Joseph Maran | Universität Heidelberg (original) (raw)
Papers by Joseph Maran
E. Borgna (ed.), Nature and Function of Bronze Deposition between Europe and the Mediterranean: Hoards of the Late Bronze Age (https://www.openstarts.units.it/handle/10077/36231), 2024
The terroristic assault by Hamas on Israel. Our position. An open letter from scholars of antiquity.
Dear Friends and Colleagues, On the morning of October 7, ca. 2000 HAMAS terrorists launched a br... more Dear Friends and Colleagues, On the morning of October 7, ca. 2000 HAMAS terrorists launched a brutal attack on civilians in Israeli kibbutzim, moshavim and towns adjacent to the Gaza Strip. They went from house to house to burn, torture, mutilate, and kill Jewish families. They gunned down hundreds of young people at an outdoor music festival that turned into a scene of rape and massacre. Not only did they kill parents in front of children, raped women and children, murdered children and soldiers still asleep in their beds, but also beheaded babies that were sleeping in their cribs.
Condemn Hamas terrorism
Dear Friends and Colleagues, On the morning of October 7, ca. 2000 HAMAS terrorists launched a br... more Dear Friends and Colleagues, On the morning of October 7, ca. 2000 HAMAS terrorists launched a brutal attack on civilians in Israeli kibbutzim, moshavim and towns adjacent to the Gaza Strip. They went from house to house to burn, torture, mutilate, and kill Jewish families. They gunned down hundreds of young people at an outdoor music festival that turned into a scene of rape and massacre. Not only did they kill parents in front of children, raped women and children, murdered children and soldiers still asleep in their beds, but also beheaded babies that were sleeping in their cribs.
It was during a conference dinner in Rome, a few years ago, that we started talking about a colle... more It was during a conference dinner in Rome, a few years ago, that we started talking about a collective volume in honour of Penelope Mountjoy that now we can hold in our hands. Being a scholar of an indisputable quality, which transcends time and space, this volume does not intend to celebrate a special anniversary, but rather our honouree's extraordinary and enduring contribution to Aegean archaeology. Penelope is a talented and dedicated scholar, with a keen eye, skilled fingers, and distinct sense of humour. Whoever has worked with her knows that, except early in the morning, she is a gift that keeps on giving, and we have all learned from her over the years. Be it Mycenaean pottery, a great passion of her life, or any other decorated pottery for that matter, but also more complex questions about pottery technology, local imitations, depositional processes, colonisation, or how to drink ouzo right! Penelope does not have students in the traditional sense of the word. But there is a whole sea of researchers in Aegean prehistory who can be considered her pupils, having learned to deal with Mycenaean pottery thanks to her masterpieces: the Mycenaean Decorated Pottery volume, later on expanded into Regional Mycenaean Decorated Pottery (RMDP), or the more condensed Mycenaean Pottery: An Introduction. Her knowledge of Late Helladic painted tableware with its innumerable regional, or even local variants, is both unmatched and legendary. On top of that, she is known for her superb art of line drawing of archaeological finds (including good old-fashioned inking), a field where she counts hundreds of apprentices, especially at the College Year in Athens, also including one of the authors of this brief introduction. Affiliated for most of her life with the British School at Athens, Penelope's scientific profile is variegated and multiform. Her early interests lay with LM IB Marine style (1972 through 1985), and she has continued, even if sporadically, to work on Crete with her influential paper on Minoanisation of the Cyclades (2000, with M. Ponting), the volume on the material from the South House at Knossos (2003) and the article in the conference volume on LM IB published by the Danish Institute at Athens (2011). While systematically working and learning at Mycenae (1976), under the guarding eye of Lisa French, her first major monographic publication (1981) concerned the early Mycenaean wells on the southern slopes of the Acropolis in Athens, excavated by Nicolaos Platon. This important LH IIIA1 settlement material encompassed not only Mycenaean decorated pottery but also the late occurrence of Aeginetan Matt Painted hydriai, as well as the Acropolis Burnished Ware, which she first defined here. From there she moved to Central Greece, a journey that resulted in
This paper dealing with the demise of the Mycenaean palaces is intended as a plea for an interpre... more This paper dealing with the demise of the Mycenaean palaces is intended as a plea for an interpretive reset and a departure from any search for a single 'prime mover' allegedly responsible for this historical watershed. The doubts regarding the validity of the 'earthquake hypothesis' should be perceived as an opportunity to look for alternatives to previous explanatory approaches that were too simplistic. In order to do this, attention must shift away from events and towards assessing those structures and processes that enabled the palaces' demise. In this respect, three closely interrelated factors of historical, political, and social relevance to which I ascribe a crucial importance will be discussed: first, conflicts among the elites; second, large-scale construction projects; and, third, changes in the palatial armed forces. It is argued that the palaces were brought down first and foremost by internal contradictions that had long built up in the palatial polities and were exploited by members of the elite. Alongside antagonistic fault lines that developed over a long period of time, centrifugal forces were unleashed by social groups pursuing their own interests and forging alliances to strengthen their power base .
