Annissa Gultom | The University of the Arts (original) (raw)
Papers by Annissa Gultom
ICOFOM Conference 2024, 2024
[Paper of this presentation is available in this platform to provide contexts and details] Muse... more [Paper of this presentation is available in this platform to provide contexts and details]
Museums are colonial products that were not only physically imposed on occupied land in the past but later became mandatory for an area to be considered "modern" or "civilized." The United Arab Emirates early museums were not "brought" by the pre-Second World War colonial power, but their establishment seems to be a requirement for an upcoming "new nation". The two leading sheikhdoms established the two oldest museums during the union's formation. The oldest museum on the land, the Al Ain (National) Museum in Abu Dhabi, was developed in 1969, with a temporary exhibition inside the Sultan Fort while waiting for the newly built building. The museum opened on 2 November 1971, a month before the union's birthday. The Dubai Museum was opened to the public in the Al Fahidi Fort in the same year. Both museums consist of two main topics: archaeology (3800BC-300AD) and the ethnography of "pre-oil" life (1800s-1971). The other five unified emirates followed suit by establishing their "fort museums" with similar content in different decades after. This pattern is typical in postcolonial states that emerged in the post-Second World War decolonization.
Postcolonial museums are an institutionalized culture with European-based "ideals", which intrigues the need for native and indigenous voices in Museology. As the maturity of native anthropology, decolonization, biculturalism, and local community museums grew, the "ideals" altered during the localized movement. The wave of UAE museum renewal started in 2006, a motion that brought in international consultants, experts and museum-specific skilled personnel. They backboned the establishment of today's prominent UAE museums while the country is developing a generation of Emirati museologists. This naturally moulded multinational museum teams who brought their versions of museum ideals. The richness of their perspectives is adjusted -to some extent- to the local setting and identity. Although often, the visualizations are in similar beige, red, or black-white monochrome hues.
Ras Al Khaimah National Museum (RAKNM) is among the ones eager for change, especially in expanding its abstract space to serve as RAK's abundant cultural resource. RAKNM dismantled its 30+ y.o permanent display of ethnography galleries and started a series of temporary exhibits. Inspired by Te Papa Museum's "Maorification, " the team gathered and co-curated Emirati vocabularies, voices, personal accounts, and collective memories while discovering generational evolution and knowledge gaps. In different projects, we have worked with an active old garden on the topics of date palm cultural heritage and madbasa (date juice extraction room); a retired police officer to document local dialects vocabularies for riffles from the 19th - 20th AD; a local private collector that collects daily items popularly used by people growing up in the Emirates in the 70s and a number of female Emirati staff on family jewellery. For upcoming projects in Emirati weddings and written memories in Manuscripts, we will include previous ethnographic documentations, observe the topics’ evolution, identify gaps and present another story of culture’s fluidity.
ICOFOM ConferenceDoha, 2024
Museums are colonial products that were not only physically imposed on occupied land in the past ... more Museums are colonial products that were not only physically imposed on occupied land in the past but later became mandatory for an area to be considered "modern" or "civilized." United Arab Emirates early museums were not "brought" by the pre-Second World War colonial power, but their establishment seems to be a requirement for an upcoming "new nation". The two leading sheikhdoms established the two oldest museums during the union's formation. The oldest museum on the land, the Al Ain (National) Museum in Abu Dhabi, was developed in 1969, with a temporary exhibition inside the Sultan Fort while waiting for the newly built building. The museum opened on 2 November 1971, a month before the union's birthday. The Dubai Museum was opened to the public in the Al Fahidi Fort in the same year. Both museums consist of two main topics: archaeology (3800BC-300AD) and the ethnography of "pre-oil" life (1800s-1971). The other five unified emirates followed suit by establishing their "fort museums" with similar content in different decades after. This pattern is typical in postcolonial states that emerged in the post-Second World War decolonization.
Postcolonial museums are an institutionalized culture with European-based "ideals", which intrigues the need for native and indigenous voices in Museology. As the maturity of native anthropology, decolonization, biculturalism, and local community museums grew, the "ideals" altered during the localized movement. The wave of UAE museum renewal started in 2006, a motion that brought in international consultants, experts and museum-specific skilled personnel. They backboned the establishment of today's prominent UAE museums while the country is developing a generation of Emirati museologists. This naturally moulded multinational museum teams who brought their versions of museum ideals. The richness of their perspectives is adjusted -to some extent- to the local setting and identity. Although often, the visualizations are in similar beige, red, or black-white monochrome hues.
Ras Al Khaimah National Museum (RAKNM) is among the ones eager for change, especially in expanding its abstract space to serve as RAK's abundant cultural resource. RAKNM dismantled its 30+ y.o permanent display of ethnography galleries and started a series of temporary exhibits. Inspired by Te Papa Museum's "Maorification, " the team gathered and co-curated Emirati vocabularies, voices, personal accounts, and collective memories while discovering generational evolution and knowledge gaps. In different projects, we have worked with an active old garden on the topics of date palm cultural heritage and madbasa (date juice extraction room); a retired police officer to document local dialects vocabularies for riffles from the 19th - 20th AD; a local private collector that collects daily items popularly used by people growing up in the Emirates in the 70s and a number of female Emirati staff on family jewellery. For upcoming projects in Emirati weddings and written memories in Manuscripts, we will include previous ethnographic documentations, observe the topics’ evolution, identify gaps and present another story of culture’s fluidity.
National Geographic Indonesia, 2021
Kopi tidak hanya sekedar seduhan berkafein yang aroma dan rasanya membangunkan jiwa manusia, teta... more Kopi tidak hanya sekedar seduhan berkafein yang aroma dan rasanya membangunkan jiwa manusia, tetapi kini juga menjadi bagian dari identitas diri. Rapat di pagi hari tidak lengkap tanpa hadirnya kopi. Darimana kopi berasal hingga menjadi bagian dari kehidupan sehari-hari? Sejarah kopi tidak kalah getir dari secangkir kopi tubruk tanpa gula.
