Mary Bachvarova | Willamette University (original) (raw)
Books by Mary Bachvarova
NOW IN PAPERBACK, WITH A 20% DISCOUNT! This book provides a groundbreaking reassessment of the pr... more NOW IN PAPERBACK, WITH A 20% DISCOUNT!
This book provides a groundbreaking reassessment of the prehistory of Homeric epic. It argues that in the Early Iron Age bilingual poets transmitted to the Greeks a set of narrative traditions closely related to the one found at Bronze-Age Hattusa, the Hittite capital. Key drivers for Near Eastern influence on the developing Homeric tradition were the shared practices of supralocal festivals and venerating divinized ancestors, and a shared interest in creating narratives about a legendary past using a few specific storylines: theogonies, genealogies connecting local polities, long-distance travel, destruction of a famous city because it refuses to release captives, and trying to overcome death when confronted with the loss of a dear companion. Professor Bachvarova concludes by providing a fresh explanation of the origins and significance of the Greco-Anatolian legend of Troy, thereby offering a new solution to the long-debated question of the historicity of the Trojan War.
This book provides a groundbreaking reassessment of the prehistory of Homeric epic. It argues tha... more This book provides a groundbreaking reassessment of the prehistory of Homeric epic. It argues that in the Early Iron Age bilingual poets transmitted to the Greeks a set of narrative traditions closely related to the one found at Bronze-Age Hattusa, the Hittite capital. Key drivers for Near Eastern influence on the developing Homeric tradition were the shared practices of supralocal festivals and venerating divinized ancestors, and a shared interest in creating narratives about a legendary past using a few specific storylines: theogonies, genealogies connecting local polities, long-distance travel, destruction of a famous city because it refuses to release captives, and trying to overcome death when confronted with the loss of a dear companion. I conclude by providing a fresh explanation of the origins and significance of the Greco-Anatolian legend of Troy, thereby offering a new solution to the long-debated question of the historicity of the Trojan War.
Papers by Mary Bachvarova
Religious Convergence in the Ancient Mediterrean, 2019
Mountains were nodes of contact and places of continuity that allowed for the transfer across spa... more Mountains were nodes of contact and places of continuity that allowed for the transfer across space, time, and cultures within Anatolia of stories connected to the storm god's rise to kingship in heaven. Versions of the Bronze Age stories other than the ones available to us lie behind the story of the births of Cybele and Agdistis in Arnobius (Adv. Nat. 5.5-6), which represented versions not aimed at the concerns of the Hittite court, focused less on kingship and more on transgressive sexuality, gestation, and birth, which were metaphorized as volcanic and metallurgic processes.
The Fall of Cities: Commemoration in Literature, Folk Song, and Liturgy, 2016
I follow the thread of the theme of the sacked city from its earliest manifestation in Mesopotami... more I follow the thread of the theme of the sacked city from its earliest
manifestation in Mesopotamian historiography to the Iliad, showing that
the Greek epic picked up on many themes originating in early second millennium Mesopotamia, and reworked them to new purposes. As with
the Hittites, the Greeks used the claim of responsibility for the destruction
of a famous city to position themselves on the world stage and to place
themselves in world history, conceived of as a series of cities destroyed in
turn. The deepened understanding of the tradition behind the Homeric
epic improves our ability to appreciate the innovations as well. Furthermore, I suggest that we take into account not only the interplay
between female personal lament and male epic in the Iliad, but also
possible influence from an indigenous liturgical lament tradition originally
cognate with the Mesopotamian one, but diverging decisively when it
began to be used to celebrate in cult a city whose ruined walls became
the locus of cultural memories about a lost age of heroes.
Narrating the Beginnings, eds. A. Bernabé Pajares and R. Martín Hernández. Wiesbaden. 69-93., 2021
The use of general descriptive names, registered names, trademarks, service marks, etc. in this p... more The use of general descriptive names, registered names, trademarks, service marks, etc. in this publication does not imply, even in the absence of a specific statement, that such names are exempt from the relevant protective laws and regulations and therefore free for general use. The publisher, the authors and the editors are safe to assume that the advice and information in this book are believed to be true and accurate at the date of publication. Neither the publisher nor the authors or the editors give a warranty, expressed or implied, with respect to the material contained herein or for any errors or omissions that may have been made. The publisher remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Acts of the IXth International Congress of Hittitology, Çorum, 08-14 September 2014. ed. A. Süel. Çorum: Baskı. 81-100, 2019
Altorientalische Forschungen 45, 2018
in Altorientalische Forschungen 45: 1-21. The narrative tradition of the Hurro-Hittite Song of Ḫe... more in Altorientalische Forschungen 45: 1-21. The narrative tradition of the Hurro-Hittite Song of Ḫedammu is presented, arguing that two separate Hittite versions can be reconstructed, one relatively condensed, the other more prolix. Such multiformity supports the postulation of an oral tradition lying behind the scribal production of Hurro-Hittite narrative song at Ḫattuša.