A. Yasur-Landau and A. Gilboa (eds.), Nomads of the Mediterranean: Trade and Contact in the Bronze and Iron Ages. Studies in Honor of Michal Artzy, pp 177-198, 2020
Archäologischer Anzeiger, 2010
Archäologischer Anzeiger, 2010
Primordialist understandings of ethnicity that rest on the proof of a direct and unbroken line of... more Primordialist understandings of ethnicity that rest on the proof of a direct and unbroken line of descent from ancient populations have, for good reasons, been abandoned by the humanities and social sciences after World War II. They were replaced by constructivist views that regard ethnicity as rooted in how groups think about themselves in specific social and historical contexts. By contrast, the "cultures" defined by archaeology constitute mere inventions by scholarship without any linkage to self-perceptions of past societies. The two cultures known as Minoan and Mycenaean are good examples of everything that is wrong with the concept of archaeological cultures. Besides creating the impression of longterm continuity and homogeneity in the geographical zones in question, the convention of juxtaposing the Minoan and Mycenaean cultures implies that societies in Crete and the Greek Mainland remained different for many centuries. The most problematic effect of defining archaeological cultures, however, is reflected in the habit of imbuing such mere constructs of archaeology with an "ethnic significance" by employing their names as substitutes for ethnic designations and speaking of "Mycenaeans" and "Minoans". By applying such fabricated ethnicities the impression is created that collective identities are clean-cut, supra-regionally and diachronically stable and mutually exclusive, not unlike modern nationalities. The alleged connection of "Minoans" and "Mycenaeans" to certain genetic patterns may then be taken as a justification for linking ethnicities to blood-ties. Those who do not wish to grace dangerous völkische ideologies of the extreme political right with scholarly respectability must realize that "ethnicizing" archeological "cultures" or language groups and "biologizing" them by linking them to DNA-patterns is not an innocent endeavor. Scholars using the results of aDNA research should refrain from imposing an ethnic significance on archaeological cultures and resist the temptation, fueled by public expectations, of connecting aDNA to ancient or modern collective identities. Fabricated ethnicities such as "Indo-Europeans", "Corded Ware people" or "Mycenaeans" should be particularly avoided in scholarly discourses as they create a false impression of supraregional and diachronic homogeneity (in the sense of Völker) and can thus be very easily abused for political ends.
Opuscula. Annual of the Swedish Institutes at Athens and Rome
Results of the Neutron Activation Analysis (NAA) of 61 pottery samples of Middle and Late Helladi... more Results of the Neutron Activation Analysis (NAA) of 61 pottery samples of Middle and Late Helladic date from recent excavations in Midea are presented. Chronologically, the sampled pieces fall into two groups, the first of Middle Helladic and Late Helladic I/II, the second of LH III date, with most samples dating to LH IIIB or IIIC. The analyses suggest an Argive/North-eastern Peloponnesian provenance for the majority of the sampled pottery, since 26 of the samples are assigned to the NAA group Mycenae-Berbati (MYBE) and 15 to the NAA group Tiryns (TIR), including their subgroups. In addition to the two main groups the analyses include three other categories: “non-Argive”, unlocated, and singles. The differentiation into a small number of distinct chemical patterns is much more evident in the second chronological group of sampled pottery than in the earlier one which comprises a variety of chemical patterns in a small number of samples. Evidently, during the Mycenaean Palatial perio...
Origini è una rivista annuale soggetta a processo di peer-review ed è pubblicata da / Origini is ... more Origini è una rivista annuale soggetta a processo di peer-review ed è pubblicata da / Origini is subject to a peer-review process and is published yearly by: "SAPIENZA" UNIVERSITÀ DI ROMA Dipartimento di Scienze dell' Antichità
Archäologischer Anzeiger, 2021
Mit dem Herunterladen erkennen Sie die Nutzungsbedingungen (h ps://publica ons.dainst.org/terms-o... more Mit dem Herunterladen erkennen Sie die Nutzungsbedingungen (h ps://publica ons.dainst.org/terms-of-use) von iDAI.publica ons an. Sofern in dem Dokument nichts anderes ausdrücklich vermerkt ist, gelten folgende Nutzungsbedingungen: Die Nutzung der Inhalte ist ausschließlich privaten Nutzerinnen / Nutzern für den eigenen wissenscha lichen und sons gen privaten Gebrauch gesta et. Sämtliche Texte, Bilder und sons ge Inhalte in diesem Dokument unterliegen dem Schutz des Urheberrechts gemäß dem Urheberrechtsgesetz der Bundesrepublik Deutschland. Die Inhalte können von Ihnen nur dann genutzt und vervielfäl gt werden, wenn Ihnen dies im Einzelfall durch den Rechteinhaber oder die Schrankenregelungen des Urheberrechts gesta et ist. Jede Art der Nutzung zu gewerblichen Zwecken ist untersagt. Zu den Möglichkeiten einer Lizensierung von Nutzungsrechten wenden Sie sich bi e direkt an die verantwortlichen Herausgeberinnen/Herausgeber der entsprechenden Publika onsorgane oder an die Online-Redak on des Deutschen Archäologischen Ins tuts
The present contribution argues against the until-recently repeated claim that silver was neither... more The present contribution argues against the until-recently repeated claim that silver was neither produced nor used in the Aegean until the 3rd millennium BC, or at least considerably later in the 4th millennium BC than in West Asia. Even if societies in the Aegean and Southeastern Europe had very different political and economic structures than those of the Near and Middle East, the extraction, processing and use of silver seems to have begun in all these regions at about the same time. Thus, in the Aegean the use of this precious metal can be traced back to the early 4th millennium BC and possibly even earlier, and the same holds true for certain areas of the Carpatho-Balkan zone. In the last decades, especially evidence of the earliest phase of silver mining and extraction in the Aegean has dramatically increased, with the argentiferous lead ore deposits of Lavrion, Siphnos and Thasos that would later come to dominate silver production in classical Greece impressively emerging as major sources already in the earliest phase of producing silver. The reluctance to accept the use and production of silver in the Aegean prior to 3000 BC was based on a combination of diffusionist and evolutionist preconceptions. The first preconception lies in the assumption that technological innovations were developed in one particular region and transferred from there unidirectionally to surrounding areas. The second derives from the notion that diachronic changes in societies can be modelled into discrete stages of unilinear technological progression, in which the potential for innovation is tied to the degree of a given society's "complexity". It is here argued that the unidirectional model of diffusionism must be replaced by a multidirectional, dialogical model in which the geographic area between the Carpathian Basin and the Balkans in the northwest and the Iranian highlands in the southeast would have to be perceived as an interaction sphere consisting of many sub-zones, in which knowledge and practices travelled in various directions. Vasileios Petrakos has vastly improved our knowledge of the diachronic history and culture of the landscape of Attica through his research. I have learned a great deal from him and, with this contribution, would like to express my gratitude and pay him my respects for all that he has achieved.