National Geographic Indonesia, 2021
Coffee is not only caffeinated concoction with aroma and flavor that awakens the soul, but also n... more Coffee is not only caffeinated concoction with aroma and flavor that awakens the soul, but also now become part of self identity in taste. Morning meetings is not complete without coffee. In more informal cultural spaces, coffee became the partner in dragging the time, to be enjoyed slowly, to meet friends or future opportunities. This kind of spirit is still brought by coffee stallsthat are easily found in Medan and Aceh.
Borobudur Writers and Cultural Festival, 2021
The role of museums as colonial propaganda tools continues until today in the previously colonise... more The role of museums as colonial propaganda tools continues until today in the previously colonised areas and the coloniser country. Similar to how many Dutch museums present their achievement in exploiting the colonised area between the 17th and 20th centuries, the government museums in Indonesia also follow suit as the propaganda tool for the ruling body that replaced European domination. Although now progressively decolonising its exhibition content, Rijksmuseum in Amsterdam still leaves a clear bitter trace in the eyes of the ex-colony. In comparison, since the beginning of the independence period, Indonesian government museums have been crucial in creating the image of an “Indonesian” nation. This phenomenon was analysed by numerous experts, among them the late Benedict Anderson in chapter 10: Census, Map, Museum, part of his bestseller “Imagined Communities.”
Furthermore, Indonesian museums, later on, had the role of planting uniform, governmentally approved, and biased historical dogma that often ignored the liquid and varied nature of culture. Museum narration controlled by the hegemony can be the main factor of general stagnation within Indonesian museums. This also caused the limited availability of the museum’s presentation on the understanding of colonialism, the colonial system, and the transition process in 1945-1949, which focused not only on military accomplishment. Until today, only a few museums in Indonesia have been able to get out of the compartmentalisation of the “National History” of Indonesia, specifically for the periods when the ruling European colony was present, and another dominant hegemony replaced it. The period after the Netherlands “left” Indonesia is named in a history textbook in versions that are not near to “postcolonialism”, which means after the time of colonialism. Postcolonialism studies the colonised society after colonialism's completion or changing face after World War II. This study also observes how the societal system is implemented with the inherited colonial system, including identity, education, culture and museums.
On the other hand, decolonisation grew to be a movement that liberated the mind from colonial ideology, and this was not only about the ex-colony’s effort to be more independent. Then, in a similar spirit, the effort to frame fine art from the Indonesian struggle for independence is beyond the inherited colonial system framework. That bias compartmentalising that was built over it.
Borobudur Writers and Cultural Festival, 2021
Peran museum sebagai alat propaganda kolonial masih berlangsung hingga kini baik di daerah eks ja... more Peran museum sebagai alat propaganda kolonial masih berlangsung hingga kini baik di daerah eks jajahan atau di negara asal penjajah. Seperti sejumlah museum Belanda yang menyajikan kegemilangan mereka memeras area koloni di antara abad 17 hingga 20 Masehi, begitu juga sejumlah museum pemerintahan di Indonesia yang menjadi alat propaganda kekuatan yang menggantikan dominasi Eropa. Rijksmuseum di Amsterdam, walau kini semakin progresif dalam proses dekolonisasi konten pameran mereka, masih meninggalkan jejak getir yang jelas di mata eks koloni. Sedangkan museum-museum pemerintahan di Indonesia sejak Masa Awal Kemerdekaan menjadi bagian penting dalam pembentukan imaji sebuah bangsa “Indonesia.” Fenomena yang terjadi pada Indonesia ini dianalisa secara mendalam oleh banyak ahli, diantaranya oleh almarhum Benedict Anderson dalam sebuah bab 10: Census, Map, Museum, bagian dari karya populernya “Imagined Communities.” Lebih lanjut lagi, permuseuman di Indonesia kemudian berperan dalam menanamkan dogma sejarah bias nan seragam yang “disetujui pemerintah” yang seringkali menghiraukan sifat budaya yang cair serta memiliki laju yang beragam. Narasi permuseuman yang dikontrol oleh hegemoni bisa jadi merupakan faktor utama penyebab stagnasi di dalam permuseuman Indonesia secara umum. Hal ini juga penyebab minimnya penyajian museum mengenai pemahaman kolonialisme, sistem kolonial, dan proses transisi di antara 1945-1949 yang tidak hanya berfokus pada pencapaian fraksi militer. Hingga kini baru terhitung jari saja museum di Indonesia yang keluar dari pengkotak-kotakan Sejarah Nasional Indonesia untuk periode sejak kekuatan koloni Eropa hadir hingga datang masanya digantikan oleh dominasi hegemoni lain. Periode setelah Belanda meninggalkan Indonesia memiliki beberapa penamaan dalam buku teks sejarah di sekolah formil, tapi tidak termasuk “poskolonialisme” yang secara harfiah berarti “setelah (masa) kolonialisme.” Poskolonialisme adalah studi mengenai masyarakat di daerah jajahan setelah berakhirnya, atau berubahnya wajah kolonialisme setelah Perang Dunia Kedua. Studi ini juga mengamati bagaimana tata masyarakat yang berlangsung dengan sistem kolonial yang diwariskan, termasuk dalam topik identitas, pendidikan, budaya dan juga museum. Di sisi lain gerakan dekolonisasi bertumbuh menjadi gerakan yang membebaskan pemikiran dari ideologi kolonial dan tidak hanya mengacu pada usaha eks koloni menjadi lebih independen. Didasari semangat yang sejurus, maka usaha menempatkan seni rupa masa perjuangan Indonesia sebaiknya terlepas dari kerangka yang diwariskan sistem kolonial dan pengkotak-kotakan bias yang dibangun di atas kerangka tersebut.
