WalletHub’s Proprietary 100-point Credit Card Rating System (original) (raw)

WalletHub’s proprietary 100-point credit card rating system evaluates cards for each major cardholder “need” the card is applicable to – from building credit to maximizing rewards. More specifically, we identified 26 different cardholder needs that are representative of different users’ financial priorities and behaviors. Given that each group has different goals and is likely to use their credit cards differently, they have been scored differently, using different metrics. When a card meets eligibility criteria for two or more needs, it is scored for all needs but we will predominantly display the score for the need to which the card is best suited. For example, if a card offers elite rewards and a 0% intro APR for 6 months, the card will be scored both as a rewards card and as a means of financing new purchases, but only the rewards score will be predominantly displayed.

To evaluate each need, WalletHub uses 21 key metrics grouped into three major components: Editor’s Rating, User Reviews and Market Comparison. The Market Comparison component measures how appealing the fees, rewards, cost, APR and other features of a card are compared to a pool of over 1,500 credit card offers monitored by WalletHub. Each component has a maximum number of points allocated to it, based on the its importance as determined by our editors, and the points are added up for each card to create an overall rating with a maximum score of 100 points.

Ratings for each category reflect how close a credit card offer is to WalletHub’s definition of a top-rated credit card, which is based on market conditions and what we believe are reasonable terms. We compare credit card offers to that standard to give a numerical approximation of how reasonable and competitive the credit card is compared to others. If a card does not match any of the needs we defined, then it is not scored.

Below, please find a high-level version of the scoring rubric used to evaluate credit card offers and produce WalletHub’s credit card ratings by cardholder need. Please also keep the following notes in mind.

Rebuild Damaged Credit

Eligible cards: Personal credit cards that accept bad credit (excluding charge cards and store cards)

Spending profile used: Average consumer with less than good credit

Editor’s Rating - up to 13 points

User Reviews - up to 7 points

Market Comparison - up to 116 points

Not considered for this need, as the goal is to rebuild credit at a low cost:

Rebuild Damaged Credit (Store Cards)

Eligible cards: Personal store credit cards that accept bad credit (excluding charge cards)

Spending profile used: Average consumer with less-than-good credit using a store card

Editor’s Rating - up to 13 points

User Reviews - up to 7 points

Market Comparison - up to 116 points

Not considered for this need, as the goal is to rebuild credit at a low cost:

Rebuild Damaged Credit by Paying in Full Each Month

Eligible cards: Personal credit cards that accept bad credit (excluding charge cards and store cards)

Spending profile used: Average consumer with less than good credit

Editor’s Rating - up to 13 points

User Reviews - up to 7 points

Market Comparison - up to 117 points

Not considered for this need, as the goal is to rebuild credit at a low cost:

Improve Credit

Eligible cards: Personal credit cards that accept no credit on fair credit (excluding charge cards)

Spending profile used: Average consumer with less than good credit

Editor’s Rating - up to 13 points

User Reviews - up to 7 points

Market Comparison - up to 95 points

Not considered for this need, as the goal is to improve credit at a low cost:

Improve Credit by Paying in Full Each Month

Eligible cards: Personal credit cards that accept no credit on fair credit (excluding charge cards)

Spending profile used: Average consumer with less than good credit

Editor’s Rating - up to 13 points

User Reviews - up to 7 points

Market Comparison - up to 95 points

Not considered for this need, as the goal is to improve credit at a low cost:

Build Credit (Students)

Eligible cards: Student credit cards that accept no credit or fair credit

Spending profile used: Student

Editor’s Rating - up to 13 points

User Reviews - up to 7 points

Market Comparison - up to 85 points

Not considered for this need, as the goal is to help students build their credit at a low cost:

Build Credit by Paying in Full Each Month (Students)

Eligible cards: Student credit cards that accept no credit or fair credit

Spending profile used: Student

Editor’s Rating - up to 13 points

User Reviews - up to 7 points

Market Comparison - up to 85 points

Not considered for this need, as the goal is to help students build their credit at a low cost:

Earn Rewards

Eligible cards: Personal credit cards, student cards or charge cards that accept good or excellent credit and offer rewards (excluding store cards)

Spending profile used: Average consumer

Editor’s Rating - up to 13 points

User Reviews - up to 7 points

Market Comparison - up to 85 points

Not considered for this need, as the goal is to pay the balance in full monthly in order to maximize rewards:

Earn Travel Rewards

Eligible cards: Personal credit cards, student cards or charge cards that accept good or excellent credit and offer rewards on travel (excluding store cards)

Spending profile used: Traveler

Editor’s Rating - up to 13 points

User Reviews - up to 7 points

Market Comparison - up to 85 points

Not considered for this need, as the goal is to pay the balance in full monthly in order to maximize rewards:

Earn Airline Rewards

Eligible cards: Cards that accept good or excellent credit and offer rewards on airline purchases (excluding store cards)

Spending profile used: Heavy spending on airlines

Editor’s Rating - up to 13 points

User Reviews - up to 7 points

Market Comparison - up to 85 points

Not considered for this need, as the goal is to pay the balance in full monthly in order to maximize rewards:

Earn Hotel Rewards

Eligible cards: Cards that accept good or excellent credit and offer rewards on hotels (excluding store cards)

Spending profile used: Heavy spending on hotels

Editor’s Rating - up to 13 points

User Reviews - up to 7 points

Market Comparison - up to 85 points

Not considered for this need, as the goal is to pay the balance in full monthly in order to maximize rewards:

Earn Gas Rewards

Eligible cards: Cards that accept good or excellent credit and offer rewards on gas purchases

Spending profile used: Heavy spending on gas

Editor’s Rating - up to 13 points

User Reviews - up to 7 points

Market Comparison - up to 85 points

Not considered for this need, as the goal is to pay the balance in full monthly in order to maximize rewards:

Earn Rewards (Store Cards)

Eligible cards: Personal store credit cards or charge cards that accept good or excellent credit and offer rewards

Spending profile used: Average consumer usage on a store card

Editor’s Rating - up to 13 points

User Reviews - up to 7 points

Market Comparison - up to 85 points

Not considered for this need, as the goal is to pay the balance in full monthly in order to maximize rewards:

Finance New Purchases

Eligible cards: Personal credit cards that accept good or excellent credit and offer intro APR on new purchases (excluding store and charge cards)

Spending profile used: One big purchase ($5,000) followed by fixed monthly payments ($225) for 24 months with no other monthly spending.