Engaging with ... 'Engaging with ... ' is a series of big, multi-contributed volumes with between... more Engaging with ... 'Engaging with ... ' is a series of big, multi-contributed volumes with between 25 and 40 contributOrs and up to 350,000 words in length. These volumes are typically broken into three pans, Concepts, Key Terms/Methodologies and Case Studies, and they are designed co provide a reference work for researchers and students for exciting new copies. Books in this series cover the key concepts of the field or approach being studied, and conwn analysis of the signi.ficant tenus being used, as well as providing case studies of research currently being done. They are the perfect opportunity to bring together the work of established academics, early career academics and postgraduate students. In chis series: Engaging Transcultu.rality Concepts, Key T enns, Case Studies Edited by Laila Abu-Er-R'lb, Christialle Brosius, Sebastian MeHrer, Diamamis Panagiotopou/os and Susan Ridner
Jahrbuch des Deutschen Archäologischen Instituts, 2020, vol. 135, 1-99, 2020
Maritime commodity trade from the Near East to the Mycenaean heartland: Canaanite Jars in final p... more Maritime commodity trade from the Near East to the Mycenaean heartland: Canaanite Jars in final palatial Tiryns.
Canaanite jars from the palatial site of Tiryns in mainland Greece are shown to have been producedat a number of centres on the Levantine coast, emphasising the key role of the Argive coastal citadelin trade with the eastern Mediterranean at the end of the 13th century BCE. The analytical study ofthis assemblage draws on a detailed examination of key deposits connected to the last phase of thepalace at the site and its destruction, and combines thin section petrography and chemical analysis(NAA), providing major new insights into the specific production locations of these containers alongthe Levantine coast. Based on comparative material from other Aegean sites and especially theharbour of Kommos in southern Crete, typological, epigraphic and analytical data are combined todemonstrate that, towards the end of the 13th century BCE, Tiryns was interacting with differentLevantine centres than did Kommos roughly 100 years earlier. This diachronic shift in the source ofCanaanite jars reaching the Aegean has much to tell us about changing centres of political power,the emergence of regular commodity trade and even diplomatic problems, all at a time whencontainer shipment takes off and the demand for commodities starts to dominate relations betweenthe states surrounding the seaways of the eastern Mediterranean at the end of the Late Bronze Age.
E. Borgna (ed.), Nature and Function of Bronze Deposition between Europe and the Mediterranean: Hoards of the Late Bronze Age (https://www.openstarts.units.it/handle/10077/36231), 2024
The terroristic assault by Hamas on Israel. Our position. An open letter from scholars of antiquity.
Dear Friends and Colleagues, On the morning of October 7, ca. 2000 HAMAS terrorists launched a br... more Dear Friends and Colleagues, On the morning of October 7, ca. 2000 HAMAS terrorists launched a brutal attack on civilians in Israeli kibbutzim, moshavim and towns adjacent to the Gaza Strip. They went from house to house to burn, torture, mutilate, and kill Jewish families. They gunned down hundreds of young people at an outdoor music festival that turned into a scene of rape and massacre. Not only did they kill parents in front of children, raped women and children, murdered children and soldiers still asleep in their beds, but also beheaded babies that were sleeping in their cribs.
Condemn Hamas terrorism
Dear Friends and Colleagues, On the morning of October 7, ca. 2000 HAMAS terrorists launched a br... more Dear Friends and Colleagues, On the morning of October 7, ca. 2000 HAMAS terrorists launched a brutal attack on civilians in Israeli kibbutzim, moshavim and towns adjacent to the Gaza Strip. They went from house to house to burn, torture, mutilate, and kill Jewish families. They gunned down hundreds of young people at an outdoor music festival that turned into a scene of rape and massacre. Not only did they kill parents in front of children, raped women and children, murdered children and soldiers still asleep in their beds, but also beheaded babies that were sleeping in their cribs.
