Fernando Grasso | Università degli Studi di Napoli "Federico II" (original) (raw)

Papers by Fernando Grasso

Research paper thumbnail of Moving Buffalo Farming beyond Traditional Areas: Performances of Animals, and Quality of Mozzarella and Forages

Agriculture

An observational case study was designed to highlight issues associated with a possible expansion... more An observational case study was designed to highlight issues associated with a possible expansion of dairy buffalo (Bubalus bubalis) farming outside the traditional coastal plains of southern Italy. Twenty pregnant buffaloes were transferred to a hilly inland farm. After calving, production and reproduction data were collected monthly throughout lactation. From 4 to 6 months of lactation, buffaloes were enrolled in a feeding trial to evaluate the effects of locally grown forages (maize silage vs. hay) on milk production and in vivo digestibility. Sensory properties of mozzarella cheese produced at a local dairy were also evaluated. No obvious effects of diet were found. Compared to the data recorded in the previous lactation completed in the farm of origin, milk yield was reduced by 37.2%, and milk protein by 6.1%, whereas milk fat improved (+4.5%). A lower pregnancy rate (−13.3%), increased days open (+122%), and a prolonged intercalving period (+26.9%) were also observed. Lactatio...

Research paper thumbnail of Risk factors associated with the expression of cross-sucking and intersucking in buffaloes

The incidence and the potential risk factors for cross-sucking in calves and intersucking in lact... more The incidence and the potential risk factors for cross-sucking in calves and intersucking in lactating cows were assessed in 73 buffalo farms located in the area of PDO ‘Mozzarella di Bufala Campana’. Two trained assessors collected the data through a questionnaire including resource and management measures, which were directly taken and asked to the farmer, respectively. The incidences of cross-sucking, intersucking and mortality were also asked to the farmer. The farm was used as experimental unit. For each discrete risk factor, an ANOVA was performed to assess the association with outcome variables (i.e. the incidence of cross-sucking and intersucking), whereas for continuous risk factors the association was tested using Pearson correlation coefficients. Cross-sucking and intersucking were observed in 91% and 45% of the farms, respectively; their mean incidences were 21.9 ± 22.3 and 1.2 ± 1.9 (mean ± SD), respectively. Cross-sucking was negatively correlated with the number of ca...

Research paper thumbnail of Produzione e longevità delle bovine da latte

Research paper thumbnail of Housing system and welfare of buffalo (Bubalus bubalis) cows

Animal Science, 2004

Twenty-eight buffalo cows were used to evaluate the effect of housing system on a range of behavi... more Twenty-eight buffalo cows were used to evaluate the effect of housing system on a range of behavioural and physiological variables. Fourteen cows were group-housed in a loose open-sided barn with a concrete floor and 10 m2 per head as space allowance (group IS). Fourteen others were group-housed in a similar barn but they could also benefit from an outdoor yard with 500 m2 per head as space allowance, free access to potholes for wallowing and spontaneous vegetation (group TS). Animals were subjected to six sessions of instantaneous scan sampling at 10-day intervals. Behavioural variables were expressed as proportions of subjects observed in each category of posture and activity. Phytohaemagglutinin (PHA) was used to perform a skin test based on non-specific delayed type hypersensitivity, whereas 20 mg of ovalbumin were injected subcutaneously to evaluate humoral immune response. Blood samples for evaluation of cortisol concentration were collected immediately prior to exogenous porc...

Research paper thumbnail of Effect of pen size on behavioral, endocrine, and immune responses of water buffalo (Bubalus bubalis) calves

Journal of Animal Science, 1999

for assistance with conducting the experiment. Thanks are also due to the farm Gaetano Iemma for ... more for assistance with conducting the experiment. Thanks are also due to the farm Gaetano Iemma for hospitality and to Mark Walters for revising the English text.

Research paper thumbnail of Application of the Welfare Quality protocol to dairy buffalo farms: Prevalence and reliability of selected measures

Journal of dairy science, 2015

Within the general aim of developing a Welfare Quality system for monitoring dairy buffalo welfar... more Within the general aim of developing a Welfare Quality system for monitoring dairy buffalo welfare, this study focused on prevalence and interobserver reliability of the animal-related variables to be included in the scheme. As most of the measures were developed for cattle, the study also aimed to verify their prevalence for buffaloes. Thirty animal-based measures (22 clinical and 8 behavioral measurements) and 20 terms used for qualitative behavior assessment were assessed in 42 loose-housed buffalo farms. All farms were located in central-southern Italy. Two assessors were used (1 male and 1 female). The time needed to record all measures (animal-, resource-, and management-based) was 5.47±0.48 h (mean ± SD). Interobserver reliability of animal-based measures was evaluated using Spearman rank correlation coefficient test (rs). If 0.7 is considered as threshold for high interobserver reliability, all animal-based measures were above this level. In particular, most of the coefficie...

Research paper thumbnail of Effect of Saccharomyces cerevisiae Live Cells on In Vivo Digestibility and Nitrogen Excretion in Lactating Buffaloes

Journal of Buffalo Science, 2014

The effects of dietary inclusion of Saccharomyces cerevisiae culture on intake, in vivo digestibi... more The effects of dietary inclusion of Saccharomyces cerevisiae culture on intake, in vivo digestibility, and fecal nitrogen excretion were examined in dairy buffalo. Forty lactating buffalo cows were equally divided into Control and Saccharomyces groups, balanced for milk production, parity, and days in milk. Two subsequent 16-d experimental phases were carried out. For both groups during the first experimental period a TMR based on maize silage (maize-TMR) was used, whereas in the second period an alfalfa haylage (alfalfa-TMR) was administered to the animals. In each experimental period, Saccharomyces group was supplemented with 50 g/head/day of yeast (Biocell®, Limena, Padova, Italy), corresponding to 20 10 9 CFU/head/day Saccharomyces cerevisiae NCYC Sc47 strain. The yeast supplement was top-dressed onto the morning feed. Dry matter intake (DMI) was assessed for 6 consecutive d on group basis, by the difference between feed offered and refused. In the last 3 days of experimental period in vivo digestibility was determined by using acid-insoluble ash (AIA) as an intrinsic digestibility marker. Saccharomyces supplemented buffalo cows presented greater DMI of maize-TMR, whereas no statistical differences between the groups were observed for alfalfa-TMR. Saccharomyces supplementation significantly improved in vivo digestibility of both TMR. Fecal nitrogen excretion was significantly reduced by the use of yeast supplementation. Results suggest that the inclusion of Saccharomyces cerevisiae culture in the diet for lactating buffaloes can be recommended for its effects on cow's digestive efficiency and fecal nitrogen excretion.

