Hunting the Ethical State. The Benkadi Movement of Côte d'Ivoire (original) (raw)
Related papers
Niezen_Violence in Cote d'Ivoire
2013
In Côte d'Ivoire violence seems to have become kaleidoscopically inscrutable in its tendency to take on complex, shifting forms. Two volumes, both published in 2011, by Mike McGovern and Joseph Hellweg, unpack some of the background to Côte d'Ivoire's ethnic strife and civil war. Ethnography plays an important part in each of these contributions, offering the only viable way to interpret such vexed conflicts as those that followed Laurent Gbagbo's efforts to hold power in the mid- to late 2000s. The astonishing plasticity of social forces in West Africa that sit astride tradition and modernity, and that defy categorization as civil or uncivil society, seem to be capable of strategic mimesis in any direction.
The Dynamics of Restraint in Côte d'Ivoire
IDS Bulletin Vol.44, No.1, 2013
Research on conflict prevention has mainly focused on the causes of war and post-conflict reconstruction. Our knowledge on how civilians manage to contain violence in unstable and conflict environments is, however, very limited. This article aims to understand, in the context of the civil war in Côte d’Ivoire, how and why ‘islands of peace’ emerge during outbreaks of violence. It identifies both the local and structural conditions and mechanisms (including formal and informal) that help to mitigate violence and encourage restraint in conflict-affected and unstable situations. Our research and analysis has focused on the western region, which is the epicentre of violence. Semi-structured interviews with Young Patriots members, the military, the business community, representatives of women’s NGOs, traditional leaders and representatives of the religious community, along with interviews in Abidjan, provided the primary data for our analysis.
The civil war in Côte d'Ivoire presents unique features with respect to the causes of civil wars and the nature of peace processes in West Africa. It is a conflict largely driven by concrete political and social grievances over citizenship. In addition, it is marked by a significant effort by the belligerents to take ownership of the peace process and negotiate directly. This article traces the civil war to the politicization of citizenship and ethnicity during the democratization process. It argues that the peace agreements engineered by the international community failed to end the conflict largely because they relied heavily on traditional peace formulas and paid insufficient attention to the underlying issue of citizenship. In contrast, the peace agreement forged by Ivorians has been relatively successful because it directly addressed the citizenship issue and restored domestic ownership of the peace process. This article focuses on the peace process and the intrinsic relation between citizenship and progress toward peace in Côte d'Ivoire. In addition, it connects the discourse on democracy in Africa with the salient issue of citizenship and underscores the fluidity of citizenship and democracy in African politics.
Maintenant, on sait qui est qui: Statehood and Political Reconfiguration in Northern Côte d’Ivoire
Development and Change, 2010
The transformation of statehood in the rebel-held northern half of Côte d'Ivoire builds on the reconfiguration of the social and political order. Though the state as an institution has almost ceased to exist, statehood as the practices that refer to it persists. This article examines the negotiations between the different non-state actors and how these interactions shape, through everyday practices, the understanding of what a state should and should not do. The widely used saying of 'Now one knows who is who' answers the older expression that one does not know who is who. Before the crisis broke out in 2002, it was often difficult to distinguish between security providers and criminals. At that time, the police and gendarmerie could be either, while, through the rebellion, role ascriptions became clear and distinct. This article argues that the normative expectations of statehood are thus embedded in the general reconfiguration of society that has led to more stability and reliability of social roles. The author would like to thank the editors of this volume and the anonymous reviewers of Development and Change for their valuable comments.
The war of 'who is who': autochthony, nationalism and citizenship in the Ivorian crisis
… creating strangers: states and citizenship in …, 2006
Over the past four years the Ivoirian crisis has seen as its central dynamic the mobilization of the categories of autochthony and territorialized belonging in an ultranationalist discourse vehicled by the party in power. More than just a struggle to the death for state power, the conflict involves the redefinition of the content of citizenship and the conditions of sovereignty. The explosion of violence and counterviolence provoked and legitimated by the mobilization of these categories does not necessarily signify either the triumph of those monolithic identities "engineered" during the colonial occupation, nor the disintegration of the nation-state in the context of globalization. The Ivoirian case shows the continued vitality of the nation-state: not only as the principal space in terms of which discourses of authochtony are constructed, but also in terms of the techniques and categories that the political practice of autochthony puts into play. While in some senses the Ivoirian conflict appears to be a war without borders-in particular with the "spillover" of the Liberian war in the west during 2003-it is above all a war about borders, crystallizing in liminal spaces and social categories and on emerging practices and ways of life.