It was during a conference dinner in Rome, a few years ago, that we started talking about a colle... more It was during a conference dinner in Rome, a few years ago, that we started talking about a collective volume in honour of Penelope Mountjoy that now we can hold in our hands. Being a scholar of an indisputable quality, which transcends time and space, this volume does not intend to celebrate a special anniversary, but rather our honouree's extraordinary and enduring contribution to Aegean archaeology. Penelope is a talented and dedicated scholar, with a keen eye, skilled fingers, and distinct sense of humour. Whoever has worked with her knows that, except early in the morning, she is a gift that keeps on giving, and we have all learned from her over the years. Be it Mycenaean pottery, a great passion of her life, or any other decorated pottery for that matter, but also more complex questions about pottery technology, local imitations, depositional processes, colonisation, or how to drink ouzo right! Penelope does not have students in the traditional sense of the word. But there is a whole sea of researchers in Aegean prehistory who can be considered her pupils, having learned to deal with Mycenaean pottery thanks to her masterpieces: the Mycenaean Decorated Pottery volume, later on expanded into Regional Mycenaean Decorated Pottery (RMDP), or the more condensed Mycenaean Pottery: An Introduction. Her knowledge of Late Helladic painted tableware with its innumerable regional, or even local variants, is both unmatched and legendary. On top of that, she is known for her superb art of line drawing of archaeological finds (including good old-fashioned inking), a field where she counts hundreds of apprentices, especially at the College Year in Athens, also including one of the authors of this brief introduction. Affiliated for most of her life with the British School at Athens, Penelope's scientific profile is variegated and multiform. Her early interests lay with LM IB Marine style (1972 through 1985), and she has continued, even if sporadically, to work on Crete with her influential paper on Minoanisation of the Cyclades (2000, with M. Ponting), the volume on the material from the South House at Knossos (2003) and the article in the conference volume on LM IB published by the Danish Institute at Athens (2011). While systematically working and learning at Mycenae (1976), under the guarding eye of Lisa French, her first major monographic publication (1981) concerned the early Mycenaean wells on the southern slopes of the Acropolis in Athens, excavated by Nicolaos Platon. This important LH IIIA1 settlement material encompassed not only Mycenaean decorated pottery but also the late occurrence of Aeginetan Matt Painted hydriai, as well as the Acropolis Burnished Ware, which she first defined here. From there she moved to Central Greece, a journey that resulted in
This paper dealing with the demise of the Mycenaean palaces is intended as a plea for an interpre... more This paper dealing with the demise of the Mycenaean palaces is intended as a plea for an interpretive reset and a departure from any search for a single 'prime mover' allegedly responsible for this historical watershed. The doubts regarding the validity of the 'earthquake hypothesis' should be perceived as an opportunity to look for alternatives to previous explanatory approaches that were too simplistic. In order to do this, attention must shift away from events and towards assessing those structures and processes that enabled the palaces' demise. In this respect, three closely interrelated factors of historical, political, and social relevance to which I ascribe a crucial importance will be discussed: first, conflicts among the elites; second, large-scale construction projects; and, third, changes in the palatial armed forces. It is argued that the palaces were brought down first and foremost by internal contradictions that had long built up in the palatial polities and were exploited by members of the elite. Alongside antagonistic fault lines that developed over a long period of time, centrifugal forces were unleashed by social groups pursuing their own interests and forging alliances to strengthen their power base .
A. Yasur-Landau and A. Gilboa (eds.), Nomads of the Mediterranean: Trade and Contact in the Bronze and Iron Ages. Studies in Honor of Michal Artzy, pp 177-198, 2020
Archäologischer Anzeiger, 2010
Archäologischer Anzeiger, 2010
Primordialist understandings of ethnicity that rest on the proof of a direct and unbroken line of... more Primordialist understandings of ethnicity that rest on the proof of a direct and unbroken line of descent from ancient populations have, for good reasons, been abandoned by the humanities and social sciences after World War II. They were replaced by constructivist views that regard ethnicity as rooted in how groups think about themselves in specific social and historical contexts. By contrast, the "cultures" defined by archaeology constitute mere inventions by scholarship without any linkage to self-perceptions of past societies. The two cultures known as Minoan and Mycenaean are good examples of everything that is wrong with the concept of archaeological cultures. Besides creating the impression of longterm continuity and homogeneity in the geographical zones in question, the convention of juxtaposing the Minoan and Mycenaean cultures implies that societies in Crete and the Greek Mainland remained different for many centuries. The most problematic effect of defining archaeological cultures, however, is reflected in the habit of imbuing such mere constructs of archaeology with an "ethnic significance" by employing their names as substitutes for ethnic designations and speaking of "Mycenaeans" and "Minoans". By applying such fabricated ethnicities the impression is created that collective identities are clean-cut, supra-regionally and diachronically stable and mutually exclusive, not unlike modern nationalities. The alleged connection of "Minoans" and "Mycenaeans" to certain genetic patterns may then be taken as a justification for linking ethnicities to blood-ties. Those who do not wish to grace dangerous völkische ideologies of the extreme political right with scholarly respectability must realize that "ethnicizing" archeological "cultures" or language groups and "biologizing" them by linking them to DNA-patterns is not an innocent endeavor. Scholars using the results of aDNA research should refrain from imposing an ethnic significance on archaeological cultures and resist the temptation, fueled by public expectations, of connecting aDNA to ancient or modern collective identities. Fabricated ethnicities such as "Indo-Europeans", "Corded Ware people" or "Mycenaeans" should be particularly avoided in scholarly discourses as they create a false impression of supraregional and diachronic homogeneity (in the sense of Völker) and can thus be very easily abused for political ends.
Opuscula. Annual of the Swedish Institutes at Athens and Rome
Results of the Neutron Activation Analysis (NAA) of 61 pottery samples of Middle and Late Helladi... more Results of the Neutron Activation Analysis (NAA) of 61 pottery samples of Middle and Late Helladic date from recent excavations in Midea are presented. Chronologically, the sampled pieces fall into two groups, the first of Middle Helladic and Late Helladic I/II, the second of LH III date, with most samples dating to LH IIIB or IIIC. The analyses suggest an Argive/North-eastern Peloponnesian provenance for the majority of the sampled pottery, since 26 of the samples are assigned to the NAA group Mycenae-Berbati (MYBE) and 15 to the NAA group Tiryns (TIR), including their subgroups. In addition to the two main groups the analyses include three other categories: “non-Argive”, unlocated, and singles. The differentiation into a small number of distinct chemical patterns is much more evident in the second chronological group of sampled pottery than in the earlier one which comprises a variety of chemical patterns in a small number of samples. Evidently, during the Mycenaean Palatial perio...