Research paper thumbnail of Repeatability of some animal-related variables in dairy cows and buffaloes

Animal welfare (South Mimms, England)

The aim of this study was to evaluate the intra-observer repeatability of some animal-related var... more The aim of this study was to evaluate the intra-observer repeatability of some animal-related variables which could be used in welfare-assessment protocols at farm level. Recordings were performed on seven dairy farms (four for cattle and three for buffaloes). The animals were observed on three occasions at three-week intervals. The variables collected for each animal were behaviour during milking (stepping and kicking), avoidance distance, lameness, and cleanliness. For each farm and each variable, intra-observer repeatability was computed using the Kendall coefficient of concordance (W). A ratio between the variance of the animal and the sum of the latter with the error variance was also calculated using a model of analysis of variance with one factor (animal), to give a further measure of repeatability. These two methods yielded similar results. In particular, in dairy cattle, a high repeatability for avoidance distance, stepping, lameness and cleanliness was observed, whereas fo...

Research paper thumbnail of Effect of pre-partum habituation to milking routine on behaviour and lactation performance of buffalo heifers

Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 2014

The aim of this study was to investigate the effect pre-partum habituation in the milking parlour... more The aim of this study was to investigate the effect pre-partum habituation in the milking parlour on behaviour and lactation performance of buffalo heifers. Sixteen buffalo heifers in late gestation were used for this study. The animals, with an age ranging from 30 to 44 months at the start of the study, were equally allocated into two treatments and balanced for estimated calving date. Eight animals received pre-partum habituation for 10 days before the estimated calving date (group H), while the eight others received no treatment and served as the control (group C). During the pre-partum habituation sessions, group H animals were moved to the milking parlour and left for 10 min in the milking stall once each day, where the udder was thoroughly washed with warm water, wiped with a disposable towel and massaged. The behaviours, registered from entrance into the milking stall to exit, were step and kick. After calving milk flow profiles, milk yield and milk quality variables were determined along with behavioural recordings. The H animals during the habituation procedure showed a reduction in the number of steps (P < 0.001) and kicks (P < 0.01). After calving the H animals performed fewer steps than the control animals at 0 (P < 0.001), 3 (P < 0.01), 6 (P < 0.01), 13 (P < 0.01) and 20 (P < 0.01) days after calving. Animals from group H also performed fewer kicks than control animals at 0 (P < 0.001), 3 (P < 0.01), 6 (P < 0.01) and 13 (P < 0.01) days after calving. In the C group a reduction in the number of steps (P < 0.001) and kicks (P < 0.001) was observed as lactation proceeded, whereas for group H only a tendency for a reduction over lactation was detected. Pre-partum habituation did not significantly affect milk quality or milk flow variables. Milk yield in the first 3 min of milking (P < 0.001), and average milk flow (P < 0.001), increased throughout the experimental period, whereas the duration of the pre-milking phase decreased as lactation proceeded (P < 0.001). This study shows that buffalo heifers exposed to a pre-partum habituation programme performed fewer steps and kicks than control animals during milking. Therefore, it is concluded that using this treatment can reduce the level of restlessness in buffalo heifers during milking.

Research paper thumbnail of Conditioned inhibition of antibody response and CD4 positive cells

Physiology & Behavior, 1998

Animals were assigned to three experimental groups, conditioned (cyclophosphamide-glucose treatme... more Animals were assigned to three experimental groups, conditioned (cyclophosphamide-glucose treatment; C group), non-conditioned (cyclophosphamide-commercial pellet treatment; NC group) and placebo (saline solution-glucose treatment; P group). The three groups were injected intraperitoneally (i.p.) with sheep red blood cells. An hemagglutination assay according to standard procedures was performed along with the flow cytofluorometric analysis of leukocyte surface antigens CD4, CD8 and CD45. C group consumed less food on Days 3 and 6 than on Day 0, NC animals showed no changes in food consumption throughout the experimental period, whereas an increasing trend was observed for P animals. The proportion of T lymphocytes expressing CD8 and CD45 did not differ significantly among C, NC and P groups. Group C showed the lowest proportion of T lymphocytes bearing CD4, whereas Group P displayed the highest. The antibody response was lower in the Group C than in the groups NC and P. We conclude that, although the mechanisms by which humoral conditioned immunosuppression occurs in mice is still unknown, a reduced T helper-mediated activation of B-cells may play an important role in producing conditioned humoral response.

Research paper thumbnail of Performance and immune response of buffalo calves supplemented with probiotic

Livestock Science, 2011

The effect of dietary supplementation with Enterococcus faecium strain SF68 (E. faecium SF68) on ... more The effect of dietary supplementation with Enterococcus faecium strain SF68 (E. faecium SF68) on growth performance, fecal consistency, in vivo digestibility and immune response in buffalo (Bubalus bubalis) calves was evaluated at a commercial dairy location. Forty calves were randomly assigned at 10days of age to one of four treatments: A—milk replacer with no additive, B—milk replacer supplemented with 0.17g/L

Research paper thumbnail of Milking behaviour of buffalo cows: entrance order and side preference in the milking parlour

Journal of Dairy Research, 2013

On two farms, three milking groups of buffalo cows were used to assess the consistency of entranc... more On two farms, three milking groups of buffalo cows were used to assess the consistency of entrance order and the preference for one side of the milking parlour. On Farm 1 (F1) all animals were primiparous (n=57). On Farm 2, three primiparous, 16 secondiparous and 36 multiparous cows (range 1–8) constituted group F2G1; whereas group F2G2 had 12 primiparous, 10 secondiparous and 14 multiparous cows (range 1–10). Animals were milked in auto-tandem milking parlours (2×5 and 2×6 for Farms 1 and 2, respectively). For each cow, entrance order into milking parlour, side where she was milked, milk yield, time and duration of milking were recorded. These data were derived from the computerised identification of cows. The sequence in which the cows entered the milking parlour ranged from 1 to 57 for group F1, from 1 to 55 for group F2G1 and from 1 to 36 for group F2G2. The analysis of data was conducted on 130, 120 and 92 consecutive milkings for groups F1, F2G1 and F2G2, respectively. Kendall...