Good evening, dignitaries, scholars and business leaders. I hope you had a lovely week behind you... more Good evening, dignitaries, scholars and business leaders. I hope you had a lovely week behind you and are looking forward to a great weekend. 你好 On behalf of our director general, His Excellency Ahmed Obeid Al Tenaiji, and Ras Al Khaimah Department of Antiquities and Museums, we would like to express our gratitude, Shukran, 谢谢, for inviting us to this dialogue of friendship. The friendship between both lands has lasted longer than forty years, as confirmed by the discovery of an official ceramic piece from the Yuan Dynasty in the UAE. The piece is a duck-decorated Yuan dynasty blue-white ceramic sherd discovered during the January-February winter season of 2019 [1] of archaeology excavation in Al Nudud, North Mataf, Julfar, Ras Al Khaimah. Julfar is one of UAE's sites listed on the UNESCO World Heritage Tentative List as of 2021. Julfar's "duck sherd" was found with 14,700 ceramic pieces, including 65 Chinese pieces, unearthed by the 2019 China-UAE archaeology
kebudayaan.kemdikbud.go.id/, 2016
Stone chambers, also known as stone tombs or sarcophagi, are commonly found, yet the ones found i... more Stone chambers, also known as stone tombs or sarcophagi, are commonly found, yet the ones found in Pasemah are particularly peculiar.
This paper was written as part of an assignment from BPCB Jambi based on a field visit in the same year Translation from a paper published as :
“Bentuk Ekspresi Estetik: Lukisan dalam Bilik Batu”, by BPCB Jambi, 20 June 2019in Indonesian Ministry of Education and Culture website, link :
https://kebudayaan.kemdikbud.go.id/bpcbjambi/bentuk-ekspresi-estetik-lukisan-dalam-bilik-batu/
The effect of "aesthetic preference" may be particularly important in shaping a visitor's itinera... more The effect of "aesthetic preference" may be particularly important in shaping a visitor's itinerary in encyclopedic art museums because the size of such collections, among other factors, forces visitors to make decisions about what they will and will not see. This kind of museum houses a wide scope of collections, which fill spacious galleries. Aesthetic preference can heavily influence visitors' itineraries in an encyclopedic art museum, and it could play a dominant role in competing with other influential factors or constraints.
This research is based on a case study to see how visitors' aesthetic preferences influenced their itineraries in an encyclopedic art museum. The study used visitor interviews at The Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York in April 2010.
The investigation of the influence of aesthetic preference on the visitor's itinerary in an encyclopedic art museum is somewhat similar to museum audience studies done by Falk and Bourdieu but different in its objectives and outcomes. Like both of their studies, this research is trying to investigate a certain pattern formed from identity-based elements. Bourdieu investigated visitors' taste patterns by correlating them with their class identity; Falk investigated visitors' experience patterns by correlating them with their identity-related visit motivations; and this research investigates museum visit itinerary patterns by correlating them with a preference shaped by visitor identity: an aesthetic preference.
This study elaborates on the hypothesis that "aesthetic preference" is a significant factor in determining a visitor's itinerary in an encyclopedic art museum. It was established to achieve a few goals: (1) to investigate visitors' itinerary plans; (2) to analyze the correlation between visitors' itinerary plan and their aesthetic preferences; and (3) to suggest possible strategies that could be adopted by museums to accommodate their audience.
Museum di Indonesia memiliki peranan strategis dalam kehidupan berban3sa dan bernegara, karena mu... more Museum di Indonesia memiliki peranan strategis dalam kehidupan berban3sa dan bernegara, karena museum dalam operasionalisasinya berpegang pada tiga pilar kebijakan permuseuman Indonesia, yaitu ,mencerdaskan bangsa, memperkuat kepribadian bangsa dan ketahan nasional serta wawasan nusantara. Sayangnya buku tentang permuseuman bisa dikatakan masih langk, baik buku untuk kalangan pekerja museum, maupun untuk khalayak umum. Menyadari kenyataan itL. Direktorat Permuseuman dalam rangka menyukseskan program Revitalisasi Museum dan Gerakan Nasional Cinta Museum 2010-2014, sengaja menerbitkan buku Sejarah Permuseuman di Indonesia, dengan maksud menjawab sebagian kebutuhan insan permuseuman Indonesia.
SPAFA Journal
The archaeology of Jakarta is a multi-layered artefact compounded with thin period separations. I... more The archaeology of Jakarta is a multi-layered artefact compounded with thin period separations. In the geographical sphere of the “greater Jakarta area”, its roots start from the Neolithic with the discovery of Buni tradition pottery. The Buni area stretched along the north coast of west Java towards the interior to the south. This geographical sphere then became the oldest kingdom in the archipelago, Tarumanagara, an Indian-influenced Hindu Kingdom. A series of different ancient kingdoms ruled until the arrival of the Europeans. First, the Portuguese signed a treaty with Sunda (a Hindu Kingdom and ruler of the port of Kalapa) to defend their territory from Cirebon (an Islamic Kingdom in the eastern part of west java). Kalapa became a prized area that was fought over until the Dutch East India Company (Vereenigde Oostindische Compagnie, or VOC), led by J. P. Coen, burnt it down and built Batavia. Kalapa, as one of the few main ports of Sunda, historically welcomed people (with or wi...
Thesis Chapters by Annissa Gultom
Master Thesis, University of the Arts, 2010
The effect of "aesthetic preference" may be particularly important in shaping a visitor's itinera... more The effect of "aesthetic preference" may be particularly important in shaping a visitor's itinerary in encyclopedic art. museums because the size of such collections, among other factors, forces visitors to make decisions about what they will and will not see. This kind of museum houses a wide scope of collections, which fill spacious galleries. Aesthetic preference can heavily influence visitors' itineraries in an encyclopedic art museum, and it could play a dominant role in competing with other influential factors or constraints.
This research is based upon a case study designed to see how far visitors' aesthetic preferences influenced their itineraries in an encyclopedic art museum. The study used visitor interviews conducted at The Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York during the month of April 2010.
The investigation of the influence of aesthetic preference on the visitor's itinerary in an encyclopedic art museum is somewhat similar to museum audience studies that has been done by Falk and Bourdieu, but different in its objectives and outcomes. Like both of their studies, this research is trying to investigate a certain kind of pattern that is formed from identity-based elements. Bourdieu investigated visitors' taste patterns by correlating them with their class-identity; Falk investigated visitors' taste patterns by correlating them with their identity-related visit motivations; and this research investigates museum visit itinerary patterns by correlating them with a preference that was shaped by visitor identity; aesthetic preference.
This study elaborates on the concept of the hypothesis that "aesthetic preference" is a significant factor in determining a visitor's itinerary in an encyclopedic art museum. It was established to achieve a few goals: (1) to investigate visitors' itinerary plans; (2) to analyze the correlation between visitors' itinerary plan and their aesthetic preferences; and (3) to suggest possible strategies that could be adopted by museums to accommodate their audience.
