their mother die in childbirth, their father killed, and their doctor killed all within minutes of birth. They were kidnapped by a chicken farmer who raised them in a cage amongst chickens. When he died a few years later, they ran of but ended up picked up by a brothel masquerading as an orphanage. At age thirteen they were given to a circus due to being "too old" for the men. At the circus, they were abused and harassed until they ran away a few years later.
• Two of the four fictional Gorillaz members:
  • Murdoc had a severely messed up childhood. He was abandoned on his father's doorstep as a baby, forced to participate in talent shows for measly amounts of money to pay for his dad's drinking habit, was beat up by his brother Hannibal and Hannibal's friends, got bullied in school, and was sexually abused by a dinner lady when he was nine.
  • Russel was possessed by a demon as a young child, which sent him on a rampage that destroyed his school, caused him to fall into a coma, and got him expelled. When he woke up from his coma, he attended a public high school where he made friends...all of whom died in a drive-by shooting.

Podcasts

• In In Strange Woods, Howl has a twofer, with episode 2 going into his sordid past with Gerda, a war correspondent, and his time in the Marines. Episode 4 delves into his childhood as part of a family of war profiteers and his murder, by inaction, of people working at a chemical plant.
• It's mostly played for laughs in Sequinox, but Sid claims to have come from a town where the only thing they celebrated was surviving the winter, and it's very possible she has killed someone.
• Belle from Pokemon: Adventures in the Millennium. She came from an abusive home, joined Team Rocket only to realize they were just taking advantage of her, and abandoned her Pokemon because she felt like she couldn't be a good trainer to them. Not to mention the baggage she has with her old partner, Starr.

Tabletop Games

• In Psionics: The Next Stage in Human Evolution the book states that there is a correlation between the manifestation of psionic talent and childhood trauma, although no causal link has been established. It also specifies that most espers have pronounced emotional problems.

Theatre

• In Chess, Florence's father disappeared during the 1956 Budapest uprising.
• Many of the dancers in A Chorus Line have one, but this is especially emphasized with Sheila, Bebe, Maggie, Bobby, and Paul, who experienced a gamut of issues from Parental Neglect to sexual abuse.
• Into the Woods:
  • The Baker was led to believe that both of his parents died when he was a baby in a freak baking accident. It drives him to want to create his own, happier family with his wife.
  • The Witch was cursed by her mother to be ugly after she failed to prevent The Baker's father from stealing the magic beans in her garden. She agrees to put a stop to the curse giving The Baker's family infertility if he and his wife get her the ingredients to make a potion that will reverse her mother's curse. Her insecurity over her looks also factors into her possessiveness over Rapunzel, thinking the girl wants to elope with the prince because she is "old and ugly" and embarrasses Rapunzel.
  • Cinderella's mother died when she was young and her father remarried a Wicked Stepmother with equally horrible daughters, turning a blind eye to their abuse of Cinderella. The only advice each parent gave to her to cope with the situation was for her to be "good" and "nice", which unfortunately made her passive and easily taken advantage of.
• The Phantom in The Phantom of the Opera was used as a circus sideshow freak until he escaped.
• In Pokémon Live!, Ash's mother Delia Ketchum used to go out with the head of Team Rocket, Giovanni.
• Siegfried in Richard Wagner's Ring of the Nibelung: An orphan, with the additional guilt-inducing bonus of knowing that his mother died giving birth to him, raised by Mime to be used to kill Fafner for his hoard and the ring. Although he doesn't know it yet, his parents Siegmund and Sieglind were siblings, and his scheming grandfather Wälse alias Wotan also wanted to use Siegfried as a pawn in a longterm project and Wotan's enemy Alberich also would like to get rid of him. Sieglind saw her mother killed and was kidnapped and forced into a loveless marriage, then had to witness her brother and lover killed (which was also due to Wotan's intervention). Small wonder that one of the leitmotifs is called the Wälsungen suffering motive (Wälsungenleidmotiv).
• Mary in Vanities has an alcoholic mother and runaway father; she sings about her desire to get away from it all in "Fly Into the Future".
• In Wicked, Elphaba was seen as a freak from the moment she was born due to her green skin. Her mother chews milk flowers in a desperate bid to make sure the next child has a normal skin tone, which technically works, but it causes her mother to experience Death by Childbirth and the second child Nessarose to be born a paraplegic. Elphaba blames herself for this, not helped by the fact that she is blatantly The Unfavorite of her father. Elphaba is extremely protective of Nessa due to this and has developed a rather caustic personality in the present day.