in: Homer in Performance: Rhapsodes, Characters, and Narrators, eds. J. L. Ready and C. Tsagalis... more in: Homer in Performance: Rhapsodes, Characters, and Narrators, eds. J. L. Ready and C. Tsagalis (2018, University of Texas Press)
An analysis of the plot twists and multi-faceted characterization of Hector in the Iliad as by-products of an aesthetic developed in the context of festival performances in which multiple bards performed their favorite sections of the story of the fall of Troy.
See "Multiformity in the Song of Hedammu" explaining my changed translation.
The Shield of Achilles is described in I lomer's Iliad (18.474-608) and has excited the imaginati... more The Shield of Achilles is described in I lomer's Iliad (18.474-608) and has excited the imagination of artists and scholars since atleast the nineteenth century. Achilles' divine armor was made by Hephaistos himself out of gold, silver, bronze, and tin. Homer uses the fantastic artifact to depict the cosmic and human order: scenes of war and peace, and joy and grief, filled the shield just as they fill these pages. The images, arranged in concentric bands, presumably evoked the detailed low reliefs engraved in metalwork, especially in the so-called "orientalizing" or Daedalic style (8th-7th cents. BCE), which inspires this rendition. The imaginary shield is too dynamic for static artwork to adequately represent. It takes us from the cosmic elements in the central scene (earth and sea, heaven and stars) to the life of human communities in the surrounding rings. In two cities, one at peace and one at war, we see a wedding party, a judgment over a blood crime, men involved in war preparations and battles, and those dedicated to agriculture and its festivities. Sea waves surround the shield's outer rim, as Greeks and Mesopotamians believed the Ocean encircled the inhabited world.
I explore here some aspects of how masculinity was constructed in Late Bronze Age Anatolia, focu... more I explore here some aspects of how masculinity was constructed in Late
Bronze Age Anatolia, focusing specifically on the masculine identity of the
Hittite king and using the insights provided by two sets of texts coming from
the Hittite capital of Hattuša, Old and Middle Hittite ritual and admonitory
texts, and Hurro-Hittite narrative song.
Commemoration in Literature, Folk-Song, and Liturgy, 2016
I present evidence for how Anatolians viewed their origins and their relationship with theGreeks,... more I present evidence for how Anatolians viewed their origins and their relationship with theGreeks, showing that East-West relations were first framed using inherited Near Eastern models,then the models changed into Greek-oriented migration stories in which Carians and Lycians,like the Greeks, were considered to have arrived in Anatolia from Crete or the Aegean islands.While the sources are all in Greek, it is possible to see Anatolian responses within the Greek stories, especially with regard to the early history of Miletus. And, while Homer studiouslyignores the Greek migrations, preferring relationships created by dynastic marriages, as withBellerophon, we can see that a conversation has already started about the migration, especiallywith regard to Glaucus and Sarpedon, possibly within the context of a Greco-Lycian epictradition. Sarpedon presents an unusually complex case. I argue that his name means 'high place'in Carian, and could be applied to both geographic features and people. That fortuitouscoincidence spurred the connection between a Lycian hero and a founding hero of the Carian cityof Miletus.
My translation of the Anatolian Telipinu Myth, from the 2013 editon of Gods, Heroes and Monsters ... more My translation of the Anatolian Telipinu Myth, from the 2013 editon of Gods, Heroes and Monsters (ed. C. López-Ruiz). It was not included in the 2nd edition
NOW IN PAPERBACK, WITH A 20% DISCOUNT! This book provides a groundbreaking reassessment of the pr... more NOW IN PAPERBACK, WITH A 20% DISCOUNT!