Books by Annissa Gultom
"Our Ancestors Knew Best: Traditional Southeast Asian Textile Treatments and Their Place in Modern Conservation, 2016
This is a part of the Indonesia Country Report on the collective research in Traditional Southeas... more This is a part of the Indonesia Country Report on the collective research in Traditional Southeast Asian Textile Treatments and Their Place in Modern Conservation in 2016. This part focuses on Bali, while another focuses on Java. The rest of the research report, including reports from other countries, can be downloaded on SPAFA's website as the leading institution. The link to the full publication is here: https://publications.spafajournal.org/index.php/spafapub/catalog/book/35
This is a self-translation from Chapter IV. Future of Indonesian Museums of 2011 published a book... more This is a self-translation from Chapter IV. Future of Indonesian Museums of 2011 published a book of the History of Indonesian Museums (Sejarah Permuseuman Indonesia) available in its original Indonesian version here: https://www.academia.edu/88509715/Sejarah_permuseuman_di_Indonesia
Catalogue of Jakarta Biennale 2017, themed JIWA
Catalogue of Jakarta Biennale 2017 "JIWA", 2017
Curatorial statement on Indonesian Museums and their contemporaneity concerning Jakarta Biennale ... more Curatorial statement on Indonesian Museums and their contemporaneity concerning Jakarta Biennale 2017's theme "JIWA". The Biennale was held in multi venues that also include spaces in and surroundinh Jakarta museums that are located in the colonial heritage site of Jakarta Kota Tua.
The statement is written as an individual work to complete the group work by 4 other members of the Biennale's curatorial team, led by Melati Suryodarmo as Art Director.
Conference Presentations by Annissa Gultom
The 3rd SEAMEO SPAFA International Conference on Southeast Asian Archaeology (SPAFACON2019), 2019
This paper will show how, through permanent and temporary museum exhibitions, the preservation ef... more This paper will show how, through permanent and temporary museum exhibitions, the preservation effort in colonial heritage can contest or defend the value we chose to preserve. The case study for this paper is the method the Jakarta History Museum used to include the Banda Massacre in its new ground-floor permanent exhibit, which was inaugurated in October 2017.
From Conservation to Conversation: Rethinking Collections Care, publication of papers from online conference "From Conservation to Conversation", 2021
"Our Ancestors Knew Best" is a breakthrough in providing open-source wisdom that combines indigen... more "Our Ancestors Knew Best" is a breakthrough in providing open-source wisdom that combines indigenous knowledge and lab-based science. It is a result of conversations since 2016 between museums, cultural institutions, and the core of this initiative: the caretaker of indigenous knowledge in textile care in southeast Asian countries. Country reports were gathered by researchers from the local museum, cultural office, and part of the community itself—the body of knowledge formed in the reports based on interviews, documentation, and material samplings. The findings were compiled and then analyzed by scientists to provide hands-on scientific interpretation of the methods and material used. Scientists established lab-based analysis and further experiments to measure the efficacy. Findings, analysis, and conclusion from the whole program presented in a 2019 publication are dedicated to being a "user-friendly" audience. While the scientific discoveries are provided, the colorful 210 pages long book also provides "how-to" tips and recipes in textile cleaning (or not "cleaning") equipped with posters that simplify the knowledge in caring for your textiles. The book and posters are currently available for free download through the website of SEAMEO- SPAFA (https://www.seameo-spafa.org/our-ancestors-knew-best-traditional-southeast- asian-textile-treatments-and-their-place-in-modern-conservation/ )
UAE Archaeology Conference 2023, 2023
In winter 2019, after 30 years of primarily unchanged structurally, Ras Al Khaimah National Museu... more In winter 2019, after 30 years of primarily unchanged structurally, Ras Al Khaimah National Museum (RAKNM) started its revitalization project by restoring the two rooms of the Natural History Gallery (RM33-34) and gradually the Ethnography Galleries (RM11-15), the unexpected finds under the plastered floors brought to the first public display of RAKNM’s Qawasim coin. The restoration uncovered three madbasa (date press rooms) in RM12, 33 and 34. The madbasa in RM12, located near the northwest tower, was reburied after documentation. While the other two became the drivers of the modified exhibit plan for both galleries. RM33-34 became a permanent exhibit of the “Madbasa Gallery”, while the Ethnography Galleries is programmed to host temporary exhibitions to accommodate the rich topics of Ras Al Khaimah cultural heritage. In the curatorial research for both galleries, the museum launched fieldwork research on date palm gardens and established a study on collections found in historical date palm garden sites (February – September 2020). The study included two date palm gardens, one with an inactive madbasa in Khor Khwer and another with an active and (slightly) modernized madbasa in Dhayah. The collection study included a gold coin from the 2019 Shimal date palm gardens survey and finds from 2000-2002 surveys in the Falaya compound. While the field research brought the RAK citizens team members on a journey of self-discovery of their collective memory, the collection study brought us to the treasures from Falaya that have never been on display. It consists of foreign coins that mark the reach of international trade, peculiar “leaf coins” with palm leaf/frond shapes on their surface and one with a “Mardhouf al-Qawasim” note attached. The ancient foreign coins found in Falaya were in their showcase. The leaf coins were shown together with a larger similar leaf coin found on a site south of Wadi Naqab, situated around 800 meters above sea level in the mountainous area of Ras Al Khaimah. In contrast, the Qawasim coin was accompanied by several other Falaya objects that speak to the topic of “The Residence of Power”: a key to a chest; a silver ring that is associated with an Omani copper coin; a copper Arabic scripted coin that is related to a bullet; and traces of pearling (one leather finger cover and sherd of mother of pearl), the source of wealth for the emirate in the past.
2023 UAE Archaeology Conference Program, 2023
Presented in UAE Archaeology Conference, November 2023. Proceedings will follow.