Research paper thumbnail of Use of peas in organic buffalo farming: effects on nutrient digestibility and milk production

Italian Journal of Animal Science, 2010

Twenty lactating buffalo cows, organically farmed, were used to examine the effects of including ... more Twenty lactating buffalo cows, organically farmed, were used to examine the effects of including peas in total mixed ration. Two concentrates were formulated to contain, as the main pro-Two concentrates were formulated to contain, as the main protein sources, either 350 g/kg of soybean cake (CC) or 450 g/kg of peas (ExpC). Cows were blocked into Cows were blocked into ows were blocked into two groups according to parity and previous milk yield and were assigned to one of two dietary treatments: one group was fed a diet with 6 kg/d of CC, whereas the treatment group was fed diet in which 3 kg/d of CC were replaced by an equal quantity of ExpC. Digestibility of the diets and milk yield of the cows were measured. The experimental period covered the whole lactation period. No differences were. The experimental period covered the whole lactation period. No differences were The experimental period covered the whole lactation period. No differences were observed between groups for milk yield and composition, and for digestibility. The main hypothesis The main hypothesis tested, that the replacement of soybean cake with peas in buffalo diet would not affect milk yield and soybean cake with peas in buffalo diet would not affect milk yield and buffalo diet would not affect milk yield and diet would not affect milk yield and would not affect milk yield and composition, was confirmed. This suggested that the partial substitution of soybean cake with peas in was confirmed. This suggested that the partial substitution of soybean cake with peas in This suggested that the partial substitution of soybean cake with peas in soybean cake with peas in diet for buffalo cows can be possible without affect performances. for buffalo cows can be possible without affect performances.

Research paper thumbnail of Positive indicators of cattle welfare and their applicability to on-farm protocols

Italian Journal of Animal Science, 2009

Most of the research on animal welfare has focused on the negative aspects of the matter includin... more Most of the research on animal welfare has focused on the negative aspects of the matter including an array of stress categories, whereas little has been done about the positive states of well being. The present study aims to describe indicators of positive animal welfare suitable for on-farm assessment. Appropriate environmental stimulation favours good welfare and, in an adequately enriched environment, positive indicators of welfare such as play behaviour tend to be more common. In addition, animals are motivated to perform these behaviours only if their primary needs are satisfied. In cattle, beneficial effects of social licking have been observed with positive correlation between being licked vs. milk production and weight gain, respectively. Ruminants are gregarious and a high degree of synchronisation within the herd may indicate a positive welfare state, in particular for subordinate animals. They may be able to meet their basic feeding and resting requirements performing these behaviours when the competition for a particular resource is low, however their welfare state would be improved if they could choose when and where (i.e. along with the other members of the group) to perform such behaviours. Due to the reduced applicability (mainly young animals), low feasibility (time consuming) and lack of research on reliability, play behaviour, albeit of proven validity, does not appear to be suitable for a rapid implementation in a welfare assessment scheme. Social licking is rarely expressed and its detection may be time consuming and scarcely feasible. Although validity and reliability need more studies, behaviour synchrony seems to be a promising positive welfare indicator as the instantaneous scan sampling technique makes this indicator easily applicable. Recently, a new methodology called "qualitative assessment of animal behaviour" has been developed. The method relies on a number of terms which are freely generated by observers. Thus, when positive aspects are observed they can be rated on a quantitative scale. Because of its high inter-and intra-observer reliability, this method appears to be the most promising.

Research paper thumbnail of The welfare of dairy buffalo

Italian Journal of Animal Science, 2009

... In buffaloes, the typical signs of oestrous beha-viour (ie excitability, standing behaviour) ... more ... In buffaloes, the typical signs of oestrous beha-viour (ie excitability, standing behaviour) are less pronounced than in cattle (Seren et al., 1992; Zicarelli et al., 1992), whereas the courtship behaviour of buffalo bulls is simi-lar to that reported in bovines. ...

Research paper thumbnail of Influence of housing conditions and calving distance on blood metabolites in water buffalo cows

Italian Journal of Animal Science, 2004

The aim of this study was to evaluate whether housing conditions allowing the animals to lie in t... more The aim of this study was to evaluate whether housing conditions allowing the animals to lie in the mud and perform more physical exercise can negatively affect reserve mobilization and milk production. In addition, the effect of calving distance on blood metabolites was assessed. The experiment was conducted on twenty-eight lactating buffalo cows, equally allocated to two treatments. Fourteen cows were group-housed in a loose open-sided barn with a concrete floor and equipped with self-locking stanchions, where they received 10 m 2 /head of space allowance, as in intensive systems (Group IS). Fourteen others were group-housed in a similar barn but they also had the benefit of an outdoor yard with 500 m 2 /head as space allowance, including spontaneous vegetation and potholes for bathing and wallowing, as in traditional systems (Group TS). Animals were included in the experimental groups 5 days after calving. Daily milk yield, and milk fat, protein and somatic cell content were determined 4 weeks after grouping (about 35 days after calving) and then at monthly intervals (5 recordings). Blood samples were collected from the jugular vein in vacuum tubes 10 days after grouping (i.e. 15 days after calving) and then at 10 day intervals (17 collections). After centrifugation, plasma and serum aliquots were frozen stored until metabolite determinations (glucose, cholesterol, triglycerides, NEFA, urea, creatinine, albumins, total proteins, calcium, phosphorus, bilirubin, alkaline phosphatase, aspartate aminotransferase, alanine aminotransferase, lactate dehydrogenase and γglutamyl transferase). Treatment did not affect daily milk yield and milk fat, protein or somatic cell count content. Blood metabolite levels were not affected by treatment and interaction treatment x time. Conversely, as expected, calving distance had an influence on most of these variables (P<0.05÷0.001). In particular, in the first two months after parturition, glucose concentration decreased, whereas NEFA and cholesterol increased as a consequence of the high energetic requirements of animals in the first stage of lactation. The systems that allow the expression of some basic natural behaviour did not have any detrimental effect on buffalo metabolism and production, thus they should be encouraged.

Research paper thumbnail of On the development of a monitoring scheme of buffalo welfare at farm level

Italian Journal of Animal Science, 2005

In the present review some animal-related indicators, possibly relevant for a monitoring scheme o... more In the present review some animal-related indicators, possibly relevant for a monitoring scheme of buffalo cow welfare at the farm level, are suggested. The indicators are discussed on the basis of their validity (meaningful with respect to animal welfare), reliability (reflecting the tendency to give the same results on repeated measurements) and feasibility (concerning time and money consume). The attention was focused on the following indicators: excessive thinning or fattening assessed with Body Condition Score (BCS) systems; cleanliness; lameness; resting, social, oral abnormal behaviours; injuries; stockmanship; animal-human relationship; positive indicators (diversity of lying postures, allogrooming, etc.). We have concluded that some of the indicators validated for cattle could be conveniently applied to buffaloes without changes (e.g. injuries and avoidance distance), while others should be appropriately adjusted to this species (e.g. BCS, cleanliness, housing factors). In addition, further studies are needed either to find reliable and feasible registration methods for some indicators (e.g. aggressive and resting behaviours) or to identify additional parameters specific for buffaloes (e.g. prevalence of buffalo cows injected with oxytocin during milking as an indicator of the quality of human-animal relationship).