This book provides a groundbreaking reassessment of the prehistory of Homeric epic. It argues that in the Early Iron Age bilingual poets transmitted to the Greeks a set of narrative traditions closely related to the one found at Bronze-Age Hattusa, the Hittite capital. Key drivers for Near Eastern influence on the developing Homeric tradition were the shared practices of supralocal festivals and venerating divinized ancestors, and a shared interest in creating narratives about a legendary past using a few specific storylines: theogonies, genealogies connecting local polities, long-distance travel, destruction of a famous city because it refuses to release captives, and trying to overcome death when confronted with the loss of a dear companion. Professor Bachvarova concludes by providing a fresh explanation of the origins and significance of the Greco-Anatolian legend of Troy, thereby offering a new solution to the long-debated question of the historicity of the Trojan War.
This book provides a groundbreaking reassessment of the prehistory of Homeric epic. It argues tha... more This book provides a groundbreaking reassessment of the prehistory of Homeric epic. It argues that in the Early Iron Age bilingual poets transmitted to the Greeks a set of narrative traditions closely related to the one found at Bronze-Age Hattusa, the Hittite capital. Key drivers for Near Eastern influence on the developing Homeric tradition were the shared practices of supralocal festivals and venerating divinized ancestors, and a shared interest in creating narratives about a legendary past using a few specific storylines: theogonies, genealogies connecting local polities, long-distance travel, destruction of a famous city because it refuses to release captives, and trying to overcome death when confronted with the loss of a dear companion. I conclude by providing a fresh explanation of the origins and significance of the Greco-Anatolian legend of Troy, thereby offering a new solution to the long-debated question of the historicity of the Trojan War.
Religious Convergence in the Ancient Mediterrean, 2019
Mountains were nodes of contact and places of continuity that allowed for the transfer across spa... more Mountains were nodes of contact and places of continuity that allowed for the transfer across space, time, and cultures within Anatolia of stories connected to the storm god's rise to kingship in heaven. Versions of the Bronze Age stories other than the ones available to us lie behind the story of the births of Cybele and Agdistis in Arnobius (Adv. Nat. 5.5-6), which represented versions not aimed at the concerns of the Hittite court, focused less on kingship and more on transgressive sexuality, gestation, and birth, which were metaphorized as volcanic and metallurgic processes.
The Fall of Cities: Commemoration in Literature, Folk Song, and Liturgy, 2016
I follow the thread of the theme of the sacked city from its earliest manifestation in Mesopotami... more I follow the thread of the theme of the sacked city from its earliest
manifestation in Mesopotamian historiography to the Iliad, showing that
the Greek epic picked up on many themes originating in early second millennium Mesopotamia, and reworked them to new purposes. As with
the Hittites, the Greeks used the claim of responsibility for the destruction
of a famous city to position themselves on the world stage and to place
themselves in world history, conceived of as a series of cities destroyed in
turn. The deepened understanding of the tradition behind the Homeric
epic improves our ability to appreciate the innovations as well. Furthermore, I suggest that we take into account not only the interplay
between female personal lament and male epic in the Iliad, but also
possible influence from an indigenous liturgical lament tradition originally
cognate with the Mesopotamian one, but diverging decisively when it
began to be used to celebrate in cult a city whose ruined walls became
the locus of cultural memories about a lost age of heroes.
Narrating the Beginnings, eds. A. Bernabé Pajares and R. Martín Hernández. Wiesbaden. 69-93., 2021
The use of general descriptive names, registered names, trademarks, service marks, etc. in this p... more The use of general descriptive names, registered names, trademarks, service marks, etc. in this publication does not imply, even in the absence of a specific statement, that such names are exempt from the relevant protective laws and regulations and therefore free for general use. The publisher, the authors and the editors are safe to assume that the advice and information in this book are believed to be true and accurate at the date of publication. Neither the publisher nor the authors or the editors give a warranty, expressed or implied, with respect to the material contained herein or for any errors or omissions that may have been made. The publisher remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Acts of the IXth International Congress of Hittitology, Çorum, 08-14 September 2014. ed. A. Süel. Çorum: Baskı. 81-100, 2019
Altorientalische Forschungen 45, 2018
in Altorientalische Forschungen 45: 1-21. The narrative tradition of the Hurro-Hittite Song of Ḫe... more in Altorientalische Forschungen 45: 1-21. The narrative tradition of the Hurro-Hittite Song of Ḫedammu is presented, arguing that two separate Hittite versions can be reconstructed, one relatively condensed, the other more prolix. Such multiformity supports the postulation of an oral tradition lying behind the scribal production of Hurro-Hittite narrative song at Ḫattuša.
in: Homer in Performance: Rhapsodes, Characters, and Narrators, eds. J. L. Ready and C. Tsagalis... more in: Homer in Performance: Rhapsodes, Characters, and Narrators, eds. J. L. Ready and C. Tsagalis (2018, University of Texas Press)
An analysis of the plot twists and multi-faceted characterization of Hector in the Iliad as by-products of an aesthetic developed in the context of festival performances in which multiple bards performed their favorite sections of the story of the fall of Troy.