ICOFOM Conference 2024, 2024
[Paper of this presentation is available in this platform to provide contexts and details] Muse... more [Paper of this presentation is available in this platform to provide contexts and details]
Museums are colonial products that were not only physically imposed on occupied land in the past but later became mandatory for an area to be considered "modern" or "civilized." The United Arab Emirates early museums were not "brought" by the pre-Second World War colonial power, but their establishment seems to be a requirement for an upcoming "new nation". The two leading sheikhdoms established the two oldest museums during the union's formation. The oldest museum on the land, the Al Ain (National) Museum in Abu Dhabi, was developed in 1969, with a temporary exhibition inside the Sultan Fort while waiting for the newly built building. The museum opened on 2 November 1971, a month before the union's birthday. The Dubai Museum was opened to the public in the Al Fahidi Fort in the same year. Both museums consist of two main topics: archaeology (3800BC-300AD) and the ethnography of "pre-oil" life (1800s-1971). The other five unified emirates followed suit by establishing their "fort museums" with similar content in different decades after. This pattern is typical in postcolonial states that emerged in the post-Second World War decolonization.
Postcolonial museums are an institutionalized culture with European-based "ideals", which intrigues the need for native and indigenous voices in Museology. As the maturity of native anthropology, decolonization, biculturalism, and local community museums grew, the "ideals" altered during the localized movement. The wave of UAE museum renewal started in 2006, a motion that brought in international consultants, experts and museum-specific skilled personnel. They backboned the establishment of today's prominent UAE museums while the country is developing a generation of Emirati museologists. This naturally moulded multinational museum teams who brought their versions of museum ideals. The richness of their perspectives is adjusted -to some extent- to the local setting and identity. Although often, the visualizations are in similar beige, red, or black-white monochrome hues.
Ras Al Khaimah National Museum (RAKNM) is among the ones eager for change, especially in expanding its abstract space to serve as RAK's abundant cultural resource. RAKNM dismantled its 30+ y.o permanent display of ethnography galleries and started a series of temporary exhibits. Inspired by Te Papa Museum's "Maorification, " the team gathered and co-curated Emirati vocabularies, voices, personal accounts, and collective memories while discovering generational evolution and knowledge gaps. In different projects, we have worked with an active old garden on the topics of date palm cultural heritage and madbasa (date juice extraction room); a retired police officer to document local dialects vocabularies for riffles from the 19th - 20th AD; a local private collector that collects daily items popularly used by people growing up in the Emirates in the 70s and a number of female Emirati staff on family jewellery. For upcoming projects in Emirati weddings and written memories in Manuscripts, we will include previous ethnographic documentations, observe the topics’ evolution, identify gaps and present another story of culture’s fluidity.
ICOFOM ConferenceDoha, 2024
Museums are colonial products that were not only physically imposed on occupied land in the past ... more Museums are colonial products that were not only physically imposed on occupied land in the past but later became mandatory for an area to be considered "modern" or "civilized." United Arab Emirates early museums were not "brought" by the pre-Second World War colonial power, but their establishment seems to be a requirement for an upcoming "new nation". The two leading sheikhdoms established the two oldest museums during the union's formation. The oldest museum on the land, the Al Ain (National) Museum in Abu Dhabi, was developed in 1969, with a temporary exhibition inside the Sultan Fort while waiting for the newly built building. The museum opened on 2 November 1971, a month before the union's birthday. The Dubai Museum was opened to the public in the Al Fahidi Fort in the same year. Both museums consist of two main topics: archaeology (3800BC-300AD) and the ethnography of "pre-oil" life (1800s-1971). The other five unified emirates followed suit by establishing their "fort museums" with similar content in different decades after. This pattern is typical in postcolonial states that emerged in the post-Second World War decolonization.
Postcolonial museums are an institutionalized culture with European-based "ideals", which intrigues the need for native and indigenous voices in Museology. As the maturity of native anthropology, decolonization, biculturalism, and local community museums grew, the "ideals" altered during the localized movement. The wave of UAE museum renewal started in 2006, a motion that brought in international consultants, experts and museum-specific skilled personnel. They backboned the establishment of today's prominent UAE museums while the country is developing a generation of Emirati museologists. This naturally moulded multinational museum teams who brought their versions of museum ideals. The richness of their perspectives is adjusted -to some extent- to the local setting and identity. Although often, the visualizations are in similar beige, red, or black-white monochrome hues.
Ras Al Khaimah National Museum (RAKNM) is among the ones eager for change, especially in expanding its abstract space to serve as RAK's abundant cultural resource. RAKNM dismantled its 30+ y.o permanent display of ethnography galleries and started a series of temporary exhibits. Inspired by Te Papa Museum's "Maorification, " the team gathered and co-curated Emirati vocabularies, voices, personal accounts, and collective memories while discovering generational evolution and knowledge gaps. In different projects, we have worked with an active old garden on the topics of date palm cultural heritage and madbasa (date juice extraction room); a retired police officer to document local dialects vocabularies for riffles from the 19th - 20th AD; a local private collector that collects daily items popularly used by people growing up in the Emirates in the 70s and a number of female Emirati staff on family jewellery. For upcoming projects in Emirati weddings and written memories in Manuscripts, we will include previous ethnographic documentations, observe the topics’ evolution, identify gaps and present another story of culture’s fluidity.
National Geographic Indonesia, 2021
Kopi tidak hanya sekedar seduhan berkafein yang aroma dan rasanya membangunkan jiwa manusia, teta... more Kopi tidak hanya sekedar seduhan berkafein yang aroma dan rasanya membangunkan jiwa manusia, tetapi kini juga menjadi bagian dari identitas diri. Rapat di pagi hari tidak lengkap tanpa hadirnya kopi. Darimana kopi berasal hingga menjadi bagian dari kehidupan sehari-hari? Sejarah kopi tidak kalah getir dari secangkir kopi tubruk tanpa gula.
National Geographic Indonesia, 2021
Coffee is not only caffeinated concoction with aroma and flavor that awakens the soul, but also n... more Coffee is not only caffeinated concoction with aroma and flavor that awakens the soul, but also now become part of self identity in taste. Morning meetings is not complete without coffee. In more informal cultural spaces, coffee became the partner in dragging the time, to be enjoyed slowly, to meet friends or future opportunities. This kind of spirit is still brought by coffee stallsthat are easily found in Medan and Aceh.