Origini è una rivista annuale soggetta a processo di peer-review ed è pubblicata da / Origini is ... more Origini è una rivista annuale soggetta a processo di peer-review ed è pubblicata da / Origini is subject to a peer-review process and is published yearly by: "SAPIENZA" UNIVERSITÀ DI ROMA Dipartimento di Scienze dell' Antichità
Archäologischer Anzeiger, 2021
Mit dem Herunterladen erkennen Sie die Nutzungsbedingungen (h ps://publica ons.dainst.org/terms-o... more Mit dem Herunterladen erkennen Sie die Nutzungsbedingungen (h ps://publica ons.dainst.org/terms-of-use) von iDAI.publica ons an. Sofern in dem Dokument nichts anderes ausdrücklich vermerkt ist, gelten folgende Nutzungsbedingungen: Die Nutzung der Inhalte ist ausschließlich privaten Nutzerinnen / Nutzern für den eigenen wissenscha lichen und sons gen privaten Gebrauch gesta et. Sämtliche Texte, Bilder und sons ge Inhalte in diesem Dokument unterliegen dem Schutz des Urheberrechts gemäß dem Urheberrechtsgesetz der Bundesrepublik Deutschland. Die Inhalte können von Ihnen nur dann genutzt und vervielfäl gt werden, wenn Ihnen dies im Einzelfall durch den Rechteinhaber oder die Schrankenregelungen des Urheberrechts gesta et ist. Jede Art der Nutzung zu gewerblichen Zwecken ist untersagt. Zu den Möglichkeiten einer Lizensierung von Nutzungsrechten wenden Sie sich bi e direkt an die verantwortlichen Herausgeberinnen/Herausgeber der entsprechenden Publika onsorgane oder an die Online-Redak on des Deutschen Archäologischen Ins tuts
The present contribution argues against the until-recently repeated claim that silver was neither... more The present contribution argues against the until-recently repeated claim that silver was neither produced nor used in the Aegean until the 3rd millennium BC, or at least considerably later in the 4th millennium BC than in West Asia. Even if societies in the Aegean and Southeastern Europe had very different political and economic structures than those of the Near and Middle East, the extraction, processing and use of silver seems to have begun in all these regions at about the same time. Thus, in the Aegean the use of this precious metal can be traced back to the early 4th millennium BC and possibly even earlier, and the same holds true for certain areas of the Carpatho-Balkan zone. In the last decades, especially evidence of the earliest phase of silver mining and extraction in the Aegean has dramatically increased, with the argentiferous lead ore deposits of Lavrion, Siphnos and Thasos that would later come to dominate silver production in classical Greece impressively emerging as major sources already in the earliest phase of producing silver. The reluctance to accept the use and production of silver in the Aegean prior to 3000 BC was based on a combination of diffusionist and evolutionist preconceptions. The first preconception lies in the assumption that technological innovations were developed in one particular region and transferred from there unidirectionally to surrounding areas. The second derives from the notion that diachronic changes in societies can be modelled into discrete stages of unilinear technological progression, in which the potential for innovation is tied to the degree of a given society's "complexity". It is here argued that the unidirectional model of diffusionism must be replaced by a multidirectional, dialogical model in which the geographic area between the Carpathian Basin and the Balkans in the northwest and the Iranian highlands in the southeast would have to be perceived as an interaction sphere consisting of many sub-zones, in which knowledge and practices travelled in various directions. Vasileios Petrakos has vastly improved our knowledge of the diachronic history and culture of the landscape of Attica through his research. I have learned a great deal from him and, with this contribution, would like to express my gratitude and pay him my respects for all that he has achieved.
Engaging with ... 'Engaging with ... ' is a series of big, multi-contributed volumes with between... more Engaging with ... 'Engaging with ... ' is a series of big, multi-contributed volumes with between 25 and 40 contributOrs and up to 350,000 words in length. These volumes are typically broken into three pans, Concepts, Key Terms/Methodologies and Case Studies, and they are designed co provide a reference work for researchers and students for exciting new copies. Books in this series cover the key concepts of the field or approach being studied, and conwn analysis of the signi.ficant tenus being used, as well as providing case studies of research currently being done. They are the perfect opportunity to bring together the work of established academics, early career academics and postgraduate students. In chis series: Engaging Transcultu.rality Concepts, Key T enns, Case Studies Edited by Laila Abu-Er-R'lb, Christialle Brosius, Sebastian MeHrer, Diamamis Panagiotopou/os and Susan Ridner
Jahrbuch des Deutschen Archäologischen Instituts, 2020, vol. 135, 1-99, 2020
Maritime commodity trade from the Near East to the Mycenaean heartland: Canaanite Jars in final p... more Maritime commodity trade from the Near East to the Mycenaean heartland: Canaanite Jars in final palatial Tiryns.
Canaanite jars from the palatial site of Tiryns in mainland Greece are shown to have been producedat a number of centres on the Levantine coast, emphasising the key role of the Argive coastal citadelin trade with the eastern Mediterranean at the end of the 13th century BCE. The analytical study ofthis assemblage draws on a detailed examination of key deposits connected to the last phase of thepalace at the site and its destruction, and combines thin section petrography and chemical analysis(NAA), providing major new insights into the specific production locations of these containers alongthe Levantine coast. Based on comparative material from other Aegean sites and especially theharbour of Kommos in southern Crete, typological, epigraphic and analytical data are combined todemonstrate that, towards the end of the 13th century BCE, Tiryns was interacting with differentLevantine centres than did Kommos roughly 100 years earlier. This diachronic shift in the source ofCanaanite jars reaching the Aegean has much to tell us about changing centres of political power,the emergence of regular commodity trade and even diplomatic problems, all at a time whencontainer shipment takes off and the demand for commodities starts to dominate relations betweenthe states surrounding the seaways of the eastern Mediterranean at the end of the Late Bronze Age.