Research paper thumbnail of On-farm welfare assessment in dairy cattle and buffaloes: evaluation of some animal-based parameters

Italian Journal of Animal Science, 2005

The aim of this study was to evaluate the repeatability of some animal related variables, which c... more The aim of this study was to evaluate the repeatability of some animal related variables, which could be used in protocols developed for assessing animal welfare at farm level. Recordings were performed in seven dairy farms (four for cattle and three for buffaloes). The animals were observed on three occasions at three-week intervals. The variables collected for each animal were the following: behaviour during milking (stepping and kicking), avoidance distance, lameness and cleanliness. For each farm and each variable repeatability was computed using the Kendall coefficient of concordance (W). In buffalo farms avoidance distance may be considered highly reliable (W > 0.64), whereas in dairy cattle its reliability ranged from medium (W = 0.43 to 0.59) to high (W = 0.64). Behavioural recordings at milking showed that the reliability of stepping was either medium or high for both buffaloes and cattle (W = 0.51 to 0.66 and W = 0.52 to 0.76 for buffaloes and cattle, respectively). Conversely, kicking was less reliable. In cattle farms the reliability for cleanliness ranged from medium (W = 0.51) to high (W = 0.62 to 0.71), whereas, it was not reliable in the sole buffalo farm where this variable was monitored. In cattle farms, the concordance for lameness score was high in two farms (W = 0.62 and 0.66) and moderate in one farm (W = 0.43), whereas no animals displayed lameness in the fourth farm. In all buffalo farms no animals showed lameness. For each species, the Kruskal-Wallis analysis of variance with one factor (farm) was performed to evaluate the effect of farm on recorded variables. For cattle, avoidance distance (P<0.001), stepping (P<0.001), cleanliness (P<0.001) and lameness (P<0.01) were affected by farm, whereas kicking was not significantly different between farms. In buffaloes a significant effect of farm was observed only for avoidance distance (P<0.01). The Mann-Whitney U test performed on data obtained from the farm where both species were present showed that avoidance distance was lower in buffaloes than cattle (P<0.001). This variable is reliable, feasible and able to discriminate among farms. Lameness and cleanliness scores were able to discriminate only cattle farms, whereas these two parameters, albeit feasible, seem to have low significance for buffaloes. Although stepping during milking was reliable and different among cattle farms, its use in on-farm assessment may be difficult because it is more time consuming, thus less feasible.

Research paper thumbnail of The qualitative assessment of responsiveness to environmental challenge in horses and ponies

Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 2008

The responsiveness of 10 horses and 10 ponies to environmental challenge (represented by an open ... more The responsiveness of 10 horses and 10 ponies to environmental challenge (represented by an open field test) was assessed using a qualitative approach based on free choice profiling methodology (FCP), which gives observers complete freedom to choose their own descriptive terms. Data were analysed with generalised Procrustes analysis (GPA), a multivariate statistical technique associated with FCP. A crossvalidation of the outcomes of this approach to data recorded through quantitative behaviour analysis, and through a questionnaire given to the animals' owner/riding instructor, was also performed using principal component analysis (PCA). Twelve undergraduate students generated their own descriptive vocabularies, by watching 20 horse/pony video clips lasting 2.5 min each. GPA showed that the consensus profile explained a high percentage of variation among the 12 observers, and differed significantly from the mean randomised profile (p < 0.001). Two main dimensions of the consensus profile were identified, explaining 60% and 5.2% of the variation between animals, respectively. The 12 observer word charts interpreting these dimensions were semantically consistent, as they all converged towards the same meaning, albeit using different terms. The most used term to describe the positive end of axis 1 was ''quiet'', whereas ''attentive'' was the best positive descriptor of axis 2. The most frequently used descriptors for the negative ends of axes 1 and 2 were ''nervous'' and ''bored'', respectively. Thus, axis 1 was labelled as ''quiet/nervous'' and axis 2 was named as ''attentive/bored''. A marked effect of animal category was observed on the scores of the animals on the first dimension (p < 0.001). Horses received significantly higher scores, and were thus assessed as more quiet and calm, than ponies. Conversely, ponies tended to receive lower scores on the second dimension (p < 0.12), therefore they appeared less curious and attentive. The results of the PCA showed that the variables from different types of measurement clearly had meaningful relationships. For instance, the variables with the highest loading on the positive end of axis 1 were all indicative of tractable and docile animals, whereas axis 2 showed high loadings on the positive end for variables indicating attentive animals. Qualitative behaviour assessment proved to be an appropriate methodology for the study of horse behavioural responsiveness, in that it provided a multifaceted characterisation of horse behavioural expression that was in agreement with other quantitative and subjective assessments of the animals' behaviour.

Research paper thumbnail of Qualitative behaviour assessment of dairy buffaloes (Bubalus bubalis)

Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 2012

This study applies qualitative behaviour assessment (QBA) for the first time to dairy buffaloes, ... more This study applies qualitative behaviour assessment (QBA) for the first time to dairy buffaloes, using three groups of observers with different cultural backgrounds and different levels of experience in animal behaviour observation and buffalo farming. Eight buffalo heifers aged 16-18 months were subjected to two isolation tests, one performed in the indoor part of their home environment, and one in a novel outdoor paddock. Animals were filmed individually for 2.5 min, and the resulting 16 video clips were shown to three observer panels, consisting of 11 applied animal behaviour scientists from 6 European countries, 11 Italian animal scientists with a background in buffalo farming but no experience in behavioural observation, and 14 Italian undergraduate animal science students with no particular experience. A free choice profiling method was used to instruct observers in QBA, and data for the three panels were analysed separately using Generalised Procrustes Analysis. All three panels showed significant inter-observer agreement (p < 0.001) and generated two main consensus dimensions characterised as 'calm-agitated' and 'curious-shy'. There were significant correlations between buffalo scores provided by each of the three observer panels on both these dimensions (dim1: Kendall W = 0.96, n = 3, 2 = 43.28, p < 0.001; dim2: W = 0.68, n = 3, 2 = 30.73, p < 0.01). Buffaloes viewed in the familiar indoor pen were assessed by all three panels as more calm and less agitated (dimension 1) than animals viewed in the novel outdoor pen (Wilcoxon z = −2.52, p < 0.01, z = −2.52, p < 0.01, z = −2.38, p < 0.01 for Panels 1, 2, and 3, respectively). Scores on dimension 1 for the same animals viewed in either indoor or outdoor pen were correlated at r = 0.60 (p < 0.10), 0.74 (p < 0.05) and 0.71 (p < 0.05) for Panels 1, 2, and 3, respectively. Quantitatively, buffalo in the outdoor pen displayed longer bouts of running and higher frequencies of sniffing (both p < 0.05) than those in the indoor pen. Principal component analysis showed meaningful associations between qualitative and quantitative assessments, allowing qualitative dimensions to play a valuable role in interpreting the animals' state. The main outcomes of this study are that QBA can be usefully applied to scientific studies of dairy buffalo, and that substantial differences in observer background do not appear to diminish the reliability of QBA.