Editor’s Rating - up to 13 points

User Reviews - up to 7 points

Market Comparison - up to 80 points

Not considered for this need, as the goal is to take advantage of an intro APR for one large purchase:

Finance New Purchases (Store Cards)

Eligible cards: Personal store credit cards that accept good or excellent credit and offer intro APR on new purchases (excluding charge cards)

Spending profile used: One big purchase ($2,500) followed by fixed monthly payments ($113) for 24 months, with no other spending.

Editor’s Rating - up to 13 points

User Reviews - up to 7 points

Market Comparison - up to 80 points

Not considered for this need, as the goal is to take advantage of an intro APR for one large purchase:

Lower Cost of Existing Debt

Eligible cards: Personal credit cards that accept good or excellent credit and offer an intro APR on balance transfers (excluding store and charge cards)

Spending profile used: One balance transfer ($5,000) followed by fixed monthly payments ($225) for 24 months, with no other spending.

Editor’s Rating - up to 13 points

User Reviews - up to 7 points

Market Comparison - up to 80 points

Not considered for this need, as the goal is to take advantage of an intro APR for a balance transfer:

Business – Rebuild Damaged Credit

Eligible cards: Business credit cards that accept bad credit (excluding charge cards and store cards)

Spending profile used: Average business with less than good credit

Editor’s Rating - up to 13 points

User Reviews - up to 7 points

Market Comparison - up to 116 points

Not considered for this need, as the goal is to rebuild credit at a low cost:

Business - Rebuild Damaged Credit by Paying in Full Each Month

Eligible cards: Business credit cards that accept bad credit (excluding charge cards and store cards)

Spending profile used: Average business with less than good credit

Editor’s Rating - up to 13 points

User Reviews - up to 7 points

Market Comparison - up to 117 points

Not considered for this need, as the goal is to rebuild credit at a low cost:

Business - Improve Credit

Eligible cards: Business credit cards that accept no credit on fair credit (excluding charge cards)

Spending profile used: Average business with less than good credit

Editor’s Rating - up to 13 points

User Reviews - up to 7 points

Market Comparison - up to 95 points

Not considered for this need, as the goal is to improve credit at a low cost:

Business - Improve Credit by Paying in Full Each Month

Eligible cards: Business credit cards that accept no credit on fair credit (excluding charge cards)

Spending profile used: Average business with less than good credit

Editor’s Rating - up to 13 points

User Reviews - up to 7 points

Market Comparison - up to 95 points

Not considered for this need, as the goal is to improve credit at a low cost:

Business - Earn Rewards

Eligible cards: Business credit cards or charge cards that accept good or excellent credit and offer rewards (excluding store cards)

Spending profile used: Average business

Editor’s Rating - up to 13 points

User Reviews - up to 7 points

Market Comparison - up to 85 points

Not considered for this need, as the goal is to pay the balance in full monthly in order to maximize rewards:

Business - Earn Travel Rewards

Eligible cards: Business credit cards or charge cards that accept good or excellent credit and offer rewards on travel (excluding store cards)

Spending profile used: Business traveler

Editor’s Rating - up to 13 points

User Reviews - up to 7 points

Market Comparison - up to 85 points

Not considered for this need, as the goal is to pay the balance in full monthly in order to maximize rewards:

Business - Earn Rewards (Store cards)

Eligible cards: Business store credit cards or charge cards that accept good or excellent credit and offer rewards

Spending profile used: Average business usage on a store card

Editor’s Rating - up to 13 points

User Reviews - up to 7 points

Market Comparison - up to 85 points

Not considered for this need, as the goal is to pay the balance in full monthly in order to maximize rewards:

Business - Finance New Purchases

Eligible cards: Business credit cards that accept good or excellent credit and offer intro APR on new purchases (excluding store and charge cards)

Spending profile used: One big purchase ($23,500) followed by fixed monthly payments ($900) for 24 months with no other monthly spending.

Editor’s Rating - up to 13 points

User Reviews - up to 7 points

Market Comparison - up to 80 points

Not considered for this need, as the goal is to take advantage of an intro APR for one large purchase:

Business - Finance New Purchases (Store Cards)

Eligible cards: Business store credit cards that accept good or excellent credit and offer intro APR on new purchases (excluding charge cards)

Spending profile used: One big purchase ($11,750) followed by fixed monthly payments ($450) for 24 months with no other monthly spending.

Editor’s Rating - up to 13 points

User Reviews - up to 7 points

Market Comparison - up to 80 points

Not considered for this need, as the goal is to take advantage of an intro APR for one large purchase:

Business - Lower Cost of Existing Debt

Eligible cards: Business credit cards that accept good or excellent credit and offer intro APR on balance transfers (excluding store and charge cards)

Spending profile used: One balance transfer ($23,500) followed by fixed monthly payments ($900) for 24 months with no other monthly spending.

Editor’s Rating - up to 13 points

User Reviews - up to 7 points

Market Comparison - up to 80 points

Not considered for this need, as the goal is to take advantage of an intro APR for a balance transfer: