CONSERVATION OF PRINCIPLES OR OBJECTS?: An Approach of Conserving the Traditional Balinese Cultural Landscape in Urban Areas (original) (raw)
Related papers
Cultural Heritage Conservation: Case Study of Pedawa Village, Bali- Indonesia
Journal of Tourism, Hospitality and Environment Management, 2021
Bali, which is famous for its tourist areas, has many cultural heritages, one of them is the Bali Aga villages. Bali Aga Village is an indigenous village that existed before the arrival of community from the island of Java in the era of the Majapahit kingdom. Pedawa Village which is located in Banjar District, Buleleng Regency is one of the Bali Aga Villages in Bali which has many cultural heritages that need to be preserved. This village is very famous for its culture, customs and belief that are still preserved by the local community. One of the cultural heritages is the temple named Pura Dalem Kayehan Desa and Kayehan Desa Alas Jeringo which both have natural springs that are used by all villagers in daily basis. These two temples are used for activities ranging from sacred activities (rituals and traditional ceremonies) to profane (bathing and washing clothes). Local community often experience difficulties when carrying out sacred and profane activities during the rainy season d...
1994
Conserving places of architectural heritage value is of prime importance for Indonesia. Multi-ethnic developing nations must retain local character while creating a national, multi-ethnic identity. During periods of rapid socio-economic change, one must both anticipate a dynamic development process and protect architectural heritage places; thus, attempts to safeguard culturally-significant living structures are crucial. The architectural conservation movement in Indonesia is still largely in its infancy; a strategy for its development is greatly needed. This strategy should incorporate an understanding of the scope of heritage conservation, development of an appropriate model, and the establishment of mechanisms for implementation. Lessons learned from the experience of other countries may constitute an invaluable resource. The choice of an intact yet decaying historic urban structure as a case study can provide a useful example for practical application." This thesis attempts to develop a model for safeguarding Indonesia's architectural heritage, with the historic Islamic district of Kudus serving as a case study. A fourstep procedure is proposed as the model. It consists of : (1) examination of historic context; (2) assessment of cultural significance; (3) development of conservation policy; and (4) directions for policy implementation. This model is intended to provide future policy directions for those involved in the urban development of Indonesia and Kudus, including professionals, policy-makers and the inhabitants. In many respects an academic exercise, this research establishes the need for further studies which could only take place with greater availability of resources. A general literature review to establish the theoretical basis of the work was carried out in Australian libraries and through discussions with relevant experts. Field research allowed for the examination and recording of architectural, historical, socioeconomic, and administrative data of the historic Islamic district of Kudus. Research in Indonesia included archival research, literature review, site and building measurements, and photographic documentation, as well as interviews with inhabitants, relevant professional practitioners, and local officials. Examination of field data led to the development of an appropriate analytical method. Application of this method established historic themes, determined statements of cultural significance for heritage areas and structures, developed a framework for both general and critical inventories, and established priorities for immediate protection. A conservation policy was subsequently formulated through appropriate application of the theoretical base to the Kudus case and review of relevant international and Indonesian experience. This policy approach considers the district as a whole dynamic living heritage, integrates conservation issues and practice with an overall planning process, and generates community participation in a more conservation-oriented planning and design process. Primary, secondary and supporting programmes for policy implementation were identified. This model provides a structure in which Kudus residents, urban design professionals and government officials can develop a conservation policy for Kudus. It does not pre-empt strategic decision-making. Rather, it can serve as a valuable tool for conservation analysis and planning applicable to other places facing similar problems. In addition, this study contains important historic and architectural information to add to current knowledge of Kudus and to serve as a source of comparative study for other historic Islamic districts of Indonesia, particularly in Java. Finally, it is hoped that this study will contribute to the development of heritage conservation research in Indonesia
National criteria for accessing Indonesian cultural properties categorized as heritage are mentioned in Article five under the Law 11/2010 on Cultural Property. In general, the four criteria are not much different from the previous legislation, the Law 5/1992. National criteria serve as a guide in determining the criteria for provincial and municipal level. Therefore, this paper aims to review the national criteria based on the opinions of 33 respondents involving local people from various professions who have an interest in the heritage conservation through semi-structured interviews and nominal group technique (NGT). The preferred method purposes to increase the community involvement to improve the heritage legislation primarily on the assessment criteria for the cultural heritage value. The literature study on cultural heritage value and national criteria applied in several other countries has been completed prior to the interview to obtain valuable input in the analysis. It can be summarized that the national criteriaa as stated under this law are vague, obscure and overlap due to the blurring of meaning and conception of cultural heritage value or significance in this legislation. The results of the study highlighted the crucial evidence of the need to review the current national criteria with the involvement of community for improvement of the assessment criteria for the cultural heritage value. Besides, it would support national, provincial and municipal governments in drafting new regulations as a guideline in practice regarding the Law 11/2010 which until today most have not been published.
“First Principles” in Conservation: The UNESCO Asia-Pacific Heritage Awards
2010
reflecting regional specificities. and houses provide a connection with earlier times, serving as physical reminders of people, events, and values and providing tangible spaces in which intangible forms of culture can be expressed. The conservation of local, national, and regional physical-cultural resources is pre-requisite to sustaining equitable social and economic development. Our built heritage is also valuable for its aesthetic beauty and symbolic qualities and for the emotions that they inspire. Yet our historic cities and the buildings and public spaces of which they are constituted are increasingly under threat from the twenty-firstcentury requirements for housing, commerce, transportation, and public services linked to development and modernization. The basic question we must confront is this: How do we balance the preservation of the heritage significance of our built environment with the transformations required by modernization? Nowhere is this question more pressing th...
