Nothing to do with medicine? Ordinary life, stories and beliefs as educational tools for physicians in Antiquity, Middle Ages and Renaissance (original) (raw)
Galen (2nd cent.) promotes experience and reason as the two pillars of his medical-educational process. In his treatise On the powers of simple drugs, he criticizes the “Sophists’” method of demonstration based on induction and example. Yet he himself resorts to examples, giving them a prominent place in the demonstrative process. Rāzī (9th cent.) exemplifies medical theory and practice resorting to stories from all kinds of people, many of them outside the medical milieu. In his treatise Spiritual book (Kitāb ṭibb al-ruḥanī), Rāzī tries to keep out malaise, discomfort and unease. He undertakes this task putting daily life under close scrutiny and giving simple examples of ordinary circumstances recognized by everyone. He showcases the difficulty of achieving a balanced and healthy condition of mind and body and reaching human happiness. These points seem closer to the so-called “non-natural” or ”six” causes than to the usual rules of disease care. Both Galen and Rāzī transform situations everyone could meet in “real life” into pieces of medical evidence. Yet “real life” is not independent of time. In the Renaissance, the erudite humanists who use Galen’s work as the source of medical education have to reconcile their respect for his authority with their own intellectual and social context. How do they handle this challenging situation? Less erudite works aimed at “professionals” engage with religious beliefs and practices as part of the readers’ “real life”, without an explicit link to piety. Our aim is to diachronically study a selection of non-medical examples in their medical context or more generally in a wellness setting. We would like to focus on the transformation of their nature and use in the framework of knowledge transmission and innovation. Medicine is not mere rhetoric, yet the rhetoric of persuasion, including thoughtful engagement with “real life”, plays a crucial role for an education whose roots are erudite and whose branches flourish transcending time and place.
Related papers
Medical Authority and the Uses of Imagination
Convultions. The aim of this document was to prove, by an empirical experiment performed at Bath Hospital, that the "tractors" (two small, pointed rods of metal used in the treatment of rheumatoid arthritis by their alleged magnetic properties)
Chapter 7. Turning the Medicine Wheel. Between Paradigms
Holism and Complementary Medicine. Origins and Principles. Allen and Unwin, Crow's Nest, NSW, 2006
Foreword vii Preface xi Introduction xv The making of a new medicine PART I ORIGINS Chapter 1 Antiquity 3 The early origins of medicine Chapter 2 Middle times 19 The gathering light Chapter 3 Modernity and beyond 36 The temple of power PART II PRINCIPLES Chapter 4 Holism and reductionism in medicine 59 Reconciling the opposites Chapter 5 The healing relationship 79 Reflections on the clinical encounter Chapter 6 The therapeutic aims of holistic medicine 96 Restoring the body, empowering the mind Chapter 7 Turning the medicine wheel Between paradigms Chapter 8 Firming the foundations Ways of knowing Chapter 9 Completing the circle Voices of renewal Glossary References Notes Index Nothing that exists exists for its own sake; it exists for the sake of the whole.
Learning from the Common Folks. Academic Physicians and Medical Lay Culture in the Sixteenth Century
Social History of Medicine (2014) 27 (4): 649-667
Drawing on some 4.000 pages of personal notes on medical practice by the little known Bohemian physician Georg Handsch, this paper studies the oral transmission of medical knowledge from laypersons to academically trained physicians in the sixteenth century. In marked contrast to their public attacks against ‘empirics’ and the ‘ignorance’ of the ‘vulgus’, numerous entries in Handsch’s notebooks reveal that he and the physicians around him were prepared to learn from the common folks, from patients and friends, from family members and even from ‘wise women’ and unlicensed ‘empirics’. They valued their ideas, observations and skills as potentially useful for their own practice. This remarkable openness, the paper suggests, was due above all to the rise of empirical approaches in learned medicine, the competition from unlicensed healers and the physicians’ own upbringing in the medical lay culture of their time.
In the Nicomachean Ethics, Aristotle places the art of medicine alongside other examples of technē. According to Gadamer, however, medicine is different because in medicine the physician does not, properly speaking, produce anything. In The Enigma of Health, rather than introducing Aristotle’s intellectual virtue of phronēsis (practical wisdom) as a way of understanding medical practice, Gadamer focuses on how medicine is a technē “with a difference”. In this paper, I argue that, despite the richness of his insights, this focus prevents Gadamer from reaching an adequate account of health and the practice of medicine, and I demonstrate how making phronēsis central via a phenomenological description furthers our understanding of the art of healing in important ways. The paper begins with an exploration of Gadamer’s understanding of phronēsis and technē (via Heidegger) to provide a foundation for a phenomenological analysis of the art of healing. After considering the shortcomings of Gadamer’s analyses, I introduce a working definition of “health” that both captures the spirit of Gadamer’s insights and prepares the ground for a phenomenological description. Finally, I introduce concepts from Merleau-Ponty in order to establish an adequate account of the relation between technē and phronēsis and a more nuanced understanding of experience as unfolding within the expressive trajectories forged by bodies that are subject to the weight of the past and the weight of the ideal. The art of medicine, I argue, needs to be understood as expressive behavior in the context of historically and socially situated individuals, institutions, and open trajectories of sense.
Loading Preview
Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.