Of zinc roofs and mango trees: tractors, the state and agrarian dualism in Mozambique (original) (raw)
Related papers
“The Keys to the Tractor: A Case Study from Mozambique on ‘Ownership’ and Decentralization”
Beyond Accra: Practical Implications of Ownership and Accountability in National Development Strategies, 2009
This paper investigates power dynamics at the district level in the implementation of the decentralisation process in Mozambique through an ethnographic approach, drawing from a number of extended stays from 2007 to 2009. After providing a sketch of the local and national context, the paper tells the story of the Malanga Farmers Union attempting to engage with district development policy in the age of decentralisation. Mozambican “ownership” of development strategies, budgets and aid — from the highest level to the most local — is based on clever appropriation not by force, but instead resulting from intimate social relations where as Mbembe expresses it, “those who command and those assumed to obey” are entangled.
The politics of mechanisation in Zimbabwe: tractors, accumulation and agrarian change
Journal of peasant studies, 2021
This article explores whether mechanisation affects patterns of accumulation and differentiation in Zimbabwe's post land reform where policy consistently disadvantages smallholders. Is the latest mechanisation wave any different? The article considers dynamics of tractor access and accumulation trajectories across and within land use types in Mvurwi area. Larger, richer and well-connected farmers draw on patronage networks to access tractors and accumulate further. Some small to medium-scale farmers generate surpluses and invest in tractors or pay for services. Thus, accumulation from above and below feeds social differentiation. Tractor access remains constrained yet mechanisation is only part of the wider post-2000 story.
Land of lost opportunities: transition and crisis in Mozambican agriculture
África, 1998
This paper analyses the reasons underlying the failure of the collectivization of agriculture in Mozambique (1975-84). Two explanations are offered; first, Frelimo's socializing policies reflected an inconsistent compromise between dualist and non-dualist views of the relationship between the peasant and "modern" sectors of the economy. Second, the poor and middle peasants actively resisted the collectivist strategy of the government. The conflict between state and peasantry led to the collapse of agricultural production, the defeat of the collectivist strategy, and the slide of the country into a vicious civil war.
Tractors, Markets and the State: (Dis)continuities in Africa’s Agricultural Mechanisation
2019
Agricultural mechanisation has once again become a topical issue in African policymaking, following the reinstatement of agriculture in the growth and development agenda for the continent since the turn of the century. This is illustrated by the pan-Africa strategy for agriculture (the Comprehensive Africa Agriculture Development Policy [CAADP]), the renewed interest in the sector within the established aid system, and the unfolding of new South-South relations involving agricultural investments, technology transfers and trade.
Tractors and agrarian transformation in Zimbabwe Insights from Mvurwi WP21 201920190422 71780 1r38qw
Tractors and Agrarian Transformation in Zimbabwe: Insights from Mvurwi. APRA working paper 21, Future Agricultures Consortium, 2019
This paper examines postcolonial agricultural mechanisation in Zimbabwe in the context of recent land reforms. It pays particular attention to the central role played by state-capital relations – with notable links to international finance – in shaping a resurgence in tractor usage following Zimbabwe’s Fast Track Land Reform Programme (FTLRP). Moreover, the economy-wide crisis triggered by land reform shaped the emerging agricultural mechanisation. This study examines the decline in tractor supply by the government, and the growth and dominance of large-scale commercial farms as a source of second-hand tractors for smallholder and medium-scale farmers. This paper relies on archival sources as well as empirical data collected in Mvurwi through surveys, focus group discussions, tracker studies and in-depth interviews. While the tractors imported by the government from Brazil on concessional terms have become a major source of tractor services for the resettled farmers in Mvurwi, resettled farmers are also reinvesting proceeds from the sale of agricultural commodities predominantly in agricultural mechanisation, creating a new source for tractor hiring services and agrarian transformation. Although patronage politics has shaped the distribution of tractors and the establishment of tractor service cooperatives, there is no evidence of concrete political gains resulting from these investments.
2018
The ProSAVANA program is one of the public policies that clearly expose the tendency of governmental politics towards market-oriented agricultural development in Mozambique. Nevertheless, it configures itself as one of, if not the most contested agrarian public policy in the country since independence in 1975. Going throughout changing of regimes, from colonial, then going through a socialist driven government to adopting a market-oriented approach roughly after only a decade of socialism, we argue that State agricultural policies and vision has always been inimical to the peasantry, although the rhetoric was generally portrayed as in favor of the poorest rural populations. ProSAVANA emerges from the same discourses and is embedded in an authoritarian populist regime operated by FRELIMO, which as we argue in this paper, was built and consolidated since independence. In this paper, we attempt a deep analysis of how, a resistance movement that was built through agency of rural constit...
Social movements, agrarian change and the contestation of ProSAVANA in Mozambique and Brazil
The team includes 25 researchers coming from a range of disciplines including development studies, economics, international relations, political science, social anthropology and sociology, but all with a commitment to crossdisciplinary working. Most papers are thus the result of collaborative research, involving people from different countries and from different backgrounds. The papers are the preliminary results of this dialogue, debate, sharing and learning.