Research paper thumbnail of Moving Buffalo Farming beyond Traditional Areas: Performances of Animals, and Quality of Mozzarella and Forages

Agriculture

An observational case study was designed to highlight issues associated with a possible expansion... more An observational case study was designed to highlight issues associated with a possible expansion of dairy buffalo (Bubalus bubalis) farming outside the traditional coastal plains of southern Italy. Twenty pregnant buffaloes were transferred to a hilly inland farm. After calving, production and reproduction data were collected monthly throughout lactation. From 4 to 6 months of lactation, buffaloes were enrolled in a feeding trial to evaluate the effects of locally grown forages (maize silage vs. hay) on milk production and in vivo digestibility. Sensory properties of mozzarella cheese produced at a local dairy were also evaluated. No obvious effects of diet were found. Compared to the data recorded in the previous lactation completed in the farm of origin, milk yield was reduced by 37.2%, and milk protein by 6.1%, whereas milk fat improved (+4.5%). A lower pregnancy rate (−13.3%), increased days open (+122%), and a prolonged intercalving period (+26.9%) were also observed. Lactatio...

Research paper thumbnail of Risk factors associated with the expression of cross-sucking and intersucking in buffaloes

The incidence and the potential risk factors for cross-sucking in calves and intersucking in lact... more The incidence and the potential risk factors for cross-sucking in calves and intersucking in lactating cows were assessed in 73 buffalo farms located in the area of PDO ‘Mozzarella di Bufala Campana’. Two trained assessors collected the data through a questionnaire including resource and management measures, which were directly taken and asked to the farmer, respectively. The incidences of cross-sucking, intersucking and mortality were also asked to the farmer. The farm was used as experimental unit. For each discrete risk factor, an ANOVA was performed to assess the association with outcome variables (i.e. the incidence of cross-sucking and intersucking), whereas for continuous risk factors the association was tested using Pearson correlation coefficients. Cross-sucking and intersucking were observed in 91% and 45% of the farms, respectively; their mean incidences were 21.9 ± 22.3 and 1.2 ± 1.9 (mean ± SD), respectively. Cross-sucking was negatively correlated with the number of ca...

Research paper thumbnail of Produzione e longevità delle bovine da latte

Research paper thumbnail of Housing system and welfare of buffalo (Bubalus bubalis) cows

Animal Science, 2004

Twenty-eight buffalo cows were used to evaluate the effect of housing system on a range of behavi... more Twenty-eight buffalo cows were used to evaluate the effect of housing system on a range of behavioural and physiological variables. Fourteen cows were group-housed in a loose open-sided barn with a concrete floor and 10 m2 per head as space allowance (group IS). Fourteen others were group-housed in a similar barn but they could also benefit from an outdoor yard with 500 m2 per head as space allowance, free access to potholes for wallowing and spontaneous vegetation (group TS). Animals were subjected to six sessions of instantaneous scan sampling at 10-day intervals. Behavioural variables were expressed as proportions of subjects observed in each category of posture and activity. Phytohaemagglutinin (PHA) was used to perform a skin test based on non-specific delayed type hypersensitivity, whereas 20 mg of ovalbumin were injected subcutaneously to evaluate humoral immune response. Blood samples for evaluation of cortisol concentration were collected immediately prior to exogenous porc...

Research paper thumbnail of Effect of pen size on behavioral, endocrine, and immune responses of water buffalo (Bubalus bubalis) calves

Journal of Animal Science, 1999

for assistance with conducting the experiment. Thanks are also due to the farm Gaetano Iemma for ... more for assistance with conducting the experiment. Thanks are also due to the farm Gaetano Iemma for hospitality and to Mark Walters for revising the English text.

Research paper thumbnail of Application of the Welfare Quality protocol to dairy buffalo farms: Prevalence and reliability of selected measures

Journal of dairy science, 2015

Within the general aim of developing a Welfare Quality system for monitoring dairy buffalo welfar... more Within the general aim of developing a Welfare Quality system for monitoring dairy buffalo welfare, this study focused on prevalence and interobserver reliability of the animal-related variables to be included in the scheme. As most of the measures were developed for cattle, the study also aimed to verify their prevalence for buffaloes. Thirty animal-based measures (22 clinical and 8 behavioral measurements) and 20 terms used for qualitative behavior assessment were assessed in 42 loose-housed buffalo farms. All farms were located in central-southern Italy. Two assessors were used (1 male and 1 female). The time needed to record all measures (animal-, resource-, and management-based) was 5.47±0.48 h (mean ± SD). Interobserver reliability of animal-based measures was evaluated using Spearman rank correlation coefficient test (rs). If 0.7 is considered as threshold for high interobserver reliability, all animal-based measures were above this level. In particular, most of the coefficie...

Research paper thumbnail of Effect of Saccharomyces cerevisiae Live Cells on In Vivo Digestibility and Nitrogen Excretion in Lactating Buffaloes

Journal of Buffalo Science, 2014

The effects of dietary inclusion of Saccharomyces cerevisiae culture on intake, in vivo digestibi... more The effects of dietary inclusion of Saccharomyces cerevisiae culture on intake, in vivo digestibility, and fecal nitrogen excretion were examined in dairy buffalo. Forty lactating buffalo cows were equally divided into Control and Saccharomyces groups, balanced for milk production, parity, and days in milk. Two subsequent 16-d experimental phases were carried out. For both groups during the first experimental period a TMR based on maize silage (maize-TMR) was used, whereas in the second period an alfalfa haylage (alfalfa-TMR) was administered to the animals. In each experimental period, Saccharomyces group was supplemented with 50 g/head/day of yeast (Biocell®, Limena, Padova, Italy), corresponding to 20 10 9 CFU/head/day Saccharomyces cerevisiae NCYC Sc47 strain. The yeast supplement was top-dressed onto the morning feed. Dry matter intake (DMI) was assessed for 6 consecutive d on group basis, by the difference between feed offered and refused. In the last 3 days of experimental period in vivo digestibility was determined by using acid-insoluble ash (AIA) as an intrinsic digestibility marker. Saccharomyces supplemented buffalo cows presented greater DMI of maize-TMR, whereas no statistical differences between the groups were observed for alfalfa-TMR. Saccharomyces supplementation significantly improved in vivo digestibility of both TMR. Fecal nitrogen excretion was significantly reduced by the use of yeast supplementation. Results suggest that the inclusion of Saccharomyces cerevisiae culture in the diet for lactating buffaloes can be recommended for its effects on cow's digestive efficiency and fecal nitrogen excretion.