Borobudur Writers and Cultural Festival, 2021
The role of museums as colonial propaganda tools continues until today in the previously colonise... more The role of museums as colonial propaganda tools continues until today in the previously colonised areas and the coloniser country. Similar to how many Dutch museums present their achievement in exploiting the colonised area between the 17th and 20th centuries, the government museums in Indonesia also follow suit as the propaganda tool for the ruling body that replaced European domination. Although now progressively decolonising its exhibition content, Rijksmuseum in Amsterdam still leaves a clear bitter trace in the eyes of the ex-colony. In comparison, since the beginning of the independence period, Indonesian government museums have been crucial in creating the image of an “Indonesian” nation. This phenomenon was analysed by numerous experts, among them the late Benedict Anderson in chapter 10: Census, Map, Museum, part of his bestseller “Imagined Communities.”
Furthermore, Indonesian museums, later on, had the role of planting uniform, governmentally approved, and biased historical dogma that often ignored the liquid and varied nature of culture. Museum narration controlled by the hegemony can be the main factor of general stagnation within Indonesian museums. This also caused the limited availability of the museum’s presentation on the understanding of colonialism, the colonial system, and the transition process in 1945-1949, which focused not only on military accomplishment. Until today, only a few museums in Indonesia have been able to get out of the compartmentalisation of the “National History” of Indonesia, specifically for the periods when the ruling European colony was present, and another dominant hegemony replaced it. The period after the Netherlands “left” Indonesia is named in a history textbook in versions that are not near to “postcolonialism”, which means after the time of colonialism. Postcolonialism studies the colonised society after colonialism's completion or changing face after World War II. This study also observes how the societal system is implemented with the inherited colonial system, including identity, education, culture and museums.
On the other hand, decolonisation grew to be a movement that liberated the mind from colonial ideology, and this was not only about the ex-colony’s effort to be more independent. Then, in a similar spirit, the effort to frame fine art from the Indonesian struggle for independence is beyond the inherited colonial system framework. That bias compartmentalising that was built over it.
Borobudur Writers and Cultural Festival, 2021
Peran museum sebagai alat propaganda kolonial masih berlangsung hingga kini baik di daerah eks ja... more Peran museum sebagai alat propaganda kolonial masih berlangsung hingga kini baik di daerah eks jajahan atau di negara asal penjajah. Seperti sejumlah museum Belanda yang menyajikan kegemilangan mereka memeras area koloni di antara abad 17 hingga 20 Masehi, begitu juga sejumlah museum pemerintahan di Indonesia yang menjadi alat propaganda kekuatan yang menggantikan dominasi Eropa. Rijksmuseum di Amsterdam, walau kini semakin progresif dalam proses dekolonisasi konten pameran mereka, masih meninggalkan jejak getir yang jelas di mata eks koloni. Sedangkan museum-museum pemerintahan di Indonesia sejak Masa Awal Kemerdekaan menjadi bagian penting dalam pembentukan imaji sebuah bangsa “Indonesia.” Fenomena yang terjadi pada Indonesia ini dianalisa secara mendalam oleh banyak ahli, diantaranya oleh almarhum Benedict Anderson dalam sebuah bab 10: Census, Map, Museum, bagian dari karya populernya “Imagined Communities.” Lebih lanjut lagi, permuseuman di Indonesia kemudian berperan dalam menanamkan dogma sejarah bias nan seragam yang “disetujui pemerintah” yang seringkali menghiraukan sifat budaya yang cair serta memiliki laju yang beragam. Narasi permuseuman yang dikontrol oleh hegemoni bisa jadi merupakan faktor utama penyebab stagnasi di dalam permuseuman Indonesia secara umum. Hal ini juga penyebab minimnya penyajian museum mengenai pemahaman kolonialisme, sistem kolonial, dan proses transisi di antara 1945-1949 yang tidak hanya berfokus pada pencapaian fraksi militer. Hingga kini baru terhitung jari saja museum di Indonesia yang keluar dari pengkotak-kotakan Sejarah Nasional Indonesia untuk periode sejak kekuatan koloni Eropa hadir hingga datang masanya digantikan oleh dominasi hegemoni lain. Periode setelah Belanda meninggalkan Indonesia memiliki beberapa penamaan dalam buku teks sejarah di sekolah formil, tapi tidak termasuk “poskolonialisme” yang secara harfiah berarti “setelah (masa) kolonialisme.” Poskolonialisme adalah studi mengenai masyarakat di daerah jajahan setelah berakhirnya, atau berubahnya wajah kolonialisme setelah Perang Dunia Kedua. Studi ini juga mengamati bagaimana tata masyarakat yang berlangsung dengan sistem kolonial yang diwariskan, termasuk dalam topik identitas, pendidikan, budaya dan juga museum. Di sisi lain gerakan dekolonisasi bertumbuh menjadi gerakan yang membebaskan pemikiran dari ideologi kolonial dan tidak hanya mengacu pada usaha eks koloni menjadi lebih independen. Didasari semangat yang sejurus, maka usaha menempatkan seni rupa masa perjuangan Indonesia sebaiknya terlepas dari kerangka yang diwariskan sistem kolonial dan pengkotak-kotakan bias yang dibangun di atas kerangka tersebut.
Good evening, dignitaries, scholars and business leaders. I hope you had a lovely week behind you... more Good evening, dignitaries, scholars and business leaders. I hope you had a lovely week behind you and are looking forward to a great weekend. 你好 On behalf of our director general, His Excellency Ahmed Obeid Al Tenaiji, and Ras Al Khaimah Department of Antiquities and Museums, we would like to express our gratitude, Shukran, 谢谢, for inviting us to this dialogue of friendship. The friendship between both lands has lasted longer than forty years, as confirmed by the discovery of an official ceramic piece from the Yuan Dynasty in the UAE. The piece is a duck-decorated Yuan dynasty blue-white ceramic sherd discovered during the January-February winter season of 2019 [1] of archaeology excavation in Al Nudud, North Mataf, Julfar, Ras Al Khaimah. Julfar is one of UAE's sites listed on the UNESCO World Heritage Tentative List as of 2021. Julfar's "duck sherd" was found with 14,700 ceramic pieces, including 65 Chinese pieces, unearthed by the 2019 China-UAE archaeology
kebudayaan.kemdikbud.go.id/, 2016
Stone chambers, also known as stone tombs or sarcophagi, are commonly found, yet the ones found i... more Stone chambers, also known as stone tombs or sarcophagi, are commonly found, yet the ones found in Pasemah are particularly peculiar.