Eine Solidaritätserklärung von Altertumswissenschaftler*innen mit Israel. A letter of solidari... more Eine Solidaritätserklärung von Altertumswissenschaftler*innen mit Israel.
A letter of solidarity with Israel from scholars of Antiquity.
Im folgenden werden wir der Frage nachgehen, wie der in weiten Teilen unseres Untersuchungsgebiet... more Im folgenden werden wir der Frage nachgehen, wie der in weiten Teilen unseres Untersuchungsgebiets zu beobachtende Kulturwandel in der Wendezeit FH II/FH III in einem größeren geographischen Zusammenhang zu beurteilen ist. Im einzelnen ist zu fragen, inwiefern sich Kulturbeziehungen zu ausgewählten Regionen Südosteuropas, des Zentralmittelmeerraumes und der Ostägäis bemerkbar machen und welcher Stellenwert etwaigen Beziehungen beizumessen ist. Bevor wir auf die Kriterien zu sprechen kommen, die die Auswahl der untersuchten Großregionen bestimmten, sind einige grundsätzliche Bemerkungen notwendig. Bis in jüngster Zeit bildete die aus Kettendatierung und komparativer Stratigraphie bestehende archäologisch-historische Methode, zumindest in der deutschsprachigen Forschung, das wichtigste Hilfsmittel für die Beurteilung nicht nur der relativchronologischen sondern auch der absolutchronologischen Stellung der chalkolithischen und frühbronzezeitlichen Kulturen Südosteuropas. Wie wir noch sehen werden, zog aber die Anwendung dieser Methode einige schwerwiegende Fehleinschätzungen im Hinblick auf die Synchronisierung der frühbronzezeitlichen Ägäis mit dem Norden, aber auch mit der ägyptischen Chronologie nach sich'. Nicht zuletzt diese, teilweise vehement verteidigten 2 Fehleinschätzungen waren es, die dazu führten, daß die archäologisch-historische Methode immer mehr an Bedeutung für die relativ-und absolutchronologische Beurteilung der Kulturen Südost-und Mitteleuropas verlor und allmählich von einem naturwissenschaftlichen Datierungsverfahren, der 14 C-Methode, überflügelt wurde. In der Tat ist der Bestand an Radiokarbondaten besonders für das Karpatenbecken einschließlich der benachbarten Regionen, unterdessen so groß, daß eine eigenständige, auf naturwissenschaftlichem Wege gewonnene absolute Chronologie der vor-eisenzeitlichen Kulturen des östlichen Mitteleuropas und Südosteuropas entworfen werden kann, wobei selbstverständlich nur kalibrierte 14 C-Daten in die Diskussion einbezogen werden dürfen 3 • Zusätzlich besteht die Möglichkeit, diese kalibrierte 14 C-Chronologie durch die für Süddeutschland und die Schweiz vorliegende Dendrochronologie des Neolithikums und der Bronzezeit zu überprüfen und zu ergänzen. In diesem Zusammenhang kann gar nicht genügend betont werden4, welcher Stellenwert den dendrochronologisch gewonnenen Daten Süddeutschlands und der Schweiz auch für eine Studie wie der hier vorliegenden zukommt, bietet doch die Dendrochronologie eine Datierungsgenauigkeit, die weder von der 14 C-Methode noch von der archäologisch-historischen Methode je erreicht werden wird. Eine Ausklammerung der Ergebnisse der Dendrochronologie ist auch deshalb unvertretbar, weil die neolithischen und bronzezeitlichen Kulturen Süddeutschlands und der Schweiz ja nicht im "luftleeren Raum" existiert haben, sondern durch mannigfaltige Beziehungen mit der Kulturentwicklung im östlichen Mitteleuropa und in Südosteuropa verflochten sind 5 • Der archäologisch-historischen Methode würden wir demnach bei der Bestimmung der absoluten Chronologie des Zeitraums vom Neolithikum bis in die Bronzezeit Südost-und Mitteleuropas keine 318 und Kap. 5.2.1.2). Schon soviel sei gesagt, daß man an sich gerade im Falle des Aussagewerts der Gefäßformen der Badener Kultur für weiträumige Horizontierungen hätte gewarnt sein müssen, da eine Leitform der klassischen Badener Kultur, der Krug mit Zylinderhals, steil hochziehendem Bandhenkel und Kannelur auf dem Körper, als Konvergenzerscheinung z.B. in der bronzezeitlichen Füzesabony-Kultur des nordöstlichen Ungarns auftritt, die beim besten Willen nicht in die zeitliche Nähe der Badener Kultur gebracht werden kann: vgl. Schalk (1992) Abb. 32.
Zu der Struktur und den Motiven des Handels im Mittelmeerraum während des 3. Jahrtausends v. Chr .
Die Broschüre gibt einen Überblick über die im Jahr 2017 durchgeführten Projekte und Veranstaltun... more Die Broschüre gibt einen Überblick über die im Jahr 2017 durchgeführten Projekte und Veranstaltungen sowie Informationen zum Haus und seiner Geschichte. Es schließt damit an die Ausgabe von 2015/2016 an.