This paper is particularly concerned with phenomena and tendencies of practices of urban conservation and inner-city revitalisation. It argues that urban development and conservation is a process of cultural appraisal. From actual conditions of urban development in Indonesia the discussion tries to elaborate the initial bases of the urban conservation in revitalisation scheme. Furthermore, it will also discuss the role of planning regarding the important interaction between built-environment and cultural processes. Two focal issues should be clearly revealed as a red line in the discussion.
Cultural Landscape Heritage Management in Indonesia An Archaeological Perspective 1
In the history of Archaeology, landscape has always been considered as an important aspect in giving meaning to an artefact or a site. It provides a condition by which archaeologists can contextualized their findings. Even in the end of 19 th Century, a pioneer of field archaeology, General Pitt Rivers, has prompted the role of natural settings in archaeological explanation . Nevertheless, strange enough, in cultural resource management such a natural context is often neglected. This is partly because in the past archaeologists were concerned more on cultural remains. Though the natural setting of the cultural remains were admittedly important, it is still considered as natural rather than cultural. Hence, it was treated as different and separate entity.
Local government' perception of cultural heritage conservation in Denpasar, Bali
Developing countries are facing many challenges to cope with the influx of population migration to cities and the associated demand for urban fabric and public facilities. Urban development strategies mainly focus on infrastructure and economy and generally do not take into account character and identity of urban areas. This paper emphasizes the importance of cultural heritage as a critical factor to improve the character and identity of Denpasar, Bali-Indonesia. Denpasar's cultural heritage attracts increasing number of tourists and it is the main source of local economy. However, tourism has led to population influx to Denpasar leading to degradation of city character. Interviews with different stakeholders were used to capture their views about the importance of cultural heritage and evolve strategies to improve the cultural identity and heritage of Denpasar. It brings out ways of conserving cultural heritage and how it could be incorporated into planning and development policies of Denpasar.
Challenges for Heritage Conservation and Management in Medan, North Sumatra, Indonesia
IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science, 2020
This paper describes the issues and challenges in safeguarding and protecting the urban heritage in Medan by observing the town heritage of Medan and interviewing the local communities. The Indonesian Law on Cultural Property Conservation number 11 the year of 2010 allows the provincial and local government for the greater representation in managing and conserving their cultural heritage. This paper also discusses the gaps in that current town planning to assist the heritage conservation in Medan. Through a semi-structured interview, field survey and the SWOT analysis, the research found a broad overview of the challenges in heritage conservation in Medan. For example, overlapping duties, lack of clarity regarding jurisdiction and the lack of inter-organization coordination between government agencies that are significant obstacles to meeting the goals of heritage conservation. Another critical problem in Medan is registration and designation. In conclusion, the local government of Medan has paid less attention to the protection of their heritage during the last three decades. Meanwhile, the awareness of the local community at the grassroots increased; however, the concepts of an active role for the community and integrated conservation linked to the town planning are underdeveloped. Therefore, it has also caused the recent heritage conservation program challenging to achieve its objectives.
Conservation of Heritage Curtilages in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia
2017
Built environment heritage is increasingly vulnerable in South East Asia due to increasing urbanisation and rapid urban development. This dissertation examines the value of the concept of heritage curtilages in Malaysia, with an explicit focus on Kuala Lumpur. The concept is still relatively new in the field of heritage conservation and it is closely related to concepts of setting or context. Curtilage comprises a broader aspect as it takes into consideration all elements involved in retaining heritage curtilage and interpreting the significance of a specific heritage item within an area. Among these elements are the functional uses, visual links, scale and significant features. The conservation of heritage curtilage has the significant potential to enhance the richness and contextual settings of heritage buildings in Malaysia. While conservation efforts are improving, there is still limited research which focuses on the implementation of heritage curtilage as a conservation practice and a strategy. Moreover, it is necessary to improve understanding of how heritage curtilage relates to and enhances the significance of individual heritage places. This dissertation initially discusses the theoretical issues and complexities related to the definition of heritage curtilage, with reference to specific initiatives in Malaysia, as influenced both by the local legislators and international heritage organisations. This discussion is Those of us who have pushed for recognition of 'the intangible' in heritage work are also those who tend to stress the 'cultural' in cultural heritage. We try to resist the tendency of heritage discourse to reduce culture to things, we try to counter its privileging of physical fabric over social life (Bryne, 2009, p. 229). Conservation efforts have involved "social practices, skills, and traditions as the equivalent of heritage objects, places or landscapes" for comprehensive actions (Bryne, 2009, p. 229). These elements are priceless and irreplaceable. In this sense, heritage is clearly something of worth to be conserved, preserved, and protected. In Malaysia, the evolution and interest in conserving Malaysia's cultural heritage began more than twenty years ago with the formation of the Heritage of Malaysia Trust in 1993. However, regarding legal documents, the implementation of conservation Acts and guidelines are still
Bali has grown large number of population from tourists and migrant which leads to degradation of Denpasar city character. Further, cultural and landscape heritage in Denpasar has been interrupted with commercial activities supporting tourism, and by new developments supporting population growth. This paper emphasizes the importance of cultural and landscape heritage as a critical factor to improve the character and identity of Denpasar from perspective of different stakeholders. It concludes that creative strategies urgently needed and the role of stakeholders includes government, private sector, local community and all level in society should be urgently improved.