Research paper thumbnail of Repeatability of some animal-related variables in dairy cows and buffaloes

Animal welfare (South Mimms, England)

The aim of this study was to evaluate the intra-observer repeatability of some animal-related var... more The aim of this study was to evaluate the intra-observer repeatability of some animal-related variables which could be used in welfare-assessment protocols at farm level. Recordings were performed on seven dairy farms (four for cattle and three for buffaloes). The animals were observed on three occasions at three-week intervals. The variables collected for each animal were behaviour during milking (stepping and kicking), avoidance distance, lameness, and cleanliness. For each farm and each variable, intra-observer repeatability was computed using the Kendall coefficient of concordance (W). A ratio between the variance of the animal and the sum of the latter with the error variance was also calculated using a model of analysis of variance with one factor (animal), to give a further measure of repeatability. These two methods yielded similar results. In particular, in dairy cattle, a high repeatability for avoidance distance, stepping, lameness and cleanliness was observed, whereas fo...

Research paper thumbnail of Effect of pre-partum habituation to milking routine on behaviour and lactation performance of buffalo heifers

Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 2014

The aim of this study was to investigate the effect pre-partum habituation in the milking parlour... more The aim of this study was to investigate the effect pre-partum habituation in the milking parlour on behaviour and lactation performance of buffalo heifers. Sixteen buffalo heifers in late gestation were used for this study. The animals, with an age ranging from 30 to 44 months at the start of the study, were equally allocated into two treatments and balanced for estimated calving date. Eight animals received pre-partum habituation for 10 days before the estimated calving date (group H), while the eight others received no treatment and served as the control (group C). During the pre-partum habituation sessions, group H animals were moved to the milking parlour and left for 10 min in the milking stall once each day, where the udder was thoroughly washed with warm water, wiped with a disposable towel and massaged. The behaviours, registered from entrance into the milking stall to exit, were step and kick. After calving milk flow profiles, milk yield and milk quality variables were determined along with behavioural recordings. The H animals during the habituation procedure showed a reduction in the number of steps (P < 0.001) and kicks (P < 0.01). After calving the H animals performed fewer steps than the control animals at 0 (P < 0.001), 3 (P < 0.01), 6 (P < 0.01), 13 (P < 0.01) and 20 (P < 0.01) days after calving. Animals from group H also performed fewer kicks than control animals at 0 (P < 0.001), 3 (P < 0.01), 6 (P < 0.01) and 13 (P < 0.01) days after calving. In the C group a reduction in the number of steps (P < 0.001) and kicks (P < 0.001) was observed as lactation proceeded, whereas for group H only a tendency for a reduction over lactation was detected. Pre-partum habituation did not significantly affect milk quality or milk flow variables. Milk yield in the first 3 min of milking (P < 0.001), and average milk flow (P < 0.001), increased throughout the experimental period, whereas the duration of the pre-milking phase decreased as lactation proceeded (P < 0.001). This study shows that buffalo heifers exposed to a pre-partum habituation programme performed fewer steps and kicks than control animals during milking. Therefore, it is concluded that using this treatment can reduce the level of restlessness in buffalo heifers during milking.

Research paper thumbnail of Conditioned inhibition of antibody response and CD4 positive cells

Physiology & Behavior, 1998

Animals were assigned to three experimental groups, conditioned (cyclophosphamide-glucose treatme... more Animals were assigned to three experimental groups, conditioned (cyclophosphamide-glucose treatment; C group), non-conditioned (cyclophosphamide-commercial pellet treatment; NC group) and placebo (saline solution-glucose treatment; P group). The three groups were injected intraperitoneally (i.p.) with sheep red blood cells. An hemagglutination assay according to standard procedures was performed along with the flow cytofluorometric analysis of leukocyte surface antigens CD4, CD8 and CD45. C group consumed less food on Days 3 and 6 than on Day 0, NC animals showed no changes in food consumption throughout the experimental period, whereas an increasing trend was observed for P animals. The proportion of T lymphocytes expressing CD8 and CD45 did not differ significantly among C, NC and P groups. Group C showed the lowest proportion of T lymphocytes bearing CD4, whereas Group P displayed the highest. The antibody response was lower in the Group C than in the groups NC and P. We conclude that, although the mechanisms by which humoral conditioned immunosuppression occurs in mice is still unknown, a reduced T helper-mediated activation of B-cells may play an important role in producing conditioned humoral response.

Research paper thumbnail of Performance and immune response of buffalo calves supplemented with probiotic

Livestock Science, 2011

The effect of dietary supplementation with Enterococcus faecium strain SF68 (E. faecium SF68) on ... more The effect of dietary supplementation with Enterococcus faecium strain SF68 (E. faecium SF68) on growth performance, fecal consistency, in vivo digestibility and immune response in buffalo (Bubalus bubalis) calves was evaluated at a commercial dairy location. Forty calves were randomly assigned at 10days of age to one of four treatments: A—milk replacer with no additive, B—milk replacer supplemented with 0.17g/L

Research paper thumbnail of Milking behaviour of buffalo cows: entrance order and side preference in the milking parlour

Journal of Dairy Research, 2013

On two farms, three milking groups of buffalo cows were used to assess the consistency of entranc... more On two farms, three milking groups of buffalo cows were used to assess the consistency of entrance order and the preference for one side of the milking parlour. On Farm 1 (F1) all animals were primiparous (n=57). On Farm 2, three primiparous, 16 secondiparous and 36 multiparous cows (range 1–8) constituted group F2G1; whereas group F2G2 had 12 primiparous, 10 secondiparous and 14 multiparous cows (range 1–10). Animals were milked in auto-tandem milking parlours (2×5 and 2×6 for Farms 1 and 2, respectively). For each cow, entrance order into milking parlour, side where she was milked, milk yield, time and duration of milking were recorded. These data were derived from the computerised identification of cows. The sequence in which the cows entered the milking parlour ranged from 1 to 57 for group F1, from 1 to 55 for group F2G1 and from 1 to 36 for group F2G2. The analysis of data was conducted on 130, 120 and 92 consecutive milkings for groups F1, F2G1 and F2G2, respectively. Kendall...