The question of how to conceptualize the role of technological innovations is of crucial importan... more The question of how to conceptualize the role of technological innovations is of crucial importance for understanding the mechanisms and rhythms of long-term cultural change in prehistoric and early historic societies. The changes that have come about have often been modelled as gradual and linear, innovations have been considered positively as a progress in the development of humankind and the focus has been on the localisation of the origin of innovations and the routes of their spread. Appropriating Innovations goes beyond the current discussion by shedding light on condition that may facilitate the rapid spread of technological innovation and on processes involved in the integration of new technologies into the life world of the appropriating societies. In particular, papers concentrate on two key innovations, namely the transmission of the various components of the so-called “Secondary Products Revolution” in parts of the Near East and Europe during the 4th millennium BCE and the appropriation of early bronze casting technology, which spread from the Near East to Europe and China in the late 3rd and early 2nd millennium BCE. Of particular interest is non-technological knowledge that is transmitted together with the technological, the latter being always deeply interconnected with the communication of social practices, ideas and myths. The acceptance of new technologies, therefore, requires the willingness to change existing world views and modify them due to the potentials and problems which are connected with the new technology. Contributions, therefore, concentrate on the conditions facilitating or hindering the spread of innovations and the transformative power of these innovations in the appropriating society. They analyse how the introduction of novel technologies and the associated non-technological knowledge led to a transformation of existing economic systems and the underlying social orders in Late Neolithic, Chalcolithic and Early Bronze Age Eurasia by integrating innovative methodological approaches and contextual studies.
Materiality and Social Practice investigates the transformative potential arising from the interp... more Materiality and Social Practice investigates the transformative potential arising from the interplay between material forms, social practices and intercultural relations. Such a focus necessitates an approach that takes a transcultural perspective as a fundamental methodology as well as a broader understanding of the inter-relationship between humans and objects. Adopting a transcultural approach forces us to change archaeology’s approach towards items coming from the outside. By using them mostly for reconstructing systems of exchange or for chronology, archaeology has for a long time reduced them to their properties as objects and as being foreign. This volume explores the notion that the signif cance of such items does not derive from the transfer from one place to another as such but, rather, from the ways in which they were used and contextualised. The main question is how, through their integration into discourses and practices, new frameworks of meaning were created conforming neither with what had existed in the receiving society nor in the area of origin of the objects.
The present volume is aimed at contributing to an understanding of the architecture of societies ... more The present volume is aimed at contributing to an understanding of the architecture of societies from prehistory to the present day as a source for social history and sociology. This endeavour is based on a notion of architecture as both document and precondition of social realities, both platform for the self - projection of those in power and an arena for a continuing renegotiation of power, both a medium of codified messages and a means of spatial ordering. The representative aspects of buildings are not left undiscussed, but the focus is on an enquiry into how architectural space and social agency together not only communicated, but reproduced systems of values, views of the world and particular social roles.
Dear Friends and Colleagues, On the morning of October 7, ca. 2000 HAMAS terrorists launched a br... more Dear Friends and Colleagues, On the morning of October 7, ca. 2000 HAMAS terrorists launched a brutal attack on civilians in Israeli kibbutzim, moshavim and towns adjacent to the Gaza Strip. They went from house to house to burn, torture, mutilate, and kill Jewish families. They gunned down hundreds of young people at an outdoor music festival that turned into a scene of rape and massacre. Not only did they kill parents in front of children, raped women and children, murdered children and soldiers still asleep in their beds, but also beheaded babies that were sleeping in their cribs.
Paper presented at 41st International Symposium on Archaeometry, Kalamata, Greece, May 2016.
gavrIlă sImIOn eCo-museum researCH institute (tulCea) CounCil of tulCea County vasIle Pârvan inst... more gavrIlă sImIOn eCo-museum researCH institute (tulCea) CounCil of tulCea County vasIle Pârvan institute of arCHaeology romanian aCaDemy (buCHarest) institut für ur-unD früHgesCHiCHte unD vorDerasiatisCHe arCHäologie (HeiDelberg)
Results and conclusions: Using domestic pigs as a local reference for isotope based mobility stud... more Results and conclusions: Using domestic pigs as a local reference for isotope based mobility studies for ancient human populations is an potential alternative to small mammals or game, if those sample types are not available in significant amounts. But since domestic animals are always dependent on human impact, cultural, economic and agricultural specifics must be reconsidered. Pig data can show a narrower distribution than humans. Still, it is hard to assess, if this reference range really represents the local human population as well. Pig isotopic ratios from Tel Nami might exceed the local distribution due to trading and extensive herding. Not only human, but also animal mobility seems to have taken place in Nami in high amounts (in the case of pigs not necessarily as living animals but possibly also as trading goods, like salted pork).
The strontium results hint at connections to the inland, more precisely Mount Carmel and the Jezreel valley etc. All strontium outliers can be explained with locations close to the investigated area, pointing inland to the Jordan valley or even the site Megiddo. The analyzed data further support the hypothesis that there was a close relation between Tel Nami and Megiddo. Even children and pregnant women seem to have been mobile in between those two settlements, which are less than a day-trip apart. Isotopic ratios which fall in between the two sites could be explained as mixtures, as the individuals were moving in between the two locations of Megiddo and Nami during their childhood.
Haaretz, 2018
Debris and bodies crushed under fallen walls had led archaeologists to think Mycenaean civilizati... more Debris and bodies crushed under fallen walls had led archaeologists to think Mycenaean civilization was brought down by quake. Can't be, geophysical study reports
Universitätsforschungen zur prähistorischen Archäologie, Band 350, 2020
For more than 150 years, the prehistoric civilizations of the East Mediterranean have fascinated... more For more than 150 years, the prehistoric civilizations of the East Mediterranean have fascinated and attracted numerous scholars interested both in the various manifestations of the respective social order within this geographical zone, and by the role and impact these civilizations may have had on the neighbouring regions.
