THE WAR IN UKRAINE AS A CHALLENGE FOR RELIGIOUS COMMUNITIES: ORTHODOXY, CATHOLICISM AND PROSPECTS FOR PEACEMAKING 1 (original) (raw)
Related papers
War and Religion: Views from Within Ukraine’s ‘Russian’ Church
ZOiS Report 6, 2024
Russia’s war against Ukraine has changed Ukraine’s religious landscape. Due to its ties to the Russian Orthodox Church, the Ukrainian Orthodox Church (UOC), once the biggest Christian denomination in the country, has faced declining membership, public scrutiny and restrictive government policies. This report focuses on the perspectives of rank-and-file UOC members regarding public disapproval of their church. Based on qualitative interviews conducted with priests and parishioners in nine parishes in 2024, it provides insights into the mood within the UOC and its members’ (un)willingness to change their religious practices and affiliation against the backdrop of growing anti-Russian sentiment in Ukrainian society
Russian Church and Ukrainian War
The Expository Times, 2022
The war in Ukraine that began in February 2014 and escalated in February 2022 to the extent unseen in Europe since the World War II, cannot be adequately comprehended without taking into consideration its religious dimension. This article explores the evolution of the “Russian world” ideology, which the leaders and speakers of the Russian Orthodox Church render in quasi-theological terms. It explains why the Russian patriarch Kirill decided to back it and turned it from an elitist to mass ideologeme. These explanations are given in the sociological framework of the public space, social contract, and civil religion. The main argument of the article is that the church wanted to regain for itself a central place in the Russian public square after the decades of exile from it under the Communist regime. In result of supporting the war, however, the church is endangered to be marginalised in this square again.
Patriotism, Peacebuilding and Patrons in Heaven: The Ukrainian Greek-Catholic Church in Times of War
What remained from the multi-ethnic, multi-linguistic, multi-confessional, all boundaries transcending experience of Maidan? How do faith communities today embody reconciliation in Ukraine? In this paper the focus is on the Ukrainian Greek-Catholic Church (UGCC). What is its role in a society and country that suffers from war, that faces a threatened political existence and a desastrous economic situation? How does its theology respond to the challenges and what is the peacebuilding potential of it? A theology of revolution has emerged in Ukraine. My paper presents the emerging political theology in Ukrainian context, and aims at contributing to it with some critical considerations.
THE UKRAINIAN ORTHODOX CHURCH A POWERFUL PEACE ACTOR
Ukrainian Autocephaly: Source of Confrontation or Conflict?, 2019
According to the Ukrainian Constitution, the country is secular, where its churches and all religious organisations are separated from the state and the legislative process. According to theologian Gennadiy Druzenko, in the regional scope, Ukraine might be described as one of the most religious countries in Europe. Demonstrated by the history of the Ukrainian Church, dating back to the time of the Kyivan Rus, when its Prince Volodymyr the Great received Christianity from Constantinople in 988. It was one of the most remarkable events in the creation of the Ukrainian state, that united the Ukrainian people spiritually. However, it further served as an instrument of manipulation and basis for lies from the Russian side so as to justify its right to exert control over Ukraine. This current paper aims to analyse the role of the Church in peace mediation versus conflict promotion in the case of Ukraine, addressing such issues as: - Official relations between and within different churches in the country and show impacts of this in reality; - The official position of the UOC KP and UAOC towards the conflict in Eastern Ukraine, the illegal annexation of Crimea, possible future reconciliation and current geopolitical challenges, reactions to fake news and disinformation; - The official position of the Church, position on the ground and the reaction on the discrimination against LGBT, religious and ethnic minorities; - Based on these points we will analyse whether the Church promotes peace or encourages conflicts in Ukraine, trying to answer whether the Church as an institution could serve as a powerful peace actor or not.
Religions
Russia’s war against Ukraine, in which the aggressor has been making use of religion, including theological rhetoric, to achieve its aims, has sparked reactions from Orthodox Churches all over the world. This has led to a revitalisation of social teaching, including discussions on war and peace within the Orthodox tradition. This may well become a further impetus for more in-depth research on religion and international relations, and possibly for more reappraisals of the secular identity of IR studies. An analysis of the attitudes of Orthodox Churches towards this war indicated that the authority of the Russian Orthodox Church, which considers itself the most important centre of Orthodox culture and civilisation, is waning. The reaction of other local churches showed that it is difficult to recognise the Russian Orthodox Church as such an authority. These revaluations may have a significant impact on Russia’s place in the new international order, although much depends on the final o...
The Ukrainian National Church, Religious Diplomacy and the Conflict in Donbas
Journal of Orthodox Christian Studies, 2020
The article analyses political mobilisation towards the establishment of an independent Ukrainian national church. Ukraine had three Orthodox churches, the largest of which is under the jurisdiction of the Moscow Patriarchate, while the others lacked ecclesiastical legitimacy. On 11 October 2018, in a dramatic decision with geopolitical consequences, the Kyiv Patriarchate received ecclesiastical recognition from the Istanbul-based Ecumenical Patriarchate. Drawing on 16 interviews with key clergy, academics and policy practitioners working on church-state relations in Kyiv, a literature review, and online data from Bulgarian, Greek, Polish, Romanian, Russian, Serbian and Ukrainian sources, the article argues that the conflict in Donbas has been a key factor in the national and international mobilisation towards autocephaly. This article demonstrates that in Eastern Orthodoxy, churches perform state-like functions in three areas, namely establishing diplomatic channels of communication; mobilising the faithful at national and international levels; and advancing human security discourses on violence, survival and tolerance.
Kalenychenko T. and Brylov D. Ukrainian Religious Actors After Russian Invasion. Policy Brief
This Transatlantic Policy Network on Religion and Diplomacy policy brief analyzes Ukraine’s religious context, the range of responses to the Russian invasion of Ukraine in February 2022 from across the spectrum of religious groups in the country, and the obstacles to and opportunities for Ukrainian religious contributions to peacebuilding. The report concludes with recommendations for how governments and civil society organizations in the international community can engage with Ukrainian religious and non-religious actors to foster a constructive response to the war.
Russian Analytical Digest, 2019
A rapid and sudden change of religious and political boundaries and identities in connection with the contestation of Ukrainian Orthodoxy by the Ecumenical Patriarchate has remodeled the church schism in Ukraine, but without resolving it. Global Orthodoxy is going to be split into mutually exclusive clusters with two major centers, Moscow and Istanbul. Against the background of the 2019 presidential campaign, this theopolitical conflict in Ukraine could trigger a bloody religious war with far-reaching consequences.