Research paper thumbnail of Use of peas in organic buffalo farming: effects on nutrient digestibility and milk production

Italian Journal of Animal Science, 2010

Twenty lactating buffalo cows, organically farmed, were used to examine the effects of including ... more Twenty lactating buffalo cows, organically farmed, were used to examine the effects of including peas in total mixed ration. Two concentrates were formulated to contain, as the main pro-Two concentrates were formulated to contain, as the main protein sources, either 350 g/kg of soybean cake (CC) or 450 g/kg of peas (ExpC). Cows were blocked into Cows were blocked into ows were blocked into two groups according to parity and previous milk yield and were assigned to one of two dietary treatments: one group was fed a diet with 6 kg/d of CC, whereas the treatment group was fed diet in which 3 kg/d of CC were replaced by an equal quantity of ExpC. Digestibility of the diets and milk yield of the cows were measured. The experimental period covered the whole lactation period. No differences were. The experimental period covered the whole lactation period. No differences were The experimental period covered the whole lactation period. No differences were observed between groups for milk yield and composition, and for digestibility. The main hypothesis The main hypothesis tested, that the replacement of soybean cake with peas in buffalo diet would not affect milk yield and soybean cake with peas in buffalo diet would not affect milk yield and buffalo diet would not affect milk yield and diet would not affect milk yield and would not affect milk yield and composition, was confirmed. This suggested that the partial substitution of soybean cake with peas in was confirmed. This suggested that the partial substitution of soybean cake with peas in This suggested that the partial substitution of soybean cake with peas in soybean cake with peas in diet for buffalo cows can be possible without affect performances. for buffalo cows can be possible without affect performances.

Research paper thumbnail of Positive indicators of cattle welfare and their applicability to on-farm protocols

Italian Journal of Animal Science, 2009

Most of the research on animal welfare has focused on the negative aspects of the matter includin... more Most of the research on animal welfare has focused on the negative aspects of the matter including an array of stress categories, whereas little has been done about the positive states of well being. The present study aims to describe indicators of positive animal welfare suitable for on-farm assessment. Appropriate environmental stimulation favours good welfare and, in an adequately enriched environment, positive indicators of welfare such as play behaviour tend to be more common. In addition, animals are motivated to perform these behaviours only if their primary needs are satisfied. In cattle, beneficial effects of social licking have been observed with positive correlation between being licked vs. milk production and weight gain, respectively. Ruminants are gregarious and a high degree of synchronisation within the herd may indicate a positive welfare state, in particular for subordinate animals. They may be able to meet their basic feeding and resting requirements performing these behaviours when the competition for a particular resource is low, however their welfare state would be improved if they could choose when and where (i.e. along with the other members of the group) to perform such behaviours. Due to the reduced applicability (mainly young animals), low feasibility (time consuming) and lack of research on reliability, play behaviour, albeit of proven validity, does not appear to be suitable for a rapid implementation in a welfare assessment scheme. Social licking is rarely expressed and its detection may be time consuming and scarcely feasible. Although validity and reliability need more studies, behaviour synchrony seems to be a promising positive welfare indicator as the instantaneous scan sampling technique makes this indicator easily applicable. Recently, a new methodology called "qualitative assessment of animal behaviour" has been developed. The method relies on a number of terms which are freely generated by observers. Thus, when positive aspects are observed they can be rated on a quantitative scale. Because of its high inter-and intra-observer reliability, this method appears to be the most promising.

Research paper thumbnail of The welfare of dairy buffalo

Italian Journal of Animal Science, 2009

... In buffaloes, the typical signs of oestrous beha-viour (ie excitability, standing behaviour) ... more ... In buffaloes, the typical signs of oestrous beha-viour (ie excitability, standing behaviour) are less pronounced than in cattle (Seren et al., 1992; Zicarelli et al., 1992), whereas the courtship behaviour of buffalo bulls is simi-lar to that reported in bovines. ...

Research paper thumbnail of Influence of housing conditions and calving distance on blood metabolites in water buffalo cows

Italian Journal of Animal Science, 2004

The aim of this study was to evaluate whether housing conditions allowing the animals to lie in t... more The aim of this study was to evaluate whether housing conditions allowing the animals to lie in the mud and perform more physical exercise can negatively affect reserve mobilization and milk production. In addition, the effect of calving distance on blood metabolites was assessed. The experiment was conducted on twenty-eight lactating buffalo cows, equally allocated to two treatments. Fourteen cows were group-housed in a loose open-sided barn with a concrete floor and equipped with self-locking stanchions, where they received 10 m 2 /head of space allowance, as in intensive systems (Group IS). Fourteen others were group-housed in a similar barn but they also had the benefit of an outdoor yard with 500 m 2 /head as space allowance, including spontaneous vegetation and potholes for bathing and wallowing, as in traditional systems (Group TS). Animals were included in the experimental groups 5 days after calving. Daily milk yield, and milk fat, protein and somatic cell content were determined 4 weeks after grouping (about 35 days after calving) and then at monthly intervals (5 recordings). Blood samples were collected from the jugular vein in vacuum tubes 10 days after grouping (i.e. 15 days after calving) and then at 10 day intervals (17 collections). After centrifugation, plasma and serum aliquots were frozen stored until metabolite determinations (glucose, cholesterol, triglycerides, NEFA, urea, creatinine, albumins, total proteins, calcium, phosphorus, bilirubin, alkaline phosphatase, aspartate aminotransferase, alanine aminotransferase, lactate dehydrogenase and γglutamyl transferase). Treatment did not affect daily milk yield and milk fat, protein or somatic cell count content. Blood metabolite levels were not affected by treatment and interaction treatment x time. Conversely, as expected, calving distance had an influence on most of these variables (P<0.05÷0.001). In particular, in the first two months after parturition, glucose concentration decreased, whereas NEFA and cholesterol increased as a consequence of the high energetic requirements of animals in the first stage of lactation. The systems that allow the expression of some basic natural behaviour did not have any detrimental effect on buffalo metabolism and production, thus they should be encouraged.

Research paper thumbnail of On the development of a monitoring scheme of buffalo welfare at farm level

Italian Journal of Animal Science, 2005

In the present review some animal-related indicators, possibly relevant for a monitoring scheme o... more In the present review some animal-related indicators, possibly relevant for a monitoring scheme of buffalo cow welfare at the farm level, are suggested. The indicators are discussed on the basis of their validity (meaningful with respect to animal welfare), reliability (reflecting the tendency to give the same results on repeated measurements) and feasibility (concerning time and money consume). The attention was focused on the following indicators: excessive thinning or fattening assessed with Body Condition Score (BCS) systems; cleanliness; lameness; resting, social, oral abnormal behaviours; injuries; stockmanship; animal-human relationship; positive indicators (diversity of lying postures, allogrooming, etc.). We have concluded that some of the indicators validated for cattle could be conveniently applied to buffaloes without changes (e.g. injuries and avoidance distance), while others should be appropriately adjusted to this species (e.g. BCS, cleanliness, housing factors). In addition, further studies are needed either to find reliable and feasible registration methods for some indicators (e.g. aggressive and resting behaviours) or to identify additional parameters specific for buffaloes (e.g. prevalence of buffalo cows injected with oxytocin during milking as an indicator of the quality of human-animal relationship).