This paper was written as part of an assignment from BPCB Jambi based on a field visit in the same year Translation from a paper published as :
“Bentuk Ekspresi Estetik: Lukisan dalam Bilik Batu”, by BPCB Jambi, 20 June 2019in Indonesian Ministry of Education and Culture website, link :
https://kebudayaan.kemdikbud.go.id/bpcbjambi/bentuk-ekspresi-estetik-lukisan-dalam-bilik-batu/
The effect of "aesthetic preference" may be particularly important in shaping a visitor's itinera... more The effect of "aesthetic preference" may be particularly important in shaping a visitor's itinerary in encyclopedic art museums because the size of such collections, among other factors, forces visitors to make decisions about what they will and will not see. This kind of museum houses a wide scope of collections, which fill spacious galleries. Aesthetic preference can heavily influence visitors' itineraries in an encyclopedic art museum, and it could play a dominant role in competing with other influential factors or constraints.
This research is based on a case study to see how visitors' aesthetic preferences influenced their itineraries in an encyclopedic art museum. The study used visitor interviews at The Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York in April 2010.
The investigation of the influence of aesthetic preference on the visitor's itinerary in an encyclopedic art museum is somewhat similar to museum audience studies done by Falk and Bourdieu but different in its objectives and outcomes. Like both of their studies, this research is trying to investigate a certain pattern formed from identity-based elements. Bourdieu investigated visitors' taste patterns by correlating them with their class identity; Falk investigated visitors' experience patterns by correlating them with their identity-related visit motivations; and this research investigates museum visit itinerary patterns by correlating them with a preference shaped by visitor identity: an aesthetic preference.
This study elaborates on the hypothesis that "aesthetic preference" is a significant factor in determining a visitor's itinerary in an encyclopedic art museum. It was established to achieve a few goals: (1) to investigate visitors' itinerary plans; (2) to analyze the correlation between visitors' itinerary plan and their aesthetic preferences; and (3) to suggest possible strategies that could be adopted by museums to accommodate their audience.
Museum di Indonesia memiliki peranan strategis dalam kehidupan berban3sa dan bernegara, karena mu... more Museum di Indonesia memiliki peranan strategis dalam kehidupan berban3sa dan bernegara, karena museum dalam operasionalisasinya berpegang pada tiga pilar kebijakan permuseuman Indonesia, yaitu ,mencerdaskan bangsa, memperkuat kepribadian bangsa dan ketahan nasional serta wawasan nusantara. Sayangnya buku tentang permuseuman bisa dikatakan masih langk, baik buku untuk kalangan pekerja museum, maupun untuk khalayak umum. Menyadari kenyataan itL. Direktorat Permuseuman dalam rangka menyukseskan program Revitalisasi Museum dan Gerakan Nasional Cinta Museum 2010-2014, sengaja menerbitkan buku Sejarah Permuseuman di Indonesia, dengan maksud menjawab sebagian kebutuhan insan permuseuman Indonesia.
SPAFA Journal
The archaeology of Jakarta is a multi-layered artefact compounded with thin period separations. I... more The archaeology of Jakarta is a multi-layered artefact compounded with thin period separations. In the geographical sphere of the “greater Jakarta area”, its roots start from the Neolithic with the discovery of Buni tradition pottery. The Buni area stretched along the north coast of west Java towards the interior to the south. This geographical sphere then became the oldest kingdom in the archipelago, Tarumanagara, an Indian-influenced Hindu Kingdom. A series of different ancient kingdoms ruled until the arrival of the Europeans. First, the Portuguese signed a treaty with Sunda (a Hindu Kingdom and ruler of the port of Kalapa) to defend their territory from Cirebon (an Islamic Kingdom in the eastern part of west java). Kalapa became a prized area that was fought over until the Dutch East India Company (Vereenigde Oostindische Compagnie, or VOC), led by J. P. Coen, burnt it down and built Batavia. Kalapa, as one of the few main ports of Sunda, historically welcomed people (with or wi...
Master Thesis, University of the Arts, 2010
The effect of "aesthetic preference" may be particularly important in shaping a visitor's itinera... more The effect of "aesthetic preference" may be particularly important in shaping a visitor's itinerary in encyclopedic art. museums because the size of such collections, among other factors, forces visitors to make decisions about what they will and will not see. This kind of museum houses a wide scope of collections, which fill spacious galleries. Aesthetic preference can heavily influence visitors' itineraries in an encyclopedic art museum, and it could play a dominant role in competing with other influential factors or constraints.
This research is based upon a case study designed to see how far visitors' aesthetic preferences influenced their itineraries in an encyclopedic art museum. The study used visitor interviews conducted at The Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York during the month of April 2010.
The investigation of the influence of aesthetic preference on the visitor's itinerary in an encyclopedic art museum is somewhat similar to museum audience studies that has been done by Falk and Bourdieu, but different in its objectives and outcomes. Like both of their studies, this research is trying to investigate a certain kind of pattern that is formed from identity-based elements. Bourdieu investigated visitors' taste patterns by correlating them with their class-identity; Falk investigated visitors' taste patterns by correlating them with their identity-related visit motivations; and this research investigates museum visit itinerary patterns by correlating them with a preference that was shaped by visitor identity; aesthetic preference.
This study elaborates on the concept of the hypothesis that "aesthetic preference" is a significant factor in determining a visitor's itinerary in an encyclopedic art museum. It was established to achieve a few goals: (1) to investigate visitors' itinerary plans; (2) to analyze the correlation between visitors' itinerary plan and their aesthetic preferences; and (3) to suggest possible strategies that could be adopted by museums to accommodate their audience.