As one would expect, our knowledge is growing continuously, triggered by new archaeological research, the progress of interdisciplinary investigations of archaeological science, and the diversification of theoretical approaches interpreting material culture from an anthropological perspective. The speed of these accumulations is increasing rapidly, while the number of studies and the variety and complexity of the themes is also continuously growing. That is why the periodic organization of conferences on welldefined themes and the publication of the respective volumes are absolutely necessary, not only in order to be able to integrate the new data into the broader picture, but also for the redefinition of the state of research within certain working areas and to show the experimental investigation of new research directions.
The present volume is the outcome of a conference with the same title organized at Tulcea, Romania, between the 10th and the 13th of November 2017, dedicated to the memory of Professor Alexandru Vulpe. Four prestigious institutions, two from Romania (the Gavrilă Simion Eco-Museum Research Institute, Tulcea and the Vasile Pârvan Institute of Archaeology, Bucharest) and two from Germany (the Institut für und Frühgeschichte und Vorderasiatische Archäologie, Heidelberg and the Deutsches Archäologisches Institut, Eurasien Abteilung, Berlin), with the generous support of the Mayor’s Office in Tulcea, managed to bring together over 50 scholars, most of them friends, colleagues, collaborators, students or simply acquaintances of Professor Vulpe. The intention of the organizers was to provide a suitable environment for sharing opinions and experience, and for an open and positive discussion, to recognize the current state of research on the topic, and to establish stronger connections for future collaboration in this field.
Contacts among human communities from various cultural areas, the circulation of people, ideas and objects, or the identification of the main communication routes as well as their role in shaping prehistoric societies are likely to remain forever topics of intense discussion within archaeology. The relations between the Carpathian-Balkan area and the Aegean during the Bronze Age and the Early Iron Age was one of the main themes of study for Alexandru Vulpe. As a supporter of the idea of Ex oriente lux, Vulpe always argued for the major role played by the Helladic civilization in the cultural development of the Carpathian Balkan area. The lectures delivered at the Tulcea conference and the papers published in the present volume highlight once again the complexity of these connections and the multitude of perspectives revealed when approaching such a theme.
Although the title of the volume indicates the main geographic areas in question, contributions from other cultural areas (i.e. Central Europe, the Middle Danube, Northern Pontic area, etc.), whose societies were in close contact with those of the Balkans, were also welcome. The four sections grouping the studies in the volume had not been established from the very beginning; they are the result of the subjects approached by the authors. Reading the papers attentively, one notices the diversity of the subjects and approaches and, in most cases, the novelty of the ideas expressed. We hope that the publication will provide research with a reference volume, opening new perspectives on the matters discussed. The present work is the result of the common effort of all authors, spanning a period of over three years. We wish to thank all contributors for their promptness and seriousness in answering our invitation to the volume, as well as for the openness and patience showed during the entire editing process. We are very much indebted to the Mayor’s Office of the community of Tulcea for the financial help and for the hospitality provided to the participants of the conference. Special thanks go to Douglas Fear (Heidelberg) for the careful language editing of the contributions to this volume.
Constructing Power - Architecture, Ideology and Social Practice, 2009
The present volume is aimed at contributing to an understanding of the architecture of societies ... more The present volume is aimed at contributing to an understanding of the architecture of societies from prehistory to the present day as a source for social history and sociology. This endeavour is based on a notion of architecture as both document and precondition of social realities, both platform for the self - projection of those in power and an arena for a continuing renegotiation of power, both a medium of codified messages and a means of spatial ordering. The representative aspects of buildings are not left undiscussed, but the focus is on an enquiry into how architectural space and social agency together not only communicated, but reproduced systems of values, views of the world and particular social roles.
Jahrbuch des Deutschen Archäologischen Instituts, 2020
Canaanite jars from the palatial site of Tiryns in mainland Greece are shown to have been produce... more Canaanite jars from the palatial site of Tiryns in mainland Greece are shown to have been produced at a number of centres on the Levantine coast, emphasising the key role of the Argive coastal citadel in trade with the eastern Mediterranean at the end of the 13th century BCE. The analytical study of this assemblage draws on a detailed examination of key deposits connected to the last phase of the palace at the site and its destruction, and combines thin section petrography and chemical analysis (NAA), providing major new insights into the specific production locations of these containers along the Levantine coast. Based on comparative material from other Aegean sites and especially the harbour of Kommos in southern Crete, typological, epigraphic and analytical data are combined to demonstrate that, towards the end of the 13th century BCE, Tiryns was interacting with different Levantine centres than did Kommos roughly 100 years earlier. This diachronic shift in the source of Canaanite jars reaching the Aegean has much to tell us about changing centres of political power, the emergence of regular commodity trade and even diplomatic problems, all at a time when container shipment takes off and the demand for commodities starts to dominate relations between the states surrounding the seaways of the eastern Mediterranean at the end of the Late Bronze Age.
Dear Friends and Colleagues, On the morning of October 7, ca. 2000 HAMAS terrorists launched a br... more Dear Friends and Colleagues, On the morning of October 7, ca. 2000 HAMAS terrorists launched a brutal attack on civilians in Israeli kibbutzim, moshavim and towns adjacent to the Gaza Strip. They went from house to house to burn, torture, mutilate, and kill Jewish families. They gunned down hundreds of young people at an outdoor music festival that turned into a scene of rape and massacre. Not only did they kill parents in front of children, raped women and children, murdered children and soldiers still asleep in their beds, but also beheaded babies that were sleeping in their cribs.
Sektion des Forum Archäologie in Gesellschaft (FaiG) bei der Tagung der deutschen Altertumsverbän... more Sektion des Forum Archäologie in Gesellschaft (FaiG) bei der Tagung der deutschen Altertumsverbände am Nachmittag des 8. Oktober 2024 (Dienstag) in Bochum