See "Multiformity in the Song of Hedammu" explaining my changed translation.
The Shield of Achilles is described in I lomer's Iliad (18.474-608) and has excited the imaginati... more The Shield of Achilles is described in I lomer's Iliad (18.474-608) and has excited the imagination of artists and scholars since atleast the nineteenth century. Achilles' divine armor was made by Hephaistos himself out of gold, silver, bronze, and tin. Homer uses the fantastic artifact to depict the cosmic and human order: scenes of war and peace, and joy and grief, filled the shield just as they fill these pages. The images, arranged in concentric bands, presumably evoked the detailed low reliefs engraved in metalwork, especially in the so-called "orientalizing" or Daedalic style (8th-7th cents. BCE), which inspires this rendition. The imaginary shield is too dynamic for static artwork to adequately represent. It takes us from the cosmic elements in the central scene (earth and sea, heaven and stars) to the life of human communities in the surrounding rings. In two cities, one at peace and one at war, we see a wedding party, a judgment over a blood crime, men involved in war preparations and battles, and those dedicated to agriculture and its festivities. Sea waves surround the shield's outer rim, as Greeks and Mesopotamians believed the Ocean encircled the inhabited world.
I explore here some aspects of how masculinity was constructed in Late Bronze Age Anatolia, focu... more I explore here some aspects of how masculinity was constructed in Late
Bronze Age Anatolia, focusing specifically on the masculine identity of the
Hittite king and using the insights provided by two sets of texts coming from
the Hittite capital of Hattuša, Old and Middle Hittite ritual and admonitory
texts, and Hurro-Hittite narrative song.
Commemoration in Literature, Folk-Song, and Liturgy, 2016
I present evidence for how Anatolians viewed their origins and their relationship with theGreeks,... more I present evidence for how Anatolians viewed their origins and their relationship with theGreeks, showing that East-West relations were first framed using inherited Near Eastern models,then the models changed into Greek-oriented migration stories in which Carians and Lycians,like the Greeks, were considered to have arrived in Anatolia from Crete or the Aegean islands.While the sources are all in Greek, it is possible to see Anatolian responses within the Greek stories, especially with regard to the early history of Miletus. And, while Homer studiouslyignores the Greek migrations, preferring relationships created by dynastic marriages, as withBellerophon, we can see that a conversation has already started about the migration, especiallywith regard to Glaucus and Sarpedon, possibly within the context of a Greco-Lycian epictradition. Sarpedon presents an unusually complex case. I argue that his name means 'high place'in Carian, and could be applied to both geographic features and people. That fortuitouscoincidence spurred the connection between a Lycian hero and a founding hero of the Carian cityof Miletus.
My translation of the Anatolian Telipinu Myth, from the 2013 editon of Gods, Heroes and Monsters ... more My translation of the Anatolian Telipinu Myth, from the 2013 editon of Gods, Heroes and Monsters (ed. C. López-Ruiz). It was not included in the 2nd edition
I examine the literary and conceptual background of a Hurro-Hittite ritual calling on divinized r... more I examine the literary and conceptual background of a Hurro-Hittite ritual calling on divinized royal ancestors (šarrena), characters from Hurro-Hittite song, members of the Sargonic dynasty, a variety of kings from far-off lands, and the “lord of Hatti” (KUB 27.38). I show that the ritual provides a unique glimpse of the complex Near Eastern tradition telling the history of the world from its beginning. The ritual also helps us to understand how historical memory informed ritual behaviors that legitimated the kingship of regional rulers, allowing them access to the distant past and connecting them to world events. Overall, the šarrena ritual suggests that the histories of the divine and human worlds were linked into a single master narrative by the middle of the second millennium BCE.
Powerpoint slides for lecture given at Brown University, Joukowsky Institute, Oct. 20, 2016
slides for a powerpoint presentation, presented at Dhlem Seminar, Freie Universität, Berlin, June... more slides for a powerpoint presentation, presented at Dhlem Seminar, Freie Universität, Berlin, June 28, 2016
Powerpoint presentation from 64th Rencontre Assyriologique, 12th Melammu Symposium, July 16, 2018