"Our Ancestors Knew Best: Traditional Southeast Asian Textile Treatments and Their Place in Modern Conservation, 2016
This is a part of the Indonesia Country Report on the collective research in Traditional Southeas... more This is a part of the Indonesia Country Report on the collective research in Traditional Southeast Asian Textile Treatments and Their Place in Modern Conservation in 2016. This part focuses on Bali, while another focuses on Java. The rest of the research report, including reports from other countries, can be downloaded on SPAFA's website as the leading institution. The link to the full publication is here: https://publications.spafajournal.org/index.php/spafapub/catalog/book/35
This is a self-translation from Chapter IV. Future of Indonesian Museums of 2011 published a book... more This is a self-translation from Chapter IV. Future of Indonesian Museums of 2011 published a book of the History of Indonesian Museums (Sejarah Permuseuman Indonesia) available in its original Indonesian version here: https://www.academia.edu/88509715/Sejarah_permuseuman_di_Indonesia
Catalogue of Jakarta Biennale 2017, themed JIWA
Catalogue of Jakarta Biennale 2017 "JIWA", 2017
Curatorial statement on Indonesian Museums and their contemporaneity concerning Jakarta Biennale ... more Curatorial statement on Indonesian Museums and their contemporaneity concerning Jakarta Biennale 2017's theme "JIWA". The Biennale was held in multi venues that also include spaces in and surroundinh Jakarta museums that are located in the colonial heritage site of Jakarta Kota Tua.
The statement is written as an individual work to complete the group work by 4 other members of the Biennale's curatorial team, led by Melati Suryodarmo as Art Director.
The 3rd SEAMEO SPAFA International Conference on Southeast Asian Archaeology (SPAFACON2019), 2019
This paper will show how, through permanent and temporary museum exhibitions, the preservation ef... more This paper will show how, through permanent and temporary museum exhibitions, the preservation effort in colonial heritage can contest or defend the value we chose to preserve. The case study for this paper is the method the Jakarta History Museum used to include the Banda Massacre in its new ground-floor permanent exhibit, which was inaugurated in October 2017.
From Conservation to Conversation: Rethinking Collections Care, publication of papers from online conference "From Conservation to Conversation", 2021
"Our Ancestors Knew Best" is a breakthrough in providing open-source wisdom that combines indigen... more "Our Ancestors Knew Best" is a breakthrough in providing open-source wisdom that combines indigenous knowledge and lab-based science. It is a result of conversations since 2016 between museums, cultural institutions, and the core of this initiative: the caretaker of indigenous knowledge in textile care in southeast Asian countries. Country reports were gathered by researchers from the local museum, cultural office, and part of the community itself—the body of knowledge formed in the reports based on interviews, documentation, and material samplings. The findings were compiled and then analyzed by scientists to provide hands-on scientific interpretation of the methods and material used. Scientists established lab-based analysis and further experiments to measure the efficacy. Findings, analysis, and conclusion from the whole program presented in a 2019 publication are dedicated to being a "user-friendly" audience. While the scientific discoveries are provided, the colorful 210 pages long book also provides "how-to" tips and recipes in textile cleaning (or not "cleaning") equipped with posters that simplify the knowledge in caring for your textiles. The book and posters are currently available for free download through the website of SEAMEO- SPAFA (https://www.seameo-spafa.org/our-ancestors-knew-best-traditional-southeast- asian-textile-treatments-and-their-place-in-modern-conservation/ )
UAE Archaeology Conference 2023, 2023
In winter 2019, after 30 years of primarily unchanged structurally, Ras Al Khaimah National Museu... more In winter 2019, after 30 years of primarily unchanged structurally, Ras Al Khaimah National Museum (RAKNM) started its revitalization project by restoring the two rooms of the Natural History Gallery (RM33-34) and gradually the Ethnography Galleries (RM11-15), the unexpected finds under the plastered floors brought to the first public display of RAKNM’s Qawasim coin. The restoration uncovered three madbasa (date press rooms) in RM12, 33 and 34. The madbasa in RM12, located near the northwest tower, was reburied after documentation. While the other two became the drivers of the modified exhibit plan for both galleries. RM33-34 became a permanent exhibit of the “Madbasa Gallery”, while the Ethnography Galleries is programmed to host temporary exhibitions to accommodate the rich topics of Ras Al Khaimah cultural heritage. In the curatorial research for both galleries, the museum launched fieldwork research on date palm gardens and established a study on collections found in historical date palm garden sites (February – September 2020). The study included two date palm gardens, one with an inactive madbasa in Khor Khwer and another with an active and (slightly) modernized madbasa in Dhayah. The collection study included a gold coin from the 2019 Shimal date palm gardens survey and finds from 2000-2002 surveys in the Falaya compound. While the field research brought the RAK citizens team members on a journey of self-discovery of their collective memory, the collection study brought us to the treasures from Falaya that have never been on display. It consists of foreign coins that mark the reach of international trade, peculiar “leaf coins” with palm leaf/frond shapes on their surface and one with a “Mardhouf al-Qawasim” note attached. The ancient foreign coins found in Falaya were in their showcase. The leaf coins were shown together with a larger similar leaf coin found on a site south of Wadi Naqab, situated around 800 meters above sea level in the mountainous area of Ras Al Khaimah. In contrast, the Qawasim coin was accompanied by several other Falaya objects that speak to the topic of “The Residence of Power”: a key to a chest; a silver ring that is associated with an Omani copper coin; a copper Arabic scripted coin that is related to a bullet; and traces of pearling (one leather finger cover and sherd of mother of pearl), the source of wealth for the emirate in the past.
2023 UAE Archaeology Conference Program, 2023
Presented in UAE Archaeology Conference, November 2023. Proceedings will follow.
International Conference 2014 Museum of Our Own, 2014
Museum Kain is far from the "more cultural" atmosphere of Ubud, Bali. This condition challenges h... more Museum Kain is far from the "more cultural" atmosphere of Ubud, Bali. This condition challenges how a museum presents centuries-old heritage in a more dynamic, engaging and relevant way. For its inaugural exhibit, the museum offers a collection of old Batik cloths (or "Kain" in Bahasa Indonesia) with a non-mainstream storyline supported by the latest touch technology. The museum's concept is a vision of a modern museum that allows visitors to explore (unguided) by themselves or accompanied by storytellers (not guide) on a journey that will enable each visitor to create their iteration.