Research paper thumbnail of On-farm welfare assessment in dairy cattle and buffaloes: evaluation of some animal-based parameters

Italian Journal of Animal Science, 2005

The aim of this study was to evaluate the repeatability of some animal related variables, which c... more The aim of this study was to evaluate the repeatability of some animal related variables, which could be used in protocols developed for assessing animal welfare at farm level. Recordings were performed in seven dairy farms (four for cattle and three for buffaloes). The animals were observed on three occasions at three-week intervals. The variables collected for each animal were the following: behaviour during milking (stepping and kicking), avoidance distance, lameness and cleanliness. For each farm and each variable repeatability was computed using the Kendall coefficient of concordance (W). In buffalo farms avoidance distance may be considered highly reliable (W > 0.64), whereas in dairy cattle its reliability ranged from medium (W = 0.43 to 0.59) to high (W = 0.64). Behavioural recordings at milking showed that the reliability of stepping was either medium or high for both buffaloes and cattle (W = 0.51 to 0.66 and W = 0.52 to 0.76 for buffaloes and cattle, respectively). Conversely, kicking was less reliable. In cattle farms the reliability for cleanliness ranged from medium (W = 0.51) to high (W = 0.62 to 0.71), whereas, it was not reliable in the sole buffalo farm where this variable was monitored. In cattle farms, the concordance for lameness score was high in two farms (W = 0.62 and 0.66) and moderate in one farm (W = 0.43), whereas no animals displayed lameness in the fourth farm. In all buffalo farms no animals showed lameness. For each species, the Kruskal-Wallis analysis of variance with one factor (farm) was performed to evaluate the effect of farm on recorded variables. For cattle, avoidance distance (P<0.001), stepping (P<0.001), cleanliness (P<0.001) and lameness (P<0.01) were affected by farm, whereas kicking was not significantly different between farms. In buffaloes a significant effect of farm was observed only for avoidance distance (P<0.01). The Mann-Whitney U test performed on data obtained from the farm where both species were present showed that avoidance distance was lower in buffaloes than cattle (P<0.001). This variable is reliable, feasible and able to discriminate among farms. Lameness and cleanliness scores were able to discriminate only cattle farms, whereas these two parameters, albeit feasible, seem to have low significance for buffaloes. Although stepping during milking was reliable and different among cattle farms, its use in on-farm assessment may be difficult because it is more time consuming, thus less feasible.

Research paper thumbnail of The qualitative assessment of responsiveness to environmental challenge in horses and ponies

Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 2008

The responsiveness of 10 horses and 10 ponies to environmental challenge (represented by an open ... more The responsiveness of 10 horses and 10 ponies to environmental challenge (represented by an open field test) was assessed using a qualitative approach based on free choice profiling methodology (FCP), which gives observers complete freedom to choose their own descriptive terms. Data were analysed with generalised Procrustes analysis (GPA), a multivariate statistical technique associated with FCP. A crossvalidation of the outcomes of this approach to data recorded through quantitative behaviour analysis, and through a questionnaire given to the animals' owner/riding instructor, was also performed using principal component analysis (PCA). Twelve undergraduate students generated their own descriptive vocabularies, by watching 20 horse/pony video clips lasting 2.5 min each. GPA showed that the consensus profile explained a high percentage of variation among the 12 observers, and differed significantly from the mean randomised profile (p < 0.001). Two main dimensions of the consensus profile were identified, explaining 60% and 5.2% of the variation between animals, respectively. The 12 observer word charts interpreting these dimensions were semantically consistent, as they all converged towards the same meaning, albeit using different terms. The most used term to describe the positive end of axis 1 was ''quiet'', whereas ''attentive'' was the best positive descriptor of axis 2. The most frequently used descriptors for the negative ends of axes 1 and 2 were ''nervous'' and ''bored'', respectively. Thus, axis 1 was labelled as ''quiet/nervous'' and axis 2 was named as ''attentive/bored''. A marked effect of animal category was observed on the scores of the animals on the first dimension (p < 0.001). Horses received significantly higher scores, and were thus assessed as more quiet and calm, than ponies. Conversely, ponies tended to receive lower scores on the second dimension (p < 0.12), therefore they appeared less curious and attentive. The results of the PCA showed that the variables from different types of measurement clearly had meaningful relationships. For instance, the variables with the highest loading on the positive end of axis 1 were all indicative of tractable and docile animals, whereas axis 2 showed high loadings on the positive end for variables indicating attentive animals. Qualitative behaviour assessment proved to be an appropriate methodology for the study of horse behavioural responsiveness, in that it provided a multifaceted characterisation of horse behavioural expression that was in agreement with other quantitative and subjective assessments of the animals' behaviour.

Research paper thumbnail of Qualitative behaviour assessment of dairy buffaloes (Bubalus bubalis)

Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 2012

This study applies qualitative behaviour assessment (QBA) for the first time to dairy buffaloes, ... more This study applies qualitative behaviour assessment (QBA) for the first time to dairy buffaloes, using three groups of observers with different cultural backgrounds and different levels of experience in animal behaviour observation and buffalo farming. Eight buffalo heifers aged 16-18 months were subjected to two isolation tests, one performed in the indoor part of their home environment, and one in a novel outdoor paddock. Animals were filmed individually for 2.5 min, and the resulting 16 video clips were shown to three observer panels, consisting of 11 applied animal behaviour scientists from 6 European countries, 11 Italian animal scientists with a background in buffalo farming but no experience in behavioural observation, and 14 Italian undergraduate animal science students with no particular experience. A free choice profiling method was used to instruct observers in QBA, and data for the three panels were analysed separately using Generalised Procrustes Analysis. All three panels showed significant inter-observer agreement (p < 0.001) and generated two main consensus dimensions characterised as 'calm-agitated' and 'curious-shy'. There were significant correlations between buffalo scores provided by each of the three observer panels on both these dimensions (dim1: Kendall W = 0.96, n = 3, 2 = 43.28, p < 0.001; dim2: W = 0.68, n = 3, 2 = 30.73, p < 0.01). Buffaloes viewed in the familiar indoor pen were assessed by all three panels as more calm and less agitated (dimension 1) than animals viewed in the novel outdoor pen (Wilcoxon z = −2.52, p < 0.01, z = −2.52, p < 0.01, z = −2.38, p < 0.01 for Panels 1, 2, and 3, respectively). Scores on dimension 1 for the same animals viewed in either indoor or outdoor pen were correlated at r = 0.60 (p < 0.10), 0.74 (p < 0.05) and 0.71 (p < 0.05) for Panels 1, 2, and 3, respectively. Quantitatively, buffalo in the outdoor pen displayed longer bouts of running and higher frequencies of sniffing (both p < 0.05) than those in the indoor pen. Principal component analysis showed meaningful associations between qualitative and quantitative assessments, allowing qualitative dimensions to play a valuable role in interpreting the animals' state. The main outcomes of this study are that QBA can be usefully applied to scientific studies of dairy buffalo, and that substantial differences in observer background do not appear to diminish the